Tell me more about the Dwarf Tomato Project! :)

Started by AndrewB, 2020-06-21, 12:46:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

whwoz

Quote from: Richard Watson on 2023-03-17, 10:27:51 PMScoresby dwarf is what I had always thought a dwarf was, first I have heard of a micro dwarf though

Scoresby Dwarf or KY1 as it is also called is referred to here as a bush, different style of growth to Dwarf project plants.  Dwarf project plants are like full indeterminates with leaf internodes about 1/3 the length of normal plants.  KY1 always shorter, more compact, bit hard for me to describe, been too long since I have grown it.

Tim DH

Hi Andrew,
   I've also got interested in the Dwarf Project. Two things particularly appeal to me about it:

   Firstly, there is a lot of information available about each cultivars parentage.
   Secondly, there are a lot of independent reviews available. (By independent I mean NOT  seed catalogues!)

   My only reticence is that I haven't yet actually grown any of them. So I'm just dipping my toe in the water this year, with Uluru Ochre and Coorong Pink.

   I'll be interested to hear how your more extensive trial goes.

Tim DH

nathanp

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-03-18, 07:57:36 AMHi Andrew,
   I've also got interested in the Dwarf Project. Two things particularly appeal to me about it:

   Firstly, there is a lot of information available about each cultivars parentage.
   Secondly, there are a lot of independent reviews available. (By independent I mean NOT  seed catalogues!)

   My only reticence is that I haven't yet actually grown any of them. So I'm just dipping my toe in the water this year, with Uluru Ochre and Coorong Pink.

   I'll be interested to hear how your more extensive trial goes.

Tim DH
Uluru Ochre is one of my favorite tomatoes, and is early enough to be grown in most short season areas.
I've grown about 10 or 11 different dwarf varieties.  Some of them don't really produce well enough for me, or are too long season.  I've settled on growing a couple of them that grow the best (Uluru Ochre, Dwarf Golden Gypsy, Banana Toes) and trying to work on a few others to select for shorter season production.

One thing I do like about them is not having to deal with plants with 8-10' vines.  They stay short enough for me to use small tomato cages.

AndrewB

#78
Thanks Tim and others,

I too have never grown the dwarf tomato project varieties before. And honestly not many that were dwarf or bush types on purpose, though probably many times on accident. I don't think my outdoor climate conditions really favor tall tomatoes here, and while I don't have a short season, I don't exactly have a long season. I think it's better to treat my season as a short season climate as that should give me better results for what I'm looking for.

I don't necessarily care which mechanism a tomato is using for shortness. Whether that is one gene for dwarfness or another, or whether it is for bush growth, or a double mutant for multiple. I am just aware that there are several things similar but different that are floating around. Joseph, being a tomato world society member, do you know anything about this topic? Bush vs dwarf, determinate vs dwarf?, etc.?

EDIT: looks like we already discussed this before on page 1 of this same thread: https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php?msg=6705

I ended up shortening my original list of varieties I wished to trial to under 75 days. I know tomatoes flavor can be really affected by soil chemistry and conditions, so I will try very hard to make sure all of these will have the same soil. I know this means that the winning varieties for flavor this year may not be the same as when planted in direct soil or native direct soil conditions, but at least they should be comparable to each other.

There are many factors that I'm screening for that requires as big a trial as possible.

The 1st is that I can't really rely on taste recommendations by others, even experts like Craig L., as my taste buds may be vastly different than others. My taste preferences may also be vastly different. Some people really like acidic tomatoes, others sweet tomatoes, still others balanced. I need to figure out what I like and match it to some good varieties. I'm one who has the recessive genetics for cilantro aversion because it tastes like soap to me. I may also be a non-bitter taster. Not sure if I'm a "supertaster" on top of those or not. These factors may be significant and may be a reason why sometimes when I share seeds for those, I've been breeding that I really like, other people tell me they taste bad or insipid to them.

The 2nd is that I am looking for those that have really good "heirloom" flavors that stand out when compared to a grocery store "cardboard flavored" tomato.

The 3rd is that I am looking for decent productivity. This means I cannot grow excellent flavored tomatoes if they only produce 1 tomato the whole season. This probably means none of the super-sized tomatoes, and beefsteak sized may be rare. Conversely this may mean that most cherry tomatoes are also out unless they can make up for their small size in an extra abundance of fruits and/or flavor.

4th. growing well in my climate. I usually do not have issues with disease, but other factors such as how they grow in higher altitude / brighter sunlight, our sometimes-arid climate and drying winds, native soil pH., etc.

Uluru Ochre is the one I'm most excited to try. From a technical standpoint it looks like it should check most if not all of the boxes I'm looking for as far as I know. Only one way to find out.

AndrewB

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2022-04-14, 06:00:14 PMThe recent webinar posted a list of the top flavor picks for the Dwarf Tomato Project and Craig suggested taking a picture so I did.

They were as follows:
Sweet Scarlet Dwarf
Rosella Purple
Maralinga
Uluru Ochre
Dwarf Mr. Snow
Rosella Crimson
Kookaburra Cacle
Loxton Lass
Dwarf Blazing Beauty
Dwarf Emerald Giant
Whereokowhai
Dwarf Jade Beauty
Dwarf Wild Fred
Dwarf Sweet Sue
Summertime Gold
Dwarf Wild Spudleaf
Coorong Pink

I asked about disease breeding. Craig addressed it and mentioned contacting him (I did send him a follow up email). He does think a cross with an F1 creates a lot of additional unknowns in terms of segregation.

I also asked about the two currant tomato crosses and in his response, Craig actually talked about plans for making more crosses with Everglades for some Florida collaborators to try to get more colors and diversity of tomatoes suitable for Florida conditions. I personally think more crosses with more currant tomatoes would be good for disease resistance breeding also so my two questions were related.

I also asked something about an assertion Craig made about starting to shut the project down in 2018 and Craig basically responded by saying how could we ever really shut it down? Which might mean Craig is somewhat up for continuing with some things.

Oh I wish I had asked about the Alaska tomatoes with the long DTM and if they may be a data mistake?

They said they will post the webinar to the OSSI YouTube channel but it hasn't posted yet.

William, were these "top flavor picks" listed in order?

William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

#81
So I just did some brief "data analysis" on this "best flavored dwarf" list.

I ended up crossing off any that were longer than 75 days to maturity and organizing the list by maturity. Here is what I found:

Best flavored:
Uluru Ochre65 * (black/orange - 'Orange Heirloom' x 'Rosella Purple')
Kookaburra Cackle70 * (brown - 'Wilpena' x 'Cherokee Purple')
Loxton Lass70 (Orange - 'Rosella Purple' x 'Orange Heirloom')
Rosella Purple75 (purple - 'Budai' x 'Stump of the World')
Maralinga75 (brown (black) - ''Wilpena' x 'Cherokee Purple')
Dwarf Blazing Beauty75 (Orange - 'Golden Dwarf Champion' x 'Elbe')
Coorong Pink75 ('Wilpena' x 'Cherokee Purple.')
Rosella Crimson78 (pink - 'Budai Torpe' x 'Stump of the World')
Dwarf Wild Spudleaf80
Dwarf Sweet Sue80 ('Golden Dwarf Champion' x 'Green Giant'
Dwarf Jade Beauty85
Dwarf Wild Fred85
Dwarf Mr. Snow90
Sweet Scarlet Dwarf90
Dwarf Emerald Giant90
Whereokowhai90
Summertime Gold90



Of those 7 left, I am planning on growing 5:

65 days - Uluru Ochre * (black/orange - 'Orange Heirloom' x 'Rosella Purple')
70 days - Loxton Lad * (Orange - 'Rosella Purple' x 'Orange Heirloom')
70 days - Kookaburra Cackle * (brown - 'Wilpena' x 'Cherokee Purple')
75 days – 'Maralinga' * (brown (black) - ''Wilpena' x 'Cherokee Purple')
75 days – Dwarf Blazing Beauty * (Orange - 'Golden Dwarf Champion' x 'Elbe')
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rosella Purple75 (purple -  'Budai' x 'Stump of the World')
Rosella Crimson78 (pink - 'Budai Torpe' x 'Stump of the World')

Of these 5 you can already see some trends which I find interesting. The types of tomatoes often found to taste the best are black/brown/purple and orange tomatoes. Uluru Ochre is interesting because it is a Black/Orange. Basically, an orange with the green shoulders gene.

The green shoulders gene has been shown to help accumulate more sugars in the fruit from the extra chlorophyl and of the tomaotoes I have grown I have noticed those with green shoulders to taste superior. Standard supermarket tomatoes have the U uniform ripening gene which is the opposite of the green shoulders gene.

https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2012/06/28/155917345/how-the-taste-of-tomatoes-went-bad-and-kept-on-going#:~:text=The%20darker%20green%20color%20comes%20from%20the%20chlorophyll,more%20flavor.%20The%20uniform-ripening%20mutation%20disabled%20this%20gene

So yes, this suggests to me that generally the best tasting tomatoes will be black/brown/purple and orange and the ideal is probably one like Uluru Ochre, especially if it has decent size, productivity, and early maturity. Bonus if it has resistance to disease.

The parents that tend to lend to the best crosses like these are:
'Cherokee Purple'
'Rosella Purple'
'Wilpena'
'Golden Dwarf Champion'
'Orange Heirloom'

This leads us to potential super F1 crosses. Although I think Craig said in one of his podcast or webinars that sometimes the F1s tasted terrible. Would be interesting to ask him about these F1 lines specifically.

William Schlegel

I think Craig mentioned that Green Giant led to really good flavor in offspring varieties.

My experience with green when ripe tomatoes up until last year was that they tasted ok but not spectacular. So my main use had been visual diversity like when sliced and eaten on pizza.

However my flavor explorations last year found three that seemed spectacular. I'm not entirely sure though more taste testing needed.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adrian

#83
Yes green giant is very cool! Some f2 between green giant and tiny tim.
https://www.les-tomos.fr/viewtopic.php?f=111&t=1916

AndrewB

#84
Very cool Adrian! I've wondered if Tiny Tim (55 days), Coyote (50 days), and Sungold (70 days) should be used in some crosses.

Potential super tasty dwarf crosses:

Uluru Ochre x Dwarf Blazing Beauty
Uluru Ochre x (Maralinga or Kookaburra Cackle)
Loxton Lass/Lad x Dwarf Blazing Beauty
Loxton Lass/Lad x (Maralinga or Kookaburra Cackle)

Maybe Uluru Ochre x Sungold ?!
Uluru Ochre x Coyote ?

85 days 'Tasmanian Chocolate' ( 'New Big Dwarf' x 'Paul Robeson') x ?
65 days Velvet Night x ?
60 days Wee Tang Shebang  x ?
54 days Bush Early Girl x ?

Parent varieties (and might be potential varieties to use as well (and others like these)):
'Cherokee Purple'
'Rosella Purple'
'Wilpena'
'Golden Dwarf Champion'
'Orange Heirloom'
'Paul Robeson'

Roland

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-18, 11:32:01 PMThe green shoulders gene has been shown to help accumulate more sugars in the fruit from the extra chlorophyl and of the tomaotoes I have grown I have noticed those with green shoulders to taste superior. Standard supermarket tomatoes have the U uniform ripening gene which is the opposite of the green shoulders gene.

https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2012/06/28/155917345/how-the-taste-of-tomatoes-went-bad-and-kept-on-going#:~:text=The%20darker%20green%20color%20comes%20from%20the%20chlorophyll,more%20flavor.%20The%20uniform-ripening%20mutation%20disabled%20this%20gene


I doubt that greenShoulders gives more sugars than Uniformripening. Is there a study where a comparison is made in the sugar content between an F2 or F3 population where only the U gene is different and therefore no study where they compare tasty heirloom varieties with green shoulders with tasteless commercial varieties which have the niformripening genes?

My 50 F2 and 80 F3 Galahad population with both green shoulders and uniform ripening shows that there is no difference in brix due to this U gene.
Netherlands

Tim DH

Hi Andrew,
   Your barking up a very similar tree to me!


   On this seminar:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3izfjQscZo

   At the 53rd minute there is a list of Craig AND Patrinas favourite Dwarfs for flavour.
Six cultivars are on both Craigs and Patrinas list. Those six split into two groups:
 
GroupA Cultivars derived from  Budai Torpe, a Hungarian variety   (Coorong Pink, Uluru Ochre, Maralinga and Rosella Crimson)

GroupB Cultivars derived from Golden Dwarf Champion, an American Heirloom from the 1890s (Sweet Scarlet Dwarf and Dwarf Jade Beauty)

   The second group are Potato Leaved cultivars. So creating F1s between the two groups neatly fit the protocols outlined in the 'F1s for the People!' thread.

        This year I'm committed to growing out my Early Red F1s and creating some Cherry F1s, but I'm seriously considering creating some Dwarf F1s in 2024!!
Tim DH


AndrewB

Quote from: Roland on 2023-03-19, 02:01:28 PMIs there a study where a comparison is made in the sugar content between an F2 or F3 population where only the U gene is different and therefore no study where they compare tasty heirloom varieties with green shoulders with tasteless commercial varieties which have the uniform ripening genes?

That's a good question.

I mean there is this study:

https://www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1126/science.1222218

Not sure how to get the full article, but it looks like the one mentioned in the NPR article where it was a GM line that reactivated the u green shoulders phenotype more-or-less in a line that was normally U. So, therefore all the other genetics were exactly the same. Hard to beat that! I doubt any non GM trial could eliminate enough variables to really trust the results.

Your brix testing is interesting, curious as to what is going on there. The article suggests there are multiple carbohydrates and carotenoids that are enhanced. Perhaps those are not detectable in a simple brix test. That is partially why I said sugars as in plural and not in the singular. I don't know enough plant biochemistry to know or understand more than that.

Here is another study by the same authors with more info:

https://academic.oup.com/plcell/article/26/2/585/6097957

Quotethe increase in transgenic fruit starch levels likely directly reflects increased fruit photosynthesis. In red tomato fruit, many desirable nutritional compounds are elevated, including not only carbohydrates/sugars, but also carotenoids and ascorbate (vitamin C) (Figure 4). Total soluble solids (oBrix, percentage w/w of soluble solids in solution) and sugar levels were significantly increased (20 to 40% and 40 to 60%, respectively), and total carotenoid levels were elevated 25 to 40% in both GLK1- and GLK2-overexpressing lines compared with the control 'M82' (u/u). Interestingly, in the red ripe pericarp tissue, β-carotene and lutein, the protective carotenoids usually found at high levels associated with the light-harvesting complexes of leaves, were also substantially increased

William Schlegel

#88
https://www.opensourceseeds.org/en/seed/tomato-m%C3%A4rchenengel

I think it would be fun to cross this Marchenengel with many others. It isn't available yet here.

Also Galahad F1 and dehybridizations and Purple Zebra F1 and dehybridizations.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Diane Whitehead

Well, it's time to figure out what tomatoes I'm going to grow this year.

Last year I grew about 55 from the Dwarf Project and made notes about just a few of them:

Tasteless:   Banana Toes, Galen's Yellow

Not tasty:  Vince's Haze ( which had a fluted top that rotted when I brought it into the kitchen).

Delicious:  Rosella Purple, but it didn't produce many tomatoes.


Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil