Sungold F1 - creating F0 parents?

Started by Cathy A, 2023-11-19, 11:29:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

I get very large amounts of F2 Sungold seeds because Sungold F1 is prolific of fruit, and each fruit is prolific of seeds.

While the F2 has potential as breeding material, past efforts to produce a stabilized OP with the key characters of Sungold F1 have failed, suggesting that heterozygosity at certain gene locations is an essential part of the Sungold genotype.

But what if we tried to stabilize, not a single OP Sungold, but two descendent OP population that, when crossed, produced an F1 very similar to the original F1?

Then we could propagate and share the two OP lines and the knowledge that crossing them produces a highly desirable F1.

This would be a big, long term project and would have to be done as a collaboration. I don't think any single amateur breeder could do it.

What do you think? What breeding techniques would you suggest? It would be necessary to isolate as many as possible descendants for several generations to get them as homozygous as possible, but do frequent crossings between different descendants to identify the lines that produce heterozygosity at the key sites.

William Schlegel

#1
I would suggest starting with the existing dehybridizations that seed can be found for.

I think Brad Gates has a Big Sungold Select and Lee Goodwin has Ambrosia.

https://jandlgardens.com/xencart/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=1_7&products_id=182

https://renaissancefarms.org/product/big-sungold-select-tomato/

There are probably more and also dehybridizations of the similar Sun Sugar hybrid (which is from a different company)

Talking about similar varieties there are:
Santiam Sunrise
https://osseeds.org/ossi_variety/santiam-sunrise/
Ambrosia Orange
https://jandlgardens.com/xencart/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=1_7&products_id=363
Tim's Taste of Paradise or Fruity
Sunviva
Dwarf Eagle Smiley

While those latter aren't Sungold dehybridizations they might be worth test crosses as if they were.

We could also collectively dip into our own seed collections and if we still have some older dehybridization projects from sungold that might get us to a more stable filial generation faster for test crosses.

Though a more interesting project to me: might be to find or create a tomato that was a really good stable source of disease resistance and vigor- and then do test crosses with it to see if any led to a good fruity flavored cherry tomato. Rather than the straighter forward deconstruction and reconstitution as open-source project you've proposed. 

https://jandlgardens.com/xencart/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=106&products_id=891

Someone was just telling me how vigourous Lee Goodwin's Wilderness is. I haven't tried it, but- you know something like that! A really vigorous plant.

Another thought might be the F1 hybrids I made in 2022 with the pimpinillifolium accessions. They came out a nice cherry tomato size basically those F1's are just really nice little red cherry tomatoes. If the orange is dominant- maybe a nice orange tomato like Exserted Orange or the Orange Segregant from my The One segregant crossed with a straight pimpinillifolium like PI 270443 which might be a good source of PH5 late blight resistance. Could that lead to a vigorous orange fruity F1 cherry tomato?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Roland

If i understand correct these are al Open Polinated varieties from Sungold F1:
Ambrosia Gold
Ambrosia Orange UBX
Ambrosia Red
Sungold Select
Sungold Select II
Big Sungold Select
And there are more?

Ivas Red berry is from a cross with Sungold F1.

So u can cross all the varieties above and hope to found a perfect F1.

If u do not found the perfect taste in the new F1, u can also cross all above varieties wit Sungold F1 and hope to find the perfect tasting tomato. If u find it, u know youre assumption is correct and Sungold F1 need heterozygous genes for perfect taste.
Netherlands

William Schlegel

I think from reading the description for Ambrosia Orange UBX it has a subsequent cross kind of like how Blue Ambrosia was a cross between the first Ambrosia and the OSU blue skinned material.

Still I think some material like that with a high Sungold parentage is probably worth being part of the investigation. That would include a lot of Lee Goodwin's work:

Ambrosia Gold
Ambrosia Orange UBX
Ambrosia Pink
Ambrosia Red
Ambrosia Rose UBX
Blue Ambrosia
Copper Current
Wilderness
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I like the idea of starting with crossing all known dehybridizations of Sungold with each other and looking at the results. Even one generation of doing this, carefully documented, could provide a lot of information that doesn't seem to be known in the community.

Steph S

Yeah, the chances of arriving at the parents by sifting through F2 progeny and beyond are technically zero.

I've heard great things about Ambrosia Gold and related cherries but haven't grown them due to being down my own rabbit hole.  Sungold has some great traits so crossing with it or its descendants is always a promising idea.

Cathy A

I wouldn't expect to reproduce the F0 parents of the actual Sungold F1.

But I think it's plausible to come up with a pair of derived lines that reproduce a few key attributes of the Sungold when crossed to produce a new F1.

The goal here is not to perfectly reproduce Sungold F1, but to produce something closer to the original than any of the dehybridizations done so far.

In particular, something that matches its sweetness level.

Tim DH

To my mind, there is a fair bit of overlap between this idea and the F1s for the People! thread.

I'll be trialling a first run at F1 cherries (created this year) next season, but I'm already collecting contenders for a 2025 hybridisation to trial in 2026!

Tim DH

William Schlegel

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-11-22, 02:44:15 AMTo my mind, there is a fair bit of overlap between this idea and the F1s for the People! thread.

I'll be trialling a first run at F1 cherries (created this year) next season, but I'm already collecting contenders for a 2025 hybridisation to trial in 2026!

Tim DH

I replied over in Tim's thread but I have gathered occassional evidence from not just dehybridizing sungold but other fruity populations as well of sungold like flavor sometimes segregating out of mixes. Just the right heterozygosity might do the trick.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-11-22, 02:44:15 AMTo my mind, there is a fair bit of overlap between this idea and the F1s for the People! thread.

Absolutely, that was one of my inspirations for this idea.

Sledgehammer Potato

It would be good if someone could dehybridise Sungold.  Given how long people have been trying, I don't know if that will happen.

I keep hearing how Sungold seed is cheap and readily available, but in my country I rarely see the seeds for sale.  Last year I bought 5 seeds for $5.18 and only 3 germinated.  The plants produced were vigorous, highly productive, and had a decent taste. 

I couldn't find seed for sale this year so am not growing it.  I should have taken a cutting to overwinter so I could keep growing it without having to track down seed again. 

Diane Whitehead

Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Sledgehammer Potato

Australia.  In some ways it feels like a world away from the rest of you.

Cathy A

If you have that much trouble obtaining modern hybrid tomato seeds, you may want to focus on locally available OP tomatoes. Either propagate and maintain existing varieties, or breed your own.

Sungold F1 is an excellent tomato, but hardly the only one worth growing.

William Schlegel

https://www.siskiyouseeds.com/collections/tomato-cherry/products/tomato-gold-currant

Now here is an interesting hypothesis I just saw on Siskiyou Seed's tomato pages. They posit that gold current is a potential parent of Sungold.

I do have a packet of golden current somewhere and likely grew some in 2022 as I think that is the year I got it from HRseeds. An orange current tomato or golden current crossed with an orange tomato should produce a Sungold sized F1.

In my garden thus: Exserted Orange x Golden Current might be an interesting cross to try. Or the orange phase of The One x Golden Current. Or perhaps any yellow or orange beefsteak- with a blue blush or not.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days