Species Current Tomatoes vs. Hybrids

Started by Joseph Lofthouse, 2024-01-03, 09:11:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

#30
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-08, 08:38:02 PMI hope it's ok to ask - what does that mean? Is it like, the percentage of genes that are not uniform through the population, or something like that?

And, if it's something like that, then I guess.... if you have a single tomato in your garden that has 25% pennellii or even 15%, plus one heirloom, then your garden might blow he entire world of heirloom tomatoes plus all the pre-Columbian lycs out of the water in terms of diversity? Since pennellii is so distant from lyc and pimp whilst those two are so close?


I think this (He = 0.21) is a statistical measure of how diverse they are. Not sure how it works mathematically (I am not that great at math, though much better than I was 25 years ago). I am simply reading it as the higher the number the better. I don't think one individual plant even of the highly heterozygous obligate outcrossing species would drive it too high. Though an entire accession, well maintained, of a hyper-diverse obligate outcrossing species might be much greater in diversity. Would love to see it or a similar statistical measure for even say specific accessions of Solanum habrochaites. Your crossing project might have extreme diversity given the large number of accessions you've crossed in.

I was just searching for South American accessions on the Seed Savers Exchange- the most accessible of gene banks for US gardeners and found five decent accessions with PI numbers from USDA-ARS-GRIN that I think may be useful.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpls.2019.01606/full

https://www.frontiersin.org/files/Articles/500236/fpls-10-01606-HTML/image_m/fpls-10-01606-g001.jpg

The 2019 paper on the increase in genetic diversity of tomatoes in the Netherlands that we discussed somewhere on the forum quite a while back uses a similar statistical measure, perhaps the same one in figure 1.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Thi spaper may be of interest, ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS PREDICT ADAPTIVE PHENOTYPIC DIFFERENTIATION WITHIN AND BETWEEN TWO WILD ANDEAN TOMATOES - Takuya Nakazato - 2007:
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1558-5646.2008.00332.x

The section RAPID SPECIES DIVERSIFICATION IN RESPONSE TO CLIMATE may be of pecial interest, including how leaf size and thickness differences correlate with drought resistance. And this paper may give insight into which pre-Columbian South American accessions we might like to try breeding with, with regard to which region they come from.

QuoteThe nature of species differences also provides insight into the predominant drivers of ecological diversification that influence each of these taxa. In S. pimpinellifolium, several traits are predominantly associated with mean annual precipitation rather than temperature, seasonality variables, and soil variation, strongly suggesting that local water availability is one of the major environmental agents driving adaptation in this species. Although selection for smaller and thicker leaves may be operating in S. pimpinellifolium in response to water conditions, the larger and thinner leaves observed in S. l. cerasiforme are potentially selected in response to competition for light. Several pieces of evidence are consistent with this provisional hypothesis. First, the native range of S. l. cerasiforme is characterized by more dense vegetation cover in comparison to other tomato species, particularly in the Amazon Basin. Second, species in shady environments have previously been found to have lower leaf mass/area and to have higher relative growth rate (Garnier 1992; Lambers and Poorter 1992; Reich et al. 1992; Saverimuttu and Westoby 1996).

This makes me think South Peru might be a good region to focus on:
QuoteECOLOGICAL FEATURES OF THE STUDY AREA

GIS maps identified steep gradients within and between the species ranges of S. l. cerasiforme and S. pimpinellifolium, for several of the analyzed environmental variables (Fig. 1). Most notable were large (in some cases up to ten fold) differences in mean precipitation and temperature, as well as daily and seasonal variation in these attributes. In particular, the climate of the Amazon basin populations were characterized by high temperature and precipitation, and relatively little fluctuation in these parameters as indicated by low-to-moderate seasonality in precipitation and temperature, and modest diurnal temperature ranges (Fig. 1). The Andean highlands appeared typically moderate in precipitation and low in temperature, particularly in southern Peru. Temperature seasonality was moderate, but diurnal temperature range and precipitation seasonality were generally high. In contrast, western coastal regions appear to be extremely dry but moderate in temperature and relatively low in precipitation and temperature fluctuations, both diurnally and across the year. The scant rainfall that occurs in this region is strongly episodic, positively correlated with elevation, and influenced by ENSO climate cycles (Haylock et al. 2006; Sifres et al. 2007). Variation among populations within this region also appears to be relatively small compared to other regions (Fig. 1).

William Schlegel

#33
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-15, 09:38:04 AMThi spaper may be of interest, ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS PREDICT ADAPTIVE PHENOTYPIC DIFFERENTIATION WITHIN AND BETWEEN TWO WILD ANDEAN TOMATOES - Takuya Nakazato - 2007:
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1558-5646.2008.00332.x

The section RAPID SPECIES DIVERSIFICATION IN RESPONSE TO CLIMATE may be of pecial interest, including how leaf size and thickness differences correlate with drought resistance. And this paper may give insight into which pre-Columbian South American accessions we might like to try breeding with, with regard to which region they come from.

Interesting paper. It really highlights the importance of Solanum pimpinellifolium for drought tolerance. Also, the diversification within S. pimp. coastal and upland being quite different.

Oh and here is a similar paper analyzing the genetics a bit with some info about hybridization between the two. Haven't read yet though.
https://bsapubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.3732/ajb.1000272


Also, they said they were working on a similar 10 species analysis and this article is old enough that it might be out. Found it: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21622430/ and that just takes you to https://bsapubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.3732/ajb.0900216
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adam Igra

Very interesting.
South Peru, west bolivia and northern Chile had the bulk of the population of the Tawantinsuyu, with large populations fairly high up, though modern Quechua are spread around into ecuador, so I would expect there to be (semi?) domesticated ancient toms all around the andes.
The religious capital of Cusco is 11k ft and was the central transport point with each province meeting there directly. They intentionally built microclimate zones to test different crop (cultivars?) in different temperature zones and so almost certainly intentionally influenced the genetics across the andes. Im aware even of them transporting months of food 1000s of km during local famines, serious business. The population of the tawantinsuyu was gigantic at its peak, perhaps 20 million, and cusco was only about half the population it is today at 200k. They were very beurocratic too, priests basically being accountants 😅 death and taxes...

The entire year at that altitude is about 10-15C and their winter has night freezes, id say USDA zone 10. They knew where to plant things though and cultivated the country in different altitude layers. They even had a welfare system! If we want "cold growing", the high altitude cities is a good bet, but frost tolerant is more doubtful.  On the north east side of the cliffs and the total ridgeline it becomes quite agricultural, with wild temperatures rainforest, but I dont know if youd find good old toms anymore. Looking at wild nightshades in europe though they might enjoy the shrubby crappy bits inbetween rather than anywhere rainy: Solanum nigrum at least seems to grow profusely in scrap yards, traintracks and building sites.

I dont know to what extent the inca actually liked tomatoes though, and whether or not modern Quechua and else have continued their genepool rather than them rewilding.

Justin Jardinier

#35
Quote from: Adam Igra on 2024-01-17, 11:32:36 PMThe religious capital of Cusco
Wow, fascinating info about that place. LA1385 and LA2688 are from Cusco, two of the four S. lycopersicum var. cerasiforme tomatoes showing 0%-20% disease severity against ToBRFV.

I've been thinking a lot about pre-Columbian South American tomatoes recently. I know the paper Genomic variation in tomato, from wild ancestors to contemporary breeding accessions - José Blanca et al. - 2015 claims to show 'cerasiforme' as separate from SLL, and claims it is 'pre-domesticated', plus all those it identifies as 'cerasiforme' are considerably small fruited, but I can't really understand their genetic reasoning. Perhaps this is down to my ignorance. I would love to hear them debate their points. I found the paper Genomic inference of complex domestication histories in three Solanaceae species - Stéphanie Arnoux et al. - 2020 quite interesting in its conclusions as I quoted previously.

Here's a new quote from that:
QuoteIn tomato, the reduction in size occurred over a long timescale, which call into question the hypothesis of a second domestication stage, that is cultivation (Meyer & Purugganan, 2013), happening systematically during a rapid time frame (Ladizinsky, 1987; Zohary, 1989).

Despite all my reading I still can't get the sense that the common idea that tomatoes weren't domesticated until they reached Mesoamerica, is true. So it's interesting that their results seemed to contradict that common idea. All I feel I keep seeing in other papers is data that people try to squash into that old idea in their analysis. Again I might be so wrong but that's my sense, and my sense at least seems to fit with this paper, which takes a seemingly very different approach at investigating the timeline.

If I understand this paper correctly, it seems they're saying lyc split off from pimp 9,900 ~ 19,040 years ago, then went to Mexico 4,410 ~ 8,480 years ago. And that we have "cultivation records for maize in Peru ~ 6,600 ya (Grobman et al., 2012) and in Mexico ~ 7,300 ya". So they might have been selecting those pimps that were better suited to their conditions, perhaps in Peru or Ecuador, and have been domesticating them for thousands of years potentially, before spreading them perhaps through trade, to Mesoamerica, and, the domestication process, or I should really say breeding process, would continue in both places for more thousands of years. I feel like perhaps the continuation of breeding in South America might have been overlooked because of Europeans' (and European emmigrants') bias towards their own tomatoes, and their history tracing back only to the Mesoamerican branch.

Now I kind of said this before but I wonder if those being identified now as 'cerasiforme' might mostly be hybrids of those old domesticated tomatoes with pimp, and if they were, I wonder how long ago they'd need to be crossed or how many times they'd need to keep crossing, until the former paper would be led to believe they weren't crosses. Or whether those results might come due to an incomplete analysis of the perhaps countless pimp populations in the regions.

So what I am really getting at, is, have the better pre-Columbian South American tomatoes been overlooked? Why I say this is because...

In the paper Genomic variation in tomato, from wild ancestors to contemporary breeding accessions - José Blanca et al. - 2015 they include this photo for example, apparently some nice large 'cerasiforme':
image.png


That has my notes on it, anyway you can see 3 of those are included in their study. Their passport ID is 'SLL_vintage'. This makes sense since 'cerasiforme' means round shaped and they're not, but it seems these papers are redefining cerasiforme to mean, if I understand this right, 'pre-Columbian domesticated tomatoes' that didn't go through breeding in Mesoamerica (even if they only accept them to be 'cultivated but not domesticated'). They've categorised these 3 tomatoes as 'SLC_Ecuador'. I don't know why they did that for the one from Chile, but the other two are from Ecuador. Bear in mind those 2 largest ones measure 11cm and just over 10cm wide respectively in that image above.

Now curiously, (some of) the same authors, in Variation Revealed by SNP Genotyping and Morphology Provides Insight into the Origin of the Tomato  -Jose Blanca et al.- 2012, exclude those from their study, I see no mention of them at all. And the largest 'cerasiforme' they studied in this paper was 5cm wide, the second 4.6cm wide, and most considerably smaller. So, what's going on there?

Now that largest one in the photo, PI 128592, was collected in 1938:
https://npgsweb.ars-grin.gov/gringlobal/accessiondetail?id=1133440

The original document says "From the market at Valparaiso".

PI 258474 (LA0410) was collected in 1959 from the Guayaquil market:
https://npgsweb.ars-grin.gov/gringlobal/accessiondetail?id=1197063

PI 129026 was collected in Ecuador, Received by NPGS: 25 May 1938
https://npgsweb.ars-grin.gov/gringlobal/accessiondetail?id=1133548

PI 129033 was collected in Ecuador, Received by NPGS: 25 May 1938
https://npgsweb.ars-grin.gov/gringlobal/accessiondetail?id=1133555

So what's to say that this type of relatively large tomato (compared to the 'cerasiforme' in some of these papers) was not normal in pre-Columbian South America? Here's a quote from the paper History of Tomato Cultivation in Chile- The Limachino Tomato Case - Adolfo Donoso et al - 2022, in the section History of tomato cultivation in Chile:

QuoteIn Chile, as reported by Gay (1865), the cultivated pre-Columbian crops were potatoes, quinoa, and large lima beans. Although, their cultivated surface had already decreased to 1865, remaining only the potato as an important crop in Chile. The tomato growing was described in that period as a crop originated in Mexico, being a widely cultivated crop with a high consumption in Chile. But there is a prior report of tomato growing in Western South America. Cobo (1653) after living since 1596 in the Viceroyalty of Peru, described botanically the cultivated crops of Peru. Between the plants described by Cobo, many of them are nowadays ornamental and no longer considered as crops. The tomato was described as a widespread cultivated crop and as a wild plant (Figure 1). The wild ones were described as bearers of smaller fruits and were left to be eaten by birds. Botanically, the tomato was described as similar in terms of leaves shape and size to yerba mora, referring most probably to Solanum nigrum L. and what would be considered nowadays as a modification in the leaf. The fruit diversity described was wide, being the smaller ones of the size of a cherry and the biggest ones the size of a prune or a lime. Red and rounds were the most common ones, but there were also yellow and green. There have been other reports from the cultivation and consumption in America, from the XVI and XVII centuries. In Argentina, Colombia and Bolivia, the cultivation of tomatoes has been presumed as a common crop in pre-Columbian times (Patiño 2002). These historical descriptions of the tomato growing must be seen in modern terms when it comes to define the territories. The description of Claudio Gay (1865) in Chile, was made before the Pacific war, after which territories from Peru and Bolivia passed to Chile. Even more, what Bernabe Cobo (1653) described might be an image of the Viceroyalty of Peru, and not from Peru only. The Viceroyalty of Peru comprehended the territories of the current Peru, Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, Bolivia, Colombia, Chile, Panamá, and Ecuador.

I wonder that the reference ot the 'wild ones' might include those small ones the papers focus on as 'cerasiforme'. But how about those ones "the size of a prune or a lime"? It would seem only the few largest ones in the paper I mentioned would qualify for that kind of size [EDIT: I wrote that before realising limes are around 5cm wide but this is still larger than most now termed 'cerasiforme' it seems].

Now, European tomatoes were introduced to South America in the late 18th century, and it seems by the 1930's there was a lot of commercial tomato growing based on European genetics:
QuoteIn 1930 the tomato growing was concentrated from the central valley to the northern frontier, comprehending 884 ha (Table 1) mainly to the north of Santiago. The varieties recommended in 1931 to be used in the central valley of Chile for early harvest were Reina temprana, Rey de los tempranos, Chemín, Favourite, Frisé hatif de París, Rey Humberto (Cocogallo), and Tomate Crespo chico. For regular harvest, Perfección, Trophy, Duke of York, Beauty, Ponderosa and Merveilles des Marché, among others. And for late harvest Marglobe, El Mikado grande, Enormous, Ponderosa, Champion, Mikado Amarillo, New King from Chicago, Mervelosa, and others. These varieties were purchased from English, French, German, Belgian, and American catalogs. (Lagarde, 1931).


But isn't there a chance that some of these early genebank accessions may represent those larger pre-Columbian ones? And if they be only hybrids with European ones, they may still be valuable.

Now back to the paper Variation Revealed by SNP Genotyping and Morphology Provides Insight into the Origin of the Tomato  -Jose Blanca et al.- 2012. Looking through the supplementary data (William that's the file I shared with you yesterday), there seems to me to be a trend showing within each location, a correlation between exserted stigmas and decreased fruit size in the various South American 'cerasiforme' they studied. And that makes me wonder if this might be explained by them originating from crosses or larger domesticated tomatoes, and pimps. And that those which either started as relatively small domesticated tomatoes and maintained their fruit size due to not crossing with pimps, or crossed reducing their size but then separated out after crossing, those segregating for reduced or no exsersion being thereby protected from further crossing which would further reduce their fruit size. I struggle to find another reasonable explanation for the apparent correlation between exsersion and small fruit size.

Anyway to bring this pack to practicality - if we are looking towards cerasiforme for the sake of genetic diversity in them representing the pre-Columbian South American tomato, I wonder that we might be at a disadvantage if we only look towards those small ones in many of these papers. It might be that the larger ones, some of which might be classified as SLL, might end up being just as valuable but have the benefit of larger fruit size and perhaps maintaining more of the hard work of those thousands of years of breeding in South America. And, even if some of them might have some European introgression, this could still be good for the possibly hundreds of years more of selection and environmental pressures those have undergone too.



Kadence Luneman


William Schlegel

#37
My order from Seed Savers Exchange has arrived (the exchange itself, not the vegetable catalogue they use as a fundraiser).

Tomato 1147 South American Large Round Accession 122549
Tomato 1962 PI 129129 (Panama) Accession 123363 (A little far North but maybe)
Tomato 2067 PI 118686 (Brazil) Accession 123468
Tomato 1148 South American Oval Accession 122550
Tomato 2065 PI 79532 (Peru) Accession 123466
Tomato 5658 PI 158171 (Venezuela) Accession 127037
Tomato 5659 PI 158164 (Venezuela) Accession 127038
Tomato 4852 Peruvian Bush Accession 126231
Tomato 4848 Oaxacan Pink Accession 126227 (Mexican but still interesting)
Tomato 2070 PI 128445 (Argentina) Accession 123471

I also accidentally ordered the variety Perun a yellow pear type from the Czech Republic. Oops, it came up when I searched for Peru.

I suspect that there are more tomatoes of interest from South America, and I think I passed up a few, at the Seed Saver's Exchange but it may be the case that they are just hiding and need just the right search term to find. The seed savers exchange is also a place where many accessions from the USDA-ARS-GRIN of domestic heirloom tomatoes have been made available again after otherwise dying out- thus the PI numbers on many of these.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDSKDok7qEI

Fun related video. SLC is 78,000 years old so predates domestication by 70,000 years or so.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#39
Wow, food production needs to increase by 60% by 2050! At the same time, from what I understand, the land suitable for agriculture is continually decreasing, due to climate annihilation by humans. And wild mammals already make up only 4% of the global mammal biomass.

If we accept continual human population increase, I wonder if there will be a single wild mammal left. Actually if we continue this direction I would expect total biosphere collapse and the earth changing to something entirely unrecognisable, maybe a loss of most multicellular life? I find it hard to understand the human species sometimes. And the ... psychopathic is to weak a word... addiction to the idea of continual growth, whether that be in terms of economics or population.

Sorry for that sad note, it's something I think a lot about!

Regarding the research in the video, that work is actually referenced in the material I provided earlier on this topic. I will put in bold the work done by the people the lady in the video mentions:

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-07, 09:01:45 AMGenomic inference of complex domestication histories in three Solanaceae species - Stéphanie Arnoux et al. - 2020:
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jeb.13723

QuoteThe cultivated tomato, Solanum lycopersicum L., was domesticated from the wild progenitor S. pimpinellifolium in Peru before experiencing two bottlenecks: first moving to Mesoamerica (Blanca et al., 2012) and then with few cultivars introduced to Europe from Mexico (Atherton & Harris, 1986; Blanca et al., 2015). These domestication events and further genetic improvement led to specific genomic footprints in tomato (Lin et al., 2014).

In section 4.3 | Species-specific timings of the domestication stages:
QuoteThe tomato domestication centre is located in Peru (Blanca et al., 2012), even though it was imported into Mexico, further increasing the bottleneck effect due to cultivation. We estimated this bottleneck to date 4,410–8,480 ya, which accurately fits the first area cultivation records for maize in Peru ~ 6,600 ya (Grobman et al., 2012) and in Mexico ~ 7,300 ya (Pohl et al., 2007). Surprisingly, our estimate of split time (9,900–19,040 ya) is largely in disagreement with the ∂a∂i estimate of ~ 78,000 ya in Razifard et al. (2020), which resemble more to a speciation event, as it predates the human presence in South America. Further sampling in Peru would be needed to evaluate if the geographic origin of the first domestication event occurred in Peru or in Mexico. Additionally, the best fitting model corroborates the two-stage domestication scenario for tomato, already proposed in Blanca et al. (2015). In the African rice, this type of genomic inference approach has been successfully applied to shade light on the geographical origin of the crop, thus unravelling its domestication centre (Cubry et al., 2018).

(I think the Peru idea is now outdated, from the work cited in the video and elsewhere it would seem Ecuador though who knows maybe it was quite spread out, not just one place). Here's a graphic from the paper, showing pimpinellifolium in grey, and lycopersicum splitting off from it in red. I think the narrowing in the red is the bottleneck to Mesoamerica if I understand that correctly. The figures on the right are how many generations ago, i.e. how many years ago:
evolution.png

Searching for how long humans have been in Mexico, I see this:
https://www.science.org/content/article/were-humans-living-mexican-cave-during-last-ice-age

which on the basis of archaeological evidence from Mexico, claims "people must have entered the Americas 32,000 years ago or more". This makes the human domestication of pimpinellifolium some time between 9,900–19,040 years ago quite plausible, even if ti started with hunter gatherers. For example in the paper ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS PREDICT ADAPTIVE PHENOTYPIC DIFFERENTIATION WITHIN AND BETWEEN TWO WILD ANDEAN TOMATOES - Takuya Nakazato - 2007, they state:
QuoteThe nature of species differences also provides insight into thepredominantdriversofecologicaldiversificationthatinfluence each of these taxa. In S. pimpinellifolium, several traits are predominantly associated with mean annual precipitation rather than temperature, seasonality variables, and soil variation, strongly suggesting that local water availability is one of the major environmental agents driving adaptation in this species. Although selection for smaller and thicker leaves may be operating in S. pimpinellifolium in response to water conditions, the larger and thinner leaves observed in S. l. cerasiforme are potentially selected in response to competition for light. Several pieces of evidence are consistent with this provisional hypothesis. First, the native range of S. l. cerasiforme is characterized by more dense vegetation cover in comparison to other tomato species, particularly in the Amazon Basin. Second, species in shady environments have previously been found to have lower leaf mass/area and to have higher relative growth rate (Garnier 1992; Lambers and Poorter 1992; Reich et al. 1992; Saverimuttu and Westoby 1996). Third, the larger seeds of S. l. cerasiforme may also be advantageous in low light conditions. Plant species experiencing dense shade and light competition tend have larger seeds than plants that occur in open habitats (Saverimuttu and Westoby 1996). Although the mechanisms underlying increased shade tolerance for large seeded plants are not clear, it has been suggested that seedlings from larger seeds can grow more quickly to reach higher photosynthetically active radiation levels (Westoby et al. 1996). Alternatively, the differences in seed size, and in fruit size between the two species—those of S. pimpinellifolium are smaller—might indicate differences in seed dispersal agents, that is, coevolution with different types of animals. Unfortunately, available information on animal/plant relationships in the tomatoes is mostly anecdotal (Rick 1966); the larger fruit of S. l. cerasiforme might be an adaptation to dispersal by mammals, including humans, whereas the smaller seeds of S. pimpinellifolium could be an adaptation to bird dispersal.

It would be great to hear the two sides debate their work with each other. I find it impossible to know which hypothesis might be right. Both have used genetic analysis to come to their conclusions.

For interest, here's some info that might shed light on the potential situation in South America back around the hypothesised period pimpinellifolium could have started to be domesticated, from 'The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity' 2021, by David Graeber and David Wengrow:
QuoteBut not all early farming expansions were of this 'serious' variety. In the lowland tropics of South America, archaeological research has uncovered a distinctly more playful tradition of Holocene food production. Similar practices were still widely in evidence in Amazonia until recently, such as we found among the Nambikwara of Brazil's Mato Grosso region. Well into the twentieth century, they spent the rainy season in riverside villages, clearing gardens and orchards to grow a panoply of crops including sweet and bitter manioc, maize, tobacco, beans, cotton, groundnuts, gourds and more besides. Cultivation was a relaxed affair, with little effort spent on keeping different species apart. And as the dry season commenced, these tangled house gardens were abandoned altogether. The entire group dispersed into small nomadic bands to hunt and forage, only to begin the whole process again the following year, often in a different location.

In Greater Amazonia, such seasonal moves in and out of farming are documented among a wide range of indigenous societies and are of considerable antiquity.
[...]

Amazonian societies blur our conventional distinction between 'wild' and 'domestic' in other ways. Animals they routinely hunt and capture for food include peccary, agouti and others we would classify as 'wild'. Yet these same species are locally considered as already domesticated, at least in the sense of being subjects of supernatural 'masters of the animals' who protect them and to whom they are bound. 'Master' or 'Mistress of the Animals' figures are actually very common in hunting societies; sometimes they take the form of a huge or perfect specimen of a certain type of beast, a kind of embodiment of the species, but at the same time they appear as human or humanlike owners of the species, to whom the souls of all deer, or seals, or caribou must be returned after hunters take them. In Amazonia, what this means in practice is that people avoid intervening in the reproduction of those particular species lest they usurp the role of spirits.

In other words, there was no obvious cultural route, in Amazonia, that might lead humans to become both the primary carers for and consumers of other species; relationships were either too remote (in the case of game) or too intimate (in the case of pets). We are dealing here with people who possess all the requisite ecological skills to raise crops and livestock, but who nevertheless pull back from the threshold, maintaining a careful balancing act between forager (or better, perhaps, forester) and farmer.39

Amazonia shows how this 'in-and-out-of-farming' game could be far more than a transient affair. It seems to have played out over thousands of years, since during that time there is evidence of plant domestication and land management, but little commitment to agriculture. 40

They go on to say:
QuoteWe now know that, by the beginning of the Christian era, the Amazonian landscape was already studded with towns, terraces, monuments and roadways, reaching all the way from the highland kingdoms of Peru to the Caribbean. The first Europeans to arrive there in the sixteenth century described lively floodplain settlements governed by paramount chiefs who dominated their neighbours. It is tempting to dismiss these accounts as adventurers' hyperbole, designed to impress the sponsors at home – but, as archaeological science brings the outlines of this rainforest civilization into view, it is increasingly difficult to do so. Partly this new understanding is the result of controlled research; partly a consequence of industrial deforestation, which in the Upper Amazon basin (looking west to the Andes) has exposed from the canopy a tradition of monumental earthworks, executed to precise geometrical plans and linked by road systems.43

What exactly was the reason for this ancient Amazonian efflorescence? Up until a few decades ago, all these developments were explained as the result of yet another 'Agricultural Revolution'. It was supposed that, in the first millennium BC, intensified manioc-farming raised Amazonian population levels, generating a wave of human expansion throughout the lowland tropics. The basis for this hypothesis lay in finds of domesticated manioc, dating back as early as 7000 BC; more recently, in southern Amazonia, the cultivation of maize and squash has been traced back to similarly early periods. 44 Yet there is little evidence for widespread farming of these crops in the key period of cultural convergence, beginning around 500 BC. In fact, manioc only seems to have become a staple crop after European contact. All this implies that at least some early inhabitants of Amazonia were well aware of plant domestication but did not select it as the basis of their economy, opting instead for a more flexible kind of agroforestry.45

I think this can blur the lines between the Western idea of a 'domesticated' species, and plants which are selected and influenced over millenia by peoples who are not planting them in fields necessarily, but still very much shaping them via selection. I do still find it plausible that this may have started from some populations of pimpinellifolium that were more adapted to the humid and shady environment of the forests, and I can't remember in which paper but I saw an accession of pimpinellifolium which was said to have more lycopersicum-type leaves (important adaptation to humid forest environment), so there may be some pimp populations which are more direct ancestors to what came next. But the increase in fruit size, and seed size, from pimp to 'cerasiforme' does seem to me to fit the overall picture of the image I am getting from what human society could have been like in that region within that '9,900–19,040 years ago' period proposed by this more recent work.

Back to the video you shared William - I really love the graphic shown at 12:21, showing the accessions of SLC in a wheel to show their relationships. We've seen graphic for the relationships of sub-populations, and plots of accessions within them as dots on charts but with no accession-specific information, no labelling, and I have been searching accession-specific data on that. That's awesome! The paper that comes from, I tracked down, it's:
Genomic Evidence for Complex Domestication History of the Cultivated Tomato in Latin America - Hamid Razifard
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31912142/

Justin Jardinier

So, as was discussed in some of those papers we were going through, Sucúa in Ecuador is the main place where the 'most pure' SLC were found. So this seems interesting, a BBC article from last month, 'Huge ancient lost city found in the Amazon':
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-67940671

And trying to track down the scientific paper it might have come from, I found 'Two thousand years of garden urbanism in the Upper Amazon'. It seems to be behind a paywall but we have this at least:
QuoteEditor's summary
When intact, the Amazonian forest is dense and difficult to penetrate, both on foot and with scanning technologies. Over the past several years, however, improved light detection and ranging scans have begun to penetrate the forest canopy, revealing previously unknown evidence of past Amazonian cultures. Rostain et al. describe evidence of such an agrarian Amazonian culture that began more than 2000 years ago. They describe more than 6000 earthen platforms distributed in a geometic pattern connected by roads and intertwined with agricultural landscapes and river drainages in the Upano Valley. Previous efforts have described mounds and large monuments in Amazonia, but the complexity and extent of this development far surpasses these previous sites. —Sacha Vignieri

Abstract
A dense system of pre-Hispanic urban centers has been found in the Upano Valley of Amazonian Ecuador, in the eastern foothills of the Andes. Fieldwork and light detection and ranging (LIDAR) analysis have revealed an anthropized landscape with clusters of monumental platforms, plazas, and streets following a specific pattern intertwined with extensive agricultural drainages and terraces as well as wide straight roads running over great distances. Archaeological excavations date the occupation from around 500 BCE to between 300 and 600 CE. The most notable landscape feature is the complex road system extending over tens of kilometers, connecting the different urban centers, thus creating a regional-scale network. Such extensive early development in the Upper Amazon is comparable to similar Maya urban systems recently highlighted in Mexico and Guatemala.
Source: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adi6317

And the supplimentary materials are available:
file:///Users/justin/Downloads/science.adi6317_sm.pdf

And then checking on the map, I see that is about 33km walk from Sucúa. So, that gives us a bit more context to the history of that region and their tomatoes.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-27, 10:53:29 AMBack to the video you shared William - I really love the graphic shown at 12:21, showing the accessions of SLC in a wheel to show their relationships. We've seen graphic for the relationships of sub-populations, and plots of accessions within them as dots on charts but with no accession-specific information, no labelling, and I have been searching accession-specific data on that. That's awesome! The paper that comes from, I tracked down, it's:
Genomic Evidence for Complex Domestication History of the Cultivated Tomato in Latin America - Hamid Razifard
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31912142/

Correction, the wheel diagram is very similar, and with much of the same data, but it seems the one from the video is actually from this paper:
Unraveling the genetics of tomato fruit weight during crop domestication and diversification - Lara Pereira et al. 2021