PawPaw (Asimina triloba)

Started by AndrewB, 2023-05-02, 09:57:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

AndrewB

I hope to start my PawPaw journey this year.

Trying to select the best-bred varieties to use with the best combination of traits was not easy, but I finally have my top 4 varieties I hope to work with.

  • Wabash
  • 'Nyomi's Delicious'
  • 'KSU Chappell' ('KSU 4-1')
  • Halvin

Edit: I made a goof on my spreadsheet. Pennsylvania Golden also makes the list if I add a point for its smaller fruit size. It may be a decent variety overall.

I had to put them all in a spreadsheet and color code each trait with a point system. Then I tallied up the points for each variety to determine which had the best stack of traits that are important to me. Trying to balance things like potential frost hardiness, relative early fruit ripening, and things like low acetogenins and fruit color break when ripe.

Wabash and KSU Chappell should have the lowest acetogenins. Halvin might be the earliest. 'Nyomi's Delicious' is reported to have a color break when ripe. Of these, KSU Chappelle certainly has the most going for it, including extra high brix.

So I think these are the four I will be trying to grow moving forward. I can't wait to grow some pawpaws!

Cathy A

If anyone knows of a pawpaw variety that would thrive in zone 4, I would potentially be interested.

I read up on pawpaws, but it was clear they were primarily a southern fruit, and generally rated hardy only to zone 5.

AndrewB

#2
Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-05-03, 08:56:49 AMIf anyone knows of a pawpaw variety that would thrive in zone 4, I would potentially be interested.

I read up on pawpaws, but it was clear they were primarily a southern fruit, and generally rated hardy only to zone 5.

Allegheny & Shenandoah are reported to do fine in zone 4.

You will need two trees to pollinate each other. But apparently you can plant them extra close together since they naturally sucker heavily.

Garrett Schantz

I've been thinking of growing some other Asimina species that are zone 7 / 8 hardy.


As well as Asimina triloba. Just wanting the other species to potentially make shorter trees, longer blooming periods or earlier / later ones. Plus the variations of some really liking or being tolerant of dry soil or being fine with full sun exposure.



For new Pawpaw growers, keep in mind that they're partial shade plants. With Apples, Pears - tomatoes and things that bare fruit, full sun is usually recommended.

Pawpaws like having other trees around them which give them partial shade conditions. They'll produce much better in partial shade than full sun typically as well.


I believe there's breeding work going on to mitigate this. There's the advent of actually breeding larger fruited pawpaws, and growing them on sort of plantations like apples.


Unlike Apples they like partial shade. It's hard to get huge trees that grow quickly and large enough to make sufficient shade and survive longer than a decade or two.


I believe they prefer to be understory, dappled sunlight sort of trees. Some breeding is going on to mitigate this.


Anyways, I'd just check the varieties and things before hopping into stuff.


I know one guy had some woods around his property. He planted some disease tolerant / heavy producers near some trees and then gradually planted some full sun neutral / tolerant, whatever the verbiage is, next stacked across from them when they hit areas considered full sun.


Planting successions of fast growing trees might work too. I don't think it's considered ideal though. Those trees also take up a lot of nutrients with how fast they grow.

AndrewB

#4
Most of the paw paw varieties this time of year were sold out. I've had to settle on just Wabash for now and 'Fernandez' Anonna reticulata. So now I am determined to breed a red fleshed and red skinned 3/4 pawpaw.

pawpawPapi

If anyone is ever interested in Paw Paw seed pm me.  Especially in zone 4, because as a pawpaw grower, I worry about the trunks cracking in the spring after a warm day with a freezing night. I have to paint my trunks white to avoid losing trees.  I may even propose this as a project on the experimental farming network.

AndrewB

In my climate we get dry air in the winter and extra bright sunlight because of the altitude. This tends to kill the tops of lots of grafted trees.

I am considering painting my future tree trunks with white latex paint and also airlayering while young to eventually cut off the rootstock. I want the specific traits of the varieties I picked, so I still need named varities to start, but I admire anyone starting with seed. I wish I could do that.

UnicornEmily

Well, I imagine you'll be starting from seed in your next generation of pawpaw trees, right?  ;)  So you can look forward to that!

pawpawPapi

Pawpaws need to figure out a way to propagate themselves without seed.  I have successfully dug up and rooted suckers.  There is a low percent chance of survival, regardless of rooting stimulant... to my knowledge (I have tested so many lol). I bet certain suckers from certain seedlings would be better than others at rooting. For time, this means wild pawpaw trees with suckers seeds hold the key, to I dare say it, figuring out a proper rootstock variety.  Too many times have I heard people talk of the productivity and height of a "name" pawpaw variety, and I think damn, what about the roots.   

Garrett Schantz

There's a small red fruited Annonaceae native to Africa, I think.

Can't remember the genus.


I forgot about this thread, but I've purchased seeds awhile back now - and they're germinating.


Pawpaw seeds, germinate and then put out a taproot, they stay underground or whatever for awhile.


Then they put up top growth.



I've noticed the same sort of stems you'd see on beans before they lift up out of the soil, from some Pawpaw seeds that I planted.


I purchased Asimina triloba "Tammy", from an online seller.


This supposedly puts out fruit without a pollinator.


There's another variety out there like that.




I also noticed that my Asimina obovata, the Bigflower Pawpaw, is putting out taproots. I seperated the largest and some mottled / seeds with lines or bicolored stuff to them in a different pot from the others.

I only noticed that one, because a seed was too far out of the top layer of soil, I wanted to move it down further. But I felt a small root and some give to it.


I also have some Asimina parviflora, the small flower pawpaw - seeds, planted.


The Asimina triloba seeds were pre scarfied. I liked the sellers stuff. The Tammy Pawpaw, is a specimen tree. So there's likely only one seller.



There's seemingly no other Pawpaws that grow near it.


Asimina parviflora and A. triloba crosses cam happen out in nature.

I honestly don't want to be rid of the beetle / fly pollinated flowers.


That's just me. If anything ever happens to apples or anything else - or bees. Beetles may still be around.


Other Pawpaws are actually pollinated by butterflies and other sorts of things.



There is the negative of the flesh smell.



I've considered growing an Asarum species below the Pawpaws.


If you look at some Asarum species, many have small red flowers which look like Asimina triloba flowers, to a high extent.

They also smell like rotting flesh, appearently.

Many species have pollination issues at times.


They also typically prefer shade like Asimina triloba. So, I'd have them as a groundcover underneath them. Maybe it would encourage a lot of pollination. Or habitats for potential pollinators to hang out or nest in.



I also planted other seeds. Cananga odorata, the Ylang-Ylang.

This tree, is heavily used in the perfume industry.


So long as the fruits are still edible, I'd like to see if a hybrid with Pawpaws are doable.


I planted a few seeds of Meiogyne cylindrocarpa as well. These are called Fingersop in Australia.


They'll probably do well as a potted plant / plants.



Cherimoya and things, are also on a list.


I did plant some different species of Duguetia. Single seeds from different species. One had root rot issues and came already sprouted.


Those would be grown in pots.



I'd like a interfamilial cross one day.


I don't know how possible that is.



But, any possible bridge species or just anything that can toss over fun traits, is more than welcome.


I chose Tammy, simply because sometimes self fertile specimens can work better when crossing to other species, especially when their usual flowering or pollination methods or messed up.


I want to grow others, most of these are tests.


People grow Asimina triloba in Florida and California. It's not super common to my knowledge, compared to elsewhere.


The main issue with buying plants here, is that the taproots of some plants aren't established enough for 8B, most reports show that plants die off - plus their folaiges do not like the drastic changes. I've been looking for seeds for that main reason.

In the South, these can still grow up here. But, these will likely need to be grown in pots, where I plan on placing them in the yard.


There should be populations of Southern Pawpaws of this species in Mississippi as well. I hardly ever hear of non northern populations, but I guess they exist in some places. They're just not talked about too often.


I remember reading of a semi yellow fleshed Asimina triloba, that's mushy, tastes good and it's leaves are somewhat odd, and it's fruits are arranged differently than normal.

I'd like to get my hands on that one.













Garrett Schantz

https://tropicalfruitforum.com/index.php?topic=51858.0

I've posted about Annonaceae stuff elsewhere before.

I'm unlikely to get a ton of discussions about the family started here, save for Asimina.


But, there's the stuff I've put there, if anyone's interested.

Garrett Schantz

My Duguetia lanceolata is coming up out of the ground. Also called Pindaiba.

Yay.


Like Asimina, they grow underground and develop some roots before coming upwards.

And, it's coming up towards the surface.

I actually had initial issues with apparent root rot, and the seed came pre-germinated.

I used cinnamon on the roots, just a bit.

I may have initially been overwatering the seed.

Seems to be coming up. So I can't complain.


Asimina obovata is still coming up - or rather the seeds are putting out roots.


Asimina triloba, I'm seeing the first true leaves come on out.


Still nothing on Asimina parviflora.


Annona sylvatica (Rollina sylvatica) and Annona senegalensis. I have single seeds of those in pots as well.


The Annonaceae typically has plants which produce seed that have high germination rates.


Annona amazonica, has a similar fruit and seed structure to Asimina fruits.


Being smooth, is one thing. But, some inner parts and seeds resemble Asimina to some extent.

I'm unsure if that's all superficial or not. But, it's of interest to me.

https://www.tradewindsfruit.com/uvariodendron-connivens-uvariodendron-connivens-seeds

Here's the red skinned, Annonaceae that I mentioned.


Uvariodendron connivens is from Nigeria and Cameroon.


I haven't heard of it being used as a food. Granted it's probably full of seeds. And there are some Annona species found in Africa.

Uvaria chamae and Uvaria rufa are both some other interesting Annonaceae species.


I've also found a suitable location for the Asimina species.


The edge of a wooded area. I can give the Florida species room on the outer part, and grow Asimina triloba inwards towards the shade.


Because the first leaves of Asimina triloba are coming on, I'd like to get them planted or situated over there, soon.

The species doesn't like to be moved or transplanted. Frankly, the whole genus seems to be that way.


They dislike changes in sun conditions as well. Moreso than other species and the like.


If the Duguetia species grow well - I will probably try some layerings or cuttings and attempt to root some to be grown by the Pawpaws.


I'm also going to be growing Gymnocladus dioicus near the Pawpaws as well.

Frankly, I'm in Zone 8b. It's far range is Zone 8.

The species normally prefers full sun.

I'll see what happens with partial shade / sun.


I also have a lot of local "Sabal minor" berries inside of a seed spreader, along with a Helianthus species native to Mississippi.

Plus some other things are in that mix.


I'll toss some Carya species shells / nuts into that same area.


I'm aware that some people are breeding sun tolerant Pawpaws.

I'd like to grow them as just seasonally available fruits near the house.


With a Pawpaw orchard, I'd prefer to see a woodland orchard. Probably doesn't fit into European systems of doing things.

A species of tree which prefers shade, and it's pollinated by beetles.


To me, thats a big thing that the species has going on good for itself.


In this part of Mississippi, we should typically get half of the year being a ton of heavy downpours.

Then, we get hot and dry weather later into the year.


The state has a lot of swamps.



Gymnocladus dioicus and Asimina triloba are both relatively pest and disease free at the moment.


But those species could always pick up some weird disease.


I'm unsure of how others are planning on growing out their stuff. Figured that I'd mention some other species that I'm probably growing near my stuff.


Also, the Helianthus is a perennial species.




Garrett Schantz

I got into a chat elsewhere about ants and beetles, flies.

 
Someone mentioned a Stapeliad flower.

It had a large red flower, cactus looking leaves.

Plus the flower smells putrid appearently.


In the same family as milkweed.



I brought up Asimina triloba, and how it has small, bad smelling flowers.


And Trillium foetidissimum, which I've seen in some very small patches (gradually spreading locally?), in wooded areas.

It has reddish stinking flowers.


I also mentioned Asarum canadense. Also, stinky flowers on it.


There's also some other species that I've found. Stinky ones.


Eastern skunk cabbage (Symplocarpus foetidus) and Western skunk cabbage (Lysichiton americanus). These aren't closely related - save for being in the same family. The second one, has yellow flowers.


I also mentioned Magnolias to the fellow. As well as Tulip trees.

Both, are in the same family as Pawpaws.

Magnolia macrophylla - the Bigleaf Magnolia, is fairly well known.

Magnolia acuminata, the Cucumber Magnolia is also somewhat well known.


There's Asimina obovata, with large white flowers. Pollinated by beetles and flies. But, it also attracts butterflies and bees to a lesser extent.

Magnolias also mostly attract beetles and flies, butterflies and beetles to a lesser extent.


Studies have shown that the Magnolias of North America, suffer from a ton of inbreeding depression. And the trees seem like they should grow in groves or in larger numbers, they prefer to be outcrossed.

But, instead they're found scattered in small numbers.

Asian species seem to flourish mostly, in comparison.

Many Magnolias over here, also grow slowly.

Tulip trees grow quickly, become mature and eventually get shaded out - but they spread readily and in large numbers.

There's an Asian species and a North American species of Tulip tree.


Many of these species, also have a seed coating which ants take into their ant hills.


Solenopsis invicta, is invasive here. It also collects seeds which have that coating, for usages in their homes.


Borage has the coating as well. Usually it's found in species which grow in drier areas or need help spreading their seed around.



Many of these species, also have inbreeding depression, or issues with pollination or outcrossing.



Asimina triloba, seems to be an exception, concerning trees pollinated in this way.


The trees prefer to outcross, and inbreeding depression doesn't seem to be common. There's actually a ton of diversity in the species.


But, you can look to Florida, and see a ton of Asimina species, with unique features, only found in specific counties.


Animals still eat the fruit. Insects love the flowers, the same story as Magnolias here.



Magnolia macrophylla, usually grows in some shade. Not full shade, but a decent amount of it. As it grows, it reaches for sunlight.


Usually it grows alongside a new forest.


It's thickets and stands, should be similar in size to Asimina triloba stands. But, there's usually around 6 - 8 trees, at maximum.


Sometimes they're found alongside roadways here.


With mammals, some species aren't found in large numbers, naturally.

But, Magnolias and some other Pawpaws seem like they should've been widely dispersed at some point.



I've collected some red berries from either a younger or another native species of Magnolia. Maybe even a hybrid.


These are taken away by chipmunks, birds and other animals.


A lot of the times, the seeds are destroyed. They aren't typically stored away like acorns either.


They can fall from trees, but they're usually searched for by animals before dropping from cones.



I've tasted the berries. They taste like pine and wintergreen. They taste like what some Christmas pinecones smell like.



I'm assuming that's one reasoning as to why Asimina triloba and parviflora are more successful and have less of a bottleneck.


The fruits drop to the ground. The fruits are pretty large, and bears, chipmunks, raccoons and other animals devour them immediately.


They have some pretty large seeds.

And they have a high germination rate.


They grow well in the same conditions as Magnolia macrophylla.



But, Florida presents populations which likely had other counterparts elsewhere in North America at some point.

They also have edible fruits.


So. Maybe Florida didn't have nearly as many large animals for some time or it lacked large populations of such things.


That would cause fruits to stick to one county or smaller areas.


Plus Pawpaws are usually only available for short periods of time.



I've mentioned elsewhere, that Osage Orange is eaten and spread by larger buck in Texas and other places.

Doe nibble at them.


Larger necked horses, can and do spread them as well.



Some states tend to have smaller deer or smaller mammals. Maybe some species were larger and hunted by whoever.


Either way. The best reasoning that I can think of as to why Asimina triloba is succeeding, is due to deer and large populations of bear and maybe wolves / coyote.



The deer in Mississippi are smaller than back in Pennsylvania, and Asimina parviflora is more prevalent here and has smaller fruit.



I'd like to grow some of the mentioned Trillium foetidissimum plants over here. And maybe try out some Asarum species and both Skunk Cabbages.


Along with spice bush and Magnolia macrophylla, other Magnolias.

I'd like to grow Red as Red Magnolia, Vulcan and Magnolia liliiflora.


There's also probably some stinky Magnolias out there.


I'd like to see what happens if I try to breed any sort of a red magnolia.


And then have it grow next to Asimina triloba, and see if insects will pollinate either species more or whatever.


I mainly want to remove a bottleneck.




I'm mentioning this here, because again. Apples and other species like Banana. They're falling into a state of where they're grown as clones and eventually massively dying off.


This can easily happen with Pawpaws.


I've been looking into Pawpaws growth habit and preferences and flower types. Not many trees in North America are pollinated by beetles.


Growing more stinky plants, wouldn't necessarily mean that the Pawpaws get less pollinators. It would mean, that more pollinators would build up in the area.


Not everything flowers at the same time. Which, that means that these beetles and things, would have multiple flower food sources at multiple times in the year.



I don't know if anyone else studies these things to the extent that I do.


But I think this stuff has merit.




Jeremy Weiss

Technically, Magnoliacae and Annoacae are sister families, not the same one. Sort of like how now they upped the three legume subfamilies (Mimosoidae, Ceaspaloidae, and Faboidae into three separate actual families.

Garrett Schantz

Whoops my mistake.


But yeah, they're related.


Still, I noticed that a lot of these trees which attract beetles are closely related.

If they're less related, maybe they have different disease resistances and the like.


I wasn't sure about planting them together.



Still, increasing beetle populations sounds like fun.