Advice for selection procedure for F1 x F1 crosses

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-09-25, 05:37:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I'd love to hear advice and experiences regarding selection when growing out double crosses. I am growing out various F1 crosses I have made, and am crossing some of these together whilst also crossing some F1s to some stable and/or relatively varieties. For example... and I will abbreviate tomato species names:

  • [pimp x chm F1] x [pimp x pen F1]
  • [pimp x chm F1] x gal
  • [domestic x chm F1] x [domestic x gal F1]
  • [(domestic with some wild mixed in, already tasty tomato) x arc F1] x gal
  • [(domestic with some wild mixed in, already tasty tomato) x gal F1] x domestic

And so on.

Taking a simple example, [domestic x gal F1] x domestic, how would you approach this? If we just grow out the domestic x gal F2, I would expect perhaps all to be tasty, but perhaps select mostly for size. So for [domestic x gal F1] x domestic, would we similarly select their immediate offspring (can we still call that F?) for size?

My concern is that this generation will already be diverse, but we are 1 step away from unlocking the next step of diversity from the male parent.

So I'm wondering if there are any special tips for the F1 selection when one, or both parents, are themselves F1? And anything we should particularly avoid doing? This relates to various traits.

This relates to what you were saying William:
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-09-23, 06:43:00 AMFrom my own experiences working with Joseph's crosses and now my own. We got the first elites when Joseph brought the percentage down to 25%.

For the arc crosses, on the  hand I'm trying to establish an SI population through crossing the various crosses I have made. And on the other hand (at the moment separately), I am trying to directly cross them to edibles such as late blight resistant domestics, and to gal and che. My thinking was to gain more access to edibility through going quickly to 25%. And I was considering mainly selecting the direct offspring, 25% arc, by taste (and/or size). But I was thinking perhaps there could be many tasty ones missed this way that might appear one generation later. I don't mind doing that if this way would be overall more efficient, but thought consulting those with experience would be a way to avoid excessive foolishness on my part.

You also mentioned this in that same other thread so I thought to address it here:
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-09-23, 06:43:00 AMLee writes about fruits that drop on their own on at least one of his varieties. That is distinctly a wild species trait.

If I remember, that's Wild Child? I don't have that one but I did think about this in relation to that - crossing it with cheesmaniae LA0166. I am actually crossing some chm and arc crosses to that, specifically because of the jointless trait it has. I thought that could be a neat quick fix to that issue, as well as being curious about the taste of che hybrids. I would guess 1/4 of the F2 should be jointless, right? I'm actually curious what people here think of the jointless trait - I know it has been employed in industry and that's probably irrelevant for most of us here since I expect there is little interest here in mechanical harvesting? But I thought for wild crosses it might be more interesting.



William Schlegel

I think with such complex crosses there will be a lot of segregation so your new F1 will segregate a lot.

I've been doing some similar rapid crossing this year and expect a lot of segregation in the F1s but not so many species.

I expect I need to pause and let things segregate on mine if I am to recover favorite traits.

Simular to your simple example. I found two domestic x galapagense crosses amongst my galapagense seedlings last year. I crossed those to my MMM F2. The new F1 segregated orange and red. I had a strong preference for saving seed from the orange. Also it was not very wild like anymore at 25%

I also made more crosses with it taking the galapagense down to 12.5% and I bet a lot of them are with the red which may disappoint me next year.

These do become interesting puzzles!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days