How to Key Out The Tomato Species

Started by William Schlegel, 2023-11-16, 06:15:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/taxonomic-key

Hmm this key might be worth a thread of its own. I have to go to work, but perhaps I can explain it later.

Botanical Glossary is needed + general process of going through one.

Of course a hybrid won't quite fit!

A disclaimer on this: I haven't myself yet attempted to use this key with actual specimens, even of those species I commonly grow in my own garden.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#1
Most Taxonomic Keys for plants are dichotomous in nature. You have two options at a time. You read them as a pair. Carefully read and choose between the two options- looking up any unknown technical terms in a usually accompanying glossary.

The first key break of this key https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/taxonomic-key for tomato species is a variant! It has three options. So the first step is to read all three.

"1. Interior of ripe fruit red; seeds 1.5 mm or longer." Which can be simplified to: Hey is it a domestic tomato or a cherry tomato or a red mainland current tomato? Oddly a yellow, orange, green when ripe, or etc. tomato would key here.

OR

"2. Interior of fruit yellow or orange; seeds 1.0 mm or shorter ...S. cheesmaniae (L. cheesmanii)" Which can be simplified to: Hey is it one of those yellow or orange current tomatoes from the Galapagos islands?

OR
 
"3. Interior of ripe fruit green or whitish; seeds of varying sizes." Which can be simplified to: Hey is it any of the other tomato species all of which are kind of green or maybe kind of white but nothing like a domestic tomato?

Then you simply choose which of the three options your tomato belongs to and go into the sections within each of those.

There are some other variants from a standard dichotomous two choice key- under the cheesemaniae group there are only two lines one for cheesemaniae and one for galapagense.

However, the process is still much the same as if it were the more standard dichotomous form.

The next step is to find a high quality botanical glossary and look up all the technical terms. I am a bit tired tonight so I may delve more into that step tomorrow or Saturday when I should have such a glossary handy. I personally find that a glossary is indispensable and I am never able to memorize enough botanical terminology to stop needing one, especially for groups of plants I haven't keyed out recently.

However: it is also possible with many groups of plants to learn many species by sight identification- though their can be pitfalls when certain species have high levels of within species morphological diversity. It can really help speed your way through a key though!

A final note: in the case of hybrids a key is going to be inadequate. They shouldn't quite fit right in the key: but where they really wouldn't fit is in the species descriptions that a true flora should accompany the key with. True floras are thus more useful than field keys that lack the more detailed descriptions.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

I subscribe to the wild tomato reports coming into iNaturalist. They really help me to learn to identify the wild tomatoes by sight.

William Schlegel

#3
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-16, 11:20:27 PMI subscribe to the wild tomato reports coming into iNaturalist. They really help me to learn to identify the wild tomatoes by sight.

That is very interesting and a good use of Inaturalist! I forget sometimes it is a global resource. It functions essentially as a photographic herbarium- at least for plants.

Another source for photography of the wild species is the TGRC, many of the accessions have original photographs from the time of collection as well as sometimes from grow outs. Sometimes there are photos in the USDA ARS-GRIN records as well though I haven't checked it for tomatoes specifically. Another source is published field trip reports often come interspersed with species identified photos.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

The misidentification I observe most often involves calling lycopersicon a  pimpinellifolium.


William Schlegel

#5
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-11-18, 12:07:54 AMThe misidentification I observe most often involves calling lycopersicon a  pimpinellifolium.



Morphologically in the key it would be easy to be right morphologically with a current tomato ID but still wrong genetically. Without a ruler and a key in hand it would be very easy to call any small cherry a pimpinellifollium.

Theoretically for example the domestic x pimpinillifolium crosses I made in 2022 could segregate into all three morpho species in 2024.

Keys are valuable but they do have limits.

I love the saying "keys are written by botanists who no longer need them, for botanists who do not yet know how to use them" a lot of error arises from that space.

Next step up is comparing herbarium specimens and published species descriptions. That is what the master botanists who write the keys are doing.

Though DNA analysis has changed things up considerably!

One I should take the key to is Coyote also known as white current. Morphologically it is kind of borderline I would need a ruler out on the fruit size. Genetically I bet it's an very old hybrid- think we may have discussed it before and someone may have even found a reference. Has it been genotyped? 

Also- just an interesting thought- we might be able to create a morphological pimpinillifolium with no recent pimpinillifolium ancestry by crossing other wild tomato species with domestic tomatoes. Though such a hybrid might get through the key- it wouldn't likely pass a thorough comparison of descriptions.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Continuing with some thoughts on how to use this key: https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/taxonomic-key I want here to go through some of the technical terminology. Please point out if I have missed an important term, or if you have further questions, I or more likely, my reference books may be able to answer.

Ok so below I have a list of technical terms I think in the order they appear in the key. I am going to try to describe these using common language but I will be referring if and as necessary to H.D. Harrington's How to Identify Plants. I also have Thomas Elpel's Botany in A Day handy here and James Castner's Photographic Atlas of Botany and Guide to Plant Identification. There is also a fine book called Plant Identification Terminology but I am not sure if I have a personal copy- though I have definitely used it on and off at various workplaces over the years. Of these I can most attest to H.D. Harrington's book How to Identify Plants- it is an amazing book and I heartily recommend it.

Serrate- like a serrated knife or a saw blade.

Undulate- a bit of a wavy margin like waves or sand dunes.

Subdivided- smaller divisions as in a leaf with lots of smaller parts.

Internodes the straight stretches of stems between where they produce other stems and leaves.

Pubescent- One of many botanical terms for various types of small hairs.

Accrescent- this is a term for when, usually the sepals (usually green bracts below a flower) get bigger after flowering.

Calyx- Stuck in my head is the phrase "The Calyx subtends the Corolla" the calyx is often composed of sepals, those green bracts that are below the yellow part of the tomato flower and are often persistent until the fruit is ripe.

Sympodia- Here my glossaries failed me, and though the term sounds vaguely familiar so did my brain, so Google says it relates to the main branching of a plant or primary shoot. So we have here a key break between 3.1, 3.2, and 3.3 where the Sympodia must have two, three or, or more than three leaves. For now, I assume this means the primary shoot and its leaf count. Ideally keys come with their own, key specific glossary!

Corolla- The typically showy part of the flower, in tomatoes typically the yellow petals.

Inflorescence- the whole flowering stalk though it can include as few as a single flower.

Bracts- Any (typically) green leafy structure is usually considered to be some form of bract, and it isn't uncommon for

Anthers- These are the yellow structures, often fused or attached into a cone, that produce pollen- the male part of the flower.

Dehiscent- this is basically referring to how and when and where the pollen escapes from the anthers.

Longitudinal (in this case slits)- some of the species have anthers where the pollen escapes from long slits in the anther.

Erect- an upright plant that supports itself. Like a person standing up.

Spreading- a plant that doesn't support itself. Like a person lying down.

Congested- this just means crowded, like lots of flowers crowded together.

Pubescence- hairy or fuzzy

Bifurcate- forked, like a branch that forks.

Glandular- makes sticky stuff! In the case of glandular hairs, this often means there is a droplet on the hairs visible with a magnifying glass, hand lens, or dissecting microscope. Or if you have a bit of a geological or jeweler bent a loup.

Terminal (in this case pores) - In this case another type of exit for pollen on anthers. So look for the openings or pores on the upper tip of the anthers.

Zygomorphic- an irregular flower that isn't radially symmetrical.

Pedicel the little stalk on an individual flower

Articulation- a joint or node which naturally separates. So I see here "Pedicel articulation basal" so I would expect that when that fruit falls that the whole pedicel comes off with it at the base of the pedicel.

Basal- the base or bottom of something, the very base of a stem or stalk or pedicel.

Puberulous- a very slight short fuzziness

Pubescent- short soft hairs

Glabrous- no hairs

Succulent- fleshy leaves especially found in plants like cactus and sedums which often grow in very dry environments.

Entire- the simplest form of a leaf margin, just a nice smooth leaf margin.

Elliptic- a leaf shape where the leaf is widest in the middle and both ends are equal- one of the simplest types of leaf.

Lanceolate- A leaf with a shape a lot like a lance, should be much longer than wide, widest toward the base, and tapering towards the tip.

Leaflets- Anatomically when the big leaf is divided into a lot of little leaves. Each of these is usually not a leaf in its own right, but is technically a small subdivision of a larger leaf.

Scabrous- a sort of a scratchy rough texture, we have an important elk forage grass locally with "scabrella" as its specific epithet.

Smooth Velvety- this is the opposite texture for the scabrous above. A soft smooth texture.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

https://www.worldfloraonline.org/taxon/wfo-0001026299

The above is the first botanical description I came to when I searched just now for a description for Solanum arcanum.

Keys are great, but floras are better than field keys and one of the reasons for that is that a true flora will have also descriptions. So this worldfloraonline.org seems to have descriptions- at least for Solanum arcanum.

Descriptions are an important part and step of properly keying out a plant. Once you have reached an answer in a key- you go to the description and you check your answer against it. If everything in the description seems correct- then you can be assured that your answer is correct.

However, an aside to that is: this newfangled internet! You can simply look up almost any plant, find reference photos others have identified, and then compare the photos to your specimen.

However, we may frequently get into the weird territory of interspecies hybrids with the worldwide diaspora of tomato accessions. A interspecies hybrid may not key properly- and when compared to a description shouldn't quite fit. If it clearly has morphological variation that comes from two discrete species you might be able to, by a process of comparison, determine that it is likely a morphological hybrid between say Solanum arcanum and Solanum lycopersicum.   
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#8
A few tomatoes that might be nice to subject to morphological identification:

The Solanum chilense accession from Sacred Succulents- they thought it likely Solanum chilense: put through a rigorous ID process would we concur?

Golden Tressette: Alan Kapuler thought this a three species hybrid that arose in his garden: is there morphological evidence still to support this claim? (Note: I say still because even if on extant material there isn't, it is also plausible that there was on early filial generations before traits fully segregated).

Coyote: does it key to pimpinillifolium? Is the fruit too big? If the fruit isn't too big, does the plant really match the species description? Offhand I suspect it is of older interspecies hybrid origin- but what can the morphology tell us?

Any wild tomato species found from a commercial source that isn't identified back to a particular accession. Or any commercial source accession still sporting an older name- particularly a name from before the most recent taxanomic revisions. Or any named accession of a wild species that seems like it might be off-type. These aren't necessarily bad germplasm, especially since any wild germplasm can sometime be very hard to find, but it would be nice to know what we are dealing with- at least as far as plant morphology can inform us.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days