Timing of harvesting crossed fruits, and thoughts on Lee Goodwin's 'Wilderness'

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-07-26, 09:38:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

Firstly on Wilderness, one of Lee Goodwin's domestic-wild hybrids. I tried to make a few crosses with it earlier this year and most failed. Anyone else tried crossing with it? He said it's crossed with LA1777 hab, but I wonder maybe it has other wild genetics in it - anyone know? I wonder if some wild genetics are making it hard to cross with?

And, I just harvested a fruit from it that I had crossed back on 1st May, that's almost 2 months to ripen! It was growing indoors and I put it outdoors in the ground maybe a month ago (or more?) since it wasn't flowering much indoors, so I guess it diverted its energies into growing (and it has grown a lot! And flowered plenty, and has new fruits developing), but I am surprised it took so long.

Anyway, it was looking ripe, and tasted great, but the seed gel was green. And here's a photo of the seeds, first time I have seen this kind of result:

IMG_0267.jpg

Whereas in some crosses with wilds, I see some fully formed seeds (if I'm lucky), and then many tiny very soft seeds that I guess are maybe just embryos with no endosperm (?) nor seed coat; here I see some fully formed seeds with proper seed coats, and some that look to me like normal seeds but with the seed coat having only partially formed. I am guessing that perhaps these would have formed had I waited another week or two?

I heard someone say that the seeds form ... I forget now but some specific number of days after pollination supposedly they're fully formed and that implied that being so even if the tomatoes are not ripe. This experience brings that into question for me. I also had a cross to Black Sea Man which was unusual, all the fruit ripened except for 1, then I took it outside and this very small tomato that had been crossed many weeks before but just stayed green and really tiny, started getting bigger. It was a strange shape, more round than the usual BSM ones and with a pointy bottom. I was expecting it to have no seeds even, but actually it did have many of the tiny ones with no seed coat but also several properly formed and sized ones. That was, if I remember correctly, crossed with chmielewskii pollen. I'm so glad I waited all that time. Yet to grow out those seeds but hopefully they are successful crossed seeds.

Then one more experience, I made a Q4 x cheesmaniae cross, harvested it when the fruit looked totally ripe (and it tasted fine), but inside most of the seeds looked like the common tiny soft ones like I described above which are so common in my experience when trying to cross lyc. x per. or lyc. x arc. for example, except that they were the size of normal seeds! And a few were properly formed seeds. This made me wonder if the soft seeds with no seed coat would have become proper seeds had I waited longer. Because they don't seem to fit with my endospermless seed hypothesis. Or, maybe this is just a thing that happens with such a cross, and maybe they never would have become proper seeds regardless of how long I waited? Also I did consider the possibility that all the coat-less seeds were Q4 x che. and the fully formed seeds were just Q4 selfed - I did the cross indoors, this Q4 was nicely exserted, and the flower was horizontal, so I did not bother emasculating. Anyway growing them out will tell eventually. In the meantime I am going to wait longer for the 2 more Q4 x Galapagos crosses on that plant despite them looking ripe, just in case.

I'd be interested in the experience of others on this matter. So far I am inclined to wait some good amount of time after crossed fruits seem ripe, before processing them. I've mostly been doing this but I just got impatient yesterday after 2 months of waiting!




Steph S

If your fruit looks and feels ripe, the seeds are not going to mature any more than they are.

It's common to find immature seeds when fruit was set in less than optimal conditions whether hot or cold.  For whatever reason, those seeds without a coat, whether soft or hard, are not viable and did not develop further.
Some varieties may have a greater tendency to produce a fruit even if there isn't viable seed.  Parthenocarpy, in various degrees. It may be that seed started to form but adverse conditions afterwards stopped the development, while the fruit itself continued to grow and mature.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-07-26, 02:53:03 PMIf your fruit looks and feels ripe, the seeds are not going to mature any more than they are.

Thanks Steph. What do you make of the seed gel being green? To me in my low state of knowledge, this implies that there are still some transformational processing going on there. That combined with seeds that look only partly developed, implied that perhaps the both the stuff surrounding the seeds, and the seeds themselves, may be only part way through their transformational processes.

Thinking practically, the only way I can imagine knowing, would be for example to harvest very many crossed fruits at a specific stage where they just look to have become fully ripe, and then the same number of same crosses 1 week later (i.e. 1 week after they look to be fully ripe), and perhaps again the same but 2 weeks later, and plot:
1) The number of fruits with still green inside, and
2) The number with only partly formed but full sized seeds like I got. (Or additionally/alternatively the number of partly formed but full sized seeds proportional to number of fully developed seeds).

And probably also note which members fall into both the above 2 categories.
And then if the numbers of 2) in the first stage of harvest are high enough, the data could be considered reliable enough to see whether that rate significantly changed at the later harvesting stages. If what you say is right, there should be no significant change in the figures for 2). Whereas if my hypothesis is correct, that figure should reduce, and go along with a corresponding reduction in 1).

So may I ask, what is the basis for your conclusion?
I hope this does not sound rude. Sometimes people find my approach rude, it confuses me why and I hope you don't. I am merely trying to establish an evidence basis for forming my beliefs. So I greatly appreciate your knowledge and experience.

Joseph Lofthouse

I observe occasionally the green gel coat around seeds trait. No matter how mature the fruit becomes, the trait doesn't go away. Fruits with that trait can carry fantastic flavors.

Steph S

Joseph is right, the green gel is color trait, and not necessarily a sign of unripeness.  Often associated with gf (brown or purple fruited, such as Black Sea Man).  I've also seen the green gel in fully ripe red tomatoes that had one gf allele, but now that I think about it, some yellow fruited seem to have green gel as well.  I haven't grown Wilderness so I can't comment on that.

In general though, I don't do the seed saving process until the fruit has sat for a few days getting good and ripe after picking.  Slightly underripe fruit don't shed all their gel as easily in fermentation.  So it might take a longer ferment or in the end they're not cleaned as well. That is how it seems in my home environment YMMV.  But it's worth the wait for me, usually, to get some cleaner seeds without extra hassles.

My comments about seed maturity are based entirely on my own experience growing tomatoes and saving seeds for the past 12+ years.  I've not read any literature nor an expert I can cite to support those observations. May have participated in discussions with other tomato growers about seed maturity questions, for sure.  So you may take it or leave it, as you like.  No offense at your remarks whatsoever. 

AndrewB

Green gel is more common in the wild tomatoes, but not exclusive. I've seen it in cherry tomatoes at the grocery store. It may be tied to better flavors, not sure.

Small but viable seeds are a trait seen in the wild populations.

Fruits with only a few mature seeds usually seem to have partial sterility issues.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-07-27, 10:21:48 AMI observe occasionally the green gel coat around seeds trait. No matter how mature the fruit becomes, the trait doesn't go away. Fruits with that trait can carry fantastic flavors.

That's an interesting observation, thanks.

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-07-27, 11:09:06 AMJoseph is right, the green gel is color trait, and not necessarily a sign of unripeness.

I do however have a contrasting observation. The first 'Wild Gem' tomato I harvested (another of Lee's domestic-wild hybrids) looked ripe, but had this green gel too. It was so strikingly beautiful! And did taste lovely. Here's a photo:
DSC06793.jpg

In that case I was worried that despite it tasting delicious and looking ripe from the outside, perhaps the green indicated I had picked it too early, and perhaps that was the cause of the seeds not being developed. I still do not know if that is the case, perhaps it was parthenocarpic. However, due to that experience I tried to wait longer after merely looking ripe, to harvest more Wild Gem fruits, and sure enough from what I remember when I waited long enough the inside was not green, and even for those few that did form parthenocarpically, still there was no green inside. So whilst I do not know for Lee's Wilderness yet, at least his Wild Gem seems from these experiences at least, to potentially start with green gel inside fruits that look ripe to me and taste great, then continue to develop, changing colour. Since I did not try more of them that soon, this is really not enough data to give certainty even on that, but anyway that was my experience.

I would be happy to try to remember to report back on the 2 remaining crossed fruits on my Q4 after waiting a bit longer, to see if the gel is green or not in those. It's a tiny plant because I'm growing it inside for crossing, so only the 3 fruits in total, all crossed.

Now I have just checked my photos and I only have 1 more of open Wild Gem, and the gel does in fact appear green, so there is the possibility that my memory is in error - either that or the green does disappear if waiting a bit longer still than I did for this one. (For this taste test I was not fussy though, just grabbed on off the plant, wasn't for seed saving). I put the plant outside some weeks ago and it isn't flowering much, if it does produce more fruit then I will try to check this further. But here is that only other photo I have - one thing that is apparent from this photo is that the green is far less intense, and I do not remember any of them having that intense green of the first one, which really struck me, hence me having more patience with them since then. Here we can also see Black Sea Man as you mentioned. In order from top to bottom:
- Black Sea Man
- Wilding
- Wilding (different plant)
- Wild Gem
- HRSeeds 'Cheesmaniae' (claimed to be pure but in fact surely hybrid with lyc.)
IMG_0042.jpg

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-07-27, 11:09:06 AMIn general though, I don't do the seed saving process until the fruit has sat for a few days getting good and ripe after picking.  Slightly underripe fruit don't shed all their gel as easily in fermentation.  So it might take a longer ferment or in the end they're not cleaned as well. That is how it seems in my home environment YMMV.  But it's worth the wait for me, usually, to get some cleaner seeds without extra hassles.

Ok cool, thanks. I have mostly waited until they are very ripe on the plant, though for some I have picked them when fairly ripe and waited after that. And I have not been fermenting the ones growing indoors, except so far for non-crossed pimps and some other wilds. Mainly because I have harvested so far about 50 individual crosses this year (some of which had only 1~3 seeds, some a full set) and my place would get to chaotic if I made space to ferment each individually, in terms of having daily emergencies of fermentation times all on different schedules, and in general for space and organisational reasons. I didn't want to loose any and the likelihood of loss or mix ups/spillages would be high that way for me. So I just find when I have time, then pick a fruit, rub all the gel off with kitchen paper, wash the seeds in water, dry them off with kitchen paper, then set them on fresh kitchen paper fully labelled and put them in a place to dry. I can concentrate through that whole process and then relax, which feels much better for me than having to maintain concentration over days and in fact months continuously as so many different seeds demand their needs from me. Hopefully this method is ok.

Perhaps I should ferment the outdoor crosses. Though I wonder, if disease is a concern, perhaps my method will still be ok but then bleach the seeds before germination, which would be a shame in terms of endophytes but might be ok all things considered, if it's only until I get the F2s. Since I have made hundreds of cross attempts - probably about 300 so far outdoors and many more to come, plus the many more still to harvest indoors. Of course many will fail but I am still expecting or at least hoping for many successful ones.

If anyone finds this unacceptable, please say so.

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-07-27, 11:09:06 AMMy comments about seed maturity are based entirely on my own experience growing tomatoes and saving seeds for the past 12+ years.  I've not read any literature nor an expert I can cite to support those observations. May have participated in discussions with other tomato growers about seed maturity questions, for sure.  So you may take it or leave it, as you like.  No offense at your remarks whatsoever.

Ok cool, thanks. I definitely take on what you have said, and I will weigh it against my continuing experience. I am certainly open to the possibility that these seeds might never have continued their development, and perhaps it was down to some difficulties of compatibility between these two crosses I detailed in the OP.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-07-27, 12:32:54 PMFruits with only a few mature seeds usually seem to have partial sterility issues.
Hmm, I hope my Q4 x Galapagos crosses will be fertile! I will see I guess. Though just to add, in my lyc x arc, pimp x arc, wild-domestic x arc, or any of those but using per instead of arc, or chm, I have had many that never took, many with no viable seeds (just with what I have assumed to be endosperm-less embryos - is it so? Tiny and soft), and some with just a small number of seeds. I am sincerely hoping that at least some of those with a few or sometimes even 1 seed, will not be sterile. But in terms of what's going on, I was assuming that perhaps ... hmm, like something about ploidy level in a few lucky zygotes that form the endosperm, or, something random about endosperm formation anyway? Anyway, hopefully if there are partial sterility in these usually 'impossible' crosses, some might make it to F2 and find success there.