Tell me more about the Dwarf Tomato Project! :)

Started by AndrewB, 2020-06-21, 12:46:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

I got my Dwarf Mocha's Cherry x Mission Mountain Sunrise picked today. Will let it ripen even more before I extract the seeds and ferment them.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Andrew Barney wrote:
"There is always going to be a battle between taste and productivity."

Is that necessarily true, or just what usually happens?

I find Sungold F1 to be both the most productive variety I have tried here, and the tastiest. Whether those traits can be bred true is another question, but Sungold shows that the two traits can coexist in the same genetic variety.

I'm intrigued enough by the discussion around Uluru Ochre to add it to my Vermont tomato breeding plans for next year.

Kadence Luneman

I'd love to hear how people's dwarf projects went this year

William Schlegel

2022 results

New flavor favorites:

Dwarf Saucy Mary, Dwarf Kelly Green, Dwarf Gloria's Treat, and Dwarf Eagle Smiley.

Additional noteworthy:

I think Banana Toes is noteworthy as a productive yellow mild flavor sauce type.

Crosses:

Dwarf Gloria's treat x a pimpinillifolium pollen mix was successful.

Possible Mission Mountain Sunrise x Dwarf mix but if so a open cross I'll discern by the dominant regular leaf trait.

Possible Mission Mountain Sunrise x Dwarf Mocha's Cherry but if so an open cross I'll discern by the dominant regular leaf trait.

Likely failed: Dwarf mochas cherry x Mission Mountain Sunrise. Seeds don't look filled.

I also now have F2 seed of Mission Mountain Morning x Aztek micro dwarf which is 1/4 OSSI Big Hill HX-9 and should segregate to 1/4 Dwarf seedlings.

If I get any Mission Mountain Morning x The One seedlings in 2023 they might end up as Dwarf too. I think the one has dwarfing highly comparable to OSSI dwarfs but probably originating from the interspecies crosses somehow. If it happened I'll have to find it as a regular leaf seedling amongst the potato leaf as I failed to make it as a hand cross.

So I guess I found 4 or 5 new favorite tomatoes to grow again. Made one cross for sure, and have potential to still find seedlings for two others.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Quote from: Cathy A on 2022-09-26, 08:50:28 AMAndrew Barney wrote:
"There is always going to be a battle between taste and productivity."

Is that necessarily true, or just what usually happens?

I find Sungold F1 to be both the most productive variety I have tried here, and the tastiest. Whether those traits can be bred true is another question, but Sungold shows that the two traits can coexist in the same genetic variety.

I'm intrigued enough by the discussion around Uluru Ochre to add it to my Vermont tomato breeding plans for next year.

I'm not sure. Sungold might be an exception because it is a hybrid and has hybrid vigor. But that is an interesting example. In the case of sungold it has small fruit, I'm not sure the same could exist if the fruit were very large. At least not easily. I've heard of a few large fruited tomatoes that are also fairly productive, but that is probably not the norm. I guess it depends on your metric of what constitutes productive. I think commercial breeding programs focus on total weight of harvested fruit to indicate productivity. Sungold being a small fruit might fail that metric unless they produce enough tiny fruits to make up for the size (and I think they might).

To me it is all about resource management. If you have the exact same resources then you can only use it for so many things before you run out. In the case of tomatoes that theoretically would mean more fruit or larger fruit. Maybe more branches, leaves, or roots. In my mind the only way to get around that is to get more nutrients. For breeding for productivity I think that means focus on having an extra large and vigorous root system where this tomato variety could outcompete and have an advantage over another variety that does not have those genetics.

But you would also want to combine the vigorous large root system traits with extra trusses of flowers and maybe larger fruit and perhaps genes for less leaves. You wouldn't want a tomato with vigorous roots and lots of leaves but no fruit. But it occurs to me that I have ignored the flavor portion of this discussion. I imagine you could have a tomato with great roots and productivity but perhaps they would not have the right genetics to gather all the nutrients that might contribute to flavor.

In our world of breeding I have run into this issue with peas and other crops. They might grow great for me and taste wonderful, but when I send seeds out to others with vastly different soil they taste terrible. I think what this means is I am selecting my varieties to thrive in my soil and when they go to different soil they do not gather the same nutrients for flavor as they are no longer adapted to those conditions.

Nicolas

I think there is room to improve both yield and taste. At least there are studies about brix x yield in tomatoes

Kadence Luneman

I just got a response from Craig Lehoullier and he will be sending me seed to grow out and look for interesting plants. I'm gonna have to revise what tomatoes are being planted haha.

UnicornEmily

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2022-12-04, 09:48:28 AMIn our world of breeding I have run into this issue with peas and other crops. They might grow great for me and taste wonderful, but when I send seeds out to others with vastly different soil they taste terrible. I think what this means is I am selecting my varieties to thrive in my soil and when they go to different soil they do not gather the same nutrients for flavor as they are no longer adapted to those conditions.

Yeah, you may be breeding for plants that cooperate really well with your soil's microbes, for instance, and you aren't sending those microbes along with the seeds to someone in a different climate.

I can easily see fruit size and flavor being negatively correlated -- there are so many species where the sweeter the fruit, the smaller it seems to be.  But there are enough exceptions to make it clear it's not a zero-sum game, just a strong correlation.  For instance, big sweet apples versus little sour crabapples.  I bet that has been the result of a lot of work by a lot of our ancestors.

Also, while tiny alpine strawberries are very sweet, and supermarket strawberries tend to be huge and rather sour, one of my neighbors has everbearing strawberries that are huge and super sweet.  (I asked her for thinnings to plant in my yard.  ;P)

So my suspicion is that it's a strong correlation, but it can be overcome by having more resources available to the plant, allowing it to do both.  This can be accomplished by having more fertile soil, having genetics (or epigenetics?) that allow the plant to form optimal relationships with local microbes, and just simply leaving fruit on the plant until perfectly ripe, so that the plant has as much time as possible to put nutrients into it.

AndrewB

I'm proceeding with hoping to try to trial 24 dwarf tomato project varieties. Will have to try them all in large containers. I think I can squeeze 2 rows of 3, or 6 in each bucket. So 4 total buckets.

Here are the ones I'm planning to try:


60 days - 'Bundaberg Rumball'

65 days - Sarandipity

65 days - Uluru Ochre

65 days - 'Dwarf Galen's Yellow'

65 days - Dwarf Mocha's Cherry



70 days - Dwarf Velvet Night

70 days - Dwarf Dainty Isabel

70 days - 'Kookaburra Cackle'

70 days - Loxton Lad

70 days - Dwarf Purple Heart



75 days - Dwarf Jeremy's Stripes

75 days - 'Maralinga'

75 days - Dwarf Vince's Haze

75 days – Dwarf Blazing Beauty

75 days - 'Dwarf Franklin County'

75 days - 'Dwarf Maura's Cardinal'

75 days - Dwarf Orange Cream

75 days - 'Dwarf Andy's Forty'

75 days - Dwarf Beauty King

75 days - Dwarf Firebird Sweet

75 days - Fred's Tie Dye

75 days - Dwarf Mary's Cherry

75 days - Dwarf Metallica

75 days - Dwarf Jeremy's Stripes Tomato

In the end I ended up ordering a few extra, so the trial varieties may change slightly. We will see. I also need to find room to at least plant "the one" from William, even though it's not a dwarf. Also would like to try growing Big-Hill from Joseph again, I think it is a dwarf or bush variety.

William Schlegel

#69
I think you can think of "The One" fairly safely as a dwarf. Though the mechanism might be slightly different. Big Hill HX-9 is a more or less full-size plant for me but my shallow soil and aversion to support tends to keep tomato plants smaller. I have grown it in a container before.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

William, are you trying to stabilize The One, or use it primarily as a genetic input to other projects?

Kadence Luneman

I forgot to post the dwarf project seeds I got in.

-- Dwarf oriole, 8-16oz, orange, should be regular leaf

-- Dwarf Gloria's treat, 6-12oz, bicolor heart, potato leaf

-- Sandy Dwarf stripes (not yet released) variegated leaves, chocolate, 4oz round, green stripes

-- Dwarf beastly yellow heart, (not yet released) potato leaf, 6-8oz, yellow heart

-- Dwarf Phyl's ivory beauty (not yet released) medium size, ivory

AndrewB

I may be wrong but it is my understanding that in tomatoes bush and Dwarf are not the same, but similar. Then there is micro dwarf. Maybe it is like peas where there are multiple ways to get dwarf or bush type plants, some taller than others.

William Schlegel

Re "The One" I definitely was trying to both stabilize and cross with "The One" last year. I am not sure what I'm doing with it this year. I am definitely excited to find out if I have crosses with it.


Re: types of tomatoes. Yeah, I haven't really heard of bush tomatoes before. There are some other things out there too like dwarfisms that aren't the same as what the dwarf tomato project went for. Sometimes things show up in a category just because they are small too.

Microdwarf has more genes involved somehow. Not all may be the same. I was told that the cross I made with the microdwarf Aztek should segregate out both microdwarf and regular dwarf.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Richard Watson

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-17, 02:31:18 PMI may be wrong but it is my understanding that in tomatoes bush and Dwarf are not the same, but similar. Then there is micro dwarf. Maybe it is like peas where there are multiple ways to get dwarf or bush type plants, some taller than others.

Scoresby dwarf is what I had always thought a dwarf was, first I have heard of a micro dwarf though
Changeable climate manly during winter & spring - 500mm average yearly rainfall. 23 years of soil improvements plus sub soil top soil reversal means my garden beds are about half metre deep. Below that is 100's of metres of alluvial shingle