Vermont Short & Sweet Tomato Project

Started by Cathy A, 2023-03-03, 08:39:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

#60
I tasted a Dwarf Eagle Smiley the other day, and I would rate it among the sweetest OP tomatoes I've had. I will aggressively save seeds from this variety and plant a full bed of them next year.

I harvested the last Krainy Sever fruit and saved as many seeds as possible. I plan to have at least half a bed of Krainy Sever in 2024.

I'm saving and isolating three different Sungold F3 seeds (produced by F2 plants). None of them produces as much fruit per plant as Sungold F1, none produces the large, sprawling plants of the F1, and none is as sweet as the F1. There is a case to be made for hybrid vigor in the original Sungold.

- One makes very firm, bright orange cherry tomatoes, although they lack the sweetness of Sungold.
- One orange cherry tomato is prone to skin-splitting, like the original F1, and is sweeter than my other F2 Sungold fruits.
- One is a plum tomato with fruit that is "reddish" (i.e., more red than Sungold F1), a little larger than Sungold F1 fruit, and not sweet. It may be an accidental cross.

Jagodka from EFN, which I am guessing is Joseph's strain as it has a different growth pattern from Earl's Jagodka, is a decent variety. It produces larger fruit than most of the other varieties being trialed, is red, and has a typical tomato taste. It also produces seeds in quantity.

I'm rejecting Earl's Jagodka and Sub Arctic Plenty for 2024, although I save seeds anywhere where I can. Both of these varieties lack any kind of upright growth habit and would need a lot of support to keep them off the ground.

Wildling is starting to produce more fruit, and I am tasting all of them. So far they all appear to be the typical lycopene flavor, not sweet or fruity. Many have blossom end rot or very misshapen fruit. I plan to cull most of these.

I will be tasting Alaska soon. The plant looks like it has potential, but I need to check the fruit first.

High-priority crosses to attempt in 2024 will be Sungold F1/Dwarf Eagle Smiley, Sungold F1/Krainy Sever, and Dwarf Eagle Smiley/Krainy Sever.  Has anyone made any of these already?

Cathy A

I harvested three Alaska tomatoes today. They are larger than cherries, more of a saladette size. All three show signs of splitting, but they still appear promising. I haven't tasted these yet. I would rate them as promising.

Alaska top:
Alaska top 8-19-23.jpg

Alaska bottom:
Alaska bottom 8-19-23.jpg 

Cathy A

This is a Big Hill fruit harvested today. I am not sure it is 100% ripe, but it feels soft enough to make me think it should be harvested.

Big Hill top
Big Hill top 8-19-23.jpg

Big Hill bottom. I think it is showing initial signs of blossom end rot.
Big Hill bottom 8-19-23.jpg 

Cathy A

This Dwarf Eagle Smiley was the sweetest tomato I have tasted this year, the plants are upright and productive, and the fruits generate plenty of seeds. I rate this one A+.

Dwarf Eagle Smiley fruit, uncut
Dwarf Eagle Smiley 8-19-23.jpg

Dwarf Eagle Smiley fruit, cut
Dwarf Eagle Smiley cut open 8-19-23.jpg

William Schlegel

#64
I finally made a cross with Krainy Sever this year. Also made a cross with Dwarf Eagle Smiley. Sungold comes into my Exserted Tiger tomatoes ancestry via Blue Ambrosia but the percentage is now low as I've made some new crosses with ET that would bring it down to 1/8th ancestry (with some guesstimating). I think those three are good breeding material too!

EFN Jagodka is definitely Joseph's strain. They've been selling a lot of his seed in recent years freeing up a lot of his time.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

I like the sound of Sungold crossed with Krainy Sever, after hearing your report on KS. 

Cathy A

I checked the Uluru Ochre again today, only to find that the blossoms noticed a few days ago have disappeared.

Either the plants are suffering from blossom drop in my wet summer with cool nights, or something (slugs? snails?) is eating the flowers.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-08-19, 07:20:38 AMWildling is starting to produce more fruit, and I am tasting all of them. So far they all appear to be the typical lycopene flavor, not sweet or fruity. Many have blossom end rot or very misshapen fruit. I plan to cull most of these.

Yeah I was expecting almost all of them to be orange, so I was surprised, I only managed to grow a few but they're almost all red. But I have a question about this - a couple of them I thought were going to be orange since the fruit turned from green to orange. But then from orange to red! Which made me wonder, are there tomatoes that are classed as orange but are... 'dark orange' which to most people would be a colour they'd call 'red'? I wonder because I also have an heirloom which is said to be 'pink' but I would say any normal person would call that colour 'red' also, not 'pink'. And I remember as a kid my school trousers were black but my mother insisted they were 'grey'. That's pretty damn dark grey!!! So I'm wondering if this is like that when it comes to 'orange' tomatoes?

William Schlegel

I'm not sure, but one thing is that bicolor tomatoes turn red eventually. If you take some bags full of Big Hill HX-9 you are growing for seed increase and let them sit too long they'll eventually turn red. Most of the project has some Big Hill ancestry and it seems to interact with the wild genes that bring out the orange. One copy two copies? Then they cross. So orange tomatoes, bicolor tomatoes seem to have red offspring the next year. They also seem to continue to segregate and there are a lot of red ones in some of these populations. My current grow out of Joseph Lofthouse's promiscuous tomato project I expect to have a lot of red as I left XL red in.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Re: orange fruit that turn red - this is characteristic of Beta/- fruit.  So if you are looking for orange, you should find some orange that stays orange in the offspring of those fruits, assuming Beta orange is in the Wilding population - which makes sense due to the involvement of wild relatives that carry Beta.

Justin Jardinier

#70
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-08-20, 07:54:30 AMI'm not sure, but one thing is that bicolor tomatoes turn red eventually. If you take some bags full of Big Hill HX-9 you are growing for seed increase and let them sit too long they'll eventually turn red.

Ah, I see! So then does this one class as a bicolour?
IMG_0415.jpg

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-08-20, 01:47:27 PMRe: orange fruit that turn red - this is characteristic of Beta/- fruit.  So if you are looking for orange, you should find some orange that stays orange in the offspring of those fruits, assuming Beta orange is in the Wilding population - which makes sense due to the involvement of wild relatives that carry Beta.

Would that change the taste? Oh and by the way, the brown parts of the leaves in that pic - any idea what's going on there? Some of my plants have a lot of that. Figured it maybe wasn't blight but wondering what it is. Some plants are looking pretty sad from it, on so many of their leaves, including some of the wilds. Some are looking fine.

That's a wilding. The Q series with the 'Brad spots', the ones I brought inside have also changed from orange to red.

Also has anyone done breeding with arcanum? I have some hybrids growing, both seem to be unable to self, which is nice. F1. One has fruit growing that I pollinated with arcanum, will be cool if I get seeds from that. I intend to grow out all my arcanum crosses and cross them all with each other in an attempt to get an SI population if possible. My indoor arcanum flower really easily in low light conditions, so, not sure how early they'll be but I'm thinking that it could be useful for low light climates, and perhaps they could do well in cold conditions too. And just had some pimp x pennelli flowers opening, they look just like pen flowers, but the leaves are different, and the stem is nicely thick. And some chmielewskii hybrids with that lovely chm. smell on the leaves - anyone here done breeding with chm.?

I'm also wondering, when making interspecies crosses, do you folk just grow them out for a few generations, or do you also cross them again straight away? I'm crossing some of them straight to lyc or other lyc-wild hybrids thinking that could be a good idea too.

William Schlegel

I judge if it is a bicolor by cutting an fruit in half to me bicolor is an interior flesh trait.

When Joseph did his initial crosses with habrochaites and the penellii hybrid Andrew obtained from TGRC I recall that we grew them out a few times which was difficult and then he crossed them back to domestic grew out a large population and then we got the elites.

So when I started another round of crossing to habrochaites LA2329 I crossed back to domestic in the F1. Though this has led me to precisely one reproductive 1/4 LA2329 plant so far. I have two others that survived but haven't produced any offspring yet. I made some crosses from that plant as well.

Krainiy Sever turns orange then red https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Krainiy_Sever though in its case it isn't ripe at orange.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-08-22, 06:01:58 AMI judge if it is a bicolor by cutting an fruit in half to me bicolor is an interior flesh trait.

Ah in this case this I guess would class as red - it's red inside. So that makes most of my wildings and Q series red. Have 1 elite that's quite a lighter shade of red and tastes almost like mango! Haven't seen any evidence yet of any of the elites being SI in terms of not being able to receive SC pollen - 1 of them seemed to form almost not a single tomato aside from the ones I pollinated with SC pollen, so I wonder if perhaps not fertilising themselves has been tricking someone into thinking they're SI in that sense? Though my data set is very small, so, can't judge too much. But I think the best and maybe only real way to judge that kind of SI is really to do proper testing, i.e. isolate some flowers to check if can self-pollinate, isolate some others and use SC pollen, and then others with known SI pollen. When I brought this up elsewhere, it seemed nobody had actually done any such testing, but I can't see how that's not essential for an SI project.

Cathy A

Interesting. I thought this Wildling was a bicolor, but when cut open it is mostly red.

Top is blackish:
Wildling bicolor top 8-22-23.jpg

Bottom is red:
Wildling bicolor bottom 8-22-23.jpg

Inside is red, except very close to skin on top:
Wilding bicolor cut 8-22-23.jpg

I saved a lot of seeds from this one. It's the only bicolor plant in my wildling patch, and unlike most of my wildlings, it doesn't have blossom end rot on the bottom. Taste was typical lycopene tomato.

We are starting to get nights in the upper 40s Fahrenheit, so I don't know how much longer I'll be getting tomatoes. I will be watching closely to see which plants have a little more cool weather tolerance.

Cathy A

The tomato patch out front has been devasatated in the past couple of days. I thought perhaps a deer was munching on it and then leaving, but it turns out to a much nastier pest.

Tomato hornworm 2.jpg

This is the largest Manduca quinquemaculata I have ever seen. Usually they are not found in my garden, but this year I had two.

Fortunately they were only in the front yard, and didn't find the larger tomato patch out back. I had already saved seeds from the most desirable plants in the front yard patch, so it shouldn't have any effect on the project, though it certainly will cost me some eating tomatoes this year.