Vermont Short & Sweet Tomato Project

Started by Cathy A, 2023-03-03, 08:39:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

#75
Here is my end of season summary of year 1 of the Vermont Short & Sweet tomato project.

The varieties I see as most promising for 2024 are:
- Dwarf Eagle Smiley (sweet, lots of fruit per plant, upright plants are medium sized and healthy)
- Krainy Sever (lots of fruit on one small plant, very "fruit dense")
- Alaska (high amounts of medium-sized fruit)
- Sungold F1 (sweet, high productivity)
- Bicolor Wilding Panamorous (1 selected strain)

Varieties that may have potential, but were not my top picks:
- Jagodka, Joseph's strain (large fruit, high seed production)
- Siberian Red (very early)
- Glacier (early)
- Nevsky (large fruit, late)
- Sungold F2 (3 selected strains - plum, bright orange, sweet)

Varieties that were generally disappointing in my garden (but may do well elsewhere) were:
- Mission Mountain Rising (Mission Mountain Morning x Aztek Blue F2); died early, apparently low disease resistance
- Big Hill; didn't get many edible tomatoes relatively to the large plant size, though I think the wet season messed it up

Varieties with specific problems:
- Uluru Ochre; three plants all produced healthy stems, leaves, and blossoms, but zero fruit
- Olena Ukrainian; tall, indeterminate plants, but extremely low fruit production
- Sub-Arctic; wrong growth habit for my goals

Wildling Panamorous was a special case. I wasn't necessarily expecting them all to be great, and figured I would have to do serious selecting and culling. However, I was expecting a lot more variety in flavor, color, and possibly shape. Instead, they all had standard lycopene taste. They left me wondering if a lot of selection has already been done on them in the last couple of years, removing most of the interesting, unusual flavors (good and bad)? They also were more prone to blossom end rot than anything else trialed, except for the lone bicolor plant.

New varieties I will trial next year include:
- Q series
- Black cherry
- Sweet 100
- Neandermato
- Fuzzy mix (from tienchiu)

and repeats from last year:
- Sungold F1
- Sungold F3 (plum, possibly a cross)
- Sungold F3 (sweet, dark orange, splitting)
- Sungold F3 (firm, bright orange)
- Dwarf Eagle Smiley
- Krainy Sever
- Alaska
- Bicolor Wildling
- Siberian Red
- Jagodka (Joseph's)

I'm planning large quantities of some varieties, intending to try a lot of crossing, while other will only be a few plants to trial again and contribute to the crossing attempts.


Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-10-25, 01:36:04 PMNew varieties I will trial next year include:
- Q series

Do you get late blight? If so, you might want to consider the BH series.

William Schlegel

#77
Exciting, good work. Still find it interesting that Krainiy Sever and Dwarf Eagle Smiley are also winners for you. I made a single 2023 cross with each of them, I should have some F2 seed to share at the end of the 2024 growing season. 

Also, interesting that Big Hill and its grandchild Mission Mountain Rising aka (Mission Mountain Morning x Aztek) did not. I've crossed Mission Mountain Morning's descendants with some more disease resistant tomatoes now, but locally there isn't much tomato disease, so I don't expect locally bred tomatoes to be strongly selected for disease resistance. Probably best for me to transfer some of those crosses to folks who do have disease pressures at early generations such as the F2.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

#78
I only grew a single Big Hill plant, and this was an unusually wet year. So it's possible that it was just bad luck. The few fruits that it produced tasted fine and produced seeds, but many went bad before harvest, or fell to the ground on their own.

MMR appeared to be more vulnerable than anything else. Three separate plants were all the first variety to turn brown and die out, while surrounded by healthy tomatoes of other varieties. The fruit they produced look interesting, but with so little disease resistance they won't work for me. Could still be good crossing material for someone else, and if crossed with something with disease resistance, I would be happy to try them again. The fruits were lovely!

When all my tomatoes turn brown and soft, stem, leaves, and all, I assume that's late blight. It has never prevented me from getting a decent crop of tomatoes before dieback, so I haven't worried about it. This year, however, I lost practically my entire tomato patch when there was still plenty of warm weather that could have produced fruit, so I paid a price.

I think the best solution here may be to plant the first wave of tomatoes in late May, which is the normal planting time, and another batch 3 - 4 weeks later. The second batch would be in a different bed, not near the first one. Then when late blight takes down the first patch, the second may still be producing.

Why do I think this will work?  Because the Sungold F1 plants happened to be planted a couple of weeks late,just because I didn't get around to buying and planting them until then, and they avoided the brown-and-mushy problem. I just pulled the mostly green, healthy, and fruit-producing Sungold F1's about an hour ago because we expect repeated frosts next week, and I needed to put the lid back on the cold frame, which couldn't be done until they were pulled.

I don't think Sungold F1 has strong vertical resistance to blight, though. If it did, at least one of the many Sungold F2's that I planted would have retained that resistance, and none did. I think it was the late planting that made the difference.

William Schlegel

I have made some crosses specifically for late blight and other tomato diseases in 2022 and 2023 now. However, I think if something is to come of them they need to be selected in someone's garden who has those regularly.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

I am now looking for tomatoes resistant to Alternaria, pretty sure it's A. alternata causing the trouble with tomatoes here, as A. solani is pretty much confined to leaves, and the telltale ring spots on a number of other plants in the garden also suggests the multi-hosted mother-of-blight.
This seems to be the tomato disease of the future here at my site for sure, with hot and humid weather being the trigger, and now we are getting that weather persistently for weeks on end.
As with your blight, Kathy, the timing is everything.  I had one later plant from the seedlings that volunteered in the greenhouse, which turned out to be a Skipper cross from the garden, and going down with disease depended heavily on the point of plant maturity under the right conditions for the disease.  Only a couple of my F2s seemed able to ripen fruit and continue setting without succombing to blight on the stems, which is deadly. The sunscald was bad enough, and they all lost plenty of leaves.  So for sure, I have to breed for resistance if I want to get a crop under changing climate conditions.
I've never seen late blight here, so no possibility of selecting for that resistance.
I did notice though, that a lot of seasoned growers had difficult year in 2023 with one disease or another.  A lot of blight in other parts of Canada as well as the States.
Definitely a good time to get some great OP flavors into some more disease resistant plants.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-10-28, 12:13:36 PMI am now looking for tomatoes resistant to Alternaria

I thought I remembered a page on the TGRC website where it lists all the accessions (I know of wild species but maybe domestic to?) for each kind of disease resistance. I just spent ages looking for it for you searching in various ways, but no luck, sorry!

How about Joseph's tomatoes - are they good against early blight?

Diane Whitehead

Kathy wrote that all her tomatoes "turn brown and soft, stem, leaves, and all" and she thinks that is late blight.

It's been quite a few years since I've had late blight but my plants never did that.  Maybe it was because I removed them as soon as I saw the first symptom, which was usually a rough patch on the fruit.  The disease appeared with the first rain, which usually occurs in September, though not till October this year.  Tomatoes under cover did not get blight.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

#83
I wish I was better at tomato pathology. I would struggle to ID the diseases if I had any important ones. Still if there are tomatoes that do better those are the ones to save seed from and breed with.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I could easily be wrong about the nature of the disease that killed the tomatoes.

The symptoms were the leaves shrivelled and fell off, the stalks became and stopped supporting themselves and the fruit.

Look at the MMR tomato in this picture:

MMM x Aztek F2 dying 8-4-23.jpg

Eventually the whole patch succumbed to that. The MMR were just the first to go.

To what would you attribute that?

Garrett Schantz

With Joseph's tomatoes and the like, I've noticed a few issues with blight.

Earlier generations or ones crossed back to wild types, seem more resistant to blight.


I believe that Joseph and some others just lack or lacked a large form of selective pressure for blight resistance.


It can be lost in backcrosses, the resistance / resistances.



I believe that some people are working more on stabilizing some resistances in their own populations.

Which can naturally happen due to selective pressures elsewhere.



Since moving to Mississippi, I've noticed Solanum carolinense grows wild here.

The leaves develop powdery mildew, yellowed leaves. And aphids then attack the plants.


Then, they decide to go after related species once those die.


With my cuttings that I took of some tomatoes before moving from the rental property. Squirrels and things have been trying to burrow in the planter. Two seedlings never really took off due to constant attacks.


These other two, I made sure that they weren't leaning on one another.


One, I can't quite remember what I planted there. It may be Island Sunrise.


I got that awhile back. I've grown it a few times. It seems fairly disease resistant. Obviously it's still fruiting despite issues.


The other plant, taller one. That would be a Exserted Tiger. It's also doing OK.


I didn't take cuttings of these at an optimal time. And plants that I took cuttings from, were already planted out too late.


Either way, they almost immediately had issues after being established. Drought and heat, for one.

Plus chipmunks.


I'm unsure of what the exact diseases here are, at the top of my head.



Anyways. Joseph's population, when I grew it in Pennsylvania.


There are some plants which suffered from blight worse than even known susceptible varieties that I grew.


Others outgrew blight.


J&L Gardens, sells a few wild crosses which also outgrow blight and it doesn't spread or seem as noticeable on them right away.



Anyways, the point is. If you're getting Joseph's Wildling or other groups, I'd expect a lot of them to die if there's serious blight around.

I'd also recommend against growing them all too closely together. At least until you create your own resistant population.


Aphids seemed to love some of those wild crosses, others they wouldn't touch.


So. They could act as a large disease vector and you'd lose anything that's resistant. So, I'd let them have space and whatnot.



I'm now in Mississippi, rather than Pennsylvania. But, early tomatoes are still pretty cool.



Garrett Schantz

I was very interested in cold tolerant tomatoes and the like.

Saraev-M22 does fine.


https://www.bestcoolseeds.com/collections/tomatoes-1/products/tomato-sub-arctic-25-453-outdoor-greenhouse

https://www.bestcoolseeds.com/collections/tomatoes-1/products/tomato-polar-beauty-organic-seed-573-outdoor-greenhouse

https://www.bestcoolseeds.com/collections/tomatoes-1/products/tomato-stupice-443-outdoor-garden-patio-greenhouse

https://www.bestcoolseeds.com/collections/tomatoes-1/products/tomato-stupice-443-outdoor-garden-patio-greenhouse



My first time on that site, I purchased some of the listed tomatoes.


These are grown and produced in Alaska. This is related the Denali seed company, which went out of business in 2017, after their founder died. It started in 1977.

They packed seeds in Michigan and may have grown the actual seed stock there. I don't really know.


I did see Alaska and some other tomatoes listed here.


Best Cool Seeds sounded like a scam site to me at first.


Either way. If anyone thinks some of the tomatoes seem familiar, they're relatives in programs of parents used to create some cold tolerant tomatoes, some of which were mentioned here.


These are hard to find.



If anyone's interested, I put some links up.


They all tasted a bit bland to me. Granted, I don't like red tomatoes.

Steph S

It's impossible to tell, Kathy, from the picture.  Or at least, I couldn't get a closeup look for detail. It's usually easier to tell at early stages of disease.
Alternaria has a characteristic ring spot, distinctive and easy to tell.  I'll post some pics in my thread before winter is out.
It's easy enough to select for 'disease resistance' in general but also handy to know what you've got, sometimes it can make a difference.  And especially for picking up plants that have been bred for resistance to add to the brew.

Thanks for looking for me, @Justin Jardinier.  I have a couple of lists now for resistant leaf, stem, or both, so the question will be which of the best ones I can easily get for next season. 

Diane Whitehead

It would be useful to have a separate section of the forum with photos of diseases.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Joseph Lofthouse

Make a list of about 50 threads about diseases, and I'll create a forum for them.