What is happening with this pea please

Started by galina gardiner, 2023-06-06, 03:13:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

galina gardiner

The photo shows two plants of a cross I made 3 years ago.  I love the very dark flowers (bottom left in the photo) and try to cross that feature into high quality shelling peas.

One plant of that batch displays a rather fascinating flower colour change.  On the same stem the first node is a little lighter purple flowered with white spots on the wings, on the same stem out of the second node grew a couple of pink flowers.  Third node flowers haven't developed yet.visi x mummy white dark pu flo and 2 different on a separate plant.JPG

I have never seen such colour changes on a single plant.  Can anybody explain what is happening here please?

Mica Winnower

Looking at the leaf patterns as well, you might be looking at some kind of variegation trait; or this could be the result of transposon activity, resulting in the different types of marbling you're getting on the flowers and leaves.

Either way, this shouldn't negatively the health of your plant or its offspring. You might also find that the bean pods have similar streaking and banding.

Congrats! You have an emergent phenotype!

galina gardiner

Thank you Mica.  Never thought of jumping genes, transposons.  That explains it perfectly.
 The white 'variegation' however, is not new, but from one of the parents of this cross.  Just looked back at old photos and it is already there.

I will wait for further nodes and for the pod colour patterns with interest.  And further grow-outs if I can save seeds.  Have marked up the various pods with different coloured strings of wool.  Fascinating. 

Steph S

Wow!
All of those flowers are lovely, Galina.
Will the different pods be expected to produce the parent color?
I hope you'll keep us posted on the next generation.

galina gardiner

I have absolutely no expectation regarding different pods following the different flower colours.  Or indeed what the next generation might produce.  I see no reason why it would not be the same (boring) plain green shelling pods.  That there could be striping or colour patches on the pods too, like on the flowers of the first node, is a possibility, we will have to see and hope that the pigeons etc don't get the pods. 

What we do know, however, since this morning, is that the next node also has pink flowers.   

UnicornEmily

That's really exciting!  It would be awesome if more interesting differences show up as a result of this.

AndrewB

I have be idea what is actually happening here. A few random guesses though. Perhaps a standard coloroplast mutation for varigated leaves. Since flowers are modified leaves this could make sense. Though those don't necessarily look more varigated than usual. Could be a sport. Most likely won't breed true in any case I would imagine.

galina gardiner

#7
As one of the parents has the same leaves, we can safely ignore that as a mutation.  Unfortunately I can find nothing on coloroplast mutation on google, but I don't think anything on the leaves has mutated, because one of the parents already has those same leaves. And none of the other plants from the same parent (who also have those same leaves), have white flecks on the flowers or the colour change on the flowers between nodes. 

It is the colour change on the flowers that I am puzzled by, not the leaves.  A change which now seems to have stabilised into the new pink coloured flower.  Pods are green as expected, nothing strange there.  Unicorn Emily, just for interest, the former very purple axil spot has also changed to a much lighter purple.  Not a full pink as such, as we usually get with pink flowers, but markedly different from the colour it started out on node one.  Other plants from the same parents still have the dark purple axil spot. 

Steph S

You didn't mention if this is an F1 or a group of F2's? or F3?  If not F1 identical, there might be a gene x environment explanation.
Did the temperature change, from the time of first blooms to second and third nodes?
Just wondering if crimson/ cr  is involved in the dark red color, because if so, I've been told that cr  produces pink flowers in hot weather.

Another strange case was mentioned here:
https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/983886.pdf
Where a red flowered parent produced pink flowered offspring, which then produced red flowered again in the next generation.  The inference was that the plants were genetically red, but the B gene had somehow been deactivated or failed to interact normally with A.

galina gardiner

Thank you Steph.  The article you referenced has it, I think.  Its discussion on 'rogues' includes this - "Still another way in which a rogue could easily occur has its basis in a change in environment and in the fact that all factors or factor combinations do not react alike to such changes, so that while under one environment a variety might breed true, under another, variations would appear, due to unsuspected factorial differences".

Well yes, the temperature this year did change from a long, cold, wet spring to dry and summery, but this is a change that applies to all peas equally and every year. 

But there is more to it than just environmental changes happening this year.  The cross was made under very different soil conditions and climate conditions as the grow-out of this f3 generation, as we had moved in the meantime. 

This batch is a diverse group, which I sowed as a group, because they had the same seed colour and shape.  Another batch from the same cross, but with different seed colour and shape, is much more uniform, even in this early generation.   

I grew this batch specifically to observe what would happen from seeds that looked identical, and to study what I can know and predict before growing, just from the seed characteristics in this cross.  I know very little about how seed characteristics translate to plant characteristics (beyond the basics round, wrinkled, drum shaped, and the normal colours).  Mid brown, round, medium sized was a new seed colour for me, darker than the sandy light brown seed colour from pink flowered peas.  Do you know of literature that deals with seed colour in more detail, Steph? 

     


Steph S

I wish I did, Galina.  Really like your approach to that through observation of like seeded.

I went back through some of our prior discussions and found the link to the Catalogue of Pisum genes:
Catalogue-of-Pisum-genes_02.01.2019_small.pdf
I also have notes somewhere on seed color genetics from random readings, which might have links to other work, I'll check if I can find the file. 

There was a thesis I found online, with fantastically detailed work on colour genetics in peas, but on revisiting I found access denied:
https://eprints.utas.edu.au/21680/1/whole_StathamCarmelM1975_thesis.pdf
That is University of Tasmania, and perhaps they would grant permission if you request.
The author Carmel Statham also published "Biochemical genetics of pigmentation in pisum" through Elsevier which I couldn't access without paying:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0031942200884575
If you can get it, I highly recommend this author.
 

galina gardiner

Thank you Steph.  Yes the Statham thesis is  my 'go to' for pea flower colours and I was lucky to save the information at some stage.  Thank you for the other reference which I am trying to find.  Would appreciate any other info as you find it. 

There is simply a lot that is not yet researched in peas.   




Steph S

I found my reading file, just going through it now.
With regards to linkage between seed color and other traits the note says "Lock" cited in the book "Anthocyanins in Plants":
"White flowered plants have no colour in the leaf axils and no red or purple colour
in the testas.  Red flowerd have red in lf axils and red spots on testa; purple flrd
have purple clr in axils and purple spots on testas."

I'll scroll through the file and see if there's anything else of interest.

galina gardiner

I appreciate this Steph. 

Pink flowered peas generally have sandy coloured seeds is another one we noticed. 

Steph S

That is good to know, Galina. 

The rest of my notes were all from the Catalogue of Pisum Genes, so nothing to add there.
I did try Google scholar with the search terms "Pisum testa color" and that turned up quite a few references more than the searches for flower color, I took a look at a couple of them.

Stig Blixt was referenced here:
https://ds.amu.edu.et/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/11378/Genetic%20resources%2C%20chromosome%20engineering%20and%20crop%20improvement.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y#page=75

"Seed color and patterns are very important, particularly for the dry pea market. Most
major markets prefer a uniform color with no visible markings. Up to 48 genes interact to
determine seed color and pattern (Blixt et al., 1978).
"Testa colors range from translucent,
which incorporates the major grain types marketed (blue and white peas) to ochre (och),
salmon (sal), red brown (oh), umbra (umb), and violet (U). Testa patterns include
marbling (M) (i.e., maple type peas used in bird seed stockfeed), violet spots (F, Fa),
forks or moons of discolored areas (dem, den, cal, cat, mp, ve, z) brown (Rf), ochre (gl)
and grey colors (Ca, rag) over the radicle, and brown (str) and grey (gri) strips. The
major gene for anthocyanin formation, A, is recessive and epistatic to the majority of
these genes (Blixt, 1972)."

And a further search for his work turned up articles that look to be directly relevant to your interest in linkage between testa color and other traits.  Not open access but looks to be an important source.  Hope you can read it and become our resident expert!

https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4684-2994-7_9
The Pea   Stig Blixt  Handbook of Genetics pp181-221

One other abstract I saw, a Canadian study looking at green and yellow peas found nine QTL's controlling yellow seed lightness, 3 for yellow seed greenness, 15 for seed shape, and 9 for seed dimpling. 
This kind of multigenic interaction means many shades are possible, very cool!  Peas are pretty amazing.
https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/abs/10.1139/g10-117