Orange tomatoes - tangerine and beta

Started by Cathy A, 2023-04-19, 02:28:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

Is there a list somewhere of known orange tomatoes, preferably stabilized, and information on which ones are tangerine and which are beta?

I'm interested in trying to breed some tangerine cherry tomatoes into the Vermont Short and Sweet project. However, the only varieties I am aware of that definitely have tangerine tt are Kellogg's Breakfast, KBX, and Aunt Gertie's Gold, all of which are large beefsteak, late tomatoes.

Anyone know of a cherry that is definitely tangerine?

I realize that crossing recessive tangerine genes into a tomato population will be a multi-year project, but combined with repeated backcrossing, selection seems straightforward.

But I would prefer to start with a short-season, probably cherry variety as the source of the tangerine gene, so I am not introducing late beefsteak genes and then having to select them out again.

Has anyone here done any breeding work with tangerine?

Steph S

There are at least a few small tomatoes on the list of tt tangerine tomatoes here:
https://www.heritagefoodcrops.org.nz/table-of-tomatoes-containing-tetra-cis-lycopene/

I have a tangerine project in early stages, which I'm working on this year.  I have two tangerine crosses at F2, and growing out this year to select for determinate plants.  One cross used the cherry tomato Datlo from Czech Republic, which is dark orange tangerine and pear shaped.  The other cross used Amish Yellowish Orange Oxheart. 
I've also done some work over the years with Beta tomatoes and just growing out anonymously 'orange' tomatoes to try and untangle which are which, so I have a few more tt tangerine that aren't mentioned in the NZ list.  Samorodok, Yellow Clusters (Ukraine), Zolotoy Zapas, but they're probably not widely available except through seed stewardship groups. I should have seeds for Burzstyn in the stash too, although I didn't think much of them, they weren't too tasty in a cold miserable year. 
There are a few more well known ones, Valencia comes to mind, and Tangerine of course, which I believe are non beefsteaks however they are on the late side too.  But there is probably something in the list to suit your needs.  I notice they sourced a couple from Tradewinds Fruit, that is a US company, and I can vouch for their good service, seed quality, and generous seed counts for the price. 

Diane Whitehead

I have three from the New Zealand list if anyone wants some seeds:

Bursztyn
Earl of Edgecomb
Loxton Lass
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Nicolas

Why specifically t and not B ? Introgressing a dominant would be easier

AndrewB

Also it looks like there is a third orange gene: Del or Delta carotine

Are there any lines with Del available? Anything been bred for Del?

Cathy A

Nicholas,

Simply because I want to try something different, and tangerine tomatoes appear to be much less common than beta.

I am working with Sungold F2 already, which should be a good source of beta genes if I decide to use them.

Vesa Tee

#6
Cathy, I believe Uluru Ochre is a tangerine (and gf) which you already have in your radar. That was at least my observation when growing it some years back.

You could cross Jagodka and Uluru Ochre to get started, and then cross the F1 to some tangerine cherry (assuming you will find a good one). Just an idea.

I have been using Gold Dust and Justyna as the source of tangerine in my projects. This season I will be using Ida Gold (also tangerine) to get more of the green shoulders to my breeding lines. Gold Dust is obviously not a cherry, and very mild (bland), Justyna crosses have been the opposite, strong, zingy and sweet. GD and IG have confirmed t gene (by the literature) while Justyna is my own observation. I believe the Justyna cross had originally both a dominant and a recessive orange genes involved and at least the Justyna line circulating in Europe seems to have tangerine; based on the behavior in the crosses (recessive) and the flower colour.

Roland

Orange Banana is a paste tomato with tangerine.
Netherlands

whwoz

I have seed of Tangella about if you want some, likewise about 10 or 12 more on the NZ list heading this way that I could probably spare a few seeds of Cathy A

AndrewB

Quotemule
9 years ago
Actually if your goal was to increase beta-carotene do not use Delta. Just work with B. Cross it to red or yellow "r" types and it will clearly segregate for you. You won't need testing to know it's there. The only issue would be crossing with the orange tangerine gene based tomatoes. Unless you get stock from TGRC, Almost all orange tomatoes you could easily obtain will be the tangerine gene. Even still, Beta effects flavor so much it should be pretty evident. Visually when crossing with reds, even the intermediate types clearly stood out in F2's when I was working with it.

The flavor is a big issue.

If you want fairly decent Beta-carotene material you may inquire Dr Stommel at the USDA who released lines somewhere about 2000. I know one that comes to mind is 97L97. This material is in a processor type background not fresh market type. If you search google for Stommel, USDA, Beta you will find release notices and contact information.

Does anyone know about the relationship between these different orange types and flavor?

https://tgc.ifas.ufl.edu/vol40/v40p8.html
Gene Del in L. chmielewskii



https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Genes/detail/t

https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Genes/detail/B

https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Genes/detail/Del


Vesa Tee

#10
There are no confirmed Del cultivars available commersially to my knowledge. But it is difficult to know for sure because both Del and Beta originates from green fruited wild tomato relatives, and at least the hobby breeders are not able test the carotenoid types of their releases. Del is supposed to be more reddish-orange than Beta. In my experience, Beta is also more reddish orange than tangerine. So, from orange to reddish it is supposed to be in the following order (in my opinion): tangerine, Beta and Del.

Both Beta and Del requires the wild type R (red) gene to be expressed. The advice to use the yellow r in crosses in the above quotation is simply wrong and incorrect. Beta and Del further modifies the lycopene of red tomato, and if there is no lycopene (like in yellow or tangerine tomatoes), the result is plain yellow or tangerine. Beta and Del would be somewhat masked. Best use reds only in such crosses.

In my experience, Beta cherry tomatoes are the best tasting cherry tomatoes ever. Never tasted Del that I know of, however, tangerines have been often in the milder side although I have tasted also sweeter and better tasing tangerines lately too. Maybe the tangerines just need more flavour genes blended in (e.g. because the gene does not originate from wild relatives)?

Joseph Lofthouse

#11
Paper chromatography is readily available to the general public. It would be easy make an assay protocol to separate the different types of colored pigments in tomato fruits. It's the kind of chemistry that we did in middle school science class.


Nicolas

From "Characterization of a repertoire of tomato fruit genetic variants in the San marzano genetic background"

337730508_984857999591641_2153972303474855196_n.jpg

Steph S

Both Del and at (apricot) are rare enough as cultivars to pretty well discount the possibility when breeding with an orange tomato of unknown genetics.  I have heard that "Dad's Sunset" is Del.  Not sure if the NZ list values contradict that claim.
Vesa's point is important, you cannot have Beta expressed unless red background is present. So crossing with yellow would be a wasted effort.
tangerine has the advantage of being expressed with both red and yellow background (and maybe bicolor too?).
Another interesting thing about Beta, it is believed to be an allele of og (crimson) which produces high lycopene and intense red color.  So this color intensifier is also basically wasted in a cross with Beta. Not sure if og would also produce more pigment intensity in a tt tangerine.
There are other intensifiers of Beta for high carotene, for example the 97L97 mentioned above is reported to have another gene that intensifies beta carotene content.
Beta is also reported to have strong linkage to the sp locus.  So ratios may be way off in crosses involving det vs indet plants.
So there are a number of reasons why you might choose tangerine vs Beta for a specific project.

As shown in the pic that Andrew posted, the tangerine flower type is very distinctive, a really deep orange anther cone.  The petals also fade to pale orange.  So there is no problem to distinguish Beta from tangerine in an orange fruited plant once it flowers.

I have also found that the majority of tangerine orange fruit I've tasted have been mild and if anything, melony.  But I agree with Vesa, it may be simply that complementary flavor genetics need to be brought into the mix. I haven't tasted Moonglow, which was rated highly for taste, so there seem to be exceptions.  Datlo cherry was tasty and sweet, and a darker orange than other tt tangerine I have tried.

AndrewB

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-04-22, 11:11:28 AMSo there are a number of reasons why you might choose tangerine vs Beta for a specific project.

As shown in the pic that Andrew posted, the tangerine flower type is very distinctive, a really deep orange anther cone.  The petals also fade to pale orange.  So there is no problem to distinguish Beta from tangerine in an orange fruited plant once it flowers.

I have also found that the majority of tangerine orange fruit I've tasted have been mild and if anything, melony.  But I agree with Vesa, it may be simply that complementary flavor genetics need to be brought into the mix. I haven't tasted Moonglow, which was rated highly for taste, so there seem to be exceptions.  Datlo cherry was tasty and sweet, and a darker orange than other tt tangerine I have tried.

Thanks for this info!

I have seedlings for "dwarf moonglow" growing, but there is no mention of a dwarf version of moonglow, and so far, the seedlings do not look like a dwarf. Should I grow them anyway and try to cross them into a dwarf background? Is Uluru Ochre for sure a tangerine type? Does Uluru Ochre have gf? I was under the impression it has u for green shoulders.

There was a introgression line from TGRC from S. peruvianum that reportedly has dark orange anthers similar to the tangerine gene in domestic tomatoes. Line LA0214 Dark anthers from S. peruvianum. I mention it in case future wild crosses have a similar flower color.