Former Soviet Bloc Tomato Genetics

Started by William Schlegel, 2024-01-14, 09:31:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10358335/

The above paper on the status of tomato breeding genetics in Kazakhstan is interesting. It seems like it finds that modern resistance markers, with a few notable exceptions like PH3, are a bit lacking in the country's tomatoes, particularly commercial tomatoes. Much of the genetics is soviet and or Russian in origin. It strikes me as potentially similar to what you might likely find in a similar assessment of the old tomato varieties bred in North Dakota, Idaho, and Alberta. From the published genealogies I have found they tend to share a high degree of ancestry. So I would expect genetic mapping to show little diversity within a group of tomatoes like that- just as this paper seems to show for Kazakhstan tomatoes. The Kazakh paper suggests future lines of inquiry that might answer even more questions. One obvious one to me is: How valuable, genetically, are tomatoes from the former Soviet Bloc for breeding? I'm guesstimating partly based on this article, that they are no more or less valuable for breeding than are any other groups of tomatoes from outside South America. I would have guessed they were more valuable, because of the Vavilov institute and some perception perhaps from the popularity of such tomatoes here. Bill McDorman's 1989 trip story is certainly one I have heard! https://www.seedstrust.com/blog/2018/6/10/the-great-siberian-adventure

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9727544/  Another interesting article that includes some interesting accessions but I need to study it more.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adam Igra

#1
There are many tomatoes advertised as russian in origin (forgetting as is often the case that the USSR =/= russia, something russia seems to be happy with people forgetting).
They are often advertised as cold hardy, early, etc.
Most of the USSRs population lived in zones 5-6 and areas such as ukraine actually have warmer growing seasons than say, the UK, though winters are also colder: Continental effect, same as the US gets.

Latitude is between the UK and Spain so has similar light to mid to northern US. I dont know to what extent they did experimental breeding there, but the caucuses, azerbaijan, southern central asia can get warmish climates with long seasons.

I found this page on their climate from a US perspective:
https://www.mobot.org/MOBOT/research/russia/climatic.shtml

Overall there should hopefully be some nice genes in their toms but I wouldnt be hopeful for rare real frost hardiness and else. I heard "Glacial" was a ruskie tom that was happy growing in lower temps but tasted terrible.

Cathy A

"Most of the USSRs population lived in zones 5-6 and areas such as ukraine actually have warmer growing seasons than say, the UK, though winters are also colder: Continental effect, same as the US gets."

This is something that is often forgotten or overlooked. I'm very interested in cold-hardy tomatoes, as they would be the best for my latitude and warmth profile.

So at first glance Russian or Soviet varieties look promising, but if they were bred near the Black Sea and optimized for that climate, they are unlikely to be better than other options.

On the other hand, if they were bred near St. Petersburg, they would be of great interest and relevance to me.

Steph S

The second article is more interesting, which started with 59 accessions for which some resistance to cold and drought and diseases had been reported, and reviewed their genetics.  I've grown or have heard of a number of these, which are in circulation in north america.
I only recognized one from the Kazhakstan list - Zagodka Prirody.

But in both cases, these are not large numbers of accessions compared to the number of cultivars that exist in Russia and around Eastern Europe.  Just within Russia alone, there are a number of large breeding and seed selling establishments which continue to put out new OP's, that is in addition to the long tradition of public breeding plus the independents, and the conservation of heirlooms, which are a large and robust group in their own right.   
I only gave the article a quick read (and a big zoom of that accession list which I could barely pick out), but I believe they implied some introgressions were evident in accessions related to breeding work of Gavrish, that's a big seed enterprise.
Russian heirlooms may be similar to those in Europe and North America, conserved mainly for taste qualities, and not designed for cold tolerance or disease resistance, or mass production for that matter. OTOH the public and private breeding efforts of the last 70 years have obviously tried to push the envelope for cold tolerance and disease resistance, which makes sense in basically all environments where tomatoes are grown.
 

Adam Igra

I have a tomato named Galina, which is supposedly very early. Seeing the name occur in that article suggests it is indeed siberian. I will trial it vs latah.

Cathy A

Quote from: Steph S on 2024-01-16, 03:42:58 PMJust within Russia alone, there are a number of large breeding and seed selling establishments which continue to put out new OP's

Do we know where they are located? Even if not specifically selecting for cold tolerance, fruiting in shorter seasons, ability to be pollinated and bear fruit in cool (not cold) weather, just knowing that a particular breeder was based in or near St. Petersburg (probably the northernmost major city in Russia) rather than in the southern regions down toward the Black Sea would make varieties developed there of much more interest to me.

For that matter, if Russian breeders developed a tomato variety that was intended to be grown in the St. Petersburg area, that would also be a strong indicator that it could have useful traits for the more northern parts of the US and the southern parts of Canada.

I did a quick search on "St. Petersburg tomato", but the hits you get refer to St. Petersburg, FL. :-)

Steph S

All I know about the Russian seed sellers is that their webpages with descriptions turn up in googles for Russian tomatoes.  (I haven't done that at all recently, since before the war, so IDK how it stands now.)
Quite a few Russian tomatoes are also described and listed at Tatiana's Tomatobase, where they have often been trialed in Canada as well and results reported.
https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Tatiana%27s_TOMATObase_-_Heritage_Tomatoes

Growers everywhere are interested in pushing the envelope of cold tolerance, whether you live in a warm climate that gets too hot in the summer, or a cold short season place, the interest is there, and breeders have paid attention to that.  Certainly in Russia the state sponsored breeding in the past included a focus on cold tolerance and disease tolerance.   And as their work also entered the stream of breeding material for their commercial seed sellers, introgressions and carefully selected varieties also feeds into the OPs they created as well.   
Yes it is similar to what our governments also sponsored in the past (if less so in the present day) to create cultivars resistant to stress and disease.
Are the Russian cultivars more cold tolerant?  I did see that as a trend in my trials, but I was looking for shorter season cold tolerant material anyway, nothing later than 'midseason'.  I could find perhaps equally rugged material from Europe or North America too.  But the Russian accessions tended to be more diverse in terms of shape and color and taste in that early-rugged category.  Vs. the omnipresent round red on this side of the pond.

Cathy A

Steph, I'll take cold-tolerant tomato genetics from any source I can get. :-)

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-01-16, 02:09:04 PMSo at first glance Russian or Soviet varieties look promising, but if they were bred near the Black Sea and optimized for that climate, they are unlikely to be better than other options.
Funnily enough the only Russian/Soviet tomato I really know is Black Sea Man, and it's the favourite of a friend in the far North of Sweden. So it does well there at least. Lacks disease resistance but is delicious and has a nice strong stem, and PL. I've been trying to cross resistance into it.

Steph S

I was never able to find the true seed for the determinate "Black Sea Man".  The first one I trialed was indeterminate but very early, reliable and cold hardy.  But it was not disease resistant, and for that reason I stopped growing them (to the dismay of my mother, who really loves them).
According to Tatiana "Chernomor" is the indeterminate version of Black Sea Man.  (and translates to 'black sea man'.)
I notice that Chernomor is listed in that second article that William linked, where they say it is resistant to Alternaria and some other diseases.  But if my experience and disease ID is correct, our Chernomor was susceptible to the hot weather Alternaria and quickly affected the stems in greenhouse conditions, which is worse than leaves.   OTOH in outdoor conditions (cool that is!) growing in my mother's garden, it got some funky leaves only and seemed to tolerate it with no big issues.
So I'm wondering about 'resistance' and how that is qualified by conditions, also whether the seed was a mutant that reverted to indeterminate from determinate conditon, or the same 'Chernomor' reported in the paper.  If there were sibling lines, determinate and indeterminate, there's no doubt in my mind that one could end up with resistance that's missing in the other.
Anyway I did source and try a couple of other 'Black Sea Man' seeds and none of them were determinates. They all tended to make a big first cluster, but the growth afterwards was 3 lfs between clusters, definitely indeterminate.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Steph S on 2024-01-18, 08:18:23 AMI was never able to find the true seed for the determinate "Black Sea Man"

How curious. I didn't even pay attention to whether mine were determinate or not. But they were short. So, perhaps indeterminate? I will try to pay more attention if I grow it again though I might just be growing the crosses.