Back Crossing Latah

Started by Tim DH, 2022-09-02, 02:13:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tim DH

I Like Latah, except that it is determinate and I also wonder how it would be as a potato leaf.

As an offshoot of the F1 project I can work on an indeterminate potato leaved version!

The F1 is 50% Latah, indeterminate and regular leaved. Given that both parents are 'early' I should manage to squeeze a ripe fruit out of the F1 this season. The plant pictured is romping away! I think I can already see flower buds in its crown.

The F2 should be 75% Indet and 25% Potato Leaved. So next year, raise a batch of F2s, scrap all the regular leaves and pot up a few potato leaves. Back cross Latah pollen onto the earliest flowers and subsequently scrap any plants that terminate their growing point. Treat the F3 like the F1 and try to squeeze a ripe fruit out of it before the end of the season.

The F4 should be nominally 75% Latah, not allowing for gene linkage. (Gene linkage is likely to be a factor since I'm selecting for two non-Latah characteristics)
It should be 25% PL and 75% or 50% Indet (depending on whether the mother plant was homo or heterozygous for Indet.) Back cross a few PL seedings with Latah pollen and scrap any which terminate. Treat the F5 like the F1 & F3.

The F6 should be nominally 87% Latah
The F8 nominally 93% Latah

Obviously this two generation per year program could be continued indefinitely, subject to the law of diminishing returns and on the presumption that the Almighty doesn't decide to re-allocate my resources to pushing up daisies!

At any point, stabilising the line for Indet should take just one extra generation.

I'll call my back-crossed Latah Hatal

Tim DH

Tim DH

#1
First flower today, so hopefully I'll get a bit of seed before the nights draw in. This 46 days after planting. The pot is in my best/sunniest window. It's quite fun having a bit of tomato excitement this late in the season. The possibility of two generations a year is very exciting!

Tim DH

I'll try adding the picture when the system lets me!IMG_3011_edited.jpg

Tim DH

     Eighty days from sowing and my F2 fruit is swelling. Our day length has just dropped below 10 hours, so I'm wondering what these fellows will do about ripening.

     The curious thing about this fruit is the length of the sepals, up to 35mm. I've just been out into the greenhouse to check the failing fruit on the parents and non of them have sepals even half that length EXCEPT that one side shoot I failed to prune out has recently set some green fruit, and it has the long sepals! So I'm guessing its a physiological response to either the low light, or lack of warmth.

Tim DH

   We ate the first F1 tom today. ... Sorry, I should have photographed it first! .. Attached, a picture of the fruit as it started to ripen taken 5 days ago. It was surprisingly tasty for a plant that had seen little heat or sunshine. (The texture was rather mealy.)
   Ninety Five days, sowing to picking. ... add on three days for fermenting the seed and it gives a generation time of just under 100 days. .... Hmmm. .... I wonder if I could squeeze in three generations next year? ... I'm not selecting for anything which would require optimal growth conditions (taste or yield). I'm just selecting for objective criteria (Leaf form and Stem Growth form)
   Incidentally, I am fermenting most of this F2 seed, but I also saved some by the 'eat it and spit it out' method. Germinating them side by side should test the cause of the differential germination noted on the F1 thread.

AndrewB

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-11-09, 01:31:19 PMWe ate the first F1 tom today. ... )
   Incidentally, I am fermenting most of this F2 seed, but I also saved some by the 'eat it and spit it out' method. Germinating them side by side should test the cause of the differential germination noted on the F1 thread.

Nice. Congrats.

Can you expound on this?

UnicornEmily

What are the advantages of potato leaves, over normal tomato leaves?

William Schlegel

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-09, 07:29:11 PMWhat are the advantages of potato leaves, over normal tomato leaves?

The manager of an organic greenhouse I worked for when my son was new liked them and thought them advantageous for healthier plants.

I'm not convinced of that. I like them because they are recessive so I can use them as mothers with regular leaf fathers.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Vesa Tee

#7
There are more than one "broad leaf" genes in tomato but the classical PL gene is cc. The c comes from the wild type Cut Leaf CC. The indeterminate (Sp) and determinate (sp) are named after self pruning.

Here comes my point: the C and Sp genes are located both in the same chromosome  so close together that they form a classical "linkage group" that is very difficult to break. This means that if you cross an indeterminate PL with determinate RL, all PLs in F2 generation are indeterminates. It is am exception to the mendelian rule where one would expect normal segregation between indeterminates and determinates. This is documented in some very early linkage studies done in 1950s or even 1930s. Tried to find a reference but didn't find it now.

I have tested this in practise and it seems to work. In my case, I was selecting determinate plants and cut away all PLs in F2. None of the RLs segregated back to PL in F3.

A problem is of course to know if you really have a PL (cc) plant imvolved in the cross. Not all plants that amateurs call PLs are because of cc.

Vesa Tee

And then I found the reference, seems to be from year 1934 (look for Chromosome IV group).

https://www.ias.ac.in/describe/article/jgen/029/01/0123-0133

Tim DH

Hi Andrew,
   Prior to the F1 project I only ever wanted a few seed. Enough to raise a couple of plants and maybe give away a couple plus save a few for future years just in case. So I'd save maybe a dozen seed from two different fruit, just by popping a pip into my mouth, nipping the jelly bag with my teeth and wiggling the seed out with my tongue. These seeds were then dried on paper. Quick and easy, it often happened in the course of a meal or whilst cooking.
   For the F1 project I wanted a lot of seed, so I started saving seed by the three day fermentation route.
   When it came to testing the F1s for leaf form I also planted some parental seed alongside for comparison. The F1s germinated much better, which I hoped was an early expression of hybrid vigour HOWEVER since the seed was saved differently, (F1 seed fermented, OP parent seed 'spat') it is possible that that was the explanation.
   With this F2 seed I now have fermented and spat from the same tomato.....

Tim DH

Hi Emily,
   This paper:
https://nph.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/nph.16403
   suggests that tomato plants with 'rounder leaves having significantly improved fruit quality '

        Maybe when I've got my PL Latah I'll be able to give an opinion on that too!!


Steph S

That is fascinating, Vesa, about the linkage between potato leaf and sp.  I've had some PL involved in my crosses but none of my determinates have been PL - now I know why!

UnicornEmily

Wow, that's fascinating!  Thank you!

Tim DH

Hi Vesa,
   Thanks for the link to the 1934 article. What a fantastic testament to good old scientific endeavour! The paper was ten years in the making and involved growing more than 48,000 plants!!!

   The bit about linkage between Potato Leaf and Indeterminate traits is good news for me on three counts.

   Firstly, I'll be able to achieve almost all my selection at the seedling stage on leaf shape.

   Secondly, I had assumed that, since I was selecting for two non-Latah traits there would be a certain amount of other non-Latah genetics that would be difficult to eliminate because of gene linkage. However since the two non-Latah traits I want are themselves so strongly linked, there will be a lot less other non-Latah material than if the traits had been on separate chromosomes.

   Thirdly, Stabilising a recessive characteristic in an open-pollinated line is easier than stabilising a dominant one.


   If you HADN'T posted this article I would have been curious about the lack of Determinate plants in the F2 and even more perplexed come F4, when standard Mendelian genetics would suggest up to half of the plants should be Determinate.

Vesa Tee

Hi Tim, I am glad that you found the article useful!

If you find a determinate PL during the process, you may want to save it too. Such cultivars are rare, and might be worth saving. Breaking the linkage is rare but must happen sometimes.

I have been planning a small back crossing project myself too but only with one dominant trait, the green shoulders (U). I have some compact determinate lines which have the uniform (u) trait and would benefit from U as flavour booster. I was thinking of crossing uu x UU first, and the F1 uU immediately back to the uu parent, all within one year. 50% of the resulting plants should be Uu which I could continue to stabilize. I could do some further back crossing, however, it would require using multiple parallel plants because I would not know anymore if the U gene is there or not. The first two crosses are safe to do with single plants.