Super Fast Tomatoes

Started by Diane Whitehead, 2023-12-29, 03:30:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-30, 06:27:41 PMI'm trying 4.5cm (1.78 inches) spacing in 2 rows, 11 plants per container

Sorry I meant 9cm spacing (about 3.6 inch). I will edit the above now but saying this for those who read it already!

Roland

Interesting videos about optimal tomato conditions:

Vegetative and generative growth:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVLJPFGGqtM

Growth & Light:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-rj7om2A14

Temperature for the plant as speed and development:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GkHZ1Kkqj4
Netherlands

Roland

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-30, 06:27:41 PMWas that with equal daily photon quantity? If so, that would be a fair judge of day length as a single variable (especially if they tested it at various photon levels). What I meant by 'amount of sunshine' though, was not day length, but basically hours of cloudless sky. So I'm really talking about total photons per day.

This paper shows the same results, earliness is increased with less hours of light. But also the ripening is only a few days different.
https://edepot.wur.nl/20530

12H: Exposure time 12 hours, Light intensity 162μmol/m2.s (12,500Lux), Light sum 7mol/m2.day
15H: Exposure time 15 hours, Light intensity 162μmol/m2.s (12,500Lux), Light sum 8.8mol/m2.day
18L: Exposure time 18 hours, Light intensity 135μmol/m2.s (10,400Lux), Light sum 8.8mol/m2.day
18H: Exposure time 18 hours, Light intensity 162μmol/m2.s (12,500Lux), Light sum 10.5mol/m2.day
The 24h temperature was kept as similar as possible for all treatments.
Although I understand from the data that the high intensity (162μmol/m2.s) have slightly greater DIF (difference in temperature between day and night). This was necessary to get a more generative crop.
It was 14C at night and 24C during the day and the 24-hour average temperature was 19.2C.

Ripening fruit after flower formation 12H at 63 days
Ripening fruit after flower formation 15H at 62 days
Ripening fruit after flower formation 18H at 65 days
Ripening fruit after flower formation 18L at 67 days

So a total of 5 days difference and short exposure means faster ripening.

Increasing the exposure time from 12 hours to 15 hours results in an increase in production of 4.2 kg (20%).
Increasing the exposure time from 15 hours to 18 hours results in an increase in production of 2.1 kg (8%). (corresponds 1 to 1 to the extra light per production)
Extending the exposure time from 15 hours to 18 hours with the same amount of light per day results in an increase in production of (-5%).

This study also shows that shorter lighting gives a better result. But mainly in production and not in earliness. I think the 5 day difference over a total of 65 days is negligible.

My conclusion from the many papers so far is that temperature is much more important than lighting for faster fruit ripening.
As described in the conclusion of this paper:
https://academic.oup.com/aob/article/88/5/869/2587168
Tomato fruits ripened 95, 65, 46 and 42 d after flower opening when plants were grown under controlled environmental conditions at 14, 18, 22 and 26 °C, respectively.

It may also be worth mentioning that several publications indicate that tomatoes need at least 8mol/m2.day for fruit production. And that the maximum production is 30mol/m2.day.

Light saturation of photosynthesis in the leaves takes place at an intensity of approximately 500 μmol/m².s (40,000 lux)

Does anyone have these 3 publications and would you like to share them:
Growth and Development in the Young Tomato Hussy
https://academic.oup.com/jxb/article-abstract/14/2/316/516776
https://academic.oup.com/jxb/article-abstract/14/2/326/516783
https://academic.oup.com/jxb/article-abstract/16/3/373/542054
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

#18
Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-01, 02:17:27 PMIncreasing the exposure
This study also shows that shorter lighting gives a better result. But mainly in production and not in earliness. I think the 5 day difference over a total of 65 days is negligible.

I think it could have been interesting if they had also tested the lower intensity at 12 and 15 hours also. And tested 12 hours and 15 hours at the same light total. But yes it makes sense that they need to do their thing for long enough in the dark. And when the difference is only slight, there is also the factor of the price of light, in terms of electricity and also LED lifespan, and perhaps even the number of light systems. Run brighter the energy efficiency decreases and the LED lifespan decreases. And for my own lights, I have had them further from the plants than recommended simply so I can supply light to a larger area - not ideal but suits my limited circumstances. It's all useful information though. So many things to balance!

Edit: I wrote the below before re-writing the above, before realising what I have misunderstood but anyway here it is:

For me, earliness is the most important thing really, for my indoor crossing, though yes a few days doesn't make much difference. I think keeping the root pace small probably has a much more significant difference. I just checked one of my crosses that is flowering now - I first made the seed wet to try germinating it on November 2nd, and the first flower flowered on December 13th. I have no memory of how long it took to germinate, but from seed to open flower that's 41 days. It's a mix of 6 different species but I think that's perhaps not unusual, it was the first one I checked. Oh.... sorry I just realised the above was flower to ripening fruit, not germination to flower opening - sorry it's so late and I've been working for many hours straight! I should probably rest. Anyway does 41 days from seed to open flower seem reasonable? Some of my fruits may have taken only one month I think. Some do take longer though. I have records for each length from pollination to harvest for all my crosses but it's all on the seed bags so I'd have to check if I wanted those figures. They're a bit skewed though, like I said being so busy, sometimes I do not harvest them until quite some time after they're ripe. But I did harvest some ripe fruit today, might have been ripe for a while, some of them, but here are 3 of them:

Pollinated on:   Mother:
November 21st.   50% lycopersicum 50% galapagense
November 17th    50% lycopersicum 50% chmielewskii
November 13th    lycopersicum

So the fastest of those was 41 days. The temperature seems to be around 21~22°C. I don't have an e-PAR meter so I don't know the light intensity.

Diane Whitehead

Update to my first message:

It has been four days since I sowed a single tomato seed either in a pot of soil mix or on a slice of banana covered with soil mix.

Today no seeds have germinated, but each banana slice has grown a bush of feathery gray fungus.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Mica Winnower

It's really annoying the amount of misleading and bad information that gets propagated for the current 'content mill' cycle nowadays online. There's a lot of eye-catching, well-edited content that does things like this to make gardening seem like some magic trick or hidden skill that you just need to be clever enough to follow these shortcuts to make all your friends jealous. Plus, if something goes wrong, or if it's not going as quickly as the video, you'll go back to watch it again to make sure you did it like they showed in the video.

There's money to be made in getting people to watch content, so if they make some slightly outlandish claims, then more people will watch their video. It doesn't matter if they're lying, and the advertisers don't care, because they've got you to watch the video and look at the advertisements while the host website sells them your data and demographics.

Diane Whitehead

You are so right, Micah.  I've seen several even wilder ideas - growing an orchid stem in a potato, various things being grown in a mushed-up avocado. What an imagination some people have!

Anyway, my tomato seedlings in potting mix have sprouted on day 5.  I'll have some micro tomato plants to grow under lights this winter - Birdie Rouge, Gemma, Jochalos, Laura #5

The banana slice pots with gray fungus have been tossed outside.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Adrian

#22
We forgotten that the seeds don't required nutrients for the germination.
Spread too shot of fertiliser can burned the  seedlings.
Water and the t° adapted at the species are the main.

According my experience objets in decomposition in a planter seedling attracted the fly of the seedling.

Eventually for a light fertiliser more assimilable, i think that dramp the banana slices some hours in the water irrigation before the watered will be more efficient that sow in the banana slice.It will give a water a little more rich in potasium and others nutrients eaven if the effect is low.
Spread fertiliser is efficient after the germination.

  All solid product with a nutrients composition can be diluted in water some hours before the watered.Just warned at the inhibitors of germination and toxic nutrients.



Cathy A

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-12-29, 04:35:18 PMThere is a video where they boil a red cabbage, strain it, and boil a cotton shirt in it. Then pull out a commercial deep purple shirt.

Trivia note:  the liquid produced by boiling purple cabbage is a pretty good poor man's pH tester. It won't give you an accurate pH, but it will turn different colors depending on whether it is acid or alkaline.

It's a great "science for kids" project.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-01-09, 02:44:08 PMTrivia note:  the liquid produced by boiling purple cabbage is a pretty good poor man's pH tester. It won't give you an accurate pH, but it will turn different colors depending on whether it is acid or alkaline.

It's a great "science for kids" project.

Given how it reacts when you add acid, I imagine butterfly pea flower powder (like they use to make the tea) works about the same.

Justin Jardinier

Sharing this in case it is useful for anyone:
Quantitative trait locus mapping associated with earliness and fruit weight in tomato:
https://www.scielo.br/j/sa/a/n53xX6nvxz4x8HfPbtGHh6R/?lang=en&format=html&stop=next

Roland

Unripe fruits that fall from the plant can be allowed to ripen and the seeds are fertile.

Now I wonder how many days after pollination you can remove the unripe fruit from the plant and let it ripen in a warm container (+25C) with ethylene?

This could accelerate the ripening process even more due to the Ethylene and the high temperature.
Netherlands

ThomatoGarden

'So this is the fastest procedure i figured out atm after testing soil, temperature , moisture , root space:

- Soak Seeds in water (not more than 12 h)
- fill 9 cm pots with plant soil leave a 2x2 cm hole
- fill hole with Good germination soil
- plant seed in this germination soil
- water good
- cover pots with transparent foil or put in mini grow house
- choose a place with 25°C
- keep moist!
- as soon as the tomatoes sprout remove them and put them into the dedicated grow enviromnent (20°C
  800Lumen  (otherwise they will shoot)
- replant the Tomatoes as soon as possible to not disturb the root growth, LATEST! when
   the roots show at the bootom of the pots.

After 21 days the plants are 10-20cm high depending of the variety.

What are your procedures, particularly later on where my plants still start too shoot up?

ThomatoGarden

Quote from: Roland on 2024-01-24, 03:59:23 PMUnripe fruits that fall from the plant can be allowed to ripen and the seeds are fertile.

Now I wonder how many days after pollination you can remove the unripe fruit from the plant and let it ripen in a warm container (+25C) with ethylene?

This could accelerate the ripening process even more due to the Ethylene and the high temperature.

Thats a really interesting thought maybe seeds are allready fertile when the recoloring occurres.
For soil testing i used supermarket tomatoes and this are normallay harvested unripe. Maybe seeds are ripe as early as the couloring of the fruits star.

Steph S

Other growers report germination from seeds from green ripe fruit not yet at breaker stage, if planted immediately.  So if the point is to begin the next generation immediately, it's not impossible to cut a few days off your seed harvest.
However the caution is that the seeds from unripe fruit will not have the same shelf life as seeds from a ripe and fully colored tomato.  They may only be viable for a year or two, compared to 10+ years for seeds from fully mature fruit.
For the best shelf life of seeds,  green ripe or breaker fruits should be allowed to color and ripen fully before seed is harvested.