Breeding Sweet Potatoes (turning them into a seed grown annual)

Started by reed, 2019-01-13, 06:44:39 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Richard Watson

So how cold are you talking when comes to cold hardy seedless bananas. Man I would love to grow them. ;D
Changeable climate manly during winter & spring - 500mm average yearly rainfall. 23 years of soil improvements plus sub soil top soil reversal means my garden beds are about half metre deep. Below that is 100's of metres of alluvial shingle

Kadence Luneman

This has been really interesting on sweet potatoes. I'll have to see how next year goes before I add more  ::) but definitely might have to make room to try sweet potatoes.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-10-18, 07:13:32 PMOh, nice!  If it's seedless, it's probably a Dwarf Namwah or Dwarf Orinoco.  My suspicion is Dwarf Orinoco, since that seems to be the most popular seedless banana for cold hardiness.  Dwarf Namwah seems to be the second most popular.

If anyone in your area ends up with extra pups, let me know!  Cold hardy seedless bananas are very welcome in my yard, too.  :)  I have a baby Dwarf Namwah, and I'm hoping it'll survive this winter without protection.  If I get any extra pups next year, I'd be happy to send you one if you'd like it.

My primary landrace goal is cold hardy, tasty seeded bananas, but if I manage to get brand new cold hardy, tasty *seedless* banana . . . well, that's sorta the holy grail of banana breeding!  *grin*  If I ever happen to have a seeded banana and a seedless banana flowering at the same time, I'll definitely try to cross them and see if anything interesting results.

Do you have any sweet potato seeds you wouldn't mind sharing?  I'd be interested in trying to grow some, and I'll probably trial them for drought tolerance.  I'd be happy to send you back seeds next year from anything promising.  I'm very sold on the idea of growing things from seeds instead of constantly cloning them.  Genetic diversity is so much better.



I suppose it also depends on the species. I've seen many banana seeds, and depending on which one, you could be talking about a banana you'd have to mash up before consumption to avoid cracking your teeth on thumb end sized rock hard seeds!

I have my own little pet project (trying to bring the Asian rice bean farther north and make it a feasible crop for growing in the US.

reed

It can hit -20 C or colder here but usually only does it for a day or two at a time. The fellow I know that has the bananas lives in the valley about 400 feet lower elevation and with deep black flood plain soil and at the base of a south facing hill. I don't think he knows what kind they are or much about them really, someone gave them to him, and they lived. The leaves are very dark green and reddish on the underside. He has quite a patch of them, I'm not sure, but I think the larger ones die in winter and the pups survive under the mulch. I don't think he ever gets a banana, but his grove of trees is a popular drive by tourist attraction. He gave me a couple of pups one time and they grew well but did not grow any more pups or survive winter, even with lots of mulch. The ones my niece has look the same but don't get as big, she lives up a ridge like I do.


AndrewB

Off topic, but just saw a video from allthefruit on YouTube where an Avacado tree is growing in Germany

UnicornEmily

Quote from: Richard Watson on 2022-10-19, 05:46:36 PMSo how cold are you talking when comes to cold hardy seedless bananas. Man I would love to grow them. ;D

Well, I'm in zone 7b, so at least that cold hardy!  ;P

It looks like you're in zone 9?  There are a TON of options for zone 9 that you could grow right now!  Including quite a few seedless ones.  Here are some I've considered for myself (even though some of them aren't hardy to my zone) that would all work in zone 9 easily:

Dwarf Namwah (a.k.a. Pisang Awak, Dwarf Ducasse): Zone 7.  Triploid ABB.  Tastiest, sweetest, high-quality fruit.  One of the best ladyfinger bananas.  6-8 feet tall.  Great container banana.  Drought resistant and vigorous.
Dwarf Orinoco: Zone 7. The most popular seedless cold hardy banana.
California Gold:  Zone 7.  It was a sport of Dwarf Orinoco.  It grows back as quickly as Basjoo in the spring and will fruit in eleven months from pup to mature height.  Mature and producing fruit at six feet tall.  Fruits every single year.  It's very rare, and pups often cost $100 each.
Raja Puri: Zone 8.  Triploid AAB.  8-10 feet tall.  Immune to Panama Disease and resistant to insects.
Thousand Fingers: Zone 8.  Triploid AAB.  8-10 feet tall.  Fruit is small, with a pleasant flavor.
Misi Luki (a.k.a. Mysore, Pisang Ceylon, Pisang Keling): Zone 9.  Triploid AAB.  15-20 feet tall in the ground; 10-12 feet tall in a container.  Sweet, silky, with a slight apple flavor.  Some say it tastes like strawberry shortcake.  Some say it's the best-tasting ladyfinger banana in the world.


If I were you, with zone 9 to work with, I'd try all of them!  Raja Puri and Misi Luki are definitely varieties I'd like to try; I'd definitely have to mulch them heavily to get them survive in my zone, but it may be possible.


UnicornEmily

Quote from: Jeremy Weiss on 2022-10-20, 12:41:59 AMI suppose it also depends on the species. I've seen many banana seeds, and depending on which one, you could be talking about a banana you'd have to mash up before consumption to avoid cracking your teeth on thumb end sized rock hard seeds!

Yep.  All of the banana seeds I have are as hard as rocks.  (Well, little pebbles.)  And too big to swallow.  And a lot of the fruits are chock full of those seeds.

One of the things I'm planning to do is to follow Carol Deppe's example in breeding squash.  She said she actively selects for fewer seeds that are bigger, and a higher ratio of fruit to seed.  I figure if that can be done with squash, it can probably be done with bananas, too!  (Especially since it's obvious a lot of domesticated fruits have been bred that way, compared to their wild counterparts.)

I figure when it comes to the seeds, there are several different paths to success, and I'll favor any plant that shows any of these:

  • Seedless.  This tends to mean triploid, which is really tough to get, so I'm not holding my breath, and it's not my primary goal.  Besides, it would be a genetic dead end that could only be propagated asexually.  Still, a new cold hardy seedless banana plant would be awesome, and I'd definitely propagate it to share if I got one.
  • Mostly seedless.  This is a very intriguing possibility that I only just stumbled across.  Some tetraploid bananas produce a lot of seedless fruits and a few fruits with very few seeds, mostly clustered up at the top.  If I could manage that, I'd have the best of both worlds.  That may be very cool, if something like that turns up for me.
  • Larger seeds and a lot fewer of them.  Right now, the seeds are small enough to be hard to avoid, yet big enough to be too large to swallow.  I figure seeds that are twice the size would be easier to notice and eat around, especially if there are a lot fewer, and germination may be easier.
  • Smaller seeds that can be swallowed.  I don't really favor this one because I suspect that would be selecting for less vigorous seeds -- small seeds have a tendency to be more difficult to germinate, in my experience.  And banana seeds are already hard to germinate, because the seeded species are mostly wild and haven't been domesticated at all yet.  Still, if something like this turns up, I'd certainly keep it around and see what I can do with it.
  • Softer seeds that can be chewed.  This might be particularly interesting, because that would imply a thinner seed coat, which may make germination much easier.  This would only work if the seeds taste fine and don't spoil the flavor of the fruit.


So yeah, seeds are definitely an issue.  For now, my plan is to eat the bananas by taking a bite, sucking on the pulp, and spitting out the seeds.  If the banana tastes even halfway decent, I'll immediately direct sow half the seeds and save the other half.  Heck, for the first generation, if I don't have a lot of plants to choose from, I'll probably save and sow even the seeds from fruits that don't taste very good, since survival is the highest priority at the beginning.  For sure I'll be selecting for flavor once survival becomes consistent.

I would say my priorities, in order, are:

1) Survival to produce mature seeds (which happily also means fruit).
2) Larger seeds, smaller seeds, fewer seeds, or the same number of seeds but more fruit flesh.  (If both larger and smaller seeds pop up, I'll keep the populations as separate as possible.)
3) Delicious flavor.

I have a ton of other things I want that I will get excited about if they show up (variations in color or flavor or shape, exceptionally beautiful plants, drought tolerance, etc.), but those are all bonuses.  I figure plant breeding is collaborative by its very nature, so I'll see whatever the plants offer me!



UnicornEmily

Quote from: reed on 2022-10-20, 03:39:36 AMIt can hit -20 C or colder here but usually only does it for a day or two at a time. The fellow I know that has the bananas lives in the valley about 400 feet lower elevation and with deep black flood plain soil and at the base of a south facing hill. I don't think he knows what kind they are or much about them really, someone gave them to him, and they lived. The leaves are very dark green and reddish on the underside. He has quite a patch of them, I'm not sure, but I think the larger ones die in winter and the pups survive under the mulch. I don't think he ever gets a banana, but his grove of trees is a popular drive by tourist attraction. He gave me a couple of pups one time and they grew well but did not grow any more pups or survive winter, even with lots of mulch. The ones my niece has look the same but don't get as big, she lives up a ridge like I do.

Ohhhh!  I bet that's an Ensete, not a Musa!  It sounds like Red Banana, which is in the Ensete genus and hardy to zone 7.  That would be consistent with what you've described.  Do they produce fruit?  Do they make pups (suckers)?  If they make suckers, they're probably a Musa.  Same for if they make fruit.

I'm less interested in Ensete, because I think it's mainly ornamental for the leaves, and I want fruit.  If it makes fruit I can eat, though, I'm not too fussed about the genus.

Edit: Whoops, you said it made pups, and I'm a doofus and didn't pay enough attention.  Probably a Musa, then!

How tall do they get?  Do they have a dwarf growth habit (leaves really close together, trunk really thick and stocky) or a tall growth habit (each new leaf grows upwards quite a bit, trunk quite thin)?  I may be able to figure out what species they are from those details.  If nothing else, it's fun to know that.  :)


reed

I'm planning next season's sweet potato project. I have clippings of 10 different plants from what I'm calling the "ornamental" class growing in the south facing kitchen windows. They vary in leaf shape, color and vine growth habit. What they have in common is prolific blooming and lack of large storage roots. They all matured seeds and are all sprouts from 2022.

I have storage roots from fifteen different plants of what I'm now calling the "culinary" class. These also vary in leaf shape and color and to a lesser degree in vine growth type. Most are in the bushy range or semi-vining, with a couple large vine types. These all make nicely sized storage roots of the clump root type. Root skin and flesh color varies with most being white fleshed. About half are "best of the best" clones from 2021, 2020 or 2019 and the rest new sprouts from 2022.

In preparation to begin planning for some kind of marketing and distribution late in 2023 or 2024 I'm setting up a comparison trial for 2023. The trial will include 100 newly sprouted plants, along with clones from "best of the best" and some commercial clones. The commercial clones I'm considering are the most recent releases from university breeding programs (Covington) from North Carolina State University and (Evangeline) from Louisiana State University and maybe a couple of popular "heirloom" varieties as well.

My own clones and the university clones will be compared to each other in production, flavor and so on as well as similar comparison to newly sprouted plants.

The newly sprouted plants will be closely monitored and documented for the following.   

During the Growing Season
*Days to germination
*Color and shape of leaves
*Internode distance between leaves
*Type of vine growth, bushy - vining - semi vining
*Number of flowers overall
*Number of flowers per cluster
*Ability to accept pollen and mature seeds
*Thickness of primary stem where it enters the ground
*Date of first blooms
*Response to temperature extremes
*Susceptibility to insects, specifically Japanese Beetles
At Harvest
*Type of root growth
*Configuration of root growth
*Color of root skin
*Color of root flesh
*Size of roots
*Shape of roots
*Number of roots per plant
*Sweetness (before curing)
*Weight of roots per plant

Along with determining a true germination rate of seeds, I want to know if traits observable during the growing season can be used to predict the root type, prior to actual harvest. If so, it will be useful in the future for eliminating undesirable plants before harvest time, perhaps even before they bloom.

I may also grow a few that I suspect of being self-pollinating in semi-isolated spots just to see what happens. My very first seeds came from a self-pollinating, rootless ornamental. I think it would be very cool if some self-pollinating culinary plants could be confirmed. Those plants might be very useful in expanding breeding projects with sweet potatoes.

I will also be recording daily weather data and types of pollinators visiting the flowers.


UnicornEmily

This sounds incredibly awesome.  When your seed variety is purchasable, I will definitely buy some.  :)

AndrewB

Love this project. Can't wait for seeds! Keep up the hard work!!

reed

I have an unusual situation with some of my ornamental class clones that I'm keeping for next year. As shown in the picture some of them don't look great. A cold drafty window isn't the best place for sweet potatoes but that's expected and not really a concern. From past experience any tiny bit of life remaining when warmer temps and increasing light arrives is enough. Those to the left in the photo also were infested with aphids and it's been a struggle keeping them washed off.

These are the best of last year's ornamental class seedlings, they lacked large storage roots, and all bloomed excessively. Lack of storge roots is why they have to be kept as house plants instead of just sprouting slips next year.

What is unusual is that several have continued to bloom since being brough it back in October. It's normal for existing buds to go ahead and open but this is the first time new buds have formed after being brought inside. Only one has a flower right now on January 3rd, 2023, but several have been doing it all through December.

IMG_2681.png

Kadence Luneman

How curious. I wouldn't have guessed that they would even think about flowering inside, though I'm a sweet potato novice. I guess just because they are always talked about like, so difficult to grow.

If you have some excess seed I'd be interested in trying to grow some. And we aren't too far away.

reed

Yes, flowering inside is a surprise. I've been at this for ten years and haven't always kept any of the ornamental plants as clones, probably only five of the ten, but this is the first time I've seen this.

reed

Here is a little video about one of the houseplant sweet potatoes that up from seed in April of 2022.



*clearly, I have a lot to learn about making good videos.