Species Current Tomatoes vs. Hybrids

Started by Joseph Lofthouse, 2024-01-03, 09:11:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Joseph Lofthouse

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-03, 05:46:12 PMhttps://www.siskiyouseeds.com/collections/tomato-cherry/products/tomato-gold-currant

They identify the tomato as solanum pimpinelifolium. I wouldn't call it that, because pimpinelifolium bears red, pea-sized fruits, not orange fruits an inch in diameter.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2024-01-03, 09:11:50 PMThey identify the tomato as solanum pimpinelifolium. I wouldn't call it that, because pimpinelifolium bears red, pea-sized fruits, not orange fruits an inch in diameter.

True, probably has a decent amount of the genetics like all current and probably a lot of cherry tomatoes but not small enough.

I did grow this golden current- but from HRseeds in 2022. I think I saved a few seeds but I wasn't super excited by it- I didn't think the fruits were quite that large though.

I've never found anything I particularly thought was a current tomato in dehybridizing Sungold and Joseph you reported back that your current hybrids got size recovery back to current. Though these are already larger than currents as you just pointed out- and I was just thinking to myself that was a point against the hypothesis.

Though I had tons of current like but obviously part domestic tomatoes in my 2023 garden and I did grow quite a few current tomatoes in 2022 including this one- though most if not all of the 2024 versions had a bit of a blue blush indicating something crossed with something else in my 2022 garden.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#2
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-03, 09:22:04 PMI did grow this golden current- but from HRseeds in 2022. I think I saved a few seeds but I wasn't super excited by it- I didn't think the fruits were quite that large though.

From the seed size of a number of his 'pimpinellifolium', I am suspicious of at least some of them. And he sells this as pimpinellifolium, for example:
https://www.hrseeds.com/product-page/mini-parvula-tomato
Photo from that page:
HRSeeds.jpeg

So far as I understand, it would be impossible for that to be genuine pimpinellifolium rather than a hybrid.

But the seed size of his 'golden current' does look to me to be consistent with pimpinellifolium. And unlike some of his others, it does look in his photos like genuine pimpinellifolium size and shape. Here's the photo from his website:
hrs golden currant.jpeg


What seems curious to me however is the colour, as Joseph mentioned.

Here's the information provided on pimp fruits in TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE) Iris E. Peralta - 2008:
QuoteFruit to ca. 1 cm in diameter, globose, 2-locular, bright red when ripe, sparsely to densely glandular-pubescent with short uniseriate trichomes ca. 0.5 mm long, with multicellular and unicellular heads during maturation, glabrous when mature; fruiting pedicels 1.5–2 cm long, straight or bent in towards the rachis at the articulation point; calyx lobes in fruit 10–12 mm long, 2.5–4 mm wide, strongly reflexed and parallel with the fruiting pedicel.


And this might be of use from the same text:
QuoteOur rule of thumb for identifying individual specimens (especially those that we suspect are of hybrid origin) is to assign to S. pimpinellifolium any specimen that has a majority of these characters: 1) corollas stellate, deeply (>3/4) divided, the lobes narrowly lanceolate; 2) the sterile appendage of the staminal tube longer than the pollen-bearing portion, the buds thus long and thin in comparison to those of S. lycopersicum; 3) elongate inflorescence (longer than 3 cm) with many (>20) flowers; 4) very small fruits (<1 cm in diameter); 5) few interjected leaflets; 6) leaflets entire or only slightly crenate in proximal 1/3; 7) terminal leaflet base cordate. In addition, identification can be facilitated by noting the nature of the terminal leaflets, broadly elliptical in S. pimpinellifolium rather than narrowly ovate (S. lycopersicum), and the overall velvety pubescence of very short trichomes in S. pimpinellifolium and without long trichomes (except in putatively introgressed populations).

In the description of lycopersicum, regarding the fruits it specifically states:
Quotered, yellow, or deep orange at maturity

However, this brings a question to my mind, in particular bearing in mind what the same text says in the introduction:
QuoteFrom Matthioli's description of the tomato (1544) all that is clear is that the earliest described tomato in Europe had yellow fruits and had the Italian name "pomi d'oro." In a later edition of his work, Matthioli (1554) cited both yellow and red fruits

[...]

Georg Oelinger, a pharmacist in the German city of Nuremberg, was an avid plant collector in the mid-sixteenth century (Lutze & Retzlaff 1949). He cultivated tomatoes in his garden, probably as a curiosity or for their medicinal value. An edition of unpublished paintings from Oelinger's herbarium (Lutze & Retzlaff 1949) contains a drawing of a tomato plant with both red and yellow fruits; the flowers are mixed 5- and 6-parted and all the fruits are deeply furrowed (fasciated).It is clear from early illustrations that the flowers of tomatoes grown in sixteenth and seventeenth century Europe had duplications of sepals and petals (6–7-parted), and exserted styles. Dodoens (1554, 1563) listed the Latin ("Mala Aurea"), German ("Goldtapfel"), Flemish ("Guldapel") and French ("Pome d'amour") names for the fruit along with an illustration of the entire plant (see Fig. 1), but did not mention uses. His later publications (Dodoens 1574, 1583) illustrated round fruits with furrows, flowers with 7–8 petals, and two of the flowers with exserted styles. The illustrations in L'Obel (1576) and Tabernaemontanus (1591) were similar to those of Dodoens (1554, 1563). Gesner (1561) mentioned that the tomato was easily grown in Germany, matured early, and had fruits varying in color from gold, red, and white, and in shape from round to lumpy. It is also clear from the Fuchs description and illustration in the 'Vienna Codex' (frontispiece; Meyer et al. 1999) that by the second half of the sixteenth century tomato plants yielding red, orange, yellow, and white fruits were cultivated, which varied in shape from small and spherical to highly fasciated and lobed.

That question is, where did the fruit colour variation come from? Was it through mutation only within lycopersicum populations? I even have wondered if it might have come from interspecial crosses, since for example F1 lycopersicum x chmielewskii give lovely yellow fruits, and I have been happily eating them so if I were a grower in the jungle centuries ago, whereas I might discard accidental crosses with other species due to bad taste, these I might keep, and due to the ease with which they cross, and the apparently relatively high rate of outcrossing of pre-Columbian lycopersicum, I would expect such crosses to appear where lyc. and chm. ranges overlap:
lyc x chm.jpg

However, I do not see evidence of that in the DNA analyses I have seen, so I do not put much faith in that hypothesis.

So I would not find it implausible that there could be yellow pimps, and that yellow populations might have been domesticated into lycopersicum, or bred with lycs to make some of those early yellow domesticated varieties. However, this would seem a strange omission from this text's description of the species. Does anyone have any further information as to whether there are indeed wild populations of pure pimps that are yellow fruited?

Justin Jardinier

Searching online, I did find one genebank accession of pimp which they described as having 'yellow green' mature fruit colour. The colour in their photo actually appears to me as orange. It originates from Argentina.


https://cgngenis.wur.nl/accessiondetails/CGN15809

reed

I don't know how to tell pimpinellifolium from other tomatoes except by the leaves and the small seeds. In those now wild in my garden they all look like pimp in the leaves, and all have small seeds.  A pretty solid rule is regardless of color, the smaller and more spherical the fruit the better the flavor, not that any of them are really bad. I'm not sure how reliable of a tell seed size is though, because I have one quite large tomato that has similarly small seeds.

A very small yellow one showed up this past year that has the best flavor I've encountered so far. This one is still a little bigger than the original pimps.

William Schlegel

#5
I'd be surprised if the same sort of color mutations haven't happened before.

I know experimentally all the species tomatoes have been hybridized. Andrew Barney shared an interesting figure from someone's research paper with photos of many of the resulting hybrids many years ago on other forums. What I don't know is to what extent some of the same hybrids have occurred in the wild. Theoretically some probably occurs and both genetic and morphological studies could potentially tease some of that out. Guess I'm heading over to Google to search!

This article is interesting just Lyc and pimp:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://bsapubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.3732/ajb.1000272&ved=2ahUKEwiKiObv9cSDAxWWDDQIHd_rBXIQFnoECCsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw0qkQZXNPD8ozYFDOWR5cyy
"key results : The two species represent genetically distinct lineages largely separated by the Andes, but hybridize extensively
in central to northern Ecuador, likely mediated by the transitional climatic conditions between those of the two species.  Sola
num lycospericum  has likely experienced a severe population bottleneck during the colonization of the eastern Andes followed
by a rapid population expansion. "- quote from above. So varieties and accessions from central and northern Ecuador might to some extent represent a natural zone of hybridization and more diversity at the genetic level. Though that could also be recreated by crossing the two species.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

A possible analog might be seen in S. nigrum. The default fruit color for nigrum is, of course, black. But it appears that natural mutations have created at least two more, the yellow orange of the Ortricoli (it was found just growing on the banks of the Tiber, mixed in with regular nigrum, so it pretty much has to be a natural mutation, and red (apparently grown in some parts of India for Ayurvedic medicinal use.)   

William Schlegel

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5714242/

Found the above poking around for scientific papers on this topic. It is a bit of a doozy. They particularly took a hard look at Solanum peruvianum and Solanum chilense but they found some other interesting introgressions as well. It has some implications for if some of the species in the peruvianum group should be so differentiated (thus my doozy comment). LA 1932 is one of the interspecies hybrids they found between S. per and S. chi.

I suspect that there may be other similar studies out there or that someday some may be conducted. The general pattern with closely related plant species is that they tend to form nice species barriers but then if they come back into contact somewhere else in their ranges that often breaks down the species barrier at the original zone of contact and you end up with a bit of a hybrid swarm. So given that we know virtually all tomato species can cross in the lab, there are probably hybrid zones in existence where they've naturally crossed in the past in the wild. Though that is all dependent on species ranges and geography.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

https://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-015-1444-1

"We described and analyzed the genetic diversity of 1,008 tomato accessions including Solanum lycopersicum var. lycopersicum (SLL), S. lycopersicum var. cerasiforme (SLC), and S. pimpinellifolium (SP) that were genotyped using 7,720 SNPs. Additionally, we explored the allelic frequency of six loci affecting fruit weight and shape to infer patterns of selection." - above article

"Our results revealed a pattern of variation that strongly supported a two-step domestication process, occasional hybridization in the wild, and differentiation through human selection. ... Fruit weight was strongly selected in SLC in the Andean region of Ecuador and Northern Peru prior to the domestication of tomato in Mesoamerica. Alleles affecting fruit shape were differentially selected among SLL genetic subgroups. Our results also clarified the biological status of SLC. True SLC was phylogenetically positioned between SP and SLL and its fruit morphology was diverse. SLC and "cherry tomato" are not synonymous terms. The morphologically-based term "cherry tomato" included some SLC, contemporary varieties, as well as many admixtures between SP and SLL. " - also above article.

Interesting! var cerasiforme has a real basis in genetics, but genetically cherry tomatoes can be either domestic tomatoes, var. cerasiforme, or hybrids with pimpinillifolium. Also some hybridization did happen in the wild as we suspected and know from some of the other articles we've seen.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-04, 07:46:13 PMhttps://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-015-1444-1

I've read that before but now looking again, I notice this:
Screenshot .png

It looks like Asian domestic tomatoes might be considerably closer to pre-Columbian tomatoes than 'vintage' tomatoes, which I assume means European heirloom tomatoes and those international ones derived from them, if I am interpreting that correctly. Which might make the idea of breeding with Asian tomatoes more appealing.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-04, 07:46:13 PMTrue SLC was phylogenetically positioned between SP and SLL and its fruit morphology was diverse. SLC and "cherry tomato" are not synonymous terms. The morphologically-based term "cherry tomato" included some SLC, contemporary varieties, as well as many admixtures between SP and SLL. " - also above article.

Interesting! var cerasiforme has a real basis in genetics, but genetically cherry tomatoes can be either domestic tomatoes, var. cerasiforme, or hybrids with pimpinillifolium.

Just going by what I quoted there, I don't see any reason not to consider var cerasiforme a hybrid of pimp and lyc. And would find it entirely plausible that they are just older hybrids than some of the more recent cherry tomatoes made from recently hybridizing the two species. Searching the article for any counter-argument to that, all I find is:
QuoteOne striking difference between the two classifications occurred for 102 SLC accessions that were located in the PCA between SLC and SLL and classified as mixture (Figure 1). These accessions included many of the commercial cherry tomatoes. These data imply that most cultivated cherry tomatoes are not true SLC.

And yet in Figure 1, the only difference I can see between what they claim are SLC and the area. they say (though do not specify at which points) modern lyc-pimp hybrids lie in, is the colour they have chosen to give them. Without their addition of colour (which might be arbitrary so far as genetics are concerned?), I see no reasoning for differentiating the two on a genetic basis. In fact some of the blue and grey dots are intermingled.

Also it would be interesting to know more about the distribution of the Sp and SLL accessions in that figure. For example, I wonder if the SLL towards the top right are the pre-Columbian ones, and the pimps towards the top, those pimps which are found in the same ranges as lycs, and the blue dots said to be 'LLC' perhaps representing natural hybrids and maybe even also some early domestic populations that may not have gone far, perhaps even abandoned (or their farmers slaughtered by the colonists) and were re-found in the wild. I would hypothesise mostly or all the former of those two options, since even abandoned SLL would be likely to hybridise in the presence of pimps.

The modern hybrids would be using European origin SLL in the cross rather than pre-Columbian SLL, and might also be choosing different pimps, searching obscure ranges for disease resistance. This I hypothesise would five results indicating a genetic difference to natural hybrids within the range of pre-Columbian SLL, even if the latter were hybridising after European colonisers took over.

If there is reasoning to counter my hypothesis (which I believe to be in harmony with the view TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE) Iris E. Peralta - 2008, I would be interested to hear it, but I don't see it in the paper. I think I have shared quotes from that on this already but here's a couple:
QuoteBauhin (1623) referred to tomato as "mala peruviana" and "pomi del Peru," which suggested initial domestication and transport of tomato from Peru to Europe, 3) its origin was from the wild cherry tomato (S. lycopersicum, "var. cerasiforme" of prior authors), which by Candolle's time was known from coastal Peru, and in Mexico and the southwestern U.S.A. (California), 4) the distribution of cultivated tomato and its progenitor outside of Peru originated by garden escapes, and 5) the plant was domesticated only just before the discovery of the Americas by Europeans. Candolle's hypothesis of Peruvian origin was later supported by other authors (Moore 1935; Müller 1940a, b; Luckwill 1943a, b), but recent genetic investigations have shown that the plants known as "cerasiforme" are an admixture of wild and cultivated tomatoes rather than "ancestral" to the cultivars (Nesbitt & Tanksley 2002).

QuoteWe do not recognize taxa below the species level, most notably the small-fruited tomatoes known to many as "var. cerasiforme." The name "cerasiforme" has been used to refer to putatively wild forms of S. lycopersicum that have been regarded as progenitors of the cultivated tomato (although see Frary et al., 2000, and Nesbitt & Tanksley, 2002). It is impossible to distinguish wild from cultivated forms using herbarium specimens, and we regard many specimens labeled as "var. cerasiforme" to be possible revertants from cultivation (i.e., feral plants) or possible hybrids of wild and weedy taxa.

William Schlegel

#10
I am not sure I agree with you on that Justin. You are disagreeing with a newer paper because it does not quite jive with an older paper. Typically, newer papers add some bit of knowledge to the older papers.

The quote from the 2015 paper where they believe there is some true genetically distinct var. cerasiforme is really interesting! It actually confirms one of your latter quotes in part because it confirms that many cherry tomatoes are not in a discrete group and may be wild admixtures or just small-fruited domestics. It shows that not all cherry tomatoes are equal as germplasm. It also makes var. cerasiforme accessions from certain areas of South America particularly interesting as germplasm.

Here are a few in Ecuador where the article identifies some hybridization between domestic and pimp. It is clear from some of the accession notes that the morphology always showed that some hybridization was occurring there and now it has been confirmed with some genetic data:

https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Accession/Detail/LA4683 - "Intermediate pimpinellifolium-cerasiforme, slightly exserted stigmas, 2-2.5 cm fruit diameter." TGRC

https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Accession/Detail/LA4688 - "Atypical cerasiforme, slightly flattened fruits, hairy stem and inflorescence, slightly exserted stigmas, 3-3.5 cm fruit diameter." -TGRC

https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Accession/Detail/LA4685 - Now this accession is interesting! Exserted stigmas, peanut shaped! Also pimp like but identified as cerasiforme.




Also that "SLC Asia" point on that figure seems like a single point on it, could just be an errant accession and not necessarily represent a trend?

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adam Igra

Some of the galapagose toms mutated yellow, or perhaps came from the mainland already yellow. There is a long video by a researcher on youtube on the galapagose toms origin.
If its done via the same gene as domestic toms then it should be extremely easy to mutate. blue eyes has mutated a few times in humans and lactose tolerance in adulthood nearly a dozen times, though that has multiple genes. Blonde hair has a handful of origins, one in north europe, one or two in africa and one in persia at least.
I vaguely remember someone mentioning a tom SPORT that randomly turned yellow. bizzare.
they seem different colours to physalis in origin, which are mostly different shades of orange and mucky yellow. There are pale yellow tomatillos though.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-04, 09:32:20 PMI am not sure I agree with you on that Justin. You are disagreeing with a newer paper because it does not quite jive with an older paper. Typically, newer papers add some bit of knowledge to the older papers.

I did notice it was a newer paper. But I did also search (albeit in a hurry) through it for any reasoning or data to back up any counter to what I reasoned, and I could not find anything. For example, was there anything in it that you saw that would show that their results could not have been due to the 'SLC' being older hybrid populations, perhaps having undergone many crosses (potentially over several centuries) in one or both directions? Perhaps I missed something. And did you notice them explain why the grey and blue dots intermingle? I couldn't work out on what basis they were choosing the colours since all I found them referencing was that figure

William Schlegel

I would need to read it much more throughly to know for sure. However, it sounded like they did a robust genetic analysis of a large number of accessions. That sounds like very good data.

I used to work for a plant ecologist who primarily looked at the figures and I primarily read the text. It takes me a while longer to understand the figures.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

I'm scanning through the article https://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-015-1444-1 using the search term SLC to try to examine their basis for differentiating SLC from SLL-SP hybrids. I'll go through them here as I go through them there. It should be remembered that I am coming from an ignorant and uneducated position, so my reasoning may be faulty, but I will try my best.

QuoteOur results also clarified the biological status of SLC. True SLC was phylogenetically positioned between SP and SLL and its fruit morphology was diverse. SLC and "cherry tomato" are not synonymous terms. The morphologically-based term "cherry tomato" included some SLC, contemporary varieties, as well as many admixtures between SP and SLL.

Since pre-Columbian SLL had a high diversity of fruit morphology, I would expect hybrids with those SLL and SP to similarly have a high diversity of fruit morphology, compared to hybrids made between post-Columbian European-derived SLL and SP. I would also expect the level of diversity of the latter to be effected my commercial market pressures, possibly causing a further narrowing of fruit morphology diversity in those modern cherry tomatoes.

QuoteThe distribution of fruit weight and shape alleles supports that domestication of SLC occurred in the Andean region. Our results also clarify the biological status of SLC as true phylogenetic group within tomato.

Let's see what reasoning they give for this. Just to recap on the 2 explanations I hypothesised in my previous comment:

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-04, 09:02:17 PMAlso it would be interesting to know more about the distribution of the Sp and SLL accessions in that figure. For example, I wonder if the SLL towards the top right are the pre-Columbian ones, and the pimps towards the top, those pimps which are found in the same ranges as lycs, and the blue dots said to be 'LLC' perhaps representing natural hybrids and maybe even also some early domestic populations that may not have gone far, perhaps even abandoned (or their farmers slaughtered by the colonists) and were re-found in the wild. I would hypothesise mostly or all the former of those two options, since even abandoned SLL would be likely to hybridise in the presence of pimps.

Let's call these 2, which need not be mutually exclusive (since the latter maybe include hybridising), the 'hybrid hypothesis' and the 'abandoned landrace' hypothesis.

Ok so back to the paper:
QuoteSLC grows either as a true wild species, in home gardens, along roads, sympatrically with tomato landraces, or as a cultivated crop [9]. SLC thrives in the humid environments of Ecuador and Peru at the eastern edge of the Amazon basin whereas SP occupies the drier Peruvian coasts and valleys and the wetter Ecuadorian coast [9,11,12]. Although there is no reproductive barrier between SP and SLC [13], the Andes mountains impose strong physical and ecological barriers for cross reproduction among these species.

These physical and ecological barriers weaken the hybrid hypothesis. I'd love to see a map of their accessions. The best I seem to be able to do is use the map function on the TGRC. I'll focus on Ecuador and Peru since they seemed to. Now the issue here is we I not know if the TGRC is using the same way of classifying SLC. But it's all I have to go on. On their maps, SP=P, SLL=L, SLC=C.
top.png
middle.png
bottom.png

[Edit: they do provide a map, in their supplementary material, and from what I can see it basically conforms to the TGRC maps: https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1186%2Fs12864-015-1444-1/MediaObjects/12864_2015_1444_MOESM6_ESM.jpeg ]

I have added blue circles where SP and SLL occur close to each other, and pink circles where SP and SLP occur close to each other. We also have to bear in mind that this data is likely skewed by botanists collecting samples presumably mainly along roads due to the ease of access. But let's see what we might make of it. From this distribution, I do not find it implausible that it might be explained by SLC resulting from hybridisation between SLL and SP occurring within the range of SP, then SLC being spread via trade routes or general travel, potentially being spread along the way via defecation. I have added black arrows for potential lines of distribution.

I also find it not implausible that travellers may have eaten SP, spread it along those routes, SP growing and hybridising with SLL resulting in SLC, then SLC outcompeting SP.

Entertaining one of the domestication hypotheses, they state:
QuoteThe first step would have consisted of a selection from SP or primitive SLC by early farmers resulting in the Ecuadorian and Northern Peruvian SLC. The second step likely occurred in Mesoamerica, and consisted of further selection from these pre-domesticated SLC after their migration from Ecuador and Peru. This second step completed the domestication process of tomato. Genetic data confirmed that European SLL accessions originated from Mesoamerica and constitute the genetic base of the SLL vintage varieties [9]. It has also been proposed that a genetic bottleneck was associated with the migration of SLL from Mesoamerica to Europe [18-20]. Blanca et al. [9] proposed that the main bottleneck happened during the migration from Peru and Ecuador.

Suppose those in Equador and Peru actually did domesticate tomatoes for a moment, then the bottleneck experienced through transmission to Mesoamerica and again on to Europe should result in genetic difference and relative lack of diversity (in at least some respects) in SLL-SP hybrids made from European SLL.

Now, my time is running short, but looking at their charts such as figure 2, 'Principal Component Analysis for SP, SLC, SLL and SLL Mesoamerica and genetically close SLC subgroups.', I notice they include various South American SLC groups, but I do not see any inclusion of any South American SLL, which I would think would be essential for investigating this topic, i.e. seeing where those lie in relation to SP and SLC in South America, and also how they compare with more recent SLL-SP hybrids. They do have the category 'SLL vintage'

Searching the article for 'landrace', they only mention it twice in the text. Here's the first:
QuoteSLC grows either as a true wild species, in home gardens, along roads, sympatrically with tomato landraces, or as a cultivated crop [9].

This implies that these landraces (in particular pre-Columbian South American SLL landraces) would be essential to analyse for understanding the relationship with SLC. The second is in the section 'Plant material and passport data':
QuoteFor SLL, the vintage, landrace and heirloom categories were grouped together and classified collectively as vintage consistent with the nomenclature of Williams and St. Clair [19].

Unless I am misunderstanding something, I find this dissapointing. And, I notice that this does not specify which landraces - there are many European and Asian tomato landraces, and usually when I encounter 'tomato landraces' in the literature, it has been those that have been referred to.

They provide this chart, Additional file 8: Figure S6.
Neighbor-joining tree based on the population distances measured as Dest among genetic subgroups. Bootstrap values based on 1,000 trees are shown. Branches with a bootstrap support lower than 70 have been collapsed.
, which is very interesting but without adding South American pre-Columbian SLL to it, how are we to use this for understanding the relationship we aim to understand, the relative positions of those pre-Columbian SLL compared to SLC? Wouldn't that be the most important group to differentiate after SP and SLC?


Then, searching their Additional file 1: Table S1.
Sample list, passport data and genotyping data for fruit shape and weight (SUN, LC, OVATE, FAS, FW2.2 and FW3.2). A, wild allele; B, derived allele and A/B, heterozygous.
I see that for their species classification, for SLL they included:
From Peru:
7 SLL, 5 of which they classify as 'SLL_vintage'

From Ecuador:
5 SLL, all of which they classify as 'SLL_fresh' in column 'group1' though 1 of them is classified 'SLL_vintage/fresh' in column 'group2'.

So far I do not see whether these are post or pre-Columbian SLL.

In the section 'Diversity and genetic differentiation' they state:
QuoteThese groups are defined as follows: SP, SLC Ecuador and Northern Peru, SLC non Andean, SLL vintage and SLL contemporary (split for some analyses into SLL processing and SLL fresh).

This implies that all of their Ecuador accessions are post-Columbian, derived from European tomatoes. And still does not clarify if any of the 5 'SLL_vintage' from Peru are from Europe (or hybridised with European varieties imported by the colonisers) or not.

I'm starting to wonder even if they could have been working from the a priori assumption that SLL did not exist in South America until SLC was domesticated in Mesoamerica?

Unfortunately I have run out of time, the plants are calling me. I am totally open to the possibility that this paper does prove what it claims to prove. But I am rather struggling to see how that is possible at the moment, particularly due to the apparent lack of examination of pre-Columbian South American SLL landraces. Or, perhaps they just conceptualise those as 'SLC'? In fact that may be implied, by the image they provide as Figure 3:
figure 3.png

Now, if we take their 'SLC vintage' to mean pre-Columbian South American SLL, then their evolution tree makes sense to me, showing Mesoamerican and European SLL are derived from South American SLL. And what I think could be interesting, would be to cross some of the pure pre-Columbian South American SLL still being farmed by native farmers, from as diverse regions as possible, with various SP (and if there were time enough, allow them to self-stabilise to some degree under feral conditions), then plot them on such charts of genetic comparison with both parent populations, along with claimed SLC and modern cherry tomatoes derived from SLL-SP crosses.

There is much I may have missed but I have to work now.