Vermont Short & Sweet Tomato Project

Started by Cathy A, 2023-03-03, 08:39:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

I just finished saving seeds from the last few tomatoes that were picked shortly before frost. All tomato projects here at the Vermont homestead are on hold for the winter.  (10F last night!)

Time to think about next year...

Cathy A

I have planted the first tomato seeds of the 2024 season this morning. Last year I started tomato seeding back in February, but found that the plants were ready for transplant long before the outside weather allowed it. Experiments in 2023 on transplanting in very early May had mixed success, so I don't plan to transplant anything before mid-May this year.  Four to six weeks between seeding and transplant seems to be about right for me.

I am improving my record keeping this year. In the past, I have only labeled the variety of seed planted in each container. This year, I am also labeling the number of seeds planted to that I can estimate germination.

So this morning I planted the varieties that will be grown in quantity for 2024:

- Alaska (13 seeds)
- Q-series (20 seeds)
- Dwarf Eagle Smiley 2022 (11 seeds)
- Krainy Sever 2023 (14 seeds)
- Krainy Sever 2017 (11 seeds)

The Dwarf Eagle Smiley 2022 is directly from William's seed. The DES 2023 is from the same strain, but harvested by me from that single plant of his 2022 seed. I will be planting more of the DES 2023 seed as we move through spring. (I have very limited space to start seeds simultaneously!)

Alaska is from last year's leftover Tomatofest seed. Later I will be planting more Alaska from seed I harvested from this strain last year.

Krainy Sever 2017 seed is from  William; Krainy Sever 2023 is from my single plant of William's strain last year. Germination was very low for Krainy Sever in 2023, but whether that was due to old seed, poor technique, or bad luck I just don't know. I also have some Tatiana's Krainy Sever seed supplied by another member of opensourceplantbreeding.org that will be planted later in 2024; thank you!

I'm excited about Alaska, Krainy Sever, and Dwarf Eagle Smiley based on their 2023 prformance in my garden. I will be making multiple attempts to cross each of these with the other two this year, and all three with Sungold F1.

I'm also excited about trying Q-series for the first time. Given that it contains at least four different strains in the mix, I will be growing as many Q-series plants as I can germinate and fit into a 4x4 ft bed. With luck I will be able to do some crossings between Q-series and the three varieties listed above.

In coming weeks, I will be planting much smaller quantities (i.e., plant 6 seeds to get 2-3 plants) of the following varieties:

- Black cherry
- Sweet 100
- Neandermato
- Fuzzy mix (from tienchiu)
- Sungold F3 (plum, possibly a cross)
- Sungold F3 (sweet, dark orange, splitting)
- Sungold F3 (firm, bright orange)
- Bicolor Wildling
- Siberian Red
- Jagodka (Joseph's)

Some of these deserve much larger growouts, such as the Sungold F3 lines. I have the seeds, but not the space, to attempt that in 2024. However, I am not trying to stabilize a pure Sungold OP descendant; that's been done and done again. Instead, I am hoping to end up with a supply of Sungold F4 that has traits worthy of being crosseed with other varietes.

I feel a little silly planting tomato seed during one of the biggest snowstorms Vermont has had this year. Gardener's have to plant today so they can harvest tomorrow!

Cathy A

I checked the germination of the first batch of tomato seeds six days after seeding, and seeded the second batch.

Germination was very variable, especially the Krainiy Sever.

Krainiy Sever 2017 seed:        0 out of 11 (0%)
Alaska 2022 seed:              4 out of 13 (31%)
Dwarf Eagle Smiley 2022 seed:  10 out of 11 (91%)
Krainiy Sever 2023 seed:      10 out of 14 (71%)

The difference between the 2017 and 2023 Krainiy Sever is eye-opening. These are exactly the same genetics. The 2017 came from William; the 2023 was harvested by me last year from the single plant of the 2017 seeds I was able to grow to adulthood.

Perhaps my seed storage techniques are not the best. I generally store them in sealed Mason jars of 1/2 gallon or quart size, with a packet or two of dessicant included. They are not in bright light, but not in total darkness either.

I will be planting more Dwarf Eagle Smiley, Krainiy Sever, and Alaska as I am planning to grow all three varieties in quantity.

The second batch of seeds was planted today:

Bicolor Wildling 2023:      6
Uluru Ochre 2022:            6
Joseph's OT Jagodka 2022:    5
MMR (MMM x Aztek Blue, 1/4 will be dwarf):  9

Yes, some varieties I had not originally planned to grow in 2024 snuck back in when I want through the available seeds.

I had quite a few Uluru Ochre seeds left over from the packet I bought last year, and everyone but myself who grew it was very pleased with the result. So I will give it one more chance, growing ~3 plants. If I don't get any fruit again this year, it's getting culled.

The MMR went down to disease last year, but 2023 was the worst disease-and-pest year I have ever had. Perhaps it will do better this year. I planted 9 seeds in the hope that I will get at least 2 dwarf plants, then cull or give away the remaining plants.

Next round will probably be Fuzzy Mix, Black Cherry, and Sweet 100. I'll also need to start more Alaska, Krainiy Sever, and Dwarf Eagle Smiley. (Sungold F1 plants I just purchase locally from a nursery. The cost is minimal and it makes up for my lack of space for starting transplants indoors.)

Later rounds will round things out with Neandermato, some Sungold F3 lines I collected last year, and a few other miscellaneous types. I may try a couple of Brad, for example.

Cathy A

Planted an additional 13 seeds of Alaska 2023 seeds a few days ago.

Planted Joseph's Jagodka (9 seeds from 2023 plant), Sweet 100 (6 seeds), Black Cherry (9 seeds), Sweet Cherriette (6 seeds from William 2021), and Big Hill (7 seeds from 2023 plant).

I'm aiming for 2-3 of each of these, plus as many Alaska as possible.

The 2017 Kraniy Sever germinated later than the 2023 Kraniy Sever, but ultimately had a decent germination rate.

Cathy A

Some lines are germinating extremely well, others not.

Over a week ago, I planted 3 Uluru Ochre seeds left over from the commercially-purchased 2022 seeds. None have shown the slightest trace of germination. I'm abandoning Uluru Ochre and concentrating on other varieties.

None of the 6 Wildling Bicolor seeds that I saved from my 2023 plants (planted 3/29) has germinated, so today I planted another 12 seeds. Hopefully I will get a least a couple of plants from that.

Today I also planted 6 fuzzy mix (upright) and 15 Sungold F3 from two selected lines. One of the F2 plants was very sweet and prone to cracking, like the F1, and the other is a red plum (a possible accidental cross?)

About the only thing remaining to plant is the Neandermato. And I will continue to plant additional seeds of the most-desired lines until I get some germinated!


Cathy A

Over the last two days I have planted two 4x4 ft beds of Q-series, Krainiy Sever, Wildling Bicolor, Mission Mountain Rising, Fuzzy upright, Clay Family Red Cherry, Black Cherry, Sweet 100, Big Hill, and selected Sungold F3 lines. It's about 55 plants total.

I haven't planted the Dwarf Eagle Smiley yet, but it will go in very soon, along with Joseph's Jagodka.

This morning I will be purchasing some Sungold F1 from the local greenhouse and planting that.

(I don't have enough indoor growing space to start all the tomatoes from seed that I want to grow from seed myself.)

Cathy A

Transplanted the final round of tomatoes outside today. 3 Big Hill, 7 Sungold F3, 3 Q-series, 1 Fuzzy Mix upright.

I have over 80 tomato plants squeezed into 64 square feet. We'll see how it goes. Some of the plants will probably die or perform very poorly, and that's okay. I can pull them to make room for the more successful lines.

I did not plant Neandermato and failed to raise any Uluru Ochre, or Alaska to the transplant stage. Every other selected variety is represented by at least 2 plants.

Cathy A

2024 is going to be a far more typical year than 2023 with its flooding. It will be a better test of varieties for my region. No one I know locally got any tomatoes at all last year, and most didn't harvest anything from their garden in 2023.

There has been no sign of disease or tomato hornworms. I'm picking off the snails and slugs by hand, as usual. Weather has been a mix of hot and dry, and cooler and rainier. No late frosts.

All 80 plants are doing well. Many have blossoms, and some have green fruits. It's too earlier for any tomatoes to actually be ripe.

The MMR plants are doing well, with no sign of the disease that took everything down last year. They have been some of the earliest to fruit, and the fruit is already showing interesting mottled color patterns.

Cathy A

I may have an interesting new variety developing from Sungold descendants.

Here are two pictures of two different plants.
Sungold F3 red plum.jpg
Sungold F3 red plum 2nd plant.jpg

This is an F3 generation, and it has several interesting traits:
  • "Ladder" of fruit trait from Sungold F1
  • Prolific fruit
  • Plum tomatoes
  • Red tomatoes, not orange
  • Tasty, though not Sungold F1 flavored

What do you suppose the genetics of this plant might be?

First, the plum-shaped fruit. I'm not aware of plum tomatoes having come about from Sungold F1 descendants, but perhaps this is already a known trait. Is there a plum in Sungold F1 ancestry?

I did not do any deliberate crossing to produce this plant, but it could be an accidental cross. However, I didn't grow any plum tomatoes the year that the Sungold F2 ancestor seeds were produced (and the F2 growout already had the plum phenotype), so if the plum trait comes from a cross, that trait must have come from a recessive gene in the parent variety that wasn't expressed.

Second, the red fruit. If I recall correctly, the F2 ancestor fruit was somewhat more red than the Sungold F1, but not as brilliant red as the F3 fruit. And since the orange fruit of Sungold F1 comes from the dominant beta gene, how does this trait disappear in the later generations?

I will definitely be saving seeds from at least two of these F3 plants that are producing quite a bit of tasty fruit. I look forward to playing with the F4 next year. I already like the variety enough to keep propagating it if I can stabilize it.

It's not a dwarf, of course, but appears to be a full-size indeterminate. It may be interesting to cross it with a dwarf.


Cathy A

#99
William suggested that the MMR seeds should produce 1/4 dwarf plants. It looks like most of the ~6 plants I have are full-sized, but there is at least one dwarf.

MMR dwarf 7-28-24.jpg

One of the larger MMR plants has larger fruit that is slightly riper, though not ready for harvest.

MMR full size 7-28-24.jpg

The MMR plants were among the earliest tomato varieties to produce fruit this year, but they are very slow to ripen. I'm still waiting for the first ripe fruit, while I've been eating Sungold F1, Krainy Sever, and Q-series for a week or two.

Cathy A

Q-series has produced quite a bit of fruit, and the fruit is larger than cherry, and feels like a large saladette to small beefsteak. It seems to be the earliest ripening full-sized fruit in my current trial.

Q-series 7-28-24.jpg

Unfortunately I've had problems with something (probably snails or slugs) eating the bottom half of many of the Q-series and Krainy Sever fruit. They are in the same bed, so it's probably about the location rather than a common trait of these two varieties.

Krainy Sever is also producing quite a bit of fruit, and began harvest early. The fruits consistently have a two-color exterior, though I wouldn't call them bicolor as it appears to be skin-only.


Cathy A

It's time to start planning the next phase of Vermont plant breeding.

I'm happy with the results of the trials of various fresh-eating tomatoes, including some dwarfs and some larger plants. Going forward I plan to grow significant amounts of Dwarf Eagle Smiley, Krainy Sever, selected Q-series, and selected Sungold F4, as well as a few other varieties (such as Galahad F1, Jagodka, etc.) to attempt crosses.

I haven't had success with the few crosses I've attempted the last two years, so a top goal for 2025 is getting at least one successful cross. It doesn't seem difficult in principle, but it's fussy work with tweezers that can easily destroy the entire flower. I need a lot more practice!

I'll probably make multiple attempts at DES x KS, DES x Sungold, and KS x Sungold. Maybe something involving Q-series, maybe not. Also Galahad F1 x <various types>.


I'm now starting Phase 2, which will involve doing trials on a range of canning or sauce tomato varieties. I haven't finalized the list yet, but I expect to try at least:

Orange Banana (to get some (t) genes)
Principe Borghese
Utah Heart (thank you, Reed)
Roma?

I'm still space limited, so I can't try too many sauce varieties at once, especially since I will still be growing the fresh-eating varieties.

William Schlegel

Keep trying with crosses you'll get some eventually. Also, if you save a very large number of seeds for some of the varieties whose seedlings are obvious when crossed you might be able to find a few natural crosses. Like if you save 1000 seeds from the dwarves and germinate them all and find a few non-dwarf seedlings those would probably be interesting crosses!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

KaguyaCloud

I find it easier to stab through the anther cone using a needle or the end of an acne removal tool, then carefully use it to split the anther cone in half or into smaller pieces. After that, I use the tweezers to take them off.

Micro-dwarf flowers are on another level of challenging. I swear the pistils will fall off if you breath on it. On the positive side of things, it seems that "weak pistils" is a recessive genetic trait, as the flowers of the crosses I've made hold up together so much easier than than the parent micro-dwarf plant.

Cathy A

I'm impressed that Gregor Mendel was able to cross peas so successfully. I've looked at my pea flowers, and I think it would be even harder to work with them than to work with tomatoes.