Tell me more about the Dwarf Tomato Project! :)

Started by AndrewB, 2020-06-21, 12:46:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kadence Luneman

Screen grabbed this from the ossi video for the project.

Screenshot_20230319-221733_YouTube.jpg

Vesa Tee

I believe the green shoulder phenotype often helps with the flavour and the sugars. If I had to choose between uniform and green shoulders, I would definitely take the green shoulder one.

One research paper that gives an opposite opinion is the one that investigated immature green fruit color genes: green shoulders (u+), uniform green (u), uniform gray-green (ug), apple green (uAg), medium green, and pale green (uPg). here

QuoteSOLUBLE SOLIDS. Two recent studies found that green- shouldered fruit of 'Ailsa Craig' had higher SSC than that of its isogenic u counterpart cultivar 'Craigella' (Nguyen et al., 2014; Powell et al., 2012). However, when these two cultivars were tested in the field in Fall 2013, the difference, although in the same direction, was not significant (Fig. 3). It is not clear why the results differed between the previous studies and ours. It could be purely an environmental issue related to growing in different locations and/or plants in the previous studies were grown in pots in greenhouses, whereas our plants were grown in the field. It could be that fruit in the previous studies sampled only sun-exposed fruit, and there may have been some canopy cover in our experiment.

QuoteThese results strongly indicate that the fruit color phenotypes studied are not related to SSC and that the selection of any of them would not have a significant effect on fruit quality associated with SSC. The plants used in this study encompass a wide range of variation typical of that seen in breeding programs. The individuals in the present study differed in many traits in addition to fruit color such as canopy density, plant architecture, flowering time, and leaf morphology. Some traits such as dense canopies in tomato have been shown to increase photoassimilate levels in fruit (Ho, 1980). Importantly, we found no evidence that tomato breeders should select for green shoulders to enhance SSC.

Tim DH

Hi Andrew,
   I see you list Coorong Pink as 95 Days. ... I'd question this.

   Victory lists it as 95 Days but the Dwarf Tomato Project website describes it as an early!

   I've found an Australian seed merchant who lists it as 68 to 72 days, which seems more believable to me. In addition most websites mention the danger of letting the fruit over ripen!!

   Since I'm growing Uluru Ochre and Coorong Pink this year I hope to be able to give some comparative information soon!!!


Tim DH

Cathy A

I'm deeply suspicious of claimed days to harvest figure for tomato varieties. I have seen wildly different estimates claimed on different seed sites.

Is there an authoritative source for this?  For heirlooms, I suspect not.

AndrewB

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-03-20, 07:33:25 AMHi Andrew,
   I see you list Coorong Pink as 95 Days. ... I'd question this.

   Victory lists it as 95 Days but the Dwarf Tomato Project website describes it as an early!

   I've found an Australian seed merchant who lists it as 68 to 72 days, which seems more believable to me. In addition most websites mention the danger of letting the fruit over ripen!!

   Since I'm growing Uluru Ochre and Coorong Pink this year I hope to be able to give some comparative information soon!!!


Tim DH

Good catch! Let us know what it turns out to be. Perhaps you can use Uluru Ochre as the time to judge by. I guess keep good notes!

I've noticed this on at least a few others. I think Tasmanian Chocolate? Perhaps even on Uluru Ochre where most day 65 and one said something like 72.

I think basically we need to use as many reports as possible to know the true DTM. But it can probably vary by climate and by season. It also can vary widely by how much generic diversity a variety has. The newer the variety the worse this can be.

Diane Whitehead

Definitely varies according to climate.  Out here on the cool coast, I've always had to add a couple of weeks to tomatoes developed in the interior of the continent.

But a lot of the Dwarf Project tomatoes were developed in Alaska, so day-length also has an effect.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Tim DH

A bit more digging and:

Craigs own website lists Coorong Pink as 75 Days, on the list of 2016 releases. 

 
Tim DH

AndrewB

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-03-20, 01:25:02 PMA bit more digging and:

Craigs own website lists Coorong Pink as 75 Days, on the list of 2016 releases. 

 
Tim DH

Thanks Tim, I've now edited my post to reflect this change. Let us know if you catch any other errors. This is why you can't always trust one source especially for tomato DTM.

Coorong Pink 75 DTM ('Wilpena' x 'Cherokee Purple.')

AndrewB


AndrewB

Craig's favorites from his blog:

Uluru Ochre 65* - It really never disappoints, and it in the top tier of our work.

Rosella Purple 75* - It looks and tastes like Cherokee Purple, and is similarly sized, on a nice compact dwarf growing plant. I've grown it many times and love the variety. One thing I've noted is that foliage disease can hit it pretty hard in some years, due to its dense growth and heavy fruit set.

Dwarf Blazing Beauty 75* - It is one of the very best flavored of all of our releases, particularly for those that like intensity and a bit of tartness. The rich orange color also makes it a relative rarity among our releases. It can, like many of our potato leaf selections, be a fit fussy about fruit set or foliage disease, but is well worth growing despite any challenges it presents for its flavor alone.

Dwarf Firebird Sweet  75* - This lovely tomato is out of the complex Beauty family, which provided a rainbow of colors for our project and numerous releases. When this popped up in my garden a few years ago, the stunning pink with gold striped combination was really exciting to find. Add to that it's high yield and rich, complex flavor and we have a winner (in my book!). One slight complication is that I've ended up with purple fruit (with greenish gold stripes) from supposedly stable seed lots. This isn't unusual for our Beauty family releases - stabilizing chosen colors has been a bit of a challenge.

Dwarf Beauty King 75* - Another out of the Beauty family, this one is an intense scarlet red with vertical gold stripes, of a medium size, and possessing the consistently wonderful flavor of all of our Beauty family tomatoes. And, as with other Beauty offspring, the color can occasionally offer a surprise. I think we have this one pretty well nailed down, and it is another favorite of mine, well worth growing.

Dwarf Vince's Haze 75* - My oh my, what a delicious tomato. The plentiful medium large smooth oblate purple fruit, from a vigorous healthy potato leaf plant, have a full, rich flavor that rivals types such as Cherokee Purple, and are on a par with Rosella Purple. I really love this variety and look forward to growing it many times in the future.

Dwarf Sarah's Red 75* - Yet another large fruited, totally delicious scarlet red colored variety takes its place in our project. My first growing was just this past summer, and I simply loved it. Productive, healthy, vigorous, large - and totally yummy.

Chocolate Lightning 80* - I LOVE this variety, although it can be as finicky as some of our other temperamental offerings. The plant can be on the tall side (still a dwarf, but pretty stretched), the fruit hard to find in the dense foliage, set fruit late and be a shy yielder - some years are prolific, others less so. But the color, and the flavor, are outstanding and unique. It can also shift colors a bit, as I suspect that like others in the Beauty family the genetics are pretty complex and we probably didn't stabilize this as much as we might have. The color should be a definite chocolate (not purple), with lots of vertical golden or greenish stripes. It is a "black" tomato, with dark crimson flesh and an intense, well balanced flavor.

Dwarf Confetti 80* - I've not yet grown the released selection and hope to do so in 2020 and 2021. I discovered and named this variety and it was outstanding that year.

Dwarf Caitydid 80* - This is one of my better finds, distinct in being a yellow/red bicolor that had a particularly rosy colored central core. It's combined attributes - color, flavor, productivity, vigor - move it into my "favorites" category.

Dwarf Maura's Cardinal 80 * - Dwarf Maura's Cardinal is simply a superb, large scarlet tomato that has it all - vigor, productivity, and most of all, a complete, delicious flavor.

Dwarf Tiger Eye  80* - What we have here is special and quite unique - an Uluru Ochre colored nice sized prolific paste type tomato. The flavor is just excellent, and this is a really versatile multi use variety - salads, sauces, roasting, grilling or canning.

Dwarf Kelly Green 75* - It is prolific, healthy and delicious.

Dwarf Orange Cream  75* - This is a curious one. The color is pretty unique, not quite orange, not quite yellow, and the surface is sort of matte, not shiny. The flavor is outstanding, right there with the other Tipsy family releases (Sweet Scarlet, Golden Gypsy, Blazing Beauty).

Dwarf Golden Gypsy  75* - I love this variety. It is one of the most consistent yielding of the Tipsy potato leaf releases, with nice sized medium yellow tomatoes of superb flavor (including that nice kick of tartness shown by most of our Tipsy family releases). The very pale yellow flesh is attractive as well. Certainly this is one of our finest varieties.

Dwarf Sweet Sue 80 * - To me, this is simply one of the best. It should be medium sized, vary from smooth oblate to more round, have a medium yellow color with a distinct pinkish blush at the blossom end when very ripe. Mostly, it should delight the taste buds with its sweetness and intensity. I've seen selections that are not yellow enough, too large, or too oblate. This one is very special...and it is named for my wife!

Rosella Crimson 80* - It can struggle with disease issues, getting it uniformly stable wasn't easy...but when it is at its best in a good season, the flavor of this medium large, productive release can approach Brandywine in intensity and quality. It just isn't the most reliable performer, season to season, but when it's on, it's REALLY on!

Sean's Yellow Dwarf 80* - It's pretty, really nice sized, super prolific, and the flavor sneaks up on me - it is very, very good, approaching excellent. This is actually a great variety to use to introduce people to the potential and characteristics of our dwarf varieties due to its reliability season to season.

Adelaide Festival 80* - it is a real beauty, lovely stripes, excellent yield and fine full flavor

Dwarf Egypt Yellow 80* - This tomato really exceeded my expectations in both flavor and size. I am so glad I finally got to grow it this year; it was one of the highlights of my garden in 2019. It is nice to add a big, oblate, prolific bright yellow regular leaf dwarf to our portfolio.

Dwarf Hannah's Prize   80* - And, guess what - yet another wonderful large fruited scarlet red dwarf tomato made its debut in my 2019 garden. What an embarrassment of riches - and what a fine tomato this is.

Dwarf Melanie's Ballet 80* - I really enjoyed eating - and the beauty of - this nicely shaped, good sized smooth plum shaped pink. Highly productive, this is a wonderful multi use tomato...salads, sauces, roasting, canning. It jumped into my favorites category with my first try at growing it, this past season.

William Schlegel

I really liked Dwarf Kelly Green last year. To me Dwarf Kelly Green, Dwarf Saucy Mary and Tom Wagner's non-Dwarf Muddy Waters all had the same next level green when ripe flavor.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

I'm already impressed with the germination rate and rapid early growth of Uluru Ochre. I'm looking forward to seeing the growth pattern of the full size plants and tasting the fruit.

AndrewB

#102
This is the list of the ones I've planted for this year's mini [Colorado] trial.

I'll try to have one of each plant in the same type of containers with the exact same soil. Then I may try to have a second plant of each variety in my 8ft long raised bed, so they also will have the same soil as each other. The two soils will be slightly different.

planted on March 19th:

Uluru Ochre
"The One"
Big Hill
Loxton Lad
Kookaburra Cackle
Serendipity
D. Velvet Night
D. Dainty Isabel
D. Galan's Yellow
Bundaberg Rumball
D. Mocha's Cherry

March 25th?

D. Beauty King
D. Orange Cream
D. Firebird Sweet
D. Vinces Haze

March 31st:

D. Metallica
D. Blazing Beauty
Brandyfred Dwarf
D. Purple Heart
Tasmanian Chocolate
Yukon Quest
Fred's Tie Dye
D. Mary's Cherry
D. Franklin County
D. Jeremy Stripes
D. Andy's Forty

& Dwarf Moonglow tomato

The list is a bit different than the ones I had planned. I ordered late this spring instead of getting them all last fall. I got most of them from Victory Seeds and will be doing my best to provide reviews. The rest I tried to order from Rennaissance Farm, based on Craig's recommendation. However, my order was never confirmed other than from paypal, never shipped, and multiple emails ignored. I had to get paypal to do a forced refund and do an emergency last minute order from TomatoFest. And I had to pick different varieties to fill in the gaps. The good news is now I get to try Tasmanian Chocolate, but won't get to try Maralinga.

I'll have to try the other favorites in Craig and Patrina's list such as Maralinga, Coorong Pink, and others as long as they are under 80 days maturity and better if they are 75 and above.

You'll notice that Big Hill and "The One" are in this trial despite not being strictly dwarfs. They should be determinate and still short. Willian is "The One" short or is it tall? If it is tall, I will still grow it, but perhaps put it by itself. I could fill in the gap with my micro dwarf orange rocket F3. I hope to make the cross for "Ochre Hill" between Big Hill and Uluru Ochre as they are both 65 day tomatoes.

I planted seeds for what was labeled Dwarf Moonglow Tomato sent to me from Emma Biggs on the Food Garden Life podcast in Toronto, Canada. But online I can't find any info about Moonglow being a dwarf. She is a big tomato person, so I'm going to trust her that the seeds she sent are indeed a dwarf. Sent her an email trying to confirm.

Just noticed I may have planted two more than I intended.  I may have to eliminate two varieties from the trial.

William Schlegel

For me The One is a short dwarf but not the same kind of dwarf. Somehow dwarfed by wild gene interactions. It is notably unproductive with few seeds per fruit but their is evidence that could change. Though possibly from outcrossing.

Big Hill can be a big for me plant but it can also be pretty small. I think if crowded it would not get too big. Definitely not a dwarf.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Randy Simmons

#104
My plants of The One! are noticeably larger than my plants of MMR.  I have 3 plants in one pot and the stem of each plant has wrapped around the bottom of my grow tent. I picked my first ripe tomato from The One! and it contained  21 seeds.  There are 6 more after that.