GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming

Started by William Schlegel, 2022-02-23, 07:12:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Garrett Schantz

I know of a few people that I could convince to try these.

Also aware that a lot of people will see "GMO" and shun it.

Something like this could easily "contaminate" organic exserted tomatoes as well. But, the Anthocyanin shows in the fruit the following year if there is a cross. From what I have been reading, Wild Tomatoes can pollinate other groups quite far away due to bees - pretty similar to squash in that regard.

I think that the creators of this tomato want an open source tomato that people can save seed / grow themselves and breed with. Someone on the OSSI board could try emailing them - that could open those guys up into legal troubles in the future if some court starts ruling on things. I don't know if they even have any sort of protections on the Purple Tomato from what I can tell, would need to ask them.


It would be interesting to see if this turns some people towards these types of GMO. A lot of the people I know don't like GMOs because they are used to allow for the usage of toxic chemicals on plants.

Glyphosate is more than likely toxic, some suspicious back and forth emails between the FDA and a certain chemical company were found, some of which reportedly mentioned awareness that this chemical isn't entirely safe.


I could try explaining to some people all of the GMOs currently on the market to turn them over if they really feel unsafe with this.


Here are some things on the market that are GMO:

https://www.fda.gov/food/agricultural-biotechnology/gmo-crops-animal-food-and-beyond

Some of them added things to help fight off viruses or pests, not just plain old pesticide resistances.

I believe there is a GMO pink pineapple on the market as well.


I do believe that these sorts of GMO could be really nice. A bunch of nutrient dense "superfoods" could be developed

Miraculin GMO tomatoes could prove to be interesting, especially if one of the "odd" tomato flavors from wild species was tossed in. Those will probably be GMO, and they are being developed in Japan.


There isn't a requirement to label things as GMO here in the U.S. - Purple Ketchup would probably be on the news, people would probably still buy it regardless.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2022-04-07, 08:20:31 PM
Purple Ketchup would probably be on the news, people would probably still buy it regardless.

I'm not sure the ketchup would be purple. A long time ago, I did some experiments on what color tomatoes turned when you cooked them . Based on what I saw almost everything pushes itself closer to red-orange. White tomatoes cook down to yellow; yellow to orange; orange, pink and red to the reddish orange we normally associate with tomato sauce; purple and brown to a deep red (sort of the color of  Italian Madeira sauce) and green to a really ugly greenish brown (which is why I have always said that trying to create green paste tomatoes would always be of only limited use, since the only thing you could use them in would be things where you use paste tomatoes raw, like salsa and bruschetta.) So it is likely this tomato would change color as well when cooked, depending on how heat stable the anthocyanin is.

On mu side, I have been trying to find a "pure" green flesh tomato (one that has ONLY chlorophyll as a colorant, no secondary yellow xanthophylls like most have) and see what it cooks down to (I imagine it would be the same shade of green as cooked spinach.)     

Garrett Schantz

This hasn't been updated in awhile.

https://instagram.com/littlepurpletomato?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/

The fruits can be sold, as can seeds and things.


People in the public have tried the fruits out now, in events.


So it's fully approved.


I'd give it a few months before seeds are available to the public.

Just like GMO houseplants which filter out bad stuff more efficiently, there's a chance that these may not have a ton of seed stock.


I should be notified when seed is available.


It does seem like the tomatoes will stay purple when canned.



Flavr Savr, I'm still interested in growing that out as well. Another GMO tomato. I'd love to cross the two and have a tomato with both traits.



Just figured I'd give an update.


Dunno how people here feel about breeding with GMOs.


There's been mention that they should have plenty of seed for others, and they already have the gene crossed into typical hybrids and things, cherry tomatoes and things.

Flavr Savr suffered from using a bad tasting genetic base and it wasn't all that disease resistant.



So these guys are trying to do things right.

Mica Winnower

My worry is that they'll do what Monsanto did to corn farmers, and start taking people to court for growing out their own saved seed of this (potentially) patented GMO crop.

I've got nothing ethically wrong with GMO production in and of itself, it's just that our profit-focused consumerist food systems are built specifically to harm us little folk and keep agency out of our own hands.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Mica Winnower on 2023-08-26, 09:27:39 PMMy worry is that they'll do what Monsanto did to corn farmers, and start taking people to court for growing out their own saved seed of this (potentially) patented GMO crop.

I've got nothing ethically wrong with GMO production in and of itself, it's just that our profit-focused consumerist food systems are built specifically to harm us little folk and keep agency out of our own hands.

I worry about something more. Once the big companies have developed a good base of winning such cases, they could start DELIBERATELY setting up plots in places where they know the pollen will contaminate nearby crops, so THAT they can establish grounds for suits, with the ultimate goal of so saturating the environment with their modified pollen that growing crops that WON'T be contaminated will become all but impossible, leaving farmers only the options of buying their seeds and abiding by their terms or not growing the crop at all.

With their lawyer base they might even be able to convince judges that, when crops are contaminated with their pollen, those crops should de facto become their property. Then, they can claim and try to patent any novel genes THEY may have for their own use.

They could even try and claim WILD plants that get contaminated, so as to make foraging illegal as well. Ultimately, they probably COULD achieve what they have always wanted; total, complete and absolute control of the world food supply and, eventually of all life (most GMO's currently are for food or forage crops, but I see no reason someone could NOT make GMO versions of things like timber trees and medicinal plants. If there is a profit to be made, someone will eventually try and make it.)

Nicolas

I would love to play with the colors, but also would not eat it, so i'll pass.

Garrett Schantz

I believe those who made the big purple tomato have said that they have it so that anyone can breed with it.

Not just save seeds.


I may grow it indoors, they've developed some cherry tomatoes with the gene, they're breeding these into modern hybrids.



I don't want these crossing with exserted tomatoes.


The traits and things seem sound.

The flavors are probably the same as standard.

I remember seeing them mention crossing these into Sungold. I'd probably grow those seeds indoors as a potted plant.

The house has a large sunroom. Would work great to grow potted plants in.


It's been tested for long enough that I'd say it's safe.



I just know that people wouldn't want these contaminating their own tomatoes and things.

This one sure, they likely won't punish anyone for growing these out or whatever else.


Breeding these into different lines, you don't get a full purple affect either. So a first generation cross would have a tomato that's purpleish on the inside and outside.



I likely won't be able to even give away GMO tomatoes in my area.



Also, you cannot send any contaminated seed overseas.

That could grant you actual jail time. It's only approved in the United States.




The creators want a healthy tomato that can be shared and bred with - used to make even better tomatoes.



I'll likely have these indoors if I grow them.



I'd give it a few years before these get more widespread approval in different countries. Or before people go and buy GMO tomatoes.


They look very nice in terms of color. Reminds me of Wonderberry.



Flavr Savr had its patent run out if I recall. So anyone who tried growing it would be fine doing so.


This one, if they tried going back on some things, they'd run into legal issues.



Within the next few years, I can see other tomatoes with blue pigments or other things coming to market or being approved.

I'm unsure if those ones will be allowed to have seeds shared. Probably not.

So that will be an upcoming issue.


There's a ton of blue GMO tomatoes being made in different labs with different genes and things.


I'd prefer that someone crosses Solanum retroflexum or nigrum in a lab with tomatoes or Lycium ruthenicum with them.


It's not that I dislike the big purple tomato. Wonderful idea.


I just feel like it's opened up people's minds to GMO vegetables. If it's super safe and others realize it, regulators will likely decide there's already a GMO on the market and start approving more of them.


This one likely took awhile to be released, solely because some regulators know about other purple tomatoes and that these ones would screw up those plans and future marketing.

Probably why it hasn't been approved in other countries.



There aren't enough GMO laws for accidental hybrids, or introduced hybrids becoming mostly GMOs which are using non tomato traits and things for resistances.

And nobody can breed with those, or we'd have to breed our own tomatoes.



Not everyone who's aware of Flavr Savr is aware that it had more than just some added traits which made it last longer on shelves.

It also had added genes which made it immune to damage from some antibiotics.

The antibiotics were kanamycin and neomycin.


Or maybe added gene is a better term.


From my little bit of research, any progeny with the Flavr Savr genes, would also have the other added gene.

They were linked.


So, in breeding they'd dump antibiotics on seedlings. The survivors had the Flavr Savr's desired gene.

I have no idea how they still ended up releasing tomatoes which didn't have any disease resistances. Or tasted bad.



But, my point is that other new tomatoes may have that same thing going on or something similar.

Let's say other traits that act as markers or have natural insecticides that also harm bees or something are released.


Or tomatoes that fix nitrogen.


These would cause two different issues. One, would harm nature. The other would have GMO tomatoes that nobody else can grow, and anyone who grows tomatoes for sale, typically uses some fertilizer.

Anyone growing tomatoes would then be in a position where these GMO sellers could potentially sell these for cheap prices just to wash them out.



Its technically possible to make male sterile tomatoes, which still produce fruit. These would be seedless, I'd think.


There would still need to be breeding on those lines, I'd imagine. So there would probably be lines used just for breeding.



But yeah. These I may grow just as an oddity or whatever.


I'm interested as to why these haven't been mixed with Antho tomato lines which use another form of anthocyanin production.

I believe they'd do well crossed with one another. They both have the muddying issue when crossed with certain pigments and things.


Some people may be more sensitive to certain chemicals compared to others as well. But this has been tested for awhile.

Garrett Schantz

Added flavor traits or things like genes from miracle berry could also be added.

This would give large companies who have largely disallowed its usage, the rights to mainly distribute it

Some things are acquired tastes or things.



Beauty Berry and Sabal minor are two species which have odd flavors that I've tried recently since I've moved to Mississippi.

My first impression of Sabal minor was a odd nutty taste, different from almonds or peanuts - even without eating the seed. There's something nice about it.


American beauty berry, I tried some fresh ripe berries as well.

Some unripe ones had a slight bitterness. But, these seemed to be juicy and semi sweet. There was also another unique flavor which I hadn't tried before in it.

I tried researching the species.

I've read that it has a spiciness.


I haven't tried "Asian Five Spice."

I'm unsure of what spiciness refers to. I hate the taste of peppercorns. They don't taste spicy, they taste like death.

I have been wanting to taste Szechaun peppercorns - but those seemingly have a sort of heat or burn.

These didn't have a pepper burn or herbal taste or burn wither.


I've went out a few times and chewed or eaten some ripe berries, because these taste like something I've never had before.


I also tried eating some raw Beauty berries and raw palmetto berries. The mushy consistency was replaced with a semi soft texture when eaten together.

And some I thought it tasted good.



I'd like for whatever traits these have that make these fun chemicals to end up in a GMO. Ideally I could try and breed larger fruited beauty berries and palmetto. There's not much to work with, these barely have any flesh.

I had an odd notion of wanting to dry these and mix them, then make a powder that works as a seasoning for steak. I also had an odd notion where these had something I was missing in my diet.



But yeah. In terms of GMOs there's a lot of good you could do.

Strawberries and Sour gherkins are still at the top of my favorite fruits / vegetables.



A purple large sour gherkins would be funny to me.



Researching what can be done with GMOs is fun and all.

My point with some of this, is that different people react differently to different genes or even flavors.


Added genes need to have probably been tested for long periods of time on different groups of people.

Joseph Lofthouse

QuoteOr tomatoes that fix nitrogen.

My tomatoes already have that trait. I'll try to post a write up a summary of the research in the next little bit.

Roland

At first everyone is afraid of the unknown and GMO, later everyone is used to it and doesn't know any better.
Netherlands

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Garrett Schantz link=msg=13772 d<br><br><br>I have been wanting to taste Szechaun peppercorns - but those seemingly have a sort of heat or burn.<br><br>/quote]

Sichuan peppercorns don't really have a "burn", though given how often they are paired with chili peppers, you wouldn't often know this. Their flavor is more of a sort of tingling or numbing one, they may your mouth feel as if you just got it washed out with Novocain and (at least in my case) they also cause a bit of an astringent effect, so you start salivating A LOT.

I did once have a Chinese dish where they used Sichuan peppercorns and used NO chilis, and it was an odd experience.

There are technically THREE kinds out there, the Sichuan peppercorn, the Japanese member of the genus (called sansho pepper, and often used on fried things) and an Indian member that is semi-obscure (and, no, I don't know if the prickly ash tree we grow here can be used.)   

Cathy A

Jeremy is right. Sichuan peppercorns are numbing rather than hot, though they are often combined with chilis to produce a numbing-and-hot flavor

I routinely cook foods using Sichuan peppercorns, and also use them to make a refrigerator canned green bean. There's always a pack of the dried peppercorns in my pantry. They keep a very long time.


Garrett Schantz

I didn't get a numbing taste either, but that's still nice to know.

There's American species in the same genus as Sichuan peppercorns, I've been considering growing some of those out, just to see what happens.

I've heard related species in that genus cross readily.

I've also not heard of native species being used for anything but medicine.



All that I got from the Beauty berries was sweetness then an unknown flavor, I can't quite pinpoint what it is. Same goes with the Sabal species, but I can say it resembles a nutty flavor.



Anyways yeah. Having tomatoes or anything with chemicals found in these sorts of species would be nice, or having things with larger fruits.

When it comes to larger fruits, but not having any genes for larger fruits - you run into the issue of having to wait for mutants to pop up over a long period of time. These aren't very palatable due to the lack of very much flesh at all. Plus straining and other things.


Someone else mentioned elsewhere that there are larger fruited species or accessions, but they might have air pockets - but there may be genes that would make a purely fleshy larger fruited specimen.



Just figured I'd point out some GMO benefits.


They aren't all bad. But there are negatives like laws not moving fast enough or whatnot.



And yeah GMOs do mess up organic stuff.

Cathy A

It's just as well that no one near me grows tomatoes. Few of my neighbors have vegetable gardens at all.

I may not be 100% genetically isolated from tomatoes outside my yard, but I'm pretty close.

Garrett Schantz

I had two of Baker Creeks free magazines arrive today.

I'm unsure of as to why I received two of these.

I may give one to a neighbor who also buys seed from Baker Creek.


Renaissance Farms, has complained about a fruity or odd taste that comes along with anthocyanin.



This purple tomato, is said to have a fruity taste and be to be pretty sweet.


It's safe to say, that nobody here has ever had a fully purple tomato before.



As others have said here before.

Different colors of tomatoes and the like, also have different flavors or sugars attached to them.



I hate red tomatoes.

There's also different types of red, orange and other tomatoes.


Plus yellow and whatever too.



So, some people have also probably noticed a subtle tomato anthocyanin taste.


But, Purple Galaxy is full of anthocyanins.


Inside and out. Even the gel appears to be purple.


It seems like it starts out as a chocolate brown.


But yeah. Found in a group of non fully purple tomatoes. So it's a mutant of some sort.



They mentioned a plant breeder found it. I doubt it's possible to see their breeding lines.


There's also another subtle note mentioned in the catalogue.


Some of the foliage is purple or has purpling to it.


I've seen that happen when it gets too cold. Or some types just show some purple stems.

Or purple calyxes.


But, from this it's probably easy to recognize that it's probably a transponder that was messed with in some way.


Andrew mentioned purple podded peas and purple shelled peas.


This tomato is supposedly showing purpling in the leaves and fruit.




Now, back to the fruity flavors. This could be from another breeding line, adding in a fruity aftertaste.

Or, the anthocyanin being more expressed and widespread means that people eating this, will also get to experience a larger quantity of that flavor.



I've tried Otricoli Orange (Solanum nigrum). It tasted pretty awful.

Maybe the population as a whole, was just bad tasting. I've mostly only had Solanum nigrum, Garden Huckleberry and the like, from edible lines.

But, they definitely had a different flavor than Otricoli Orange. Much more different.


Some Jaltomata and things, also taste nice to me. Similar to blueberries in some cases.

But, non blue types also taste decent enough.



But either way.


I'd like to cross Sart Roloise into this tomato.


It has the fruity flavors from White Beauty, and it already has anthocyanins.


If these have different sugars or different reasons for having fruitier tastes. Then that sounds great.


It's also likey that certain sugars and things, are just anchored or attached to anthocyanin traits and things. So, the anthocyanin itself probably has more than just it's own sugars being carried along.



Either way, crossing the two sounds like a win-win. Anthocyanin and added flavors and sugars.



I'm unsure if these carry along the same sugars and flavors as Jaltomata or Solanum nigrum. They probably don't.


Anthocyanin being expressed in the leaves, is detrimental to plants.


I've heard of wild Capsicum mutants with dark leaves and fruit.


Solanum nigrum typically doesn't have dark leaves.


Some Jaltomata types, do have darker leaves.



And, it's worth noting that Solanum peruvianum's anthocyanin could also carry along different flavors or sugars. I'm pretty sure it does.

But, anthocyanin was barely expressed before this tomato popped up. So, any flavors coming over weren't really all too different I'd imagine.


Maybe this does have Peruvianum in it. Hard to say since it's from a breeding line.



It's also interesting to note, that I've heard that the GMO tomato also tastes sweet or has a berry flavor.


It could taste different from these tomatoes as well.


I would like to personally look at, and breed with the Snapdragon tomato before I eat it.



These images belong to Baker Creek. I'd recommend requesting a magazine. This is from the free catalog. This offers a better look at the fruit.