Now I want to grow a carob tree . . .

Started by UnicornEmily, 2022-11-19, 06:34:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

UnicornEmily

Quote from: Jeremy Weiss on 2022-11-28, 12:28:26 AMAS far as I know, pretty much ALL citrus have thorns. And looking at the seedlings won't help; the thorns don't show up until the plants are older. If you are committed to thornless citrus; you're pretty much limited to the really tiny ones, like kumquats and calamondins.

That's useful to know!  Thank you!  I'll still plant seeds from any good-tasting citrus fruit I've bought (because why not?), but it sounds like kumquat is probably the citrus I want most.  I had been thinking that, anyway, since they're more cold hardy than most.

Quote from: Jeremy Weiss on 2022-11-28, 12:28:26 AMYeah, bush usually beats pole. I suspect that the only reason pole beans are still relatively common is that a lot of them were grown in small home gardens, where people could take the time to put up supports.

I thought last year that I preferred bush over pole, but I've discovered that bush beans get easily shaded to death if I plant them near bush squashes, which I grow a lot of.  (Wry grin.)  Whereas carrots do just fine underneath bush zucchinis, because the leaves are so thin and tall that they poke up between the giant squash leaves, and neither species competes with the other.  So next year, I'm thinking I'll try a modified three sisters thing -- I'll plant sorghum in between my squashes and put pole beans next to them to grow up and use them as a trellis.  My thought is, that might work really well.

I'll keep an eye out for the traits you mentioned!  If I stumble across any of them, I'll let you know.  :)

Quote from: Jeremy Weiss on 2022-11-28, 12:28:26 AMYou are aware that Austrian Winter is a soup pea as opposed to a snap pea, right? The pods are going to be pretty fibrous and not taste that great. When you said your family likes peas, I'm hoping you meant they like them as pea soup or something like that.

Nope, didn't know, but it probably doesn't matter.  We usually eat them cooked into casseroles or whatever.  And I'm the only one who's willing to eat the pods.  I eat pods even from shelling peas; I don't mind how fibrous they are, because cook them in a crock pot for a long time along with other vegetables and meat, so they become soft anyway.

Also, pea leaves are a yummy extra harvest that we all are willing to eat.  :D

In any case, if they don't work, I've lost nothing in terms of time or garden space, and I'm 99% sure they will work for something!  (If nothing else, I know I'll eat them.)

I'll keep an eye out for any black or purple seeds.  I bought a 5 pound bag, so if I see any in there, I'll try to remember to set them aside to send to you.




Jeremy Weiss

Keep your eyes peeled for marmorated (mottled) seeds as well (the mottling in question looks sort of like military camouflage). It's not that I need them, but pure Austrian Winter isn't supposed to have them (as far as I know), but some have gotten in to  a few suppliers (Seeds of Change's ones, for example). So you may want to pull them (the adulterant peas are also rather on the small size, so if you leave them in they could make your peas get smaller in the future.) 

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2022-11-28, 02:31:00 AMhttps://www.seedways.org/product-page/bambaras-village-mix

Here's a page with more Bambaras.

Dunno if it's the same type or ones that you have.

They also have landrace / rare peas and other neat stuff on there.

They had a yellow fruited ashwagandha at one point too. Wish I'd gotten it.

Oh yeah, some Pawpaw relatives are decently cold hardy - same genus, not family.

Bigflower pawpaws seem easy enough to find and grow.


There are some "very" cold hardy citrus that I'm looking into. Some may become weedy in my area eventually if I let them do whatever though.

I have those marked down and will update later.


Been looking into growing a bunch of Musa, Asimina, Yucca - other neat things just to let them wildy hybridize while I select for good fruits.

Surprisingly a lot of wild Musa species will grow in zone 8. Sorta hard to find any US sources though.

Lot of them should work in zone 7 as well, but... Those are mostly not very edible.

My Bambarra mix is in  fact rather more diverse now than theirs appears to be. I have a guy in Ghana on Etsy who can supply most colors by the bagful, and a few months ago, I found someone whose mix included a few black seeded ones, so now I think I have every color I know of them coming in.

Pawpaws aren't a citrus, they're in the Custard Apple family, like cherimoyas, soursops, and such.

With cold hardy citrus, I think part of the problem is that there seems to be a tradeoff between cold hardiness and tastiness. I've heard a pure papeda can take down to -30 C, but is totally inedible. Trifoliate orange is cold hardy, but you can use the fruit only to make marmalade, if that. Even most of the "good" ones are not noted for being all THAT good. Those that have grown Ichang Lemons say they are okay for things like lemon pie, but you wouldn't want to use them in place of real lemons for cooking.

Not sure about the Ashwagandha, but ever since I heard of it, I've been trying to locate seeds for a red-fruited version of Solanum nigrum that is apparently grown in India as part of Ayurvedic medicine. 

UnicornEmily

#18
Yeah, tradeoffs between survivability and good flavor seem to be a common challenge when it comes to adapting plants.  Hence why wild plants often survive more easily than domesticated ones, and crossing the two is often a good idea to get some survivality back into our tasty crops.

Really cool thing I just learned!  Apparently there's a college campus about twenty minutes away from me that has a bunch of kumquat trees growing in-ground that aren't given any special care!  I was told they're red, they fruit in August, and anyone can take the fruit if they want it.  Next year, when they fruit, I should pick up some of the ripe fruit and see if they're any good.  If I like them, I can save seeds, and then I'll have the means to grow a kumquat tree that's already locally adapted!

It's odd that the fruits are red.  I thought all kumquats had orange fruit.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-29, 08:26:36 AMYeah, tradeoffs between survivability and good flavor seem to be a common challenge when it comes to adapting plants.  Hence why breeding wild plants often survive more easily than domesticated ones.

Really cool thing I just learned!  Apparently there's a college campus about twenty minutes away from me that has a bunch of kumquat trees growing in-ground that aren't given any special care!  I was told they're red, they fruit in August, and anyone can take the fruit if they want it.  Next year, when they fruit, I should pick up some of the ripe fruit and see if they're any good.  If I like them, I can save seeds, and then I'll have the means to grow a kumquat tree that's already locally adapted!

It's odd that the fruits are red.  I thought all kumquats had orange fruit.


So did I. But, given that Kumquats can be crossed with other citruses to make things like orangequats and limequats, I can just imagine that someone might try to cross a kumquat with a blood orange. THAT might make them red. Or it could be a miscommunication. I have heard some mandarins described as "red" because they are a much darker shade of orange than the orange we are used to for oranges. This, of course, being apart from the "red mandarins" I sometimes find, which ARE a tangerine/blood orange cross. I think pink lemons and grapefruit also have blood orange DNA in them.

Oh, that reminds me, there are a few citruses I have encountered you probably DO NOT want to grow, at least if you are planning to eat them. There exist a few citruses that have had ALL the acidity bred out of them. That SOUNDS good, but in fact leaves them with a very flat, unappealing taste. Off the top of my head the three main ones are the Palestinian Sweet Lime, The Jamaican Sweet Lemon, and something called a mango orange. This third is an odd looking one since, when you peel it, it looks pink inside (not in the way a Cara Cara is pink in the flesh, in a mango orange it's the PITH that's pink) They taste vaguely of raspberries, and not much else. I know about them because for a few years a company called Buck Brands supplied citrus to Mrs. Green's (our local organic/health food store chain) They grew them, and Mrs. Green's would stock them, but they would mark them as blood oranges (often mixing them in the same pile with ACTUAL blood oranges from another orchard, which is how I learned to read the fruit stickers VERY closely). They dropped them a few years later (along with the minkans I was after) for more conventional citrus, and then Mrs. Green's dropped them as a supplier a bit later than that (and then recently, Mrs. Greens dropped the Mrs. and is just Green's now)


UnicornEmily

How interesting.  Those do sound like they should be good.  I love sweet fruit, and I'm not fond of sour fruit.  Are any of them particularly cold hardy?  If so, perhaps I'll see if I can track down a fruit, try it to see if I like it despite most people not liking them, and plant the seeds if I do.

UnicornEmily

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2022-11-28, 02:31:00 AMBeen looking into growing a bunch of Musa, Asimina, Yucca - other neat things just to let them wildy hybridize while I select for good fruits.

Surprisingly a lot of wild Musa species will grow in zone 8. Sorta hard to find any US sources though.

Lot of them should work in zone 7 as well, but... Those are mostly not very edible.


I've bought a bunch of seeds from wild Musa species, and I'm planning to landrace them!  :D  I want to have cold hardy bananas that can survive in my yard and produce edible bananas.  I figure if I try a bunch of different species, chances are I'll stumble across at least one that tastes pretty good.

I often hear people say seeded bananas are inedible, but what they usually mean is that most people don't want to eat bananas with seeds.  I've decided I can live with seeded bananas, just as long as they taste good and can grow without any special care in my yard.  ;)  Worst case scenario, they'll be so seedy that I'll need to suck the little pulp off the seeds.  I can live with that.  Especially since, as the landrace continues, I'll keep selecting for more and more fruit flesh and fewer and fewer seeds.  It might take awhile, but I'm determined to do it!  :D

If you want me to make a list of the Musa species I have found most promising so far in my research, I'd be happy to do so.  I haven't gotten any of the seeds to germinate yet, so I don't know yet which ones actually will be best.  ;)



Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-29, 01:59:53 PMHow interesting.  Those do sound like they should be good.  I love sweet fruit, and I'm not fond of sour fruit.  Are any of them particularly cold hardy?  If so, perhaps I'll see if I can track down a fruit, try it to see if I like it despite most people not liking them, and plant the seeds if I do.

Not to my knowledge. And they aren't as good as they sound. Even sweet fruit needs a LITTLE tartness to make it taste OK. Eating these things is like eating a spoonful of sugar straight, there's no nuance.

I found plenty of (old) sites talking about them, but no solid leads on finding them now (https://ohjoy.com/my_weblog/2012/02/taste-it-mango-oranges.html#:~:text=About%20the%20size%20of%20a,lemon%20of%20the%20orange%20world.)

UnicornEmily

"Tastes like a spoonful of straight sugar" does not deter me . . . *wry grin*  That sounds delicious.  I have a massive sweet tooth, and I have never yet found anything too sweet for me.