Delicious pimpinellifolium x pennellii

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-09-30, 05:41:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I made a pimpinellifolium x pennellii cross earlier this year and have grown out the F1 and just tasted the fruit. Here's how it looks:
pimp x pen.jpg

I'm surprised how good it tastes - sweet and tasty distinctly like wheat germ. The texture was also good, maybe similar to blueberry, rather soft and the seedy part rather mushy, rather than the more distinct separation of watery + firm. Do F1s of lyc x pen taste so good like this? I didn't make any lyc x pen but am now rather regretting that - this taste in a larger fruit could be great. So I'm curious, if lyc x pen F1 does taste this good, will some of the F2 also? Or asked in another way, since I heard the journey for lyc x hab breeding is very long to get good taste, is the journey with lyc x pen much shorter?

I haven't liked the taste of any wild green tomato species. And I had heard stories of wild green crosses not tasting good until down to 25%. So I am curious if this is just something unusual about pimp x pen specifically, or if lyc x pen can taste good also at higher percentages. I'd love to hear about experiences with crossing with pennellii.

William Schlegel

I have never managed a cross with the strain of penellii Joseph has and shared with me. It may be SC with itself though.

Andrew got some F1 lyc x penellii hybrid seed from TGRC distributed as a root stock. So I only ever grew one plant of the F1 when Andrew sent me a single seed. I did not taste the fruit. I am a bit afraid to try the green species. Joseph crossed it into his project.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#2
Oh, I'm surprised Joseph didn't use pure pennellii for crossing! This cross was also with SC pennellii but I have some other accessions that are relatively early and SI, I'm wondering about maybe trying to make an SI (or even just largely outcrossing UI would maybe fit the goal, perhaps even better than SI) edible population with them, though only 1 has sticky leaves so I might focus on that one as the sticky trait might be useful against pests?

When I tasted some other green wild species, maybe on multiple occasions, I got a headache soon after. This was from just tasting a little, not even whole fruits, though I am not certain if it was causation or just correlation, too few data points to be sure.

I was also curious about the percentage of wild heritage in Joseph's tomatoes. The most I remember him writing was '33%' but he didn't specify which of his tomatoes he was talking about, though he did say Q series has less than Wilding, so far as I remember. I was guessing that maybe 33% wild was for the Wildings and less for the other lines like Q series etc... So was it something like this for the Wilding?
([lyc x hab] x lyc) x [lyc x pen]?

That would give 37.5% wild:
lyc 62.5%
pen 25%
hab 12.5%

Or...
{([lyc x pen] x [hab]) x [lyc x hab]} x lyc

That would be 31.25% wild:
lyc 68.75%
pen 6.25%
hab 25%

Or....
{[lyc x hab] x ([lyc x pen] x lyc)} x [lyc x hab]?

Hmm, but that would give 43.75% wild:
lyc 56.25%
pen 6.25%
hab 37.5%

Sorry if any of that maths was wrong...

AndrewB

#3
I'll try to track down Joseph's map of his crosses that he posted on Permies.

But the pennellii x domestic hybrid that was originally used was LA4135. The one William is referring to is LA4488. LA4488 was never used in the project but it has superior disease resistance genetics compared to LA4135, which is something that may be critical for future success of this project in my mind.

Further grow outs of LA4135 have been hit heavily with blight or other diseases here from potato plants.

Here is a photo of the F2 grow out of LA4135. Not really that tasty. Not putrid, but not really appetizing.





Source:
https://keen101.wordpress.com/2018/02/01/wild-galapagos-island-tomatoes-and-the-secrets-of-diverse-wild-tomato-species/

Garrett Schantz

When I tried a Pimpinellifolium cross with Habrochaites before, it was with "Wild Currant Tomato From Peru."

I wanted two exserted wild sort of parents, the Pimpinellifolium had very smaller seeds and fruit.

I wanted material for crossing into other Solanum species.


Some Pimpinellifolium types lack any real flavor. I'm unsure if a straight lyco cross would do well or not.

Most pimpinellifolium types sold online, are small lyco currant tomatoes.


The Everglades tomato, and Matt's wild cherry are lyco.



Pretty nice to see something that tastes interesting.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-09-30, 01:17:11 PMMost pimpinellifolium types sold online, are small lyco currant tomatoes.

Yeah, I noticed the claimed pimps sold by HRSeeds seem to be maybe crossed with lyc at least, since the seed size is so much bigger than pure pimps. Mine are pure though. And I was not impressed by the taste of any of them. So so but I prefer lyc. I was a bit disappointed that all my pimp accessions showed late blight on the stems, since disease resistance was a main reason for using them. I should have been more selective in that regard since LB is such a big thing here.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-09-30, 11:36:49 AMBut the pennellii x domestic hybrid that was originally used was LA4135. The one William is referring to is LA4488.

I see LA4135 used pen LA0716. Coincidentally, that's the same accession I used in the cross I shared the photo of.

LA4488 also used the same pen accession. It would make sense to me to just use LA0716 directly, cross it with a lyc specifically suited to ones need, then select the next generations in under the specific disease pressures of ones target area. Maybe even cross it with something like Galahad, which is homozygous ph-2 and ph-3.

Joseph Lofthouse


reed

The pimpinellifolium that I grow taste great and make a huge harvest of pea sized fruits. They randomly crossed with something a few years back and segregated into half a dozen shapes and colors that are all also very good. They do also have larger seeds than what I call the little pimps.

William Schlegel

I still have quite a bit of seed for LA4488 F2 I should grow it out again. I took a penellii pause for a few years to concentrate a bit. On LA2329 habrochaites mostly. Hard to keep up with the seed collection. I still haven't made the progress I really want with the LA2329 project.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#10
Yeah from the chart and without keeping track of crosses, it makes sense it would be hard to calculate! Although it does clarify that there was no [lyc x pen] x hab but there was [lyc x pen] x lyc and [lyc x pen] x [lyc x hab]. (N.B. I mean those without specifying which was mother in either cross).

Just now looking up Big Hill to see what that was (I see it seems to be a lyc?) I finally found the maths I had seen ages ago and until now been unable to find!

QuoteWildling Interspecies Hybrid Swarm
If you would like to explore the tomato genome for sweet, fruity tasting fruits, this would be an excellent place to start! 3rd to 4th generation seeds from crosses between domestic tomatoes (50%) and Solanum habrochaites (~35%) or S pennellii (~15%). These are part of the polyamorous, and panamorous tomato breeding project. The end goal of this project is beautifully promiscuous tomatoes.
It's from 2019, here: https://lofthouse.com/seed-list-2019.phtml

So if the pen:hab proportion has stayed more or less constant and only the amount of lyc increasing since then, that answers my main curiosity about that which was really that proportion. So if that's so, going by your more recent calculation I guess they may be around 10% pen and 23% hab? Not that the exact amount is important, and anyway percentage of heritage doesn't equate to percentage of genes since selection may tend to increase lyc percentage. But it's still quite interesting. The best tasting tomatoes I ate this year were some wildings and some of Lee Goodwin's hab crosses. It's interesting that these all have LA1777 parentage. I'd still be interested to see how higher percentage pen populations might taste though. Especially if it could lead to a UI (and additionally optionally SI) population. I've been thinking more about UI recently. I feel like being unable to receive SC pollen whilst being at least largely outcrossing, may be more important for my aims than being merely SI whilst being able to receive SC pollen. So as to be protected against dilution from other domestic tomato populations. I wonder maybe even with SC pennellii, if a largely outcrossing UI population could be established. I have some chmielewskii crosses too, and it would be cool if they end up as a largely outcrossing UI population like their father species. Some of my arcanum F1 crosses are looking like they're SI and UI, I'm really hoping to bring those traits through to an F2 population. Having multiple full or mostly outcrossing populations that can't cross with each other nor be mothers for lyc, is looking more and more attainable.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-09-30, 04:11:34 PMI still have quite a bit of seed for LA4488 F2 I should grow it out again.

What were the leaves like? Did they have the stickiness/oiliness of the father? I'm curious if that is connected to its disease resistance.

Diane Whitehead

I've grown polyamorous, and panamorous but now there are references to "Elites".  What are they?
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

The two lyc x penellii hybrids, had some penellii like features. Unfortunately it has been too long since I grew them out to remember fine details.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

QuoteAlthough it does clarify that there was no [lyc x pen] x hab

Those crosses were made, they just don't show up on the simplified pedigree. Each of the dots on the previously uploaded pedigree represents between 5 and 20 mother plants. The lines representing pollen flow should likewise be multiplied by that amount.

I estimate that in my currently most elite populations, that the concentration of pennellii genes exceeds that of habrochaites. I figure that they are about equal in the other populations.

Early on, I selected for a population that was obviously 3-species hybrids.

By "elite" I mean seeds that are the best, of the best, of the best, which are in such limited quantity that I can only share a tiny amount of seed with the closest collaborators. A year or two later, after we grow out a large quantity of seed, then we share those elites with the world, but by then, my personal best is already 2 generations ahead of what I'm currently sharing with the general public.





Justin Jardinier

#14
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-09-30, 11:13:53 PMI estimate that in my currently most elite populations, that the concentration of pennellii genes exceeds that of habrochaites. I figure that they are about equal in the other populations.

Ah I see, thanks! I had a couple that tasted of mango/papaya, really nice. I wonder if that might be due to pen! One had extreme exsertion but unfortunately extremely susceptible to late blight (and I did not make any deliberate self compatibility test on it unfortunately), the other was the one extremely resistant to late blight but inserted and definitely able to receive SC pollen and only produced 3 fruits by itself (surrounded by SC and SI plants), and 5 hand pollinated (with SC produced seeds, with arc produced no seeds). I don't think I kept notes of the cross attempts to the highly exserted one - so much going on and I have mainly only been keeping notes of crosses once I've harvested the fruits, most of which were lost to blight on that one. But anyway both of these might continue their line usefully next year in crosses.

I've been much more systematic about SI/SC testing with the arc crosses I'm now growing out though, making a crossing chart for all of them to check exactly what's compatible with what, including crossing them back to arc both ways and for receiving per pollen too. It's quite a bit of work to be so systematic! But I figure it will be quite a speedy way for attempting to make an SI population. One of them is so far not making fruit with pollen from anything I try, nor pollinating anything I try! It's such a beautiful plant so I am persisting.

Surprisingly, a pimp x arc attempt gave many seeds, I forget, maybe 11? That made me suspect it had selfed - I'd expect only 1 or 2 lucky seeds max. Growing 3 out, at least 1 was SC which made me think yeah must have been selfed. But, the fruits are bigger than pimp and maybe bigger than arc also! So I am paying attention to them. Also they can't pollinate 2 of my 3 main SI arc crosses (1 hasn't made new flowers since this one flowered so I am still waiting to test that, and a 4th promising one is yet to make its first flowers so hasn't been tested at all - 2 other thought-to-be crosses are giving indications they aren't actually crosses, and 1 more had so many seeds I expected it was not a cross but have now germinated a few seeds to check). Perhaps they accidentally got pollinated by something else... I will see when the fruits are ripe I guess, if they stay green or yellow I think I'm in luck.