What Were Tomatoes Like Before Europeans?

Started by reed, 2023-11-26, 07:24:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-10-21, 10:32:11 PMEuropeans got perfectly domesticated, even extremely fancy heirloom tomatoes from indigenous peoples. One of the first ever painted was a yellow heirloom with those fancy deep ribs. A 1561 tomato could easily be an indigenous heirloom that had nothing done to it but be seed saved for less than 70 years by Europeans.

I have wondered about that. It seems like all the wild tomatoes people talk about and those I've seen pictures of are small, sometimes not even edible. It seems unlikely to me that early Europeans would have bothered to take them back or if they did that just a few decades or even a couple hundred years was enough time for them to evolve into those bigger fruits that later came back to the Americas.

Are you suggesting that isn't what happened? That instead large-fruited tomatoes existed in the Americas before European contact? If so, where are they now, did they do extinct here, are they still out there somewhere? I guess if they did exist but are not actually wild, then the indigenous people must have done the breeding work to create form the wild. Or if they were wild, they must be extinct now?

I'd love to see that painting of the 1561 tomato, do you happen to know where to find it? The description reminds me again of Mr. Stripy and is building my theory, probably more like fantasy, that there is something special about those big yellow heirlooms. 

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-26, 07:24:08 AMThat instead large-fruited tomatoes existed in the Americas before European contact? If so, where are they now, did they do extinct here, are they still out there somewhere?

Yes, and they are still around. The paper Exploiting the diversity of tomato- the development of a phenotypically and genetically detailed germplasm collection - Estefanía Mata-Nicolás et al - 2020, states:
QuoteThe cultivated tomato and its wild relatives came from the Peruvian and Ecuadorian regions of South America. According to allozyme variation, Rick and Fobes 1 proposed that SLL [Solanum lycopersicum var. lycopersicum] evolved from S. lycopersicum var. cerasiforme (Dunal) Spooner, G.J. Anderson & R.K. Jansen (SLC). Recently, Blanca et al. 2,3 proposed a two-step domestication process from SLC to SLL based on molecular and morphological evidence. The first step involves the pre-domestication of SLC in the Amazonian region of Southern Ecuador and Northern Peru. Subsequently, SLC would have migrated to Mesoamerica where it would be domesticated to SLL. Razifard et al. 4 proposed that many traits considered typical of cultivated tomatoes arose in South America. However, these domestication traits were lost or diminished once these partially domesticated forms spread to Mesoamerica, where it was finally morphed into the SLL5,6 . This domestication and diffusion process was accompanied by a selection of alleles related to fruit color, size and shape and also changes in plant architecture7–10 . This process also included various genetic bottlenecks that progressively narrowed the genetic diversity of modern tomato, compared to its wild species3,11 . The main loss of variability occurred during the migration to Mesoamerica from the Peruvian and Ecuadorian Amazon region. Most of the allelic variants present in european vintage tomato are already present in these Amazonian SLC populations3.

The paper Determination of Volatile Organic Compounds in Andean Tomato Landraces by Headspace Solid Phase Microextraction-Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry discussed some such old landraces. The TGRC has many accessions available. I only have 'Columbianum' which is rather small - I would be very interested in any relatively large pre-Columbian landrace that has any late blight resistance!

I've seen some photos of selections of such landraces but can't find any right now.

William Schlegel

#2
https://www.realclearscience.com/articles/2022/01/22/what_did_europes_first_tomato_look_like_812766.html#!

I was trying to Google up that yellow ribbed painting. Found the above article which seems to me even more interesting. They collected a number of images of early paintings for it both red and yellow. Likewise, they suggest in the Article going to South and Central America and collecting some heirlooms to find out what early European tomatoes were like.

Occasionally in tomato catalogues I see a tomato that's back story is a Mexican or South American origin. I think some of those likely bypassed going to Europe and the coming back hundreds of years later.

It would also be possible, for traditional landrace tomatoes grown in areas with wild tomatoes to sometimes cross with them- as they have in Reed's garden. That would lead to diversification at the genetic level. It could also provide a potential backstory for tomatoes like Coyote.

https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/collections/tomatoes/products/plate-de-haiti-tomato

The above tomato is an example of one that might be amongst those first to travel back to the old world. It probably wouldn't be a good choice genetically because it makes sense that its genetics would be very close to those that traveled back to the old world even if it didn't.

https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/collections/tomatoes/products/puerto-cortes-cherry-tomato

Here above is a likely example of one that may have never traveled back to the old world.

https://www.nativeseeds.org/collections/tomatoes  As are four of the tomatoes which Native Seed Search currently offers- the ones from their seed collection not the yellow pear or Flamenco. They likely have a few others in their seed collection they will periodically grow out and offer. Unfortunately, these examples are in the small and red category.

https://www.gardenhoard.com/tomato-reisetomate-seeds.html The reisetomate has a central America origin story.

https://www.rareseeds.com/tomato-tlacolula-pink this tomato has a Mexican origin story.

Things can get complicated fast though because tomatoes have traveled extensively. So we could potentially find a tomato with an awesome backstory- and genetic testing could prove it to be from amongst those that spent time in Europe and became genetically bottlenecked there.

It would be interesting to get a good collection of say central American tomato accessions and evaluate them for stigma exsertion. Assuming those notes aren't already there in the gene banks (they may well be).  Check out this image I found on TGRC for an accession in Ecuador https://tgrc-app.ucdavis.edu/images/LA0410-10L1623.jpg https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Accession/detail/LA0410
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#3
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-26, 12:04:04 PMhttps://www.nhm.ac.uk/natureplus/blogs/solanacae-in-south-america/tags/tomatoes.htmlI love these sorts of accounts of trips to South America. Not sure where I found this one now.

Very Interesting article and seems to support some theories I've had recently. Well less of a theory and some loosely associated clues. When I read "The sepals of Solanum pimpinellifolium – the progenitor of our cultivated tomato..." Is not the first time I've seen that. And then related or unrelated clues in other threads about tomatoes already being much larger when they were taken to Europe about 500 years ago. Just clues making me think there is something there to look for, just not sure what or how to go about it.
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-26, 09:15:30 AMhttps://www.realclearscience.com/articles/2022/01/22/what_did_europes_first_tomato_look_like_812766.html#!I was trying to Google up that yellow ribbed painting. Found the above article which seems to me even more interesting.

Wow that is a great article. I thought this interesting, "Italian physician and botanist Pietro Andrea Matthioli was the first European to mention the tomato in writing. He and his contemporaries called them 'golden apples'" Golden apples, what about that? And the tomato at bottom left in the photo, looks a bit familiar. I'm starting to get an idea. I can't go to South America to find seeds, but I can go to Kentucky, Tennesse and North Carolina. There really are some heirloom tomatoes left down there, not heirloom as in romanticized stories but heirloom as in old. Not what got took to Europe, but maybe pretty close to what came back.
 
I'm starting to get the itch to actually put my mind to breed tomatoes. It won't be an overly scientific endeavor, more just collect up some varieties based on specific commonalities and what happens.

Those mountain area tomatoes seem to me to come in a few overall types. All of those I'm interested in and am used to all my life, have in common large fruit size but come in three or four-color schemes. Pink, Purple, Red but not that bright red of some tomatoes. And of course, the yellow with orange and red swirled in. The have lots and lots of names and lots of subtle and not so subtle differences. They have different flavors, but all are very good, for different uses. None of these tomatoes produce gigantic crops like some newer kinds but still, it only takes a couple plants to provide fresh tomatoes a few at a time all summer.

I won't say they are immune to disease or even tolerant. I'm sure by now every possible tomato disease is in my garden and as far as I know they get infected with all of them. Besides that, sometimes it rains too much, sometimes not all. I just think they are just sort of generally forgiving of their environment, they're just used to it.

And it doesn't make sense to me that they all came back from Europe individually. I'm sure several did all along the east coast, but I suspect that others such as those I mentioned came back a few or maybe one each of the overall type and they got distributed in a specific area. I can't go back to the original origins of tomatoes but I'm starting to think I might be able to go back to what came back from Europe.

If my hair brained idea is right that for example all those Mr. Stripy-like tomatoes came from a common ancestor as maybe did Cherokee Purple (which has lots of subtle subgroups, in my opinion) then maybe those original "Home from Abroad" parents can be reconstructed. They diverged and adapted once already, maybe they can do it some more. Actually, all the different colors and the like may have come from a common, ancestor.   

To what purpose? I haven't completely nailed that down yet. Just seems like a good idea. 


Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-26, 05:21:49 PMAnd it doesn't make sense to me that they all came back from Europe individually. I'm sure several did all along the east coast, but I suspect that others such as those I mentioned came back a few or maybe one each of the overall type and they got distributed in a specific area. I can't go back to the original origins of tomatoes but I'm starting to think I might be able to go back to what came back from Europe.

You can go two bottlenecks further back if you find old South American landraces. You might also find greater disease resistance that way.


reed

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-26, 05:39:46 PMYou can go two bottlenecks further back if you find old South American landraces. You might also find greater disease resistance that way.

Yea, I know, but including them doesn't seem likely to yield anything much to eat in the short term and there are lots of people who know WAY more about it working on that already. I am going to try crossing to my pimp plants too. Mostly I think it will just be fun to run on faith and see what happens, that's what I generally do anyway. My Mr. Stripy for sure, one I call Hoosier Rose and one from Joseph, I call Utah Heart as well as the pimps, disease or not are all productive in my garden. Maybe they have already made their endophytic deals, and already played their epigenetic musical chairs. Makes sense to me in my real first attempt at tomato breeding to cross them with each other, and to find still more that might want to join the crowd.    
 


 

William Schlegel

#6
Quote from: reed on 2023-11-26, 05:55:45 PMYea, I know, but including them doesn't seem likely to yield anything much to eat in the short term and there are lots of people who know WAY more about it working on that already. I am going to try crossing to my pimp plants too. Mostly I think it will just be fun to run on faith and see what happens, that's what I generally do anyway. My Mr. Stripy for sure, one I call Hoosier Rose and one from Joseph, I call Utah Heart as well as the pimps, disease or not are all productive in my garden. Maybe they have already made their endophytic deals, and already played their epigenetic musical chairs. Makes sense to me in my real first attempt at tomato breeding to cross them with each other, and to find still more that might want to join the crowd.     

Utah Heart x (MMM x Sweet Cherriette)- Probably get some earliness out of these with maybe a slight chance of bicolor or blue.
Utah Heart x (MMR Dwarf)- we can probably pull yellow and red dwarfs out of this, and if we don't want dwarfs, probably just yellows and reds.
Mr. Stripey x (MMM x Purple Zebra F1)- 1/4 chance of late blight resistance, chance of purple flesh, chance of blue skin, good chance of bicolor flesh, chance of stripes.
Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375 pimpinillifolium)- chance of tolerance to that brown rugose fruit virus but only 1/4 ancestry on that.

Just checking my list of 2024 crosses with your old standby varieties Reed. Though these probably won't get really interesting until 2025 when they hit the F2- unless you can get two generations planted in 2024. Though just because there were some heterozygous materials in all four crosses you will see some segregation in the F1.

My next move would probably be to make crosses of the crosses and also cross other lines with those like my MMM x PH5 LB pimpinillfolium cross or my new (Galahad F1) x (MMM x Purple Zebra F1) cross. That PH5 pimpinillifolium did ok for Julia in her long season cool coastal garden. I think I sent you some seed for that cross too which will be in the F2 and this whole size recovery question we have been mulling over will apply to that.

I am not sure that what with me already having roped you into even more pimpinillifolium crosses we need to send you wandering through the tomatoes of South America too, if you'd rather look in Kentucky, Tennessee, and North Carolina for some good heirlooms to cross with. That pimpinillifolium cross that made itself for you probably is doing good things for adaptation. Cross it back to your old stand-byes, maybe grow those new crosses I sent you for a couple generations and look for good ones- with you having more disease problems you (and Julia) might be some of the best testing grounds we have in the U.S. in the group for making sure tomatoes are tough enough to survive for most folks who don't happen to live in the good seed potato and regular potato production areas where tomato and potato diseases are few like me and Joseph. Those of you in Britain and Europe have a great testing ground too but getting a small lot importation permit is too much paperwork for me- and I work for the USDA (though in a very different branch of it than the one responsible for seed importation) so I can't be involved in any funny business.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

I've heard a lot of people say Purple Calabash is super old (again matched tomato pictures from the 1560's) And, as I have mentioned it does have quite a few odd traits that are not super common in other tomatoes, like an integrated purple color (flesh that is a uniform purplish color, rather than being a mixture of zones of pink and green or being pink with a green overlay.) and seeds with short bristly trichomes, as opposed to long silky ones.) 

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-26, 05:55:45 PMYea, I know, but including them doesn't seem likely to yield anything much to eat in the short term and there are lots of people who know WAY more about it working on that already.

It sounds a bit like you're talking about wild green tomatoes. I was referring to the domesticated tomatoes, Solanum lycopersicum, which are perfectly edible as they are and far far bigger than pimpinellifolium from which they were domesticated long before the European invaders arrived. And having not gone through the bottleneck of those domesticated tomatoes that moved through Mesoamerica, there would likely be better chance that you have a wider genetic array to adapt to varied conditions in general, and perhaps more so specifically if your conditions are less like Mesoamerica than they are the various conditions domesticated tomatoes are found growing in South of there.

I wish I could get my hands on some of the larger domesticated tomatoes of Peru, Equador, Bolivia and Chile to trial here for late blight! There might be some with late blight resistance comparable to the pimps being used for that, which if so, would be wonderful to reduce size reduction in crossing and be generally very interesting!

reed

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-27, 03:41:24 AMIt sounds a bit like you're talking about wild green tomatoes. I was referring to the domesticated tomatoes, Solanum lycopersicum, which are perfectly edible as they are and far far bigger than pimpinellifolium from which they were domesticated long before the European invaders arrived. And having not gone through the bottleneck of those domesticated tomatoes that moved through Mesoamerica, there would likely be better chance that you have a wider genetic array to adapt to varied conditions in general, and perhaps more so specifically if your conditions are less like Mesoamerica than they are the various conditions domesticated tomatoes are found growing in South of there.

I wish I could get my hands on some of the larger domesticated tomatoes of Peru, Equador, Bolivia and Chile to trial here for late blight! There might be some with late blight resistance comparable to the pimps being used for that, which if so, would be wonderful to reduce size reduction in crossing and be generally very interesting!

Isn't Solanum lycopersicum the same as, for lack of better phrasing, plain old tomatoes? Oh, maybe you're saying that there are plain old tomatoes whose ancestors never went to Europe in the first place and who's descendants are still around in South America? Now that is interesting and now that I think about it, seems quite likely.

And the part in bold, that's one of the clues that keeps popping up. Is it actually known that lycopersicum came from pimpinellifolium and not from (pimpinellifolium x one of the other wild tomatoes)? If so, then aren't they really pretty much the same thing, evidenced by the fact that they easily crosspollinate? And, if they came only from pimpinellifolium then might not just collecting up a bunch of pimpinellifolium do the trick as far as recovering old genetics?

I guess that doesn't bring in any new resistance from the other species but in my garden the pimpinellifolium are very tolerant of all general conditions including whatever diseases are here, and some of their distant descendants are too. I'm going to try to mix them up with each other and see what comes out.

One thing I'm kind of hoping for along with keeping, and maybe reinforcing general conditions tolerance, including disease, is better production in the big tomatoes. 





William Schlegel

Yep there are plain old tomatoes in South America that never made that trip to Europe. Like that LA0410 I linked to earlier.

I think breeding with pimpinillifolium is just fine. Tomatoes have amazing diversity but that doesn't mean everyone has to work with the green fruited unpalatable species. In my own case I choose to work with both.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-27, 05:32:43 AMIsn't Solanum lycopersicum the same as, for lack of better phrasing, plain old tomatoes?

Yes, the species we eat, which is the only domesticated species of tomato, is S. lycopersicum. Domesticated likely in Peru/Ecuador, and continually grown there and further developed until now, but also spread into Mesoamerica and from there into North America and Europe.

The quote I gave above talked of two forms of S. lycopersicum, I will put them in bold below from the above quote:

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-26, 09:06:25 AMThe cultivated tomato and its wild relatives came from the Peruvian and Ecuadorian regions of South America. According to allozyme variation, Rick and Fobes 1 proposed that SLL [Solanum lycopersicum var. lycopersicum] evolved from S. lycopersicum var. cerasiforme (Dunal) Spooner, G.J. Anderson & R.K. Jansen (SLC). Recently, Blanca et al. 2,3 proposed a two-step domestication process from SLC to SLL based on molecular and morphological evidence. The first step involves the pre-domestication of SLC in the Amazonian region of Southern Ecuador and Northern Peru. Subsequently, SLC would have migrated to Mesoamerica where it would be domesticated to SLL.

That is potentially misleading, however. I think it may be better perhaps to just think of them as one species, which is a domesticated species, and to understand (so I believe anyway) that there are smaller and larger varieties of those domesticated tomatoes that never took the Mesoamerica route. It seems the smaller ones are often referred to as SLC, some of which may be feral domesticated tomatoes which have come to have smaller fruits (apparently this is common with feral species) or may have crossed with pimp. I included the above quote really to show the info on domestication and spread, though I did anticipate it might cause confusion - sorry for not clarifying this earlier.

Here is a quote from TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE), Iris E. Peralta - 2008. After describing the classification of tomatoes into 17 species, we have this:

QuoteWe do not recognize taxa below the species level, most notably the small-fruited tomatoes known to many as "var. cerasiforme." The name "cerasiforme" has been used to refer to putatively wild forms of S. lycopersicum that have been regarded as progenitors of the cultivated tomato. It is impossible to distinguish wild from cultivated forms using herbarium specimens, and we regard many specimens labeled as "var. cerasiforme" to be possible revertants from cultivation (i.e., feral plants) or possible hybrids of wild and weedy taxa.

And elsewhere in the same text:
Quoterecent genetic investigations have shown that the plants known as "cerasiforme" are an admixture of wild and cultivated tomatoes rather than "ancestral" to the cultivars (Nesbitt & Tanksley 2002).

Ths work has an entire section 'DOMESTICATION OF THE CULTIVATED TOMATO'. It goes into a lot of detail. Curiously, I have just noticed it brings into doubt whether European tomatoes even came from Mexico:
QuoteUnless some new document is uncovered that clearly identifies introductions of tomato to Europe from a particular area (see McCue, 1952, for a comprehensive summary of historical references), the origin of tomatoes first introduced into cultivation in Europe will remain unknown.

It goes on to say:
QuoteTomatoes from Europe and North America share similar isozymes with those from Mexico and Central America, suggesting the tomato was introduced to Europe and North America from Mexico or Central America (Rick & Fobes 1975a). Nevertheless, comparisons among genetic variability of primitive tomato cultivars found in Mexico, Central America, and Peru and modern varieties have neither substantiated nor disproved the hypothesis that Mexico was the center of domestication (Rick et al. 1974; Rick & Fobes 1975a; Rick & Holle 1990). Rick and Holle (1990) provided an isozyme study of different accessions of S. lycopersicum from South America, but they did not include cultivars or landraces from Mexico. The only comparative molecular studies (RAPDs and/or nuclear RFLPs) of diversity of landrace cultivars (Williams & St. Clair 1993; Villand et al. 1998) of tomato have not specifically addressed the Peruvian/Mexican domestication hypotheses.

It concludes:
QuoteLike Rick and Holle (1990), we conclude that none of the evidence is conclusive regarding either a Mexican or a Peruvian initial site of domestication, and that tomatoes may have been domesticated independently in both areas, once the tomato had reached Mexico from South America.

So maybe I was premature in claiming the sequence proposed above. But either way my impression at least is that there is more diversity in the old domesticated varieties in and near Peru.

The text gives a lot of historical information. I will quote just a bit of it for the interest of readers here, further historic reports can be found in the text itself.

QuoteFrom Matthioli's description of the tomato (1544) all that is clear is that the earliest described tomato in Europe had yellow fruits and had the Italian name "pomi d'oro." In a later edition of his work, Matthioli (1554) cited both yellow and red fruits, and mentioned both the Italian name for the tomato "pomi d'oro" and its Latin equivalent "mala aurea" or golden apple. Another early common name for tomato is "poma amoris," or "love apples," because during the sixteenth century it was believed that the fruits had aphrodisiacal properties. It could also be that "poma amoris" is a corruption of "pomi d'oro." All these names persisted well into the nineteenth century (Moore 1935).

Georg Oelinger, a pharmacist in the German city of Nuremberg, was an avid plant collector in the mid-sixteenth century (Lutze & Retzlaff 1949). He cultivated tomatoes in his garden, probably as a curiosity or for their medicinal value. An edition of unpublished paintings from Oelinger's herbarium (Lutze & Retzlaff 1949) contains a drawing of a tomato plant with both red and yellow fruits; the flowers are mixed 5- and 6-parted and all the fruits are deeply furrowed (fasciated). It is clear from early illustrations that the flowers of tomatoes grown in sixteenth and seventeenth century Europe had duplications of sepals and petals (6–7-parted), and exserted styles. Dodoens (1554, 1563) listed the Latin ("Mala Aurea"), German ("Goldtapfel"), Flemish ("Guldapel") and French ("Pome d'amour") names for the fruit along with an illustration of the entire plant (see Fig. 1), but did not mention uses. His later publications (Dodoens 1574, 1583) illustrated round fruits with furrows, flowers with 7–8 petals, and two of the flowers with exserted styles. The illustrations in L'Obel (1576) and Tabernaemontanus (1591) were similar to those of Dodoens (1554, 1563). Gesner (1561) mentioned that the tomato was easily grown in Germany, matured early, and had fruits varying in color from gold, red, and white, and in shape from round to lumpy. It is also clear from the Fuchs description and illustration in the 'Vienna Codex' (frontispiece; Meyer et al. 1999) that by the second half of the sixteenth century tomato plants yielding red, orange, yellow, and white fruits were cultivated, which varied in shape from small and spherical to highly fasciated and lobed.

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-27, 05:32:43 AMAnd the part in bold, that's one of the clues that keeps popping up. Is it actually known that lycopersicum came from pimpinellifolium and not from (pimpinellifolium x one of the other wild tomatoes)?

I can't remember a specific paper stating that explicitly, though I would not be surprised if there are such explicit statements. I at least assume lyc evolved from pimp through domestication. I have pondered myself whether lyc or even Galapagos species might have come about through wide crosses, specifically because of the lyc x chmielewskii crosses I am growing out now, which taste really quite nice even in F1, and have lovely orange colour, not bright like galapagense but still orange, or one might say yellow even, between the two perhaps. So with the yellows and oranges there in those early reports of lycopersicum, that did make me wonder. However, the DNA analyses seem to show lyc being derived from pimp, whereas if they resulted from pimp x chm, I should think we would see lyc having a closer relation with chm than pimp has with chm in those analyses, which we do not see. Rather we seem to see the opposite, hence presumably lyc evolved from pimp.

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-27, 05:32:43 AMIf so, then aren't they really pretty much the same thing, evidenced by the fact that they easily crosspollinate?

I would say no. It depends on what you mean by 'thing' - I could say pimp and carrots are 'the same thing' if the 'thing' I am talking about is 'food', but if we are talking about species, then no. Heavy metal has Delta blues as an ancestor, and one could make fusion music combining both genres. That doesn't make Delta blues 'the same thing' as heavy metal in terms of genre. In general, species evolve. Knowing that one species evolved from another, or that 2 evolved from a common ancestor, doesn't mean they are the same thing. It just informs us of their history. And the ability to cross, is just one trait of many. There are many cases of different species being able to cross. Sometimes members of different genera can cross! The species concept is more subtle than merely being able to cross or not. In fact there are even populations within the same tomato species which cannot cross with each other - I forget which but perhaps habrochaites and pennellii might be such examples? And we recently had a discussion here about Solanum galapagense, which is another species clearly very different from lyc or pimp, having evolved in very different conditions for... perhaps a million years, I'm not sure how long... but can cross easily with lyc and pimp.

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-27, 05:32:43 AMAnd, if they came only from pimpinellifolium then might not just collecting up a bunch of pimpinellifolium do the trick as far as recovering old genetics?

My main interest in pimp and pre-Columbian lyc is disease resistance, and my primary disease pressure is late blight. So why I am personally interested in those pre-Columbian lyc varieties is the potential for getting the late blight resistance offered by some pimp accessions, whilst not having such a dramatic fruit size decrease as we get crossing with pimp. A secondary reason is that there might be other traits which could also be favourable, such as interesting tastes or better growth habit, for example. I.e., not just useful 'wild' genetics but also useful domesticated genetics from the long hard work of the many generations of South American farmers.

Although, since we have already identified specific pimp accessions with strong late blight resistance, the main benefits can be derived from those and maybe a bit more time or backcrossing to get size increase, could cover most of the bases I'm talking about. However, once late blight overcomes the PH-2, PH-3, and PH-5 resistances, this idea of searching for resistance in these old landraces might look even more appealing. Also, I would guess that for horizontal resistance to various diseases, the less backcrossing we have to do to recover fruit size, the better. Which may be an added reason to look towards those old landraces rather than rely too much on pimp.





William Schlegel

I would just put in a plug for the body of work you have already done Justin. You've developed some amazing wild crosses! Don't be daunted by size recovery on those!

It might be neat to make a cross with one or two old South American landraces but to sift through large numbers of them looking for new PH genes- that should be work for a PHd candidate!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-27, 04:40:00 PMI would just put in a plug for the body of work you have already done Justin. You've developed some amazing wild crosses!

Oh thanks William! As it happens I just set some more seeds to germinate, with my arc cross as mother, I just processed seeds of a fruit with mixed per/chil pollen. The seeds look not so good so I put all to germinate now. Of the ones I did before, only 1 germinated and the leaves rotted very quickly within the seed coat. So I'm trying these the same day as harvesting, to maximise their chances like you advised. This time I also know for sure no arc pollen in the mix, made very sure.

Using another arc cross as pollen donor, I pollinated it with a che x lyc. The arc cross sibling crossed fruits are giving some seeds that look good (though no hairs, otherwise look like domestic seeds) so I figure I can save most of them for next year outside. But the arc crosses as pollen donor give seeds that look like them might not last, so, also trying to germinate some of those fresh. The arc cross has a bit more on the lyc side of it so these will be 5 species hybrid. And for fun, I'm germinating just a few seeds of another cross harvested today which is [lyc x gal] x [che x chm] - again the lyc has a bit more in it so these will be 6 species hybrids. If they germinate!

In one more cycle, if the per crosses come through I could potentially get some 9 species hybrids. Wiser to select more before doing such crosses to get flavour and size but could be fun to try some if I get the chance  :)

I think I need to design a new Kratky system to make the work easier! If anyone has any good ideas for one long system (for a single row of plants to give access to each flower) that still keep the space for each plant's roots small to force early flowering, I'm listening!

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-27, 04:40:00 PMIt might be neat to make a cross with one or two old South American landraces but to sift through large numbers of them looking for new PH genes- that should be work for a PHd candidate!

I would think if someone in a heavy late blight area could get hold of a good selection of such landraces, just planting a couple of each should tell us a lot about potential resistance by next Autumn! Even better, if a few people did it in different regions or countries, to cover different LB variants - even without knowing that the variants are or having fancy tools, that could be an awesome way to quickly learn which accessions are valuable in this respect. Hmm... I wonder, if we did have several people spread out willing to do it, a genebank might be very willing to share one pack of seeds of each, to someone to coordinate the project sharing out the seeds, and be promised to get the results of the test, which the coordinator to collate. 

Of course another way would be to deliberately infect the seedlings, though I doubt many people outside of universities/corporations have a stash of diverse spores.

William Schlegel

I think there is a lot of cool research like that someone based out of a university or gene bank willing to coordinate some citizen science could accomplish with a group of dedicated amateur citizen scientists.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days