Tomatofest discontinuing many heirloom tomato seeds

Started by Cathy A, 2023-11-24, 06:20:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

I just received an email from Tomatofest announcing that they are discontinuing over 200 low sales volume heirloom tomatoes because their farming costs have increased. They claim that they are the only commercial supplier for some of the listed varieties.

Some of the varieties on the list are not hard to source elsewhere (Amish Paste, several Brandywine colors).

Many I have never heard of (Blue Berries, Cerise Orange, Dark Tiger, Indian Moon, Nahuelbuta Pink, Watermelon Beefsteak, etc.) I don't know if they are rare because of low awareness and thus low demand, or if they simply aren't as suited for most home growers as more popular varieties.

Some of these might be interesting to breeders for genetic input to new varieties.

https://www.tomatofest.com/RARE_Seeds_To_Be_Discontinued_s/175.htm?searching=Y&sort=7&cat=175&show=300&page=1


William Schlegel

#1
I just went through the list. I recognize several of them including some of the blue skinned tomatoes released in the last decade or so also one OSSI registered dwarf tomato project tomato.I don't think I want any of them bad enough to purchase but I did see a couple like Sioux the major ancestor of Payette that would be interesting to see what are like.

It is sad, but it makes sense to me. Even inserted stigma tomato varieties, grown out properly, should recieve proper isolation or caging and a large enough grow out to detect things like crossing and off types. A single ounce of seed which is enough for most varieties is worth about $50 even a few years ago and for low sales volume types that is too much to pay for the growout and too little to pay a grower.

I think then if Tomatofests costs are too high that might mean that they are actually doing isolation or caging or paying growers. As a business it might not be logical to continue with all of them. Also there is pretty intense competition out there including for some of these same varieties, and some of it from low overhead operations who only grow say a pot full of each variety. Which could lead a bit to the larger question of how good does a tomato variety need to be to survive out there in the tomato saving world?  Will the varieties we breed make it? Should they? I'm not sure if my three early releases so far should. If I were to release an finished F7 form of Mission Mountain Sunrise it wouldn't work well for anyone with disease problems, nor does it have exceptional flavor. Pretty, potato leaf and short season are its main pros. Now that I have ~70 descendant crosses including crosses that could fix the faults of MMS should I simply move forward in my breeding project and perhaps let MMS fall into oblivion?

When evaluating potential varieties or germplasm for breeding, what is it that makes sense to make a cross with? What are your breeding goals? I found the variety descriptions inadequate for this list.

Also remember other sources exist that may help carry more obscure varieties forward such as Seed Savers Exchange. This may not really be last call on this germplasm.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I looked through the list in some detail, and I found that the varieties on the list that were most appealing were generally available from well-established seed sellers.

The ones that were listed as rare tended be those where the description did not seem to have truly unique attributes.

So at first glance, it looks like a mix of popular varieties that tend to be purchased elsewhere (Amish Paste, three Brandywines), varieties that never caught on because they don't offer much that is unique and useful, and others that don't categorize well.

Given their age, these heirlooms probably don't have sufficient disease resistance, making them more suitable as breeding material than as maintained varieties.

I will probably order a few of these, but it's telling that the ones I'd like to try are mostly still available elsewhere.

To some extent, breeding and selling of tomato seeds is a winner take all market. The most popular varieties will be the ones everyone wants, and they will crowd out others. There is room for a fair amount of difference, based on determinancy, cold/hot climate optimization, color, and disease resistance, but not enough to keep a thousand varieties properly isolated, trialed, and readily available for purchase.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-24, 10:57:08 AMI think then if Tomatofests costs are too high that might mean that they are actually doing isolation or caging or paying growers.

For their OS (original strain) versions, they'd more or less HAVE TO. Once those cross, they aren't the original strain anymore, just another version of the variety.

I recognize a few on the list I tried at some time and might pick up, like Indishe Fliesch (which I simply like peoples expression when they work out what the name actually means). But I didn't see anything much that was a "this is key, I need to get this now." on the list. 

reed

Here are some that jumped out to me.

Candy's Old Yellow - Very productive plant bearing 3-4", pale-yellow tomatoes with sweet fruity flavors with a light touch of acidity.    Isn't that description along with the odd color interesting? Like maybe it has some unusual genes, or wild genes?

COPIA - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
10-12 oz., red and yellow striped tomato with great fruity-sweet flavors. COPIA has become an American favorite.    This one looks a lot like my Mr. Stripy. I don't trust names, sometimes I buy a new one it looks like Mr. Stripy. If it tolerates conditions as well as Mr. Stripy, I might keep it.

Dinner Plate - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
Good producer of 4-6", heart-shaped, delicious, scarlet-red tomatoes. One slice to a sandwich will do it for you!     **Similar to my Utah Heart, might be worth a trial

Garden Peach - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
One of our favorite tomatoes. A peach color and peach fuzz outside. Good container tomato. Try this fresh in a salad. 
    **Another, what kind of genes does that thing have?

German Gold - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
A favorite since the 1880's. 1-2 lb. yellow, tomatoes with red marbling. Good slicer with sweet, mild, fruity flavors.  **Another Mr. Stripy like

Golden Beauty - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
2", slightly-flattened, beautiful tomato with delicious, sweet fruity flavors that are clean to the finish. Wonderful!   ***another interesting looking one, genetics wise.

Hazel Gold - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
Favorite heirloom variety. 12 oz., golden fruits with carry excellent flavors. Produces well in cooler climates.  ***assuming the color isn't off too much in the photo, I haven't seen a nice orange tomato for a long time.

Hess - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
HUGE, 1-2 lb., yellow tomato with red marbling. Mild, sweet, delicious, fruity flavors. Comes with bragging rights!   **Interesting another sort of Mr. Stripy-ish

Hugh's - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
From the 1940's. HUGE, 1-2 lb., pale-yellow, meaty tomatoes bursting with luscious, robust, sweet tomato flavors. WOW!   ***Another with tat weird color

Lenny & Gracie's Kentucky - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
LARGE crop of beautiful, 10-16 oz., pale-yellow tomatoes with meaty flesh bursting mild sweet flavors.  Exceptional!  **I'd plant some if I had them.

Marizol Gold - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
From 1800s Germany. 1-2 lb., deep-gold, slightly-ribbed, tomato with a red blush on blossom end. Outstanding!  ***You guessed it, Mr. Stripy like

Old Wyandotte - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
A staple in our garden.  4-5", golden tomato with excellent fruity flavor. A dependable producer for market.  **Another nice orange one

Peche Jaune - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
1-2 oz., pale-yellow. Looks like a delicate peach covered with fuzz. Elegant and excellent flavors. Don't miss this!  **Another sort of weird one,and fuzz

Pixie Striped - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
Dwarf plant producing small tomatoes with yellow stripes. Hollow seed cavity. Pretty tomato great for stuffing. RARE.   ***Just cause it's so unusual looking to me

Regina's Yellow - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
1-lb., red & yellow tomato with big, delicious, fruity-sweet flavors. Does well even in hot climates. A great slicer.   Mr. S, again

Stor gul - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
Good yield of 12 oz., yellow-orange tomatoes with sweet flavors. Disease resistant. Good choice for market tomato.  ***disease resistant?

Sutton - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
A beautiful tomato. Medium-sized 8 oz., slightly-flattened, white tomato with delicious, fruity-sweet flavors. RARE.   ***well, they said it's rare

Tigerella - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
Silver-dollar sized, tomato with red-orange skin with yellow jagged stripes and flesh with brisk, tangy, sweet flavors.   *****Yuck, Sometimes sold under name Mr. Stripy, it's not. Unpleasant flavor and no stress tolerance at all

Yellow Stone - Organic Heirloom Tomato Seeds
Prolific, 12 oz., oblate, orange-yellow tomatoes with red blush on end and mild, luscious, fruity flavors. DELIGHTFUL!  *** you guessed it again.

The reason I'm hung up on Mr. Stripy is because I've grown it a very long time, and am curious about any  that sound like it.

A lot of the others I am just curious about as maybe relating to your all's work with wild genetics and why they didn't get a mention. Have they all been tired already?

William Schlegel

I think a lot of the heirloom fuzzies, especially true heirloom, are just a mutation with no wild genes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

I think COPIA is half Mr. Stripey, half Green Zebra (as far as anyone knows).

As for the peach tomatoes, some tomatoes are just fuzzy. There a Red Peach, White Peach, Speckled Peach, Wapsipicon Peach and so on. Back when they were still a small operation working off of eBay, someone at Wild Boar Farms sent me some seed for a fuzzy form of Purple Cherokee (no, I don't have it anymore, and I do not know if they do, it didn't sound like they were planning to pursue it.)

Peach tomatoes tend to have good points and bad points. For bad they tend to be VERY soft (so not great if you are planning to sell extras at a farmers market or such) and they can be a bit more trouble to clean (since the fuzz catches dirt). On the plus side, the fuzz also catches marinate very well, so for things like salsa or bruschetta, it can improve the flavor of the "solid" part (so you don't wind up with a bunch of tomato pieces with all of the other flavorings stuck in the bottom of the bowl.)
 

reed

"I think a lot of the heirloom fuzzies, especially true heirloom, are just a mutation with no wild genes." Might not a mutation be interesting to breed with? I guess though, that the good or bad of it would be completely random. Would have to grow in on its own to find out.

"I think COPIA is half Mr. Stripey, half Green Zebra (as far as anyone knows)." That's just it, when it comes to so called heirloom, I don't think that names mean a whole lot. With my beloved Mr. Stripy being on the Cornel list and exhibiting the resistance they said it has, it seems like what I grow, and what they examined are the same. The only other evidence is the name. So, I don't know for sure that they are exactly the same and almost believe they are probably not.  Maybe the Mr. Stripy like tomatoes are closely related. Maybe others have that same resistance even more so, or not. I think I might get some of them and find out.

Jeremy Weiss

There are quite a few interesting trait's I'm surprised more people haven't tried to add to their lines. Naragaclang's (yes, I know I've probably misspelled that,) water shedding, more or less blossom rot resistant flowers would seem to be just the thing for lines designed for high rainfall areas, for example.