Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project

Started by AndrewB, 2021-04-23, 09:42:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Joseph Lofthouse

There were only two plants with orange fruits this year, and maybe 50 seeds total, so I won't be sending seeds to Experimental Farm Network this year. Most of the seeds got pollinated with green-fruited varieties, so it may take a couple years to get a stable orange fruited habrochaites. Wishing that I would have made clones this fall, then I could have tried to cross them this winter.

Joseph Lofthouse

I grew LA2329 two years in a row in the patch with my BC habrochaites. It's very likely that it's genetics combined with the BC population.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-12-09, 05:48:19 PMI grew LA2329 two years in a row in the patch with my BC habrochaites. It's very likely that it's genetics combined with the BC population.

Nice! The seed I sent you of LA2329 was harvested from that plant that was close to the BC1 you sent me so it had three years of potential interaction. Did the LA2329 change notably? Or did it stay its fuzzy and strong smelling self? Do any of the current BC1 have the strong smell or intense fuzz? The 50% LA2329 50% promiscuous population showed a lot of fruit size variation in the F2 in 2023, no color variation yet. I haven't noticed anything yet in the LA2329 cytoplasm population yet, but do wish I had separated them better in 2023. They kind of mixed in so that 2023 seed lot is mixed cytoplasm potentially. I would like to do a bigger grow out of The LA2329 cytoplasm material for 2024 but I don't anticipate having enough seedling starting space to do so. I can maybe grow a huge grow out of The 50% material and the 25% material as those I could probably direct seed.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

The growing season got away from me this year. I think that I didn't photograph the BC plants this year, so I can't tell what happened to LA2329.

William Schlegel

#244
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-12-09, 06:55:03 PMThe growing season got away from me this year. I think that I didn't photograph the BC plants this year, so I can't tell what happened to LA2329.

That is ok. I really struggle sometimes to keep up with my garden. There are a lot of tasks I would like to do like search for type IV trichomes and bag blossoms to get a sense of SI and SC status that don't always get done. Definitely a curiosity though. It's possible even that the accessions involved just don't cross with each other for some reason. Also possible that they've already deeply crossed. I definitely crossed promiscuous bicolors with LA2329 in both 2021 and 2022 though! I might again in 2024 to get the orange blue blushed strains of The One descendants into the mix.

I have a couple of additional accessions of Solanum habrochaites LA 1033 and one that might be cold tolerant. A cool way to go with those projects would be to cross with a more SI strain or this BC1 derived domesticated habrochaites strain. Also just a thought in general, that once we have a domesticated habrochaites, and it seems you do!- working with habrochaites accessions might just be a lot easier.

In many ways habrochaites is a better plant.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

What's the seed size like in the yellow fruited habrochaites? Same as the fully wild seeds, or, larger?

And how do people feel about the idea of domesticated tomatoes with seeds that are wild-sized? I was thinking for cherry tomatoes that could be a good thing for the eating experience, but the drawback is the seedling stage, small energy reserve in small seed. I'd be interested how growers would feel about it. This thought was inspired by eating some tasty cheesmaniae/pimp hybrids - the tiny seed size was appreciated, and this makes sense to me in small fruits where the seed:flesh ratio is so high compared to large tomatoes.

Joseph Lofthouse

#246
Seeds retained the small wild phenotype. Color of the seeds shifted towards yellow.

The pollen donors for yellow fruits included descendants of interspecies crosses with habrochaites and pennellii.

IMG_7444.JPG

Justin Jardinier

#247
I wrote before about experiencing some tomatoes in this project being self incompatible yet being able to receive self compatible pollen. I thought about that some more recently and thought that it's important to consider the stage of flower development. I don't remember for sure but 99% sure I must have emasculated those flowers and crossed them in the normal manner, when the petals were yellow but just before opening. Bearing this in mind, it could potentially be possible that they only were able to be pollinated by (recessive) self compatible pollen because of being immature, and that this would not necessarily mean that the mature open flowers could be pollinated by the same pollen.

In my own current project, I actually applied these thoughts over the last several days, seeing if I could pollinate some of my F2 [is 'F2' the right term for the offspring of F1 sibling crosses?] self incompatible hybrids (some of which should be only heterozygous for SI S-alleles) with regular lycopersicum pollen. I have not had time to keep up with documentation, but I just inspected some of the labels from failed cross attempts. I count 3 from 1 plant, 2 from another, 1 from another. That might actually be all that I tried - I will update if any actually worked but my expectation is that this means all failed. The one I tried 3 on, they were of varying maturity on the same flower cluster, one with yellow petals, one white, one green. The one with 2, I think one was yellow, one white. I did varying stages because it might be necessary to do them earlier than usual to get around the SI barrier, and I have had some success with this on peruvianum.

All crosses having failed, this could mean that the mechanisms from the S-allele were already active, or, some other barriers. In a way it's a good sign as it shows strong barriers in my current population, although it could have been convenient had it worked, since I have a lot more SI flowers than I do lycopersicum flowers right now! And I was hoping the former would make better mothers for seed production also. But I think it's a good result anyway.

It doesn't really clarify the situation regarding the odd behaviour under discussion. And it does not rule out the possibility that the phenomenon I observed previously was due to getting around post flower-opening SI barriers by pollinating unopened flowers. But after consideration, I would say that if anyone did want to run tests for SI plants, instead of testing them with SC pollen after emasculation, I would say only do that if you also test them their own pollen after emasculation, on separate flowers - only a positive result with SC and negative with self pollen, would demonstrate this anomolous behaviour. Though the ideal test I think would be to bag flowers before opening, then run both test, no need for emasculation. That way, you're testing the behaviour of the flowers under natural conditions and will be able to ascertain if they are SI, and if they would be able to receive SC pollen via natural pollination or not.

William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

Project update for 2024 growing season

I stopped working on the Q-series of tomatoes. Those were tomatoes that descended from this project. They have orange fruits about 4 to 8 ounce fruits. Often determinate vines, and lovely flavor. Flowers tend towards inbreeding types, so I stopped work on this family, and all other families without the self-incompatible trait.

I have a population (SI x SI) that acts fully self-incompatible. I shared that population with a number of growers across the country. They are trialing for disease resistance, and selecting for promiscuous flower types, and hopefully flavor. Hoping to generate lots of seed to share with others next winter. Thankful to Anna Mieritz for facilitating the grow outs.

I have a population that is a 4-species hybrid (pimpinelifolium, lycopersicon, habrochaites, pennellii). One plant last year acted self-incompatible and had open flowers. I intend to grow a population of that. Also growing its siblings that had amazing flavors. I shared seed of this clade with Experimental Farm Network as Hummingbird tomato.

Two plants from the SunSugar X SI cross acted self-incompatible last summer. I intend to grow those out. One of them tasted like tangerine.

Those three populations will be grown close together so that they can share pollen.

There were a couple of plants with astonishing flavors from the pimpinelifolium and SunSugar crosses that I intend to grow for seed to share, even though their flower types may not meet project goals.

I intend to grow out the population which I believe to be 90% habrochaites, and that had orange fruits last summer. They were pollinated by green fruited plants, so going to try to do early selection. I'll grow them isolated from the orange/yellow fruited elite varieties of self-incompatible tomatoes.

Then there are seeds from one habrochaites plant, grown in isolation, which may have been pollinated by peruvianum, pennellii, or wildling. 




William Schlegel

That is an excellent and intriguing update Joseph.

I am most intrigued to grow the deliberate cross and the probable natural cross segregates of the good flavored segregate I called "The One". Especially the ones that I marked as half strength anthocyanin.

I got some blossom bags like the ones my wife uses for her cut flower seed growing and I hope to use them to investigate self incompatibility in my likely mixed compatibility LA2329 hybrid populations. I may direct seed some of the accumulated 50% LA2329 hybrid seed from that project.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I hope that others will carry the Q-series forward as Joseph focuses on SI lines.

I plan to grow a bed of Q-series this year, in the hope that I will get some good fruity and orange tomatoes. If so, I will save all the orange and fruity seeds that I can.

Wildling Panamorous was a disappointment last year, as all the fruit was red and non-fruity, just the opposite of what Joseph had selected for earlier. Either someone growing it in the chain between Joseph, EFN, and myself re-selected for red lycopene-flavored fruit, or there is strong genetic drift pushing in that direction.

I look forward to tasting some of the fruity tomatoes this year, and attempting crosses with other varieties with desirable traits.

Kadence Luneman

I planted 198 tomatoes. Of that 20 are wilds and 65 are Promiscuous project lines. I intend to continue with lines from these. My interests aren't especially with SI lines but I plan to screen for them by bagging and buzzing flowers to see if they self. I'd like to send the bulk of the SI seed to people who are doing more work with them and I'd just keep some back up for it. I'm more interested in the exsertion, showy flowers, and raising the likelihood of natural crosses than being strictly SI.

Hmm it does seem weird that the Wildling Panamorous would produce all red fruit and quite domestic tomatoes. My packet is from this last EFN update and says 12/2022 for germination test. Probably the same lot of seed I'd think. Have to see what I get. I started 20. How many did you grow last year? Curious the sample size you had.

I'm going to make a post on my tomato plans but this seems best here...
Would it be useful for someone to reinvent the wheel? To take what has been learned and start from scratch with their own promiscuous project of wild crosses? The project is built primarily from crosses with Big Hill it seems. One could start with different domestic tomatoes to bring in different traits. I really enjoy the way Joseph gardens and landraces but I'm curious to see what else could be learned by starting from scratch and doing some more record keeping and hand pollinations.

William Schlegel

Actually Joseph didn't cross big Hill in until about 2019. Before that it was all red tomatoes and those red genetics are hard to get rid of. Joseph likely never advertised that line as red free. It just predates his declarations that he is going to work to eliminate red tomatoes from his garden.

I avoided red with my LA2329 project until last year when I crossed in exserted tiger. It has a lot of exserted genetics from Big Hill and now exserted orange and exserted tiger. The latter of which brings in red but it is a minor concern to me compared to the habrochaites flavor. Many red tomatoes taste good to me my tongue I suspect isn't as capable as Joseph's. So red flesh and blue skin are allowed in my garden.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

#254
I continuously attempt to reinvent the wheel.

I have a line with orange fruits and habrochaites cytoplasm.

I have lines that are half pimpinelifolium.

I have a line that is half SunSugar.

Hmm. I have a line, that I wasn't planning on planting, from a couple summers ago, that is a bee made cross that would be equivalent to the state of this project 10 generations ago.

I have other lines, and I keep making more crosses when suitable parents flower at the same time. I'm still keeping very few records. My work could have benefited from more records, and especially from attempting self-pollination.

In all lines, I select heavily against red fruits, cause I think lycopene tastes terrible.