Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project

Started by AndrewB, 2021-04-23, 09:42:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mica Winnower

So, I planted some Wildling panamorous in pots in the middle of the summer, mostly to test their germination. I did not expect to get this nice stretch of sunny weather this late in the season, and I was able to get fruit to ripen in that short window. Good stuff.

A squirrel got to the big one before I could, but thankfully only took a mouthful and left the most of the fruit on the ground. I picked it up and took a picture before squeezing out all the seeds I could and starting to ferment them.

I don't remember the name of the pollen donor, though I could describe the fruit. They were red inside with pink skin, cherry/plum sized fruit that was sometimes lobate, and had a very savory, mildly sweet, red tomato flavor. Nothing spectacular, but it performed a darling this year.

Anyway, here's pictures.

Garrett Schantz

I found that I couldn't post images on mobile. Turned out that I was just hitting quick reply.

I can't remember if I directly posted this fruit here.

This was a plant, from Exserted Tiger.

Well, a seed - that became a plant, however you say it.


The plant was putting out these oddly marked green fruits which eventually became red.


A family member crushed some plant which were already being harmed from the excess heat.


I stopped bothering with them after that.


The markings weren't variegation or markings that I've seen before.


I asked William here about them, he mentioned one parent.

I'd already checked on that parent.


This had the same coloration as Amurskij Tigr.



Unfortunately, I hadn't realized that the trait wasn't found in the entire population, and William didn't seem to have much hope that the trait had made its way over.


I figured at the time that other plants had the trait to a high extent and that I'd hopefully find an orange fruited one, which also had the markings.


Unfortunately the other one that I'm posting along with some other tomatoes. It's red.


I had to take cuttings and things when I moved again later in the year.


Some rotten tomatoes that I tossed could produce volunteers in certain areas, hopefully.

Garrett Schantz

The Exserted Tiger fruit made me look into them, because they resembled Vintage Wine - but the variegation was different.

So. I'm a bit upset that I didn't realize that I could've had fun seeds right there. The plants were slightly Exserted as well.


Plate de Haiti, is another tomato with odd markings. Some yellow splotches on it.


That one, the Experimental Farm Network, says this about it:


"According to Roughwood's Dr. William Woys Weaver, this tomato was depicted in the 1561 Swiss herbal of Konrad Gessner, making it one of the oldest documented tomato varieties in the world."


So. That's neat. I'd say domesticated, as in Europeans or someone else domesticating them.


I'll try and see if I can't find volunteers next year.

I still have extra seed somewhere as well.

William Schlegel

Exserted Tiger was sort of an interesting first find in my garden. It is a Blue Ambrosia x Amurski Tigr cross that I facilitated in 2017 and found the striped offspring of in 2019 in the F2. I haven't really been working on it in recent years so there isn't a better version of it. I finally made some crosses with it in 2023. It isn't however, to my mind, a part of Joseph's promiscuous tomato project though it was inspired by Joseph's writings. It doesn't contain any wild genetics. It is a subset of Lee Goodwin's Ambrosia line which originated with a Sungold F1 dehybridization which he then crossed to a blue skinned tomato from Oregon State.

I think better stripes are found in a lot of lines. I made a cross last year with Brad Gate's Brad's Atomic Grape, and with Purple Zebra F1. This year I also crossed with Tom Wagner's Muddy Waters. I think all three have better stripes than Amurski Tigr or Exserted Tiger. Not sure what genetics are at play exactly. I also managed to cross the Brad's Atomic Grape cross back to Exserted Tiger in 2023 as well as some other crosses though a few of them were with an individual that somehow managed to lose the striping.

Joseph had a "Wild Tiger" striped line some years ago. I had a hard time getting it started in my garden, but last year I got one going and saved quite a bit of seed. Not sure if it has any wild in it as it was before Joseph's more extensive wild crossings.

Europeans got perfectly domesticated, even extremely fancy heirloom tomatoes from indigenous peoples. One of the first ever painted was a yellow heirloom with those fancy deep ribs. A 1561 tomato could easily be an indigenous heirloom that had nothing done to it but be seed saved for less than 70 years by Europeans.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Yeah, that's why the 1561 tomato seems interesting to me.


Europeans wouldn't even touch tomatoes at first, save for some Germans and people who were familiar with edible nightshades.



I haven't seen anything like Vintage Wine or other fancy types segregate into something like Amurskij Tigr, so I'd assume it has some different form of variegation.


The fancy types from South America seem harder to find as time has gone on.

Jeremy Weiss

Purple Calabash is also supposed to be pretty old, and also seems to have a few odd traits (like, as I mentioned, the much shorter, stiffer trichomes on the seeds than most tomatoes, and a purple that seems more "integrated" than most purple tomatoes [as in all parts of the inside seem to be the same shade, as opposed to their being bits that are more green or more pink/red).

I don't know all that much about Red Calabash (I'm not sure I've even seen much mention of it outside of the Seeds of Change catalog) but that may also be fairly old. 

Kadence Luneman

I have a maybe weird question...
William has shared about doing crossing blocks of tomatoes. Bees and insects are not completely reliable for tomatoes naturally crossing.

Would it make sense to try a crossing block and just slice the anther cones open on flowers? Instead of hand pollinating or emasculating. Just slice it open so insects could have better odds.

I didn't want to make a topic for what is probably just a one response answer lol.

William Schlegel

#217
Might work, might not. In 2017 I made my crosses by collecting pollen and dusting it on by hand to the most exserted varieties without emasculating. That might work just as well as slicing. You really just need one plant with extreme exsertion. I think extreme exsertion is important, modest or barely didn't seem to produce many crosses. That might also be the case with sliced open anther cones unless you shortened the anther cone but left the stigma normal- thus surgically creating an extreme exsertion. Might be easier just to daub pollen onto existing exsertion like I did.

Also, with time I have gotten better at making emasculated crosses. You may too, and if you are out in the garden cutting away at tomato flowers you might as well emasculate a bunch of them until skilled at it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I'm going to have to become better at it in 2024.

I destroyed the first flower I attempted in 2023, and since I only had 1-2 plants of most varieties, I didn't want to risk it.

Next year I will be growing fewer varieties and more plants of each variety, so I can take the risk.

Cathy A

William, regarding The One, it sounds like you not stabilized it yet. Have you done a fairly large scale grow-out to see  if you can isolate the traits that made you give it that name initially?

William Schlegel

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-12-07, 01:31:14 PMWilliam, regarding The One, it sounds like you not stabilized it yet. Have you done a fairly large scale grow-out to see  if you can isolate the traits that made you give it that name initially?

Yes, I grew a large amount of it in 2022 and 2023. The current status is that it either segregated wildly and or crossed extensively. It is now many different things: red, yellow, bicolor, orange, beefsteak, cherry, with and without blue blush . My favorites are the orange with blue blush, the orange cherry with blue blush, and a successful new deliberate cross. Those three will probably take the old Exserted Orange isolation garden in 2024. I'll probably grow four seeds of each as transplants and then direct seed the rest. If the going to seed group wants more project seed I'll probably mix the rest and direct seed it in the west central garden but probably let promiscuous volunteers from the 2023 seeding there volunteer as well if they want to come back. I might also cross some of my favorite strains to LA2329 habrochaites. 

I would estimate based on 2023 traits like blue blush observed that it could have newly crossed in 2022 so could be another 6 years before stable but there could be strains in the mix that are say F4 or more. If it comes from the 2019 crosses it could be F6 or F7 but I doubt it was that straightforward.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#221
I've been contemplating why some SI tomatoes from this project receive SC pollen. I still do not know, but I am considering the possibility that the mechanism in the style with is highly specific in rejecting self S-allele pollen may be active, and those plants showing this trait being homozygous for SI S-allele, i.e. not 50% SC. But that their mechanism for blocking SC is broken down. I don't even know if this is possible as I do not fully understand the SI and UI systems. Does this sound possible to anyone?

Why this doesn't make sense to me is that usually only dominant SC pollen can break through the SI barriers, something about S-Rnase. Hence SC pennellii and SC arcanum can do as they have dominant SC whereas lyc. has recessive SC. Something like that. These however receive recessive SC pollen. But I am struggling to hypothesise any other explanation. Anyone have any other hypotheses?

William Schlegel

Could you fully tell the story of the SI individuals accepting the SC pollen from the beginning Justin? Start with what strain of Josephs promiscuous project and how you tested for SI and SC in case anyone wants to try to replicate your results. You probably told it before but it seems like there are missing details and the story is getting really interesting.

So with my The One sub strain of the promiscuous project. I was only able to make the cross with Mission Mountain tomatoes one way with The One as the female parent.

My hypothesis was that it was somehow a poor pollen producer. What if, it instead or in addition, has some partial SI mechanisms? Or is the same problem as what you have observed Justin?

I suppose there is an additional potential mechanism in there. The Mission Mountain tomatoes have the obvious blue skinned introgressions. We know that lots of such introgressions are surprisingly large. What if blue skinned tomatoes have something unintended?

There was, some years ago, someone who thought blue skinned tomatoes have an invasive form of pollen. Though the simpler explanation may simply be that the blue is a nice marker. It comes out half strength in the F1 and segregates nicely in the F2. Also if Justin's SC parent was not blue that would mean it likely isn't that.was your SC parent blue Justin?

I have an isolated patio where I grow a few extra tomatoes during the work week. For 2023 I had R18, The One, and Amethyst Cream. I didn't emasculate but no fruit was set until I daubed Amethyst Cream pollen on some stigmas of R18 and The One. I've wondered in previous years if R18 might have some SI mechanisms intact. In the main populations neither R18 or The One showed any signs of problems setting fruit. Also a past The One plant in the greenhouse in 2022 set fruit ok- though I got no crosses which I had hoped for.

It wouldn't stand to reason that SI is simple if these are real results. They could also simply be results in need of more crossing attempts. Not all hand crosses are successful. Though it does seem like it is easier with some variety mothers than. Others. Would have to tally crossing attempts. Very odd possibilities.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-07, 05:40:26 PMThe current status [of The One] is that it either segregated wildly and or crossed extensively. It is now many different things: red, yellow, bicolor, orange, beefsteak, cherry, with and without blue blush.

It sounds like it had much more heterozygosity than is typical in an F1 between two stable parents. Not surprising given the promiscuous ancestory.

Right now it is interesting breeding material, but not stable enough to grow on its own with any expectation of getting the specific traits that made you save its seeds separately.

Justin Jardinier

#224
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMCould you fully tell the story of the SI individuals accepting the SC pollen from the beginning Justin? Start with what strain of Josephs promiscuous project and how you tested for SI and SC in case anyone wants to try to replicate your results.

I did not test in a fully systematic way. I'll say what I did to the best of my memory and then I'll recommend a better approach.

I had several 'elites' (those thought to be fully SI) and had several BH-NT, a population derived from the BH series and said to be SI. I had some wildings too, that were SC so won't mention them further.

The elites and BH-NT were outside. The BH in the peruvianum patch gave either no or almost no fruit, I forget which. A BH-NT that was a bit distant (2 metres?) from others produced almost no fruit, though did start producing some later in the season, which from memory may have coincided by an SC right next to it (put in rather late) coming into flower, its only direct neighbour. 2 BH-NT surrounded by domestics, hybrids, and elites, produced plenty of fruits. Combined, this supports the idea that they are SI. I was able to pollinate BH-NT plants with SC domestic pollen in controlled crosses, and use its pollen to pollinate SC plants.

One elite had small flowers and inserted stigma. It produced plenty of fruit. This suggests it was SC.

One elite had big showy flowers but inserted stigmas. It was surrounded by domestics, hybrids, and BH-NT. It gave plentiful pollen. It produced only 8 fruits, 5 of which I had emasculated and hand pollinated with SC pollen (recessive). This suggests that it is SI due to such low fruit setting which due to the ease of manual SC pollen pollination doesn't seem to be explainable with female sterility, and since I used its pollen to pollinate an SC plant, doesn't seem to be explainable with male sterility either. I would hypothesise that the 3 fruits it set without manual pollination may have been some lucky pollen from pollinators that managed to reach the stigma.

I might have tested one more elite that seemed worth crossing with, highly exserted stigma and small but delicious fruits, but I cannot remember for sure - if I did then it died of late blight before any crossed fruits could be harvested (it was the first to die from LB), which would mean I would not have recorded the crosses - I only recorded those with seeds I harvested. Too much going on, wish I had kept better records on that but unfortunately I did not. So I can't confirm whether I tried that one or not. I did not try others due to lacking the desired traits, exsertion in particular. I grew something like 4 or 5 of them, I would have liked to grow more but could not this year.

What I would recommend:
- Bag a flower cluster on each plant before any open.
- Vibrate some flowers when open and manually attempt self pollination. This tests for SI.
- Emasculate several flowers at the right time, and manually pollinate them with SC pollen.
- Obviously, label everything carefully!

This would best be done on 2 separate flower clusters to reduce the chance of those 2 types of pollen polluting each other. One could also use a mix of SC pollen from different varieties to increase the chances of the cross. One could also do normal emasculated crosses to a regular SC plant at the same time - if those and the main test fail, then the test should be discounted as may be due to environmental conditions. A negative result for the SI test and a positive result for the 'receiving SC pollen' are more definitive results than vice versa, but the control would help make the results more reliable and multiple tests on multiple days would also increase reliability. Even on one flower bunch that should be possible as they should open over the course of several days, so tests can be made day after day on the same cluster. Bags should only be opened while working - they are to protect from foreign pollen and pollinators. Indoor crosses would be even more reliable due to no wind and pollinators.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMSo with my The One sub strain of the promiscuous project. I was only able to make the cross with Mission Mountain tomatoes one way with The One as the female parent.

My hypothesis was that it was somehow a poor pollen producer. What if, it instead or in addition, has some partial SI mechanisms? Or is the same problem as what you have observed Justin?

Could you clarify which of those is or is thought to be SI?
With the BH-NT initially I had a really hard time getting pollen from them, and thought that might be why they appeared to be SI. But later I got pollen from them fine. Also if that were the cause I would think issues should show up in a whole plot of them, though I did not confirm exactly how they have been grown by those growing them. Plus, I switched from a small vibrator with a dying battery, to a tuning form, so my initial report of pollen being hard to extract might have been due to the vibrator.

Also the pollen coming from the showy flowered elite suggests lack of pollen is not the cause. And, if this behaviour is common, SI but receiving SC pollen, then I would think low pollen production should effect an entire population negatively with low fruit set. Though if it's only a portion of the population then that might not be apparent. I would not discount the possibility in all cases.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMWhat if, it instead or in addition, has some partial SI mechanisms? Or is the same problem as what you have observed Justin?

My thought expressed in my previous comment was indeed that I wonder if some SI mechanisms are in place, specifically those that make it reject self S-Rnase, but not mechanisms that make it reject SC pollen. I do not even know if that is possible though.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMThere was, some years ago, someone who thought blue skinned tomatoes have an invasive form of pollen.

What does 'invasive form of pollen' mean?

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMAlso if Justin's SC parent was not blue that would mean it likely isn't that.was your SC parent blue Justin?

The only antho I have in any fruits is in wild fruits. I have no domestic blues. BH-NT took pure lyc, che, and gal pollen, and SC hybrid pollen. The inserted showy elite I crossed only pure lyc to it.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMI have an isolated patio where I grow a few extra tomatoes during the work week. For 2023 I had R18, The One, and Amethyst Cream. I didn't emasculate but no fruit was set until I daubed Amethyst Cream pollen on some stigmas of R18 and The One.

If Amethyst Cream is SC then that implies those other 2 can receive SC pollen, right? And suggests the possibility that they might be SI, though could be explained by other things. Did Amethyst Cream set fruit while those 2 were not? If so that would weaken other explanations such as lack of wind/pollinators. Also of course results on one or a few plants doesn't mean we know definitively about the population as a whole. But it's all important info.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMNot all hand crosses are successful. Though it does seem like it is easier with some variety mothers than.

Yes I've been finding some domestics to be hard both ways, as male or female. Curious.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-08, 06:33:31 AMIt wouldn't stand to reason that SI is simple if these are real results.

Certainly UI mechanisms are diverse. Due to observations, I conceptually view SI and UI separately, even though they overlap in nature. SI tomato species also have UI barriers, and they vary. I feel like what I am observing might be conceptualised as SI with broken down UI barriers.

There are S-RNase-dependent and S-RNase-independent mechanisms for pollen rejection. There are also HT proteins involved. I wonder if they might be involved in this issue. I have not had the time to study this topic properly yet, I have quite a backlog of work to get through. But here are some quotes from 'Restoring pistil-side self-incompatibility factors recapitulates an interspecific reproductive barrier between tomato species' -Alejandro Tovar‐M et al. - The Plant Journal - 2014

QuoteOur results show that introducing functional S-RNase and HT genes from green-fruited SI species into S. lycopersicum causes rejection of pollen from all four red-fruited tomato species (Figures 3–5 and Table 1). The common ancestor of the entire tomato clade was probably SI (Spooner et al., 2005; Igic et al., 2008), and therefore expressed a full complement of functional SI factors. Our gain-of-function experiment restored pistil-side functions lost in the transition to SC in the red-fruited group (Kondo et al., 2002a). Previous studies showed that S-RNase alone is not sufficient for self-pollen rejection in S. lycopersicum (Kondo et al., 2002b) and this is now understood on the basis of the requirement for both S-RNase and HT proteins.


QuoteThe requirement for both S-RNase and HT proteins suggests mechanistic similarity between S-RNase-dependent SI and UI, at least in terms of pistil-side function. However, it should be stressed that the two mechanisms are not identical. Crucially, SI is highly specific, and a given S-RNase only causes rejection of one S-haplotype, while the HT/S6 UI barrier operates at the species level and is inherently less specific. Because of this difference in specificity, we were able to recapitulate a UI barrier using genes from two SI species and testing for rejection of pollen from four redfruited species. This difference in specificity has also been observed in Nicotiana (Murfett et al., 1996; Beecher et al., 2001), and there may also be other differences between S-RNase-dependent SI and UI (Hancock et al., 2005).

Regarding actual aims, I think having SI plants which are not UI with domestics, is still very useful, if the aim is to have a high rate of outcrossing. For those SI plants it would still be 100% outcrossing! However I would worry about the possibility of the population tending towards SC via dilution. This is why I am interested in UI. And for me, SC UI and SI UI both seem appealing. An SC UI population would be protected from dilution and yet still be able to produce fruit with a single plant or just a few, as many might like to grow, And depending on flower structure, could still be predominantly outcrossing as a population. Whereas a single SI UI plant would be doomed by itself, in a group of 2 or 3 could set fruit so long as they didn't share the same S-alleles, but then the continuation would be highly problematic due to lack of diversity of S-alleles. So I think there are specific pros and cons to both. Both seem very valuable strategies. But for me, the UI trait seems rather important for both. I do understand that will not be the case for everyone however - some may be fine protecting from dilution via isolation plots, for example.