Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project

Started by AndrewB, 2021-04-23, 09:42:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Interesting cherry whatever it came from. I don't remember one like it with this combination of traits so it segregated from something even if just something so simple as Blue Ambrosia crossing back to a Sungold. Blue Ambrosia is Lee Goodwin's Ambrosia dehybridization of sungold crossed to a blue tomato. I played with it a lot in 2017 to 2019 because 4 out of five plants I planted in 2017 had extreme exsertion of the stigma. So I daubed pollen from a wide variety of tomatoes on those stigmas.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-09-03, 08:19:17 PMThis variant though- I already saved a tiny bit of seed to which I will add the two tresses I picked tonight. Separately though. Hmm. Mysterious tomatoes!

Reminds me of one of my galapagense:
IMG_5045.jpg

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Maf on 2023-09-04, 04:56:58 PMYes indeed, Aft and atv, which have a synergystic effect in combination? Different genes/traits but both related to anthocyanin production...


I mentioned this elsewhere, but Peruvianum supposedly has genes which aren't either of those two.


Nor are they the same genes on different chromosomes.



I'm probably going to cross Purple Smudge over to Sart Roloise or something with full antho coverage - both of the anthocyanin genes which give full coverage in domestic tomatoes.



I've tried presenting a few mentions from the creators of Indigo Rose, which pretty much confirm that Purple Smudge doesn't have any of the purple genes found in Chilense, Galapagense or other sorts of tomatoes.

They specifically mention it having a Peruvianum anthocyanin gene.



My research on finding what genes give Peruvianum any anthocyanin traits, usually brings me over to studies that talk about bioprocessors.

They mention that stress can create higher antho fruits. Temperature changes.

I think watering had a place in those studies as well.


Different bio synthesizers than related species or something.




Two people I've brought this subject up to, usually say that it has Aft - the other mentioned that it has no wild genes and it was created with novel something.



I did confirm that from older studies that Purple Smudge was created using Solanum peruvianum, and a ton of backcrosses.

Some older hybrids seem to have the whole "backcross this a ton of times until it's disease resistant or probably is."



I also had issues with Purple Smudge accepting any pollen from Muddy Waters and some other varieties when I first grew it.

Indigo Rose was only sold as numerical numbers back then, and there wasn't a ton of Antho tomatoes around at the time. I didn't wanna purchase what was a stolen or leaked variety either.



It took like a year or two after I grew those before a ton of antho varieties popped out of the woodwork.




Either way, if I can cross Purple Smudge and Sart Roloise - I could then select for antho traits from both varieties or see if they're the same or similar.

If these have the same antho trait, plants may self abort because having the same antho gene on different chromosomes can be fatal.



Some antho traits also seem to gain deeper colors when exposed to a lot of cold. The Purple color then lasts late into the year and on later growth. Plus it stunts the plants.



Burnley Bounty has a late flowering or daylight sensitive gene.

It's also an older Peruvianum cross. Probably with a different parent than Purple Smudge.

Payette has been mentioned elsewhere.



Most people seem to just grow things out or try a single cross and see if things act better as bridges or not.


Peruvianum seems to be a species, it's first generation offspring and some others, won't easily accept pollen from it. Or they get random mixes of genes from it.



I believe that these varieties probably have some genes that could up the chances of being pollinated by Peruvianum. But they probably lost some things here and there that would've helped that happen.



I may or may not grow out Double Rich and Payette.


I want Burnley Bounty and Purple Smudge mixed into a wild line as well.

Probably using multiple backcrosses.


And I'd like them to have exserted flowers.


Burnley Bounty mixed with a descendant of Orange Hill or something similar in a wild line, would act as a decent base material.



Purple Smudge, is already orange. So there's that.





There are also Purple fruited Solanum muricatum.


Pepinos are probably just as related to tomatoes as Solanum lycopersicoides is, or something like that.


So, I still have a goal of planting some of its wild relatives next to each other, and growing out hybrids and things near wild tomato crosses.



Most of the tropical flavors that people usually look for, are already found in Pepinos.



I'm hoping to grow these sort of things next year finally. Pepinos.

Purple pepinos have been hard to source in the United States.

And I'm assuming that they have a different form of anthocyanin gene than tomatoes or their relatives. I could be wrong. I can't find much of anything on their antho genes.




Unfortunately pepinos still aren't Purple on the inside of them.










William Schlegel

The quart bag on the right is the promiscuous project bag. The bag on the left is four ounces of my grex. So guessing I got about four ounces worth of the promiscuous as well.

Question now is if I should save any more seed or what the demand will be for promiscuous mix for the Going to Seed group.

One ounce is typically enough for a tomato variety unless it is very popular.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Slight Antho?! Might be The One x MM? In the F1?!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Purple / chocolate from the project.

Dark green shoulders.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

Has anyone grown Epstein's Big Zac Tomato, or Steakhouse hybrid (it has another name in Europe if I remember correctly)?

These would be 2.5 - 4lb tomatoes.

Some of them can still have heavy production, despite their sizes.


Phil's Two, has Reisetomate genetics and would probably give a large tomato if crossed into one of these super sized ones. But I don't think it would work too well for general purposes.



I haven't been able to think of a huge reasoning to breed for larger tomatoes, as most people use them for sandwiches, which other tomatoes can serve that purpose.



But, the Get Stuffed tomato, and Douchoua Pepper tomato, are pretty hollow inside. Those, I also don't view in a good light. They're too small to use for stuffing.



Has anyone here thought of encorporating these into a Promiscuous line and creating large stuffing tomatoes? I'd imagine that some wild genetics could also create stronger structures to hold up larger fruits.

Cathy A

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-09-08, 08:13:52 PMPurple / chocolate from the project.

Dark green shoulders.

That looks similar to a single tomato plant from the Wildling Panamorous line. My chocolate color was only seen close to the skin, but this could be random non-genetic variation.

I saved seeds from this plant separately.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-09-09, 06:22:51 AMPhil's Two, has Reisetomate genetics and would probably give a large tomato if crossed into one of these super sized ones. But I don't think it would work too well for general purposes.



Definitely not. Having grown Phil's Two this year, I find it has the same problem Reisentomate has, the different segments ripen at different times, so harvesting one without losing some tov either under or overripeness is hard (they connections are not so tenuous as to allow you to pluck off segments as they are ready, you'll still have more than enough open tomato flesh to let bacteria and molds get in before the wound suberizes).

Garrett Schantz

Yeah, that's the problem I've had with Reisetomate in the past.

Its cool as something to grab portions from, and carry around like that, or to wait for it all to ripen after tearing pieces off.

It also increases the size of the "tomato."

But for a standard tomato, or wanting to increase fruit size, it wouldn't work too well.


With Reisetomate, I'd always have to give fruits a wiggle rather than pull them off - they don't always detatch very well, like you mentioned.


Phil's Two, I may just grow out for fun.



But yeah, a large tomato may work well as a stuffer, if it's hollow.

A hollow tomato that's large, also may not take up as much energy as a meaty one.


Some XL tomatoes, only get a few tomatoes per plant, and need a ton of support.

Hollow tomatoes also may mean lighter tomatoes as well.

Garrett Schantz

Oscar Pearson Hard Fruit Tomato, I grew that at some point.

That was a longer lasting tomato.

I don't think it grew well for me or something.

I'll have to check if I have seed, but I don't think I have that anymore.



That had a thick skin, many people call tomatoes like that "storage tomatoes", there's a series of tomatoes which was bred in a similar way.

I can't quite remember the name.



I was thinking a bit more, and a tomato with thicker skin, and is hollow, plus huge.

Those may all pair well together.


I don't have a list of tomatoes like that variety though. And there are varieties from Oscar Pearson, but they aren't the hard fruit type.



I'm considering a newer line to add into the project. Why not.


Maybe it'll peak some peoples interest and more people will come over.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2020-02-07, 05:12:55 PMAlso found dwarf hirsutum cross saved seed but it has super inserted flowers so I doubt it will produce any crosses. I think also I would be happy with one plant of that. I think I just want to grow a plant or so of Wild Child, Dwarf Hirsutum Cross, and Weight in Gold basically for comparative purposes between the three and with our high percentage habrochaites projects. They are all stabilized high percentage habrochaites red domestic types from Lee Goodwin's J and L gardens.

Hi William! Just came across this bit you wrote. I have been really curious how much wild percentage parentage Lee's wild cross tomatoes have but have been unable to find any info on it. How do you know they are high percentage? And any idea of roughly how much?

Thanks!

William Schlegel

#207
I was just going off the limited info on Lee's website. I don't know for sure.

From my own experiences working with Joseph's crosses and now my own. We got the first elites when Joseph brought the percentage down to 25%.

So last year I brought the percentage down on my first crosses with LA2329 to ~25%. Turns out only one plant of that lineage produced seed. (I'm using the ~ symbol to indicate its not quite 25% as one parent was elites from Joseph's promiscuous project). I suspect some elites might segregate out from thr saved seed next year.

I made subsequent ~12.5% crosses and those are now in seed packets. Next year I hope for some elites from those as well.

My new 2023 grown F2 plants between Joseph's promiscuous project and LA2329 produced no elites but there is variation for fruit size and degree of non-green color expression when ripe. I might actually be producing some seed with back crossing to habrochaites by not isolating that material. I've just been saving the F3 and F2 seed as a mix this year since I made the cross two years in a row in 2021 and 2022.

Unfortunately except for one new 25% cross my F1 Big Hill x LA2329 and F1 MMM x LA2329 have produced no seed. Presumably self incompatible and not compatible with each other as I isolated them from the promiscuous x LA2329. The 25% cross may segregate out some elites in 2025.

I do have a new F1 exserted orange x LA2329 sitting on my desk, picked yesterday. That will be my 2024 replacement for the Big Hill and MMM crosses.

I'm still very curious about habrochaites cross breeding and it takes a lot of space in my garden but is a very long term project. I think I am working both angles. 1. Trying to up the habrochaites percentage which I think may be very long term. 2. Trying to reduce the percentage to try to recover very palatable strains faster.

I think past works of Lee Goodwin and Joseph Lofthouse may aid in the first idea. By crossing them in instead of those with none we might get to a higher percentage faster. However, this also conflicts with other goals like getting what I think of as fancy traits into the mix such as stripes and blue skin. It is disheartening to see percentages drop way down with subsequent crossing.

The 50% habrochaites plants currently in my garden are huge and very habrochaites like in appearance both the F1 and F2 plants. Past plants from Josephs crosses were similar. Pure habrochaites plants can also be quite large. I think that if such plants could be bred to produce tasty tomatoes it could be quite an improvement in domestic tomato diversity.

Also just on another note, I wouldn't completely rule out low percentage wild hybrids as being significant. There was a paper which I found and shared awhile back- the wild introgressions are often actually quite large gene segments. When independent breeders without access to gene sequencing capabilities breed with wild species, somewhat regardless of pedigree, we don't really know how much of the wild we get unless there are specific visible observable traits we can track. Lee writes about fruits that drop on their own on at least one of his varieties. That is distinctly a wild species trait.

It would be interesting to work with researchers with those gene sequencing capabilities and see more about these lines. It could help to inform the utility of this hobby of crossing with the unpalatable wild species itself.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#208
The tasty off shoot of the promiscuous tomato project I started from two plants in 2021 I called The One and Little Pumpkins have segregated and or crossed into at least four perhaps five distinct types. Red, yellow, Orange, and a cherry. Probably some are bicolors for a fifth. Many have a blue blush- though none what I think of as full strength blue. So possibly just say maybe the aft gene or one set or a similar gene from habrochaites doing some slight expression.

The red could probably be split into pink and red.

I've just sorted some keepers into blue red, blue orange,  blue bicolor?, cherry with a hint of blue, and a yellow.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Sharing a photo of what is likely an ripe F1 Promiscuous x LA2329 tomato. F2 seed is now fermenting. It shows some blue skin pigment that very much comes from LA2329.

So this year current tomatoes with some blue, in both orange and red variants have shown up in three of the gardens where I was growing in part promiscuous project plants. I thought the first and tastiest was a likely wrong seed getting in but I am reevaluating that. They just might be variation arising within or from natural crossing with the project.

So I just put a little more seed from three of them, one from each garden, in to ferment.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days