When planning tomato breeding

Started by Kadence Luneman, 2023-12-10, 03:08:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

#15
Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-12-12, 06:15:25 PMWhat's the current interest in the SI tomatoes?

Do you mean how popular is the idea? Or, why is there interest? I don't think there really is much interest, to be honest. For example I contacted an organic seed company and asked about their potential interest in future for a delicious SI or largely outcrossing adaptive population of tomatoes or peppers, and they basically said they are only interested in stable varieties. I did not argue the case, since I figured it's only worth doing so once I have something worth arguing for.

There are of course some of us very interested, but I think we are relatively very few! Regarding why, the way I see it is that it's really about having an adaptive population. I will try to relate this to the 'landrace' concept, in my own words. So, a landrace is a population of food crop that is genetically adapted to a specific region. Generally they have some level of genetic diversity, but are phenotypically pretty homogenous for at least some traits, in particular for the traits relating to the part that is eaten. For example, there may be a population of potatoes which give all basically similar sized potatoes which have similar shape and colour and cooking qualities such as level of waxiness or whatever. But there might be some difference in their leaves or other traits, and even regarding the tuber traits, there can be different genetics behind the phenotype. And some individuals may have differing performance in different environmental extremes or pest pressures, so, in a 'bad' year, some may do better than others. This gives the population some resilience.

It also depends on the culture. Some cultures may be selecting for more phenotype traits (often going beyond merely the edible part), and some fewer. So that will affect the amount of genetic variation. But either way, there is generally more genetic diversity than 'heirloom' crops, even in SC populations. Part of this may also be due to saving seed from a larger population, as well as not having the same concept of 'purity' that may be found in the modern heirloom movement, which seems to be a movement coming from... maybe around 18th century onwards when the European seed catalogues became popular and plant breeders would sell varieties they bred, far and wide, and people, I guess generally 'gardeners' rather than farmers, would save the seeds and continue the variety. So, many of these came from specific plant breeders and originated from deliberately stabilised varieties created by deliberate bottlenecks of selecting an individual plant each season, in the normal modern process of stabilising a cross. And probably some landraces originated like this too, but when grow long enough by farmers, and with some level of outcrossing even if small, plus saving seed at the farm population size, means some small level of continued diversity, which is generally good, but perhaps fought against in the modern heirloom community which is largely about 'preservation' as a counter-movement to the domination of modern commercial varieties from corporations.

So the idea of having a landrace is attractive for some people, being potentially a little more adaptive.

Then we have two things:
1) Due to modern agriculture being dominated by corporations and capitalism, if you are living in the West it is likely that there may be no remaining local landraces for whatever crops you want to grow. From what I understand, in most Western countries, pretty much the only landraces left are fodder crops.

2) We are in a mass extinction event with a rapidly changing climate, which brings both changing environmental pressures and changing disease and pest pressures.

Regarding the first point, if we want to create a new landrace for a particular crop, then we could do it the old way, which is basically to just grow crops from seed we acquire, which if of an SC species may mean a very low level of outcrossing, and take potentially many generations (of humans, i.e. centuries) to adapt to our current local conditions to our satisfaction. I assume this is how it happened in the past, and after centuries they had well adapted local landraces. But, we might instead be a bit impatient and want to see good results within our lifetime. So we can accelerate the process by creating what is called an 'adaptive population', for example by getting many different varieties of the crop species and planting them together. We could let the natural rate of crossing occur, which might be low supposing it is a naturally low rate in an SC population, but, due to the high diversity, the percentage of each variety will fluctuate somewhat depending on the particular year as normal variations in conditions occur. This, along with the natural rate of crossing, will make the population as a whole adapt at an accelerated rate.

Or we can deliberately cross all or many of those varieties, creating a hybrid swarm of much intensified diversity, and then proceed as above. Either way, the population will adapt at an accelerated rate and once the phenotype of the eating part has settled down, and the population is well adapted to the region, it might be designated a 'landrace'. It still could take many years for that process, but it's comparatively speedy. Also, some people may choose to keep the eating part phenotype diverse. To be honest I am not sure whether or not that fits the definition of a landrace or not. I haven't seen support for that in the literature, in terms of what 'landrace' means in the botany/farming community, but some people might choose to use that term.

Joseph has done great work in laying out methods for this accelerated way of working towards a landrace, which he called the 'modern landrace' method. The way I would express that is basically the creation of adaptive populations which lead to what I might call 'proto-landraces' which if taken far enough can become landraces. I recommend his course on that, which can be found here:
https://goingtoseed.org/collections/courses

Regarding the second point, this is rather a serious issue. So far as I understand, traditional SC landraces can, depending on the species, have a very low rate of outcrossing. Like rice, or often tomatoes, for example. So, on a traditional farm scale (and I am thinking of traditional village farms in Laos or India or South America, which might be just a few small fields, not the mega-farms of industrial US), this we might regard as relative stability, but just enough genetic mixing bubbling away that there is good enough adaptation to the gradually changing and fluctuating climate as it was before industrial humans created the current mass extinction event and the rapidly changing climate along with it.

So, for our current situation, the low level of genetic fluctuation may often simply not be enough if we want crops to keep up with the now rapidly changing environment. I don't know the maths but I will make some up merely to demonstrate the point - suppose a 2% outcrossing rate was enough to give a good balance between phenotype stability and genetic adaptation, in traditional landraces. Well, suppose the climate is changing twice as fast now, then we might want instead 4% outcrossing, or if 10 times as much, maybe 20% outcrossing! I doubt it is exactly that simple, but hopefully you get the idea.

For this reason, if we consciously want to make a landrace, I think this is important to bear in mind. We may want to start with that adaptive population, and even with deliberate crosses making a hybrid swarm, and be aiming for a landrace that still has relatively high rates of outcrossing. So, for tomatoes, selecting for open flowers and/or exserted stigmas, can help both of these stages. And given a large enough population size, SI populations will be the most adaptive, since their outcrossing rate is effectively 100%. Though for small populations SC may actually be better, and, having an SC population that is largely outcrossing or even mainly outcrossing, like some wild tomato populations (e.g. S. chielewskii, some populations of S. habrochaites and S. pennellii etc.), can give the benefit of having outcrossing rates potentially in excess of our needs even in this unstable time, but also potentially be suitable for people who want to grow small population sizes, as many gardeners may want to do, which would be an issue for SI populations.

Joseph seems to be focused on this more extreme rate of diversity for most of his crops. And to me this seems to have 3 benefits.
1) Those adaptive populations can be great for starting new landrace projects with.
2) Having perhaps more diversity than needed in his region, can mean those adaptive populations can be more widely shared with people in different regions, which relates to the above point.
3) They should be better equipped to deal with the changing climate than most traditional landraces.

For me, the issue of UI (unilateral incompatibility) is also important. If we have an SI population that can still be pollinated by SC pollen, then this would seem to me to pose the danger of it being diluted, and potentially leading to the loss of the SI trait. And if it is being polluted by mainstream tomatoes which lack adaptation to our region, then this also means that even if we adapted our population to that region, we might loose what we gained via that dilution.

Similarly, with a largely outcrossing SC population, we can also loose those traits if it is crossing with the mainstream inferior mass population. This is why for both cases, I see it as of potential great advantage if they cannot be pollinated by mainstream tomatoes. For example, if one has a largely outcrossing SC population that had the UI mechanisms from S. chmielewskii, it may be unable to be pollinated by S. lycopersicum, and only pollinated by itself, or by S. chmielewskii or S. neorickii. In that case you could grow the population without the need of any isolation measures and it would only self or cross within the population, and be in no danger of dilution from other populations so long as there were no S. chmielewskii or S. neorickii growing nearby, which is anyway unlikely. Otherwise, with an outcrossing SC or SI population that is not protected from S. lycopersicum SC pollen, it would require isolation methods in order to protect it from dilution. Such measures are of course possible, but it would seem more convenient to not require them, especially since many gardeners may want to grow without such measures and with other tomato varieties in the same garden or grown by immediate neighbours.








Cathy A

I would not expect there to be any commercial interest in SI tomatoes, even among seed sellers. If you look for landrace seeds of outbreeding vegetables, you won't find many of those either.

The real benefit is to purely amateur gardeners in support of local adaptation.

SI tomatoes are the sort of thing I would expect to be passed from gardener to gardener, either informally or through formal seed exchanges.

Justin Jardinier

#17
Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-12-13, 10:24:46 AMI would not expect there to be any commercial interest in SI tomatoes, even among seed sellers.

Various companies sell SI tomato species. And the Experimental farm Network sells Joseph's 'Wilding', which are domesticated interspecies tomatoes (mainly lycopersicum) that, as they state, are "a mix of self-compatible and self-incompatible plants":
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/wildling-panamorous-tomato

For sure SI tomatoes are not mainstream, but it does show there is *some* interest in the market at least.

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-12-13, 10:24:46 AMIf you look for landrace seeds of outbreeding vegetables, you won't find many of those either.

I don't actually know about any landraces of SI crops. But here's a new landrace wheat bred for Scotland, which is commercially viable enough that they sell the seed and flour:
https://scotlandthebread.org/product/balcaskie-landrace-organic-grain/

And evolutionary populations of grain are greatly increasing in popularity in Europe. Here's a video of an interview with Salvatore Ceccarelli and Stefania Grando on that work:
https://youtu.be/GQ0LzM1DG0c?si=jSdyK4y9rPVkKp3U

Somewhere I saw a nice chart of the number of people growing... I think it may have been that population perhaps... and how it really took off after a while, perhaps through getting the seed registered? Grain selling can be hard when going outside the huge corporations and their lobbying power in Europe. Anyway, it's a good example of a great increase in interest in evolutionary populations. And I would expect that to only increase as the climate continues to change - I feel fairly sure there will be catastrophic global food network breakdowns within a few years.

And it's being noticed in the literature. Here's just one example, 'Evolutionary Wheat Populations in High-Quality Breadmaking as a Tool to Preserve Agri-Food Biodiversity', but there are many:
https://www.mdpi.com/2304-8158/11/4/495

Now I'm not saying there will necessarily be an explosion in interest in SI domesticated tomatoes. But, I would guess that's down to breeders. If we can make populations that are reliably delicious, and better adapted to the local conditions than commercial tomatoes, especially in a low input context (which is ever more important with increasing poverty and increasing awareness of the environmental consequences of high input), then if those populations are SI, I would think they have a good chance of catching on. Who would not want something better adapted, just as or more tasty, and easier to grow? Like with the wheat - it was a very unusual idea from the perspective of modern farmers, but the results were better, and if directly experienced, that should be quite readily convincing.

And, I think passing on from gardener to gardener is also nice. Very good in fact if the gardeners are feeding enough people! But, I think that does also give the real danger of severe bottlenecks. I don't know if perhaps I worry about that too much. But for example, I received some SI seeds from someone, very kindly. It was only when I specifically enquired after growing them and increasing seed stock, that I discovered that the seed I had received had been produced by a grow out of only 2 plants, meaning I had a maximum of 4 S-alleles. Had I not known this I may have shared my seeds with others and that could have gone on a long time, with that number never increasing, and most probably decreasing to the extent of at least some people ending up with plants that can't reproduce. I can easily imagine this kind of thing happening to others. I can even imagine it maybe happening commercially already if some people are selling seeds but not growing out sufficient numbers themselves, or sourcing their original stock from bottlenecked populations. Of course there are some remedies to this, like sharing seeds back and forth, but even then it could be that everyone in one region is sharing between themselves a bottlenecked population that was already in a dire situation when it arrived in the region, like that maybe with only 3 or 4 s-alleles. Suppose I had shared my seed with 10 people, and each of them with another 10 - all 100 people could share between themselves regularly and never improve that situation.

I am definitely in favour of small scale growing and sharing. But I am also concerned about widescale food security. I would really like to see delicious neglectible SI tomatoes grown both on small and large scale, and my sense is the larger scale will be important for the security and sustainability of such crops. (By 'large' I guess I am thinking for example of the TGRC recommendation of minimum 75 plants). I guess also for SC UI tomatoes large populations would be good for general diversity, though at least they do not have the urgent issue of S-allele diversity to worry about, and a gardener could even grow just 1 plant! 

reed

I don't what to work with SI or introduce it into my population at all. I am hopeful of increasing the outcrossing rate and the successful pollination rate of my population just by doing lots of crosses both within my existing population and by introducing some varieties.

There is some reason that most large tomatoes in general have so many flowers that don't get pollinated.  I don't know what it is, but I think just mixing them up some might help.

I don't want to include anything too far off the phenotypical type that I like and that do well for me already. I need to know that no matter, the F1s the F2s and so on will be good in all ways that matter, because they came from parents that are the same in those ways.

I would like them to be like corn, where they just easily pollinate with pretty much any other similar tomato. I don't think SI is necessary for that and in a small garden might actually be counterproductive.

Joseph Lofthouse

#19
The ancestors of the Beautifully Promiscuous and Totally Tasty Tomatoes project more or less got chosen by pure chance: Both the donor and receiver of pollen flowered on the same day, when I visited the greenhouse.

Kadence Luneman

Thanks William for explaining what you're looking for in your crosses.

Thanks for explaining you guys interest and disinterest in SI tomatoes.

I think I'm going to be focused on the others more but I may continue playing with the SI population just for fun. Once I have something to show for it next fall I'd be happy to send seed of the tested SI population and hopefully elites from the Wildling/Panamorous population to anyone who is also working on it.

I'm also curious to see how things do as far as pest and diseases goes. I know Joseph is interested in having them tested elsewhere since his garden doesn't have enough of it to select for resistances. Since my place gets about 40% to 70% more rain than Joseph's does I should likely see something.

Cathy A

Justin,

Experimental Farm Network is not what I meant by a "commercial seed seller". I was thinking of Territorial, Stokes, Johnny's, etc. I don't think they would be interested in SI tomatoes. Perhaps Baker Creek would be.

I can't imagine the current commercial ag industry going for SI, landraces, or anything other than utterly predictable near-clones. They are invested in the every-plant-identically-perfect model.

Heck, modern hybrid corn has been bred to be identical so that no one plant can outcompete its neighbors.

William Schlegel

Alot of my crosses have been determined in part by what was available when I had my pollinator tool, forceps, and pollen spoon out. This time of year is a good time to think about what you really want to plant.

Just a planning thought! Double crosses might be more fun than single. Start with four types of tomato, make two crosses, then cross the two crosses in the F1. Then do a really large F2 grow out of the seed from the double cross. I know that is two years planning if you do a single generation a year. Though could be a good winter generation project to do one of the crosses or the initial F1 grow outs. The huge F2 would be fun though.

Here is a potential cross I was mentally toying with: (Flamenco x Galapagense LA1410) x (Sandpoint x Purple Zebra F1). Might make some interesting progress towards a fun tomato with a double cross like that.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-12-13, 05:52:54 PMJustin,

Experimental Farm Network is not what I meant by a "commercial seed seller". I was thinking of Territorial, Stokes, Johnny's, etc. I don't think they would be interested in SI tomatoes. Perhaps Baker Creek would be.

I can't imagine the current commercial ag industry going for SI, landraces, or anything other than utterly predictable near-clones. They are invested in the every-plant-identically-perfect model.

Heck, modern hybrid corn has been bred to be identical so that no one plant can outcompete its neighbors.


Yeah, I think the way forward is for farmers to bypass the big corporations. There's a really cool collective in Europe that even bypass the stupid seed laws (which regulate what varieties can be sold, and is a corporate scam really) by having a membership system. It's more involved than that and I can't remember the website, but anyway I think there are options for sharing and selling seeds that we can move towards outside of the current mainstream system. But, I think small seed companies play a great role too.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-13, 06:13:32 PMHere is a potential cross I was mentally toying with: (Flamenco x Galapagense LA1410) x (Sandpoint x Purple Zebra F1). Might make some interesting progress towards a fun tomato with a double cross like that.

I wonder, since Purple Zebra is itself already an F1, it might be good to grow many (or several) Sandpoint x Purple Zebra F1 and cross them all to the other F1. Like for the PH genes for example, you'd need to do several just to have a statistically good chance of getting heterozygous for PH-2 and PH-3 coming through.

Also I encourage speed breeding :-) One could start with seeds and within 6 months, or 8 months if going slow, have seeds for a double cross already, over winter.

William Schlegel

#25
Here are some actual new F1 crosses I made in 2023:
1. (MMM x Purple zebra) x (MMM x galapagense x)
2. Payette x (MMM x Galapagense X)

I could cross those two together again in 2024 if I wanted, or just let them segregate for a few generations and see which of my favorite traits segregated out- and then make another cross with them. Considering that especially the (MMM x Purple zebra) x (mmm x galapagense x) is already quite unstable it might be nice to let it segregate and see what happens- it should segregate quite a lot in the F1. It is basically an F1 of: (F2c X F1a) X (F2c X F1b)
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

Large seed companies have been the primary supporters of the Beautifully Promiscuous and Totally Tasty Tomatoes (self-incompatibile) project. They have spent tens of thousands of dollars on it. I don't talk much about it, cause I want to give them a competitive advantage when a stable-ish variety is released.

Kadence Luneman

William you mean like a composit cross?
A x B and C x D
AB x CD
ABCD mass grow out and selection

That is similar to how Cornish cross chickens are bred, there is multiple base flocks and the Cornish cross you buy to feed out are actually the result of I think 6 generations of very specific crosses.

That's actually a good point. I was just thinking that is probably how sungold (right?) that is so popular for flavor etc. They did all the testing and crossing to get the exact product. I would bet that alot of it comes down to heterozygous genes needed, which means you can't stabilize exactly because you always end up with 50% heterozygous, 25% homozygous for the dominant, and 25% homozygous for the recessive. I also think that there is alot of polygenic traits at work. Each parent or multiple grandparents have to have exactly the right genes in order for the result of the cross to have exactly what it needs. And in a way that you can't replicate by stabilizing a variety.

Kadence Luneman

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-12-13, 06:59:13 PMLarge seed companies have been the primary supporters of the Beautifully Promiscuous and Totally Tasty Tomatoes (self-incompatibile) project. They have spent tens of thousands of dollars on it. I don't talk much about it, cause I want to give them a competitive advantage when a stable-ish variety is released.

That is very interesting. I know that large companies are getting into different aspects of regenerative agriculture so it doesn't surprise me that they have lots of thumbs in different pies. As Cathy said, I don't know what angle they are going for but it's definitely going to be different than the current norm is.

William Schlegel

#29
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-13, 06:25:15 PMI wonder, since Purple Zebra is itself already an F1, it might be good to grow many (or several) Sandpoint x Purple Zebra F1 and cross them all to the other F1. Like for the PH genes for example, you'd need to do several just to have a statistically good chance of getting heterozygous for PH-2 and PH-3 coming through.

Also I encourage speed breeding :-) One could start with seeds and within 6 months, or 8 months if going slow, have seeds for a double cross already, over winter.

When I checked my actual notes I am not terribly far from this.

I have these Payette and Sandpoint crosses:
Payette x (MMM x Solanum galapagense cross)
Payette x (MMM x Sweet Cherriette RL)
Sandpoint x (MMM x Sweet Cherriette)
Payette x (MMM x LA1375)

Then I have these purple Zebra F1 crosses:

MMM x Purple Zebra F1
(MMM F2 x Purple Zebra F1) x (MMM F2 x PH5 pimpinillifolium)
(MMM x Purple Zebra F1) x (MMM x LA1375)
(MMM X Purple Zebra) X (MMM x Brad's Atomic Grape)
Amethyst Cream x (MMM X Purple Zebra F1)
Galahad F1 x (MMM X Purple Zebra F1)
(MMM x Purple zebra) x (mmm x galapagense x)
Mr. Stripey x (MMM x Purple Zebra F1)

I think it would make sense to let the Payette and Sandpoint crosses segregate for Dwarf in the F2. Though would be fine to make crosses between the four of them in the F1. Then take those dwarfs and cross them with the descendants of Purple Zebra.

Though I am a little dissatisfied with that. I think it might be nice to make additional crosses with both Purple Zebra F1 and Solanum galapagense.

On a separate note: but going back to the idea of SI tomatoes.

I think it might be sort of an interesting exercise to perhaps cross all my crosses with promiscuous x LA2329. It would take something like 80 crosses to do so, I think. The results would be mostly unpalatable in the short term but at 3/4 domestic some of them would be good. I think I've avoided crossing LA2329 more widely because I was trying to avoid inserted stigmas and I kind of like having some of my tomatoes be easily palatable. Virtually all my crosses though have at least the potential for exserted stigmas. I would rate it as: just possible. The LA2329 project has become an important one to me. So sort of looping all of my projects into it, might be one way to sort of focus in on it. If I did what Joseph did and stopped working on fully domestic tomatoes, all the garden space would be taken up by LA2329 hybrids. Though they might be mostly 25%. It could be that in a year I will have some very palatable tomatoes from the project- but they might also lack the important arthropod resistance traits that are still quite likely in Promiscuous x LA2329 and it would be nice not to dilute the LA2329 genetics too far.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days