Fruit size possibilities crossing with small fruited wilds?

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-11-22, 06:50:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I'm curious to hear about people's experience or knowledge on this topic.
Let's say I cross something like pimp or gal with a domestic. Suppose the wild has fruit size '1' and the lyc fruit size '10'. What's the max size one can expect in the F2? And would one ever be able to attain size 10 after a few generations? Or would that require back crossing?

I'm especially curious about this with reference to breeding with ph-5 pimp, but also in general. Though I suspect most of the experience with this will be with pimp. It does seem that the late blight resistant tomatoes tend to be fairly small, so I am wondering perhaps people have real struggle with breeding with pimps from which that resistance is derived, but getting larger fruit. And without marker assistance I'm assuming the task would be even harder since presumably the pros use lots of backcrossing, which without marker assistance must make it way way harder to keep the full LB resistance.

reed

I had a basically feral pimp that grew in my garden for a long time, and a few years ago I found two plants that looked like the regular pimp but had significantly larger fruits. The pimp being about the size of peas and the volunteers about the size of grapes. I don't have a guess of the origin of the volunteers but if it was, as I believe a cross with the pimp, then it was a large fruited tomato because I don't grow any other small or cherry type. I also don't know which one might have been the mother or father side.

Since then, I have seen a lot of phenotypes in size, shape, color and flavor but always with the pimp foliage.

I haven't tracked or recorded any of this in any scientific way but as a casual observation when a larger one shows up, say the size of a Ping pong ball and any color, it is probably sub-par in flavor.

When a small pear shaped one shows up, especially if it is yellow, it's terrible.



Those the size of marbles and round in shape, of any color are fine. Slightly larger of any color but more oblong shaped (not pear) are also fine.

Slightly larger than the pure pimp and round, in any color are more than fine. These in yellow or orange barely taste like a tomato, more like some kind of sweet fruit, although I can't identify which one. 

This year such a plant showed up with yellow, sort of translucent fruits, it was extra, extra fine in flavor. And for the first time I had a plant that ripened the whole truss all at once, like in pictures or that you might buy at the store. I'd never seen that in real life before. I think for future reference, because of the translucent appearance, I think I'll call it Crystal Pimp.  Its flavor was similar to one I got from Joseph several years ago that I called Captain Crunch. It also had great fruity flavor, but larger fruit and was terribly disease prone.

I also grew a new "heirloom" tomato this year that rivals my old stand by Mr. Stripy for flavor. Mr. Stripy is on Cornel University's short list of blight tolerant heirlooms. This new one called Wiard Wynn is very much like Mr. Stripy but ripens fruits in clusters of five or six instead of two or three. Most plants were not as disease tolerant as Mr. Stripy, but one was. I have its seeds of course and am going to try to cross it with Crystal Pimp, although I suspect that Crystal Pimp is not a stable variety itself.

Back to your point of blight resistance in larger tomatoes I believe that my strain of Mr. Stripy does have a significant amount of resistance but I imagine it is horizontal rather than vertical.  I'm hoping this new one I grew does too but with just one year observation, I don't know yet. All of my pimps seem to be quite tolerant. From what I've observed I think you are right resistance tends to correlate with small fruit, but I don't think that is necessarily cut in stone.
 

William Schlegel

Walt Pickens had a very interesting comment about this once on the old Homegrown Goodness forum. I can't remember exactly but kind of intermediate.

My recent result with pimpinillifolium and three crosses was an amazingly uniform three Grape sized tomatoes from two different pimpinillifolium including the one I frequently call PH5 and three different domestics. In the F1 only so far.

Joseph was able to recover large tomatoes from his wild cross project starting when he back crossed in about 2019 to domestic diluting things to 1/4 wild.

I think size recovery is possible though even with a 50% cross. The trick might be a large population size. The sort I get when I direct seed a lot of material.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-22, 07:36:36 AMBack to your point of blight resistance in larger tomatoes I believe that my strain of Mr. Stripy does have a significant amount of resistance but I imagine it is horizontal rather than vertical.  I'm hoping this new one I grew does too but with just one year observation, I don't know yet. All of my pimps seem to be quite tolerant. From what I've observed I think you are right resistance tends to correlate with small fruit, but I don't think that is necessarily cut in stone.
 

I crossed your strain of Mr. Stripey with the F1 of Mission Mountain Morning x Purple Zebra F1. I would have made a cross with MMM x PH5 LB pimp but I got a lot of failed crosses on that plant somehow or another.

Might be a fun future cross though. I did, make a few 1/4 dilution crosses of PH5 Pimp. For example: (MMM F2 x Purple Zebra F1) x (MMM F2 x PH5 pimpinillifolium which should be fun because it should segregate almost like an F2.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I'm looking forward to growing those, and some of the others you sent as well. This past summer was such a good tomato year we have tons of sauce and juices and whole tomatoes in the pantry, so I won't get nagged at for using space for my Frankenfood.

William Schlegel

This issue of size recovery that Justin brings up is kind of critical to these lines not being considered just cherry tomatoes though I doubt they'll be frankenfood- just annoyingly small. Your Mr. Stripey gave me a nice large tomato. Definitely crossed it with a smaller one and with some potential size variation. The pimpinillifolium crosses I sent you are straight this size recovery problem. One of the reasons I made some 1/4 dilutions of them this year. Though that also dilutes the potential for getting the disease resistances too. Hopefully Julia will grow some of the same crosses in 24 and 25 and that will maybe enhance the population size.

I can always grow a bigger population here for the size recovery but then we would need to check the big ones somewhere with more diseases like you or Julia's gardens and or pay for some of those expensive trait tests.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Diane Whitehead

My late blight resistant tomatoes are almost all small, except for these:

Skykomish   4" beautiful bicolour, out of this world flavour and near 100% late blight resistant  the breeder Tom Wagner called it "one of my better creations"

Aunt Ginny's Purple   PL, excellent yields of deep pink 1 to 2 pound beefsteaks with great taste, on the sweet side, but more complex than that.   early   from Sandhill Preservation   
   
Big Rainbow aka Rainbow or Rainbow Bi-Color   very large (18-26 oz) bi-color, bright yellow with pink/red marbling OR pretty orange/yellow with red streaks radiating from the blossom end. deliciously sweet   75 - 80   days    Introduced in 1990 by S. S. Ex.....a family heirloom for years, from Polk County, MN, sent to Dorothy Beiswenger.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

Those would potentially make good out crosses or base varieties to try to get size recovery.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Thanks everyone, very interesting.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-22, 08:56:36 AMI think size recovery is possible though even with a 50% cross.

That sounds promising. One thing I found quite unusual that might be of interest to say - I made a pip x pen cross, and the F1 seems larger than both parents! Pen is LA0716, pimp is CGN15950. This pimp is slightly larger fruited than my other pimps, and the only one to have a hairy stem. has anyone else ever encountered hairy stems on guaranteed pure pimp? The seed size was also slightly large, so I wonder if it might actually have some lyc in it, though it is listed as pure. I'm not sure though - the fruit size is at least very similar to the other pimps I have, just a tiny bit bigger.

The F1 fruit is way bigger. I'm not so clear about the exact size of the father's fruits, I probably have a photo somewhere with a measurement, but anyway at least according to my memory (which is not guaranteed to be right, especially since the pen I have been harvesting lately have been much smaller accessions), the F1 still exceeds the pennelli father's fruit size. I suppose I should not take that too seriously without double checking, but even if it's the same as pen size, that seems impressive to me. Here are a couple of photos:
pimp 950 x pen.jpg

pimp 950 x pen - 2.jpg

Joseph Lofthouse

There is a mathematical forumula for estimating the fruit size of F1 hybrids in purely domestic tomatoes.

The formula is something like ((weight small) + (weight large))^0.5.

So crossing a 1 ounce fruit with a 10 ounce fruit, we expect fruits in the F1 to be 3 ounces. That is close to what I observe in my garden.

Also, among the F2, I observe recovery of the largest-fruit size in about 1 in 30 plants.




Kadence Luneman

#10
What is the ^ in the equation? Math is not my strong suit lol.

If I remember correctly from Craig lehoulier in his dwarf project videos they did some everglades tomato crossing or something? And the resulting offspring to a beefsteak seemed to have fruit that was grape size. The genes trended heavily to the small fruit size.

Edit-
Mexico midget (pea sized) to Summertime green (1#)
F1 was normal cherry tomato size

Adrian

"^" wanna say exponant
2^3 = 2 x 2 x 2=✓64=8
2^2=2x2=✓16=4
2^1=✓4=2
2^0=✓1=1 =2÷2
2^0,5 =2^1/2= ✓2
2^-1 =2÷2÷2 =0,5




William Schlegel

Adrian has that right, it is another way to say (annotate) something like "to the fifth power" when you can't make the number small and above the other numbers. Though just looking up in the options at the top here it looks like we might be able to do just that. X5

Normal cherry tomato size in the F1 was my experience with my two cherry tomato crosses. Will have to wait till 2024 to have any notes on size recovery in the F2. Though I am, somewhat, encouraged by Joseph's one in thirty. That might save me some population size. I am also in the size recovery step for my 1/4 habrochaites LA2329 cross.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-11-25, 11:12:55 PMWhat is the ^ in the equation?

The equation could also be written as:

Square root of (weight1 + Weight2)

reed

That didn't sound right at all because what ever happened to cross with pimp a few generations ago has never yielded anything bigger than an ounce, and that's probably pushing it.

But then I went back and read your other post again, "There is a mathematical forumula for estimating the fruit size of F1 hybrids in purely domestic tomatoes"

So, if I do manage to make a cross between my Mr. Stripy and one of the little pimp descendants, it will take a while to get them back up to any size. I guess though if Mr. Stripy was the mother, the expected smaller size of resulting fruit would be a good tell that the cross had worked. If it went the other way, with pimp as the mother, might I see increased size in the F1? Mr. Stripy probably averages about a pound.