Back Crossing Latah

Started by Tim DH, 2022-09-02, 02:13:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Steph S

Good luck, Tim!   The three generation challenge is a tough one..  I don't even bother with two, even for the F1 where you only need one plant, um, in the living room.  ::) Well I've done it a few times, and decided that a fallow period without tomatoes suits me best. :) Greenhouse is just way too cold.  Here's hoping your compost stays unfrozen as and when required.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-01-03, 08:57:21 AMHappy New Year!

The race is on to see if I can get three generations of my Latah Backcross done in a year. (I'd have begun yesterday, only the bags of compost were frozen.)

For starters, here is a visual comparison of the (F2) fermented and spat seed. (See post #4 & #9 on this thread. Also the thread 'F1s for the People!' #40 & #41 for more info..) I've sown eight of each to see if they grow differently. In theory those 16 F2 seedlings should provide me with approx 4 Potato Leaved plants.

Hmm my fermented seed is hardly ever dark like that.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-01-03, 11:43:47 AMGood luck, Tim!   The three generation challenge is a tough one..  I don't even bother with two, even for the F1 where you only need one plant, um, in the living room.  ::) Well I've done it a few times, and decided that a fallow period without tomatoes suits me best. :) Greenhouse is just way too cold.

I think you would need a heated greenhouse to grow tomatoes in midwinter in zone 4/5a.

My living room doesn't have enough light on its own, so that wouldn't work even if hubby would agree.

Like you, I am content to have a winter season without tomatoes. But I wish I had a way to start getting fruit by early summer. July tomatoes in Vermont would be a treat!

William Schlegel

You could start some Sweet Cherriette early. Up pot it in a big pot then outplant it late May when it is already blooming good and maybe has some green fruit on it already.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Tim DH

Day 11 from sowing.

Five rows of four cells.
The left hand row is Latah (F0)
The right hand pair are Hatal F2 fermented
The middle pair are Hatal F2 spat

The Latah are a bit bigger and taller. Not surprising since they are seed from a July fruit and the F2s are seed from a November fruit!

There is no significant difference between the spat and fermented seed, which leads to the encouraging conclusion that the earlier difference in seedling vigour noted on the F1s for the People! thread IS hybrid vigour....

My set up is a Vitopod made by Greenhousesensation. It was purchased for orchid culture but has seen FAR  more service raising tomato seeds!

The Vitopod sits on a Sunny windowsill. However since our day length is currently only around 8 hours I boost the light levels with a basic grow lamp timed to come on for 3 hours at both ends of the day. The lamp is just posted in through the top ventilation hole.

I'm really enjoying running a little growing experiment in these dark days. It shouldn't be long now, til I can differentiate between (true) leaf types.

In response to William's observation about seed colour: I've had a look at my other fermented seed and that F2 is easily the darkest of them. I have wondered about the implications of 'using' wild yeast in the seed fermentation. Personally I don't rely on wild yeast in any of my other fermentation operations (Brewing & Bread making) because that gives inconsistent results.

I wonder if commercial seed producers use a known strain?

Tim DH


Steph S

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-01-10, 09:05:42 AMI think you would need a heated greenhouse to grow tomatoes in midwinter in zone 4/5a.

My living room doesn't have enough light on its own, so that wouldn't work even if hubby would agree.

Like you, I am content to have a winter season without tomatoes. But I wish I had a way to start getting fruit by early summer. July tomatoes in Vermont would be a treat!
An unheated greenhouse should easily do it for Vermont.   I regularly have tomatoes in July.  June is pushing the limit and not worth the extra care (and plant misery) for a few scrawny cherries.  But early July is doable, and mid July is even a bit late for me to start getting a crop.
Granted I have a couple of advantages, it is an attached greenhouse on the south of my home, so sheltered from the north;  there's a lot of mass in the stone floor; and growing in containers the soil warms faster.  At least those are some reasons why I'm usually two weeks earlier than my friend's farm, where they are planting in the ground.  It takes longer for that to warm up.   Even so there are ways of speeding it to plant earlier.  raised rows will warm quicker like containers.  Covering with clear or black plastic will also heat it up faster for an early planting. 

Steph S

Quote from: Vesa Tee on 2022-11-13, 10:34:08 PMThe only practically useful linkage rule for me has been this group of c, og, B and sp. There might of course be others but a challenge is that many of the genes listed in these maps are not easily identifiable. And sometimes the phenotype is because of multiple genes.

Wikipedia/Genetic linkage explains how to interpret the recombination frequency. If there is no linkage, the frequency is 50%. The basic unit (cM) is 1% of recombination. Frequency less than 7 is considered hard to break.

In below tomato linkage map from 1963 (pages 6 and 7), the distance between c and sp is 2 (10-8) which I think means frequency of 2%. So some cross over does happen. But c and og (or B and sp) have difference of 0. So these links must be very difficult to break.

https://tgc.ifas.ufl.edu/vol13/Volume13.pdf

Edit: this version of the map lists gf, gs, y, r genes too, just to mention some



Just wanted to mention that some recent work concluded that Beta and og are alleles of the same locus:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC27155/

Not sure why the frequency of breaking linkage with sp would be different for one allele vs the other, but add that to the list of mysteries in genetics.

I did get a Beta/- indeterminate in F2 of a cross with Zolotoe Serdtse and Indian Stripe.  No luck trying to recover a determinate plant in two subsequent generations.  So I'm not sure what happened with the linkage there.   I have also read in a paper somewhere that Black Cherry has the og allele.  This was a parent in another multi-parent cross involving ZS, which led to the non-Beta determinate black fruited lines which are now Skipper and Rodney.  IDK if they have og, but that left me wondering whether og wouldn't also have a linkage to determinate/indeterminate status. 
If different alleles (Beta, og, wild type) have varying degree of linkage to sp, then perhaps specific combinations of alleles in the heterozygous plant are easier to unlink.  Thinking Beta/og and sp/- in the F1 might go either way.


William Schlegel

#37
I have been using sourdough starter since 2010 quite a bit mostly for pancakes.

I've wondered about just inoculating the tomato fermentation with sourdough starter or the liquid layer that forms on the top.

I have been saving some liquid from older tomato seed ferments when I strain and then wash them and using it to inoculate new ones. I think it hurries the process along.

I have occasionally gotten dark seeds but usually I get nice bright looking seeds that clean and dry really nice.

A lot of commercial outfits just use chemicals to remove the gel than rinse and dry. There are instructions out there. I like the fermentation because it is natural.

I wonder if yeast alone would effectively break down the gel. I read some brewing books about a decade ago about older wilder fermentation and there are middle road options available to brewers that use some of the wilder yeast species but from a culture that gives more consistent results. That could be an interesting but perhaps odd direction to take tomato fermentation experimentation. That is buy special cultures for like a sour fruit beer from a brewing supply company then use them on tomato seed ferments?! Something like this and it turns out to be a mix of yeasts and bacteria https://homebrewing.org/products/white-labs-655-belgian-sour-mix-1


I doubt common bread yeast would be very satisfactory. I can imagine trying to rinse that mess now- wonder if it would rinse off nicely with the sink sprayer or cling to the seeds.

I do wonder about just using a bit of sourdough starter liquid though as I always have sourdough starter on hand. I don't think I've ever tried it. 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

I thought the liquid on the top of sourdough starter was like a vinegar or alcohol? It would definitely be interesting to just save a ton of bulk seed and split them into different ferments just to see what happens.

Steph S

Sourdough starter... might be a mix of wild yeasts and lactobacillus?  A quick google says yes, that lactobacilli outnumber yeasts in sourdough by about 100x.

Lactobacillus is for sure the organism involved in a clean tomato seed ferment. So a bit of your starter would probably be quite fine. 

You can also prepare a lactobacillus culture by soaking or washing rice, according to some documents I read and don't have handy atm.  Yup the google turns up many refs to that and recipes as well.

Cathy A

#40
Quote from: Steph S on 2023-01-14, 10:35:09 AMAn unheated greenhouse should easily do it for Vermont.   I regularly have tomatoes in July.  June is pushing the limit and not worth the extra care (and plant misery) for a few scrawny cherries.

A slight misunderstanding. When you talked about growing tomatoes in winter in an unheated greenhouse, I was thinking about getting fruit in January or February. In Vermont, that is definitely "heated greenhouse with supplemental lighting" territory.

I think you could get tomatoes in early July here with weaker measures than a greenhouse. Strong transplants of early varieties started very early, planted outside a few weeks before last frost under low hoop houses with water-filled cloches, would probably do it. But that seems like a lot of work to only get a benefit of a few weeks.

If you already have a greenhouse, this would be a good use of it, but it would be really hard for me to justify building a greenhouse to get a few extra weeks of tomatoes.

But I would really like to start getting a few tomatoes in late June, about a month after last frost. That would be challenging here. In a normal to good year, getting a few tomatoes in late July with the main crop coming in August and early September would be about right. So for a tomato that produces fruit in 50 days, you would need to get the first 20 - 25 days before last frost, either by growing inside or growing outside with a lot of protection.

Tim DH

19 Days from sowing. ... Here is one of the F2 potato leaved seedlings, surrounded by regular leaves. There are three PL seedlings in total. I'll pot up a couple of Pls and a couple of Latah. Hopefully I'll have an F2 and a Latah in flower before the end of February.

Whatever happens, this little project will get evicted from the propagator once the main crop tomatoes get going! (When that happens I've negotiated a small space for the project in the bedroom window!!)

The business of 'justifying a greenhouse' is an awkward one. My current greenhouse has to go as it spoils the view from the new extension (!!!) I agreed on the understanding that it will be three times as big in its new location.

Greenhouses aren't just about extending the growing season. Potato blight has never been a problem with my greenhouse toms. Similarly I understand Peach Leaf Curl is not a problem under cover.

Steph S

Too true Tim, having shelter over tomatoes prevents a lot of foliage disease for me.  I have to put them outdoors to assess how resistant they are.
In a normal year here we also need the extra degree days to ripen our crop on the vine.

Kudos on the plan for a bigger greenhouse! :)

Adrian

#43
Warning with the powdery mildew under the shelters if the weather is dry.
The shelter can protect of the blight but its worst than in outdoor with the powdery mildew.

Tim DH

Things were going really well until the seedlings outgrew my propagator!
Without the extra warmth/light/humidity they suffered.

I've had particular difficulty harvesting pollen. Those plants (Latah) are in smaller pots because I only need/want them to produce pollen. They are showing serious signs of oedema. (The mother plants (F2s) are in bigger pots and seem happier.)

After a few days of trying to 'milk' pollen with my toothbrush and black plastic spoon, I resorted to cutting the tip off an anther cone. This seems to have helped release some pollen, So, HOPEFULLY the first backcross is now made.

From here on the days are getting longer/brighter and warmer. That should aid/speed fruit ripening. Last generation it took 49 days, (from first flower to first fruit) but those were mostly October days. 49 days from now is April 30th. ... So I am in with a chance of completing this year's first generation in under 4 months!

Tim DH