Two Prairie Fires?

Started by Diane Whitehead, 2023-11-29, 05:34:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Diane Whitehead

Baker Creek is excited about Prairie Fire - "an insanely sweet fruit with a brix reading of 10.0".  The picture shows a fruit an inch wide and three inches long, red with yellow markings.

However, there is another Prairie Fire, bred by the New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station at Rutgers.  It is a cross between a SubArctic and a beefsteak, and is round. I don't know when it was introduced, but it has been sold since the 1990s.

It seems unlikely that the new one is a sport.  Does anyone know more?
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

#1
I know a little and there might be three or four Prairie fires.

I think the Rutgers version is the same Heirloom offered by Fisher's garden seeds in Belgrade MT. It may have been bred by Fisher and just obtained by Rutgers or vice versa. It's the version of small red tomato I grew this year. https://www.seedstrust.com/tomatoes/tomato-early-prairie-fire and https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Prairie_Fire

So when I was searching the other day and earlier the longer striped version may have been bred by one of the few artisan tomato seed breeders. https://awhaley.com/product/cream-of-the-crop-prairie-fire/ I think Cream of The Crop includes Mark McCasslin the breeder of Purple Zebra F1.

However maybe some folks have saved seed because there is the long version at baker creek, an F1 version that looks the same (Edit I don't now think there is a hybrid version- just saw one photo with a "hybrid" caption but when you click on it the description doesn't include hybrid.  Then I saw photographs of a shorter version from some sources. So I guess that makes three (Edit I thought there were four). Heirloom short season red, long striped, and short striped.

https://www.juliadimakos.com/product/prairie-fire-tomato/  This link is to the shorter version. This may be a variant that arose for some growers.





Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Mica Winnower

Gather them all up and cross Prairie Fire in to Prairie Fire, and then Prairie Fire into Prairie Fire. That way you can be 100% certain that you have a Prairie Fire somewhere in the background.

William Schlegel

Because of my habit of complete ridiculousness, I impulse ordered the Baker Creek Prairie Fire to go with my heirloom Prairie Fire which I made a cross with last year- and yes, I was thinking about making a cross with the cross with it. Though genetically I am still kind of just thinking about it as just two things because I think the three striped versions all sprung from the same well so to speak.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

I think it's actually pretty common for multiple items to wind up getting sold under the same name (and the same under different names). Between mis-communication, mis-translation, and a lot of people simply taking others identifications as accurate on faith, things can get quite muddled. In tomatoes, I remember how someone wound up turning Black Krim into  Black Crimean due to some translation errors. And, back when I was trying to do some corn work, I remember ordering some  Navajo Robins' Egg* from Prairie Gardens and getting a packed that did not in any way resemble the seed I had gotten the last time I ordered it from another company (as far as I can tell, PG has a mis-labeled version, while Native Seeds/SEARCH has the correct one.)

*Or, I suppose Dine Robins' Egg now.

Cathy A

You're absolutely right, Jeremy. And sometimes names that are similar but not the same make it worse. For example, there have long been tomato varieties called "Abraham Lincoln" and "Abe Lincoln", and I don't think they are the same.

And sometimes a variety will be derived from an existing variety, such as "Maestro" and "Improved Maestro" peas. But the modifier "Improved" ends up getting dropped by someone, and then it's impossible to tell whether any given "Maestro" is improved or not.

William Schlegel

The second Prairie Fire tomato was just named the same as the heirloom. Bred totally separately.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-12-01, 07:47:35 AMYou're absolutely right, Jeremy. And sometimes names that are similar but not the same make it worse. For example, there have long been tomato varieties called "Abraham Lincoln" and "Abe Lincoln", and I don't think they are the same.

And sometimes a variety will be derived from an existing variety, such as "Maestro" and "Improved Maestro" peas. But the modifier "Improved" ends up getting dropped by someone, and then it's impossible to tell whether any given "Maestro" is improved or not.

Back when I was trying to acquire every black, white and green tomato there was, I got a Russian one called "Black Moor" some time later, I got some seed for one called "Black Mavr" it wasn't until I got the second one it occurred to me that the two were probably the same tomato, with the difference in name due to whether the second word was kept in Russian or translated to English.

What I think is the supreme example of the other side (in that we are not just talking about different varieties but actual different species) has to do with grapes. Ever since I heard about them, I have been very interested in a Chinese grape called the Dragon's Eye grape, which has been used in Chinese grape wine production for millennia (while it is nowhere as large as the rice, sorghum or millet "wine" industries, China has always had a grape wine industry as well. The wines themselves tend to be terrible ("Great Wall" is an example of a wine made from Dragon's eye grapes) but I have always been curious what would happen if someone brought the grapes to France, California, or some other area with a long and storied wine reputation and placed them in the hands of an expert wine grower and maker. So I have been interested in locating seeds or cuttings.

Here's the problem. In Chinese "Dragon's Eye" is lung yen. This also happens to be the Chinese for a kind of very popular tree fruit (in this country, we usually call them longans) which is FAR better known than the grape is. So when I try to find information on the former, I usually wind up being directed to sites about the latter.

As for similar, I'm still not sure if "White Russian", "Russian Nights" and "White Russian Nights" are the same tomato or not. And, going back to corn again, among the colored sweet corns out there, there seems to be a bit of a mess as to the difference between "Paiute" and "Cocopah", caused by a difference in opinion with Native Seeds/SEARCH again (this time with La Boutique du Kokopelli in France.) 

I also recently had to re-think the name for a bean variety I was working on, since someone on the site I was on named their bean the same way (I named it first, but I doubt I could find the records on the site to prove it, and, in any case, theirs is ready for distribution and mine is not, and quite possibly never will be.)   

Cathy A

Has anyone grown or done breeding with Prairie Fire?

I was reading through the 2024 Baker Creek catalog, and ran across this description:

Prairie Fire (NEW!)
"Insanely sweet fruit with a Brix reading of 10.0...this may be the sweetest tomato we have ever tried! Compact vines produce fruit that are 1 inch across and 3 inches long."

This sounds like it has great potential for crossing. It could potentially add sweetness without introducing the sprawling, large indeterminate vine trait.

Diane Whitehead

In December I started a discussion -  Two Prairie Fires?  -
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

Yeah I have both Prairie fires now. I'm liable to cross the new one with my cross with the old one. Also the new one being a Paste type would be good to cross into my Paste hybrid for some more fanciness.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

William, feel free to merge this thread with Diane's "Two Prairie Fires" thread.

Cathy A

I've ordered the Baker Creek Prairie Fire and will give it a go in 2024.

If it's truly as sweet as they claim, it will be good breeding material for the Vermont Short and Sweet project, and also a worthy competitor to Sungold F1 in its own right.

Sungold F1 x Prairie Fire would be an interesting cross. Do both use the same genes to develop sweetness, or do they use different chemical pathways?

William Schlegel

Oh I don't know, but you could have the same chemical produced by two different genes or you could have different chemicals produced by two different genes because there are lots of different types of sugars like Fructose and Sucrose but they are all C6H1206. Andrew sent me a high sucrose strain of tomato once. Single gene introgression.

I actually am not sure if I like the trend towards making all fruits and vegetables sweeter and higher in sugars.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 08:54:37 AMI actually am not sure if I like the trend towards making all fruits and vegetables sweeter and higher in sugars.

I agree with you for vegetables, but for fruits, especially tropical fruits (which tomatoes really are), I like the sweetness and think it's appropriate.

Some garden foods, though, are almost too sweet. I've experimented with using Blue Hubbard squash in pumpkin pie recipes instead of pumpkin, and the result is way too sweet because the squash is much sweeter than the pumpkin it replaces. If you try this, be sure to reduce the amount of sugar you add to make the pie filling.