F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tim DH

Sharp observation Steph!
   The 'mitten leaf' form (good name) was the main reason I didn't do my assessment on the first true leaf! Most of those seedlings are now in the compost, but the few I saved for working on a back crossed Latah are showing that the leaves stabilize as the plant gets older. On these two photos first and third true leaf is on the right, second true leaf is on the left.

Tim DH

Steph S

Interesting...  Carolyn Male used to say, don't judge leaf type by the first true leaf on the plant.  I know it's highly variable but I do wonder if there's a trend in those first leaves, to tell something about the lurking genes.
"Mitten" is someone else's term btw, to describe that PL leaf pheno.   I don't recall where I saw the pics posted of studies done on leaf shape, but it's out there somewhere. ;)

Tim DH

For the purposes of this project I've decided to 'sideline' the seed from Stupice.

I've done loads of reading about Stupice, which originates from Stupice Farm near Prague. Some commentators suggest that the farm's name may have got attached to four (or even more) distinct varieties! What I want is an F1 recipe which is re-creatable by anyone anywhere. SO: Even tho' I like the Stupice which I grow, publishing it as a parent in an F1 recipe would lead to confusion.

Fortunately the variety Bloody Butcher is morphologically VERY similar to the Stupice I grow. The analysis I posted in Reply #31 confirms that they are also genetically very similar. Bloody Butcher appears to be reliably only one cultivar. (In addition it has the advantage of being given a Royal Horticultural Society 'Award of Garden Merit'.)

I am less concerned about the variability of Moskvich, since there only (!) appear to be two cultivars circulating under that name. They are quite distinct in fruit size, so I can specify that I used the beefsteak one!

Tim DH

   This year's crop of F1s is stored away waiting for trials next Spring. The project started as a scramble, just putting together the material I had to hand, trying to create an Early Red F1. It's been great fun so far, but next season I'd like to be a bit more intentional!

   Being intentional starts here! ...  I've set myself a new goal. Creating some Cherry F1s. The Cherry Toms I grow are not very productive, in terms of weight. Maybe a bit of hybrid vigour would help.

   In theory I'd like to work with three Potato Leaf mothers (a red, a yellow and another colour) and three Regular Leaf fathers (a red, a yellow and another colour). I'd like the parents to be as geographically diverse (in origin) as possible. In the hope of getting hybrid vigour. Three by three would give me nine F1s to trial in 2024. A bit of a 'Scatter Gun' approach! Hopefully something will hit the target!!

Current contenders are:

Red PL ABC (South American?) or Piennolo del Vesuvio(Italian)
Yellow PL Galina's(Siberian) or Cereza Amarilla (South American?)
Other PL Brandywine Cherry(American) Japanese Black Trifele(Russian)

Red RL Gardener's Delight (German) or Chadwicks Cherry (American)
Yellow RL Ildi(Hungarian?) or Sunviva(German)
Other RL Sunrise Bumblebee(American), Dancing with Smurfs(American) or Rosella(English)

I'm aware that some of these aren't technically Cherrys. Can anyone suggest any better choices?

Tim DH

Diane Whitehead

My most prolific one this year is Barry's Crazy Cherry - a pale yellow oval with a little nipple on the bottom.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Roland

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-10-30, 11:28:36 AMThis year's crop of F1s is stored away waiting for trials next Spring. The project started as a scramble, just putting together the material I had to hand, trying to create an Early Red F1. It's been great fun so far, but next season I'd like to be a bit more intentional!

   Being intentional starts here! ...  I've set myself a new goal. Creating some Cherry F1s. The Cherry Toms I grow are not very productive, in terms of weight. Maybe a bit of hybrid vigour would help.

   In theory I'd like to work with three Potato Leaf mothers (a red, a yellow and another colour) and three Regular Leaf fathers (a red, a yellow and another colour). I'd like the parents to be as geographically diverse (in origin) as possible. In the hope of getting hybrid vigour. Three by three would give me nine F1s to trial in 2024. A bit of a 'Scatter Gun' approach! Hopefully something will hit the target!!

Current contenders are:

Red PL ABC (South American?) or Piennolo del Vesuvio(Italian)
Yellow PL Galina's(Siberian) or Cereza Amarilla (South American?)
Other PL Brandywine Cherry(American) Japanese Black Trifele(Russian)

Red RL Gardener's Delight (German) or Chadwicks Cherry (American)
Yellow RL Ildi(Hungarian?) or Sunviva(German)
Other RL Sunrise Bumblebee(American), Dancing with Smurfs(American) or Rosella(English)

I'm aware that some of these aren't technically Cherrys. Can anyone suggest any better choices?

Tim DH

Why not using parent lines from Artisan Seeds, they have the best tomato varieties, like:
Blush
Blush 2.0
Lucky Tiger (this was for me the best tasting oud of 60 varieties)
And maney more
Netherlands

Tim DH

Hi Roland,
   Thanks for the recommendation. ... I already have one 'Artisan' in the list: Sunrise Bumblebee. In the interests of trying to get genetic variability (so hopefully hybrid vigour) I don't want more than one variety from any particular source. Sunrise Bumblebee is more cherry shaped than Lucky Tiger.

Hi Diane,
   Thanks for the recommendation. ... I've not heard about Barry's Crazy Cherry before. Thankfully Tatiana's TOMATObase is back up so I can check it out! It looks like a pale Ildi. With me Ildi appears to be productive, but the actual weight of fruit isn't that impressive. When you say BCC is productive do you mean numbers of fruit or weight? BCC hasn't made it into the commercial seed market here in the UK, but I have found one UK based Etsy seller. If you can confirm its better than Ildi I might give it a punt!

Tim DH

William Schlegel

I am curious about how much genetic variability there is in fully domestic tomatoes and how much a breeding project source tends to cross their own lines with each other. I certainly am tending that way in my own work but I am also making extreme outcrosses to wild species and other peoples work.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Diane Whitehead

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-11-08, 04:43:11 AMBarry's Crazy Cherry .  When you say BCC is productive do you mean numbers of fruit or weight?

Numbers of fruit. I don't weigh my tomatoes.  But I haven't grown Ildi for a few years, so can't compare them.  I suspect I would prefer Ildi.

Diane
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Cathy A

Tim, I hear you on planning and being intentional. Any breeding project needs to have a year added on to the front end for research, planning, and obtaining the right seeds!

William, I recall reading somewhere that there is more genetic variation in a single wild tomato relative than in the entire worldwide domesticaled population. That's depressing if true.

I'm grateful to William, Joseph Lofthouse, and others who have done the difficult work of outcrossing S. lycopersicum with distant relative like S. pennellii, S. habrochaites, and others.

William Schlegel

#55
Quote from: Cathy A on 2022-11-08, 12:59:39 PMTim, I hear you on planning and being intentional. Any breeding project needs to have a year added on to the front end for research, planning, and obtaining the right seeds!

William, I recall reading somewhere that there is more genetic variation in a single wild tomato relative than in the entire worldwide domesticaled population. That's depressing if true.

I'm grateful to William, Joseph Lofthouse, and others who have done the difficult work of outcrossing S. lycopersicum with distant relative like S. pennellii, S. habrochaites, and others.

Somewhat true. Obligate outcrossing populations of Solanum habrochaites can have more genetic diversity than all domestic tomatoes.

However 50+ years of introgression breeding by universities has created much less susceptible tomatoes and the work of professionals is ongoing.

My own work is just getting started. I'm working with domestic material from several sources. Josephs wild crosses and finally after many years of just growing wild species tomatoes I have several F1 and F2 crosses of my own but it is a long haul proposition to work with wild species.

However there is a potential there for hybrid vigor. Joseph got the biggest albeit unpalatable fruited tomato plant ever a few years ago with an S. Habrochaites x Brad cross. Maybe someday we can make an essentially habrochaites but tasty tomato that would produce a spectacularly productive F1 every time.

In the meanwhile though hunting for cultivars with higher rates of introgression might be a good choice for F1s. I just had some Purple Zebra F1 with dinner and that is a throughly modern but heirloom style tomato with lots of resistances and therefore lots of introgressions. You would almost need to dehybridize it to get a consistent result but that might be worth doing. Though if inconsistency is fine go for it! If I understand the relationships correctly purple zebra is a cream of the crop introduction from Artisan seeds group of breeders. However I don't think I would consider their high resistance lines to have hardly any relationship to their low resistance lines. Each of those resistances comes with an introgression often a big one. Vastly different genetics.

I also think that galapagense, pimpinillifolium, and cheesemanii crosses could be good for a pollen parent if small cherry tomatoes are an desirable outcome.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

#56
Just put a post in the other thread that may have big repercussions for this topic:

https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,404.msg12271.html#msg12271

This leads us to potential super F1 crosses. Although I think Craig said in one of his podcast or webinars that sometimes the F1s tasted terrible. Would be interesting to ask him about these F1 lines specifically.

Potential super tasty dwarf F1 crosses:

Uluru Ochre x Dwarf Blazing Beauty
Uluru Ochre x (Maralinga or Kookaburra Cackle)
Loxton Lass/Lad x Dwarf Blazing Beauty
Loxton Lass/Lad x (Maralinga or Kookaburra Cackle)

Parent varieties and might be potential varieties to use as well (and others like these):
'Cherokee Purple'
'Rosella Purple'
'Wilpena'
'Golden Dwarf Champion'
'Orange Heirloom'

Maybe Uluru Ochre x Sungold ?!
Uluru Ochre x Coyote
(50 days) Early Girl / (54 days) Bush Early Girl / (50 days) Dirty Girl x ?
Momotaro Gold x Sungold
Momotaro Gold x Wee Tang Shebang
Uluru Ochre x Thorburn's Terra Cotta

AndrewB

I finally asked Craig L. about the flavor of the F1 using Cherokee Purple x Lillian's Yellow. And if there are any dwarfs bred from Lillian's Yellow?

I'm curious if a dwarf cross of something bred from Cerokee Purple X something dwarf bred from Lillian's Yellow would produce something similar in flavor.

Here was Craig's response:

QuoteHi Andrew!

I used Lillian's Yellow a few years ago in two crosses - with Dwarf Speckled Heart, and with Dwarf Mocha's Plum. The team is just working through some of the offspring, but the outstanding flavor of Lillian's didn't show to the level I hoped - they certainly are diverse and interesting.

The hybrid between Lillian's Yellow Heirloom and Cherokee Purple is just superb, and we are finding some interesting selections when growing out seed saved from the hybrid.

The sky is the limit - there is so much more to discover!  I think using Captain Lucky would lead to some great dwarfs - and Cheroke Purple has only been used in one family (Plentiful) - but lots of great things emerged from that.

Craig


Tim DH

And so the fun really starts!

One of my new varieties is not behaving properly!!

One of the ABC Potato Leaf seedlings had regular leaves. .... And now the PL seedling (I chose to graft) has flower buds on. WAY ahead of any of the recognized early varieties. It is also side shooting. A quick trawl of online descriptions reveals wide variation! Tall or Dwarf. Indeterminate or Semi determinate. Early or Midseason.

Fortunately non of these variations will matter this time. The rogue regular leaf could have come from an accidental cross or a foreign seed dropped into the batch. Either way, the Potato leaved seedling should still be 'true'. Tho' quite what true is I'm now not sure!  In the proposed F1s, any determinate tendency will be over ruled by pollen parent.

I wish all my grafts looked this good!

Tim DH

Vesa Tee

That ABC PL looks great and exactly like my Kotlas x pimp line that I selected for PL pimp leaf type (i.e. no trichomes, almost naked). They start flowering very early.

Maybe ABC simply has some pimp heritage and for that reason starts flowering early. Or the crafting shortenes the time to flower?