Tasty Anthocyanin Breeding

Started by Garrett Schantz, 2023-08-28, 11:57:33 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Garrett Schantz

I haven't seen many Anthocyanin breeding topics or general ones.

I saw a topic from around 2021 that mentioned something like this.

Taste is also subjective.


Blue Beauty, Black Beauty and Midnight Tiger are obviously upwards on a list of tomatoes with a lot of Anthocyanin.


But, I frankly dislike red tomatoes.

Orange ones are OK. Depends on the orange tomato.


Wild relatives also produce flavanoids not found in domestic tomatoes.


So, there's some potential that blue tomatoes already have some good bases to start out with.



One of the better tasting Tomatoes I've had, was White Beauty.

White Currant was OK. Edible.

But, I've had good luck with decent tasting tomatoes with white ones, versus others.



White Beauty is somewhat of a whiteish yellow, a slight yellow.

I'd been wanting to cross it with Black Beauty or Midnight Tiger.

Midnight Tiger is something of a bicolor. Black Beauty has a nice bit of Anthocyanin and multiple Antho traits.


Recently, I've heard of a relatively newer White Tomato, with a decent amount of anthocyanin.

Sart Roloise. Which also seems to have the same fruity tastes as White Wonder and White Beauty.



Now, there's also Mission Mountain Sunrise.

I can't tell if that's still a grex with multiple colors or not.


Either way. Potentially different antho genes are in that tomato, about the same amount of potential coverage of antho.


I'd prefer to cross a yellow antho tomato with an exserted trait into Sart Roloise, and work into a antho tomato with an exserted trait and wild genes.


Then I'd cross in Black Beauty for a fuller anthocyanin color.


Or, I'd try a few others first.


There's White Currant and Blue Cream Berries. White Currant may be more translucent than Blue Cream Berries.


Onto the point. Translucent skins.

I don't know if the skin is thinner or what. But, I can see the seeds inside of White Currant. It has flesh, not too super watery either.


Anthocyanin in tomatoes, depends on sunlight hitting the fruit.

Open canopy or exposed fruits would be important here. Not everyone selects for that when breeding for anthocyanin.


Blue Cream Berries can have the inside of its tomatoes have some purple splotches on the inside.



My theory, is that it's able to have the inside of the tomato hit by sunlight. The outside also gets hit, which that then means you only end up with splotches because a blue pigment shows up and may block sunlight, possibly.



White Currant is very waxy / glossy or smooth. White Beauty has some fuzz and it's a different sort of white.



So, I've also been thinking a bit more.


Exserted Tiger is a bicolor.

And it has something of a blue tint.

I could cross that with Blue Cream Berries or White Currant.


The Exserted trait would be helpful here.

Crossing offspring back and forth, or whatnot.


Or once I get into crossing different lines in this project, they'll be exserted - as will their progeny.



Once I have an Exserted white antho tomato, I could then cross it with an exserted little white tomato with anthocyanin.

Saves me time, selecting for blue traits over and over, plus selecting for the exserted trait again.



I'm unsure if or how a bicolor trait would work in these sort of white tomatoes, whether they'd show up in any capacity.


Exserted Tiger. Amurskij Tigr is a parent.

William bred Exserted Tiger.


The mentioned parent has some sort of striping.

There are other striped tomatoes out there. I believe that there are some anthocyanin ones as well.

The gene that gives these guys any form of striping, seems to be somewhat different than others.


The typical striping, does usually bypass anthocyanin. So you can have antho tomatoes with stripes.



Now, breeding a white tomato with striping. That probably doesn't work too well.


But, anthocyanin shows up over top of some other pigments and things.


So, a white tomato with anthocyanin could have striping.


If you were to mix this with a translucent tomato, you'd potentially have an Anthocyanin translucent tomato with striping

Hypothetically, this would prevent certain areas from being marked with anthocyanin, but also potentially let anthocyanin creep into the center of the fruit.



Plus the whole thing with fruity flavors.


I've mentioned elsewhere that Solanum nigrum or retroflexum crosses would be very nice interspecific hybrids.


That would be a stretch project.



I haven't seen anyone else mention my idea or whatnot.


I'm also unsure if the translucent trait works well in larger tomatoes.

I think I remember seeing a translucent cherry tomato before.



This would take awhile to create and stabilize, I'd imagine.


I'd also like to try and mix in Purple Smudge.


I've seen it mentioned elsewhere, I've asked some breeders about it a few times.


The first time, I was told that someone had looked into it before and that it was developed with conventional methods and lacked wild genes, an older tomato.


The second time, I asked elsewhere - this year.


Got a response of it having the Aft gene.



Oregon State University, claims that the variety in particular doesn't contain Aft or related genes found in other Purple tomatoes. Genes from S. galapagense, S. chilensis, S. cheesemanii and some other tomatoes were mentioned to be present in Indigo Rose.

But they mentioned Purple Smudge multiple times.

And they mentioned that it has its Purple gene, from Solanum peruvianum.



That's helped me out a bit. The tomato was bred quite some time ago. It was donated to the USDA years after being bred. Years after that, it made its way to the seed savers exchange - it barely has any anthocyanin and because of that, it seems to have just sat there.


It has Purple splotches.



I looked around for the Purple gene found in Solanum peruvianum. I haven't exactly found a ton.

I mostly found that Solanum peruvianum can produce anthocyanin, from excess stress or drought - unlike other anthocyanin sorts of tomatoes.

Other factors can also make the tomatoes produce anthocyanin. Different biosynthesizers or something cause that to happen.



I found a few different sources which claimed that unlike other species, it doesn't have Aft on different chromosomes. It has "novel, unidentified genes."

That's also very cool.


I found these as kind of on the side sort of mentions. Not as main research mentions or whatever.


This doesn't mean that it necessarily won't be related to Aft or mix in with it in any way, or cause fatalities.


Another source mentioned something about there being unidentified supplementary anthocyanin genes in S. peruvianum.



I didn't jot the sources down. Pretty smart of me.



So. Purple Smudge may have an unused anthocyanin gene. I dunno.

I've asked some people, who have simply done color comparisons and said they already had better tomatoes and didn't bother breeding with it or said I could find something better to breed with.


I wasn't meaning to be rude to anyone with the questions and things.


I also found multiple sources which confirmed that Purple Smudge has Solanum peruvianum bred into it as a parent. It's also still considered to be highly disease resistant.


To me, a tomato sent to the USDA in 1963, then sent to the seed savers exchange in 1984 still being considered highly disease resistant and not being a hybrid.

That says a lot about the tomato itself.

The Purple gene and the high disease resistance implies that there were some backcrosses and the breeder selected for other fun traits.

Payette and some others like Double Rich aren't as disease resistant as they originally were.


Burnley Bounty is a late flowering tomato. As in, daylight sensitive. It flowers later in the year.

Today's standards, genes are tested in labs for the progeny - or kept as unstable hybrids.

Most backcrosses are to domestic tomatoes.


It's very likely that disease resistances are based on more than just single genes, and that this practice isn't so good.


In the past people would breed with a disease resistant relative, over and over until they felt that it was enough.


For some older Peruvianum crosses, this means that a ton of genes made their way over.


I may or may not grow double rich again.

I will grow Burnley Bounty and Purple Smudge again next year.


I'll likely cross them over and over again, to Burnley Bounty and Purple Smudge.


I may use Mission Mountain Sunrise as the other base.


I haven't found mention of this here, but I did try using Purple Smudge as a mother before. This was before Purple tomatoes had been widely circulated to general websites.

Tom Wagner had some varieties for sale, you could find some sites selling some as well.

Indigo Rose was shared around a bit, and people bred with it. I found names for it under number labels and things.



So, I found Purple Smudge.

I think this was in 2016 or 2017.

Before I joined this forum.


I kept emasculating the flowers but no crosses were taking.

I used white currant as a mother in some crosses, and Reisetomate.

That was just to see if I could do it.


I ended up harvesting two fruits from Purple Smudge, the others ended up as emasculation tests.

Nobody wanted to eat the things. The whole odd orange and purple color or something.

But yeah. The crosses didn't take.

Those were just experiments anyway. I don't like tomatoes but I'd heard that some of them taste nice.



Looking back, its possible that it was rejecting pollen from other plants.

This may still be able to pollinate other plants.

Or maybe I was just unlucky that year.


Either way. I probably do need to get Purple Smudge as a mother and father in these sorts of crosses.

Same goes with Burnley Bounty.

I've looked back and remembered that interspecific crosses can sometimes only carry genes from mothers or fathers.



But yeah. I want to try getting some Peruvianum up in these.


Whether for disease resistance or otherwise.

I dunno if this belongs as a thread, or if it should be moved somewhere.


Figured I'd mention it though.




















AndrewB

Some interesting ideas there. Many of them similar to Williams ideas. Sounds like some good ideas for some to try.

I will say this:

Some are thinking now that anthocyanins themselves may provide some disease resistance. So it may make sense that antho tomato lines may be disease resistant all on their own without other disease resistance genes. Can't remember where I read that though. But I found it an interesting idea.

Maf

It seems like the strongest antho expression comes with the combination of the dominant gene Aft (introgressed from S. chilense) and the recessive gene atv (atroviolacea, derived from the interspecific cross with S. cheesmaniae). The combo of the two genes produces a synergistic effect, see this paper: Transcriptional analysis in high-anthocyanin tomatoes reveals synergistic effect of Aft and atv genes. There may also be other unidentified modifiers that affect the level of antho expression.

An interesting read (if you have not seen it before) is Frogsleap Farm's blog post Breeding for the Blue Tomato. It is from over 10 years ago but still very interesting. A couple of points he brings up worth mentioning are that the initial genetic material available was not the best tasting, so there may be some merit in crossing and subsequently backcrossing or re-crossing, or, in these days when there are more antho tomatoes available, work with something more removed from the initial OSU lines. Also, that the anthocyanin accumulates preferentially in stripes of both gs and fs striped tomatoes.

On a similar line which I don't think was mentioned in the blog is that dark green shouldered types preferentially accumulate the antho in the shoulders, see the pic below and look at the yellow line which has the dark shoulders in background. If you observe the antho patterns it is clear thet the highest antho expression is not simply following sun exposure in the yellow line, but is strongly affected by the geometry of the dark shoulders.
IMG_20230828_202207.jpg

Garrett Schantz

Yeah, William usually has good ideas.

I may be trying some of this.

Probably will be.


With the green shouldering stuff, the antho focusing on those markings, is interesting.


I think antho tomatoes are pretty great.


They have a large issue of not accumulating any anthocyanin in the innermost parts of themselves. There's not much anthocyanin in these tomatoes due to this.


Pepinos are also of interest:

https://www.etsy.com/listing/1534071470/8-cuttings-of-pepino-melon-pepino-dulce?click_key=6f75e010644bae2d03b4b353243021c316c50c67%3A1534071470&click_sum=ee811487&ref=shop_home_active_5&frs=1


https://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-016-2656-8


The Etsy link leads to a seller who is offering some Pepino cuttings.

4 Purple pepinos and 4 non purple cuttings.


These are in a grouping that includes Tomatoes and Potatoes.


Believe I've mentioned them already elsewhere on the wild relatives of tomatoes breeding sorta topic.


Believe I mentioned that it has some of the exact same lines of genetic coding, or very similar code to S. lycopersicoides but on different chromosomes.



In short. A close relative of tomatoes.


It could have the same or similar anthocyanin traits as tomatoes.


I am planning on growing them, near interspecific hybrids and the like.



Pepino mosaic virus resistances may be nice, as well as other traits.

Like the flowers with striping.


I haven't heard of any natural crosses out in nature with Pepinos either.



But, I will mention that there are anthocyanin containing pepinos.


They're also very difficult to find here in the United States. And they take longer than Kendall Gold to produce ripe fruit.


Most Pepinos are clones or landraces.


I don't believe they're purple on the insides.



I've also read that Lycianthes may be semi related to tomatoes and potatoes but to a lesser extent.

Lycianthes moziniana exists, it's green. Lycianthes acapulcensis though is smurf blue, and pink colored on the inside. I don't know if the blue color is anthocyanin though.

These may be related to Capsicum to an extent.



Jaltomata also has blue / anthocyanin fruits on the inside.


I've been trying to label a few relatives with blue / antho traits.

Preferably something with larger flowers than Solanum nigrum.


I feel like the GMO tomatoes are going to screw over a lot of antho tomato breeding. We can't currently get the antho affect all throughout the tomatoes.

And GMO ones aren't splotchy or variable with their anthocyanin content. Nor do they require sun exposure to high extents. Plus they contain more of it everywhere.


I'm in a better position to grow things than before.





Garrett Schantz

Anthocyanin may still show up on some of the mentioned tomatoes with striping to them.

But, nonetheless. They do show lesser types of anthocyanin and it shows up at different levels.

In typical tomatoes, tomatoes are green, and then they slowly turn to whatever color.

If a fruit is translucent or maybe another color like how Solanum habrochaites can have a ton of green shouldering, but be white underneath from the very start.

Then maybe some things could change.




I did find one tomato that I marked as something that I'd like to use as breeding material.




Rebel Starfighter Prime. It's an interesting name. The fruits can vary from beefsteak to oval shaped on the same plant.

I think in terms of appearance, you'd be able to just sell these at a higher price than standard tomatoes.



Ideally with breeding, I'll find things that already have multiple traits that I want.

Interesting fruit shapes, decent sized fruit, striping.




I could probably do a straight cross over to Sart Roloise, and easily have multiple lines which are similar right from the start.


The biggest pain, may be stabilizing the fruity and good tastes again.




I found another translucent tomato like White Currant - which is Wild Gem. I think I've grown it before, White Currant is more see-through due to an odd white color that it has.



I would also like to cross either Muchacha! or Sugar Drop Cherry from J&L Gardens into this sort of line. Sugar Drop Cherry supposedly has sweetly scented foliage which seems cool. The small amount of seeds in the fruit, isn't something that sounds too good.


If you have an attractive anthocyanin tomato with striping, white flesh on the inside, tastes tropical and is disease resistant - and is pretty sweet, sweeter than pretty much any other tomatoes out there.


Then, people may be more interested in that tomato regardless of whether or not it's fully purple inside.


And others may use it as breeding material.


If anyone has any ideas for anthocyanin tomatoes, tasty varieties or things with unique traits.

That may be appreciated.



William Schlegel

Two of my favorites for tasty anthocyanin breeding are Tom Wagner's Muddy Waters and Brad Gate's Amethyst Cream. I wasn't as impressed by the flavor of Brad's Atomic Grape but it is a real powerhouse when it comes to traits as it is striped, green when ripe / tricolor, and has the anthocyanin skin. I've now made some crosses with the lot of those three and am very excited to see them segregate.

My own Mission Mountain Sunrise is remarkably stable even at the F4 I shared. It has a variable appearance because of individual fruit variation mostly it has red skin which is odd for a bicolor. The anthocyanin is the least stable bit at F4. I have saved seed for the F7 this year. The crosses I have made with other Anthocyanin varieties with it and Mission Mountain Morning have some good promise. I would not recommend it for flavor though it seems as good as many other bicolor like Big Hill and Blue Gold. You can however find better flavored bicolor tomatoes like Dwarf Gloria's Treat. Though it may be good for a short season variety- if you need short season for which there are few non-red options.

Exserted Tiger is not a bicolor (a flesh trait), just a simple red, and the anthocyanin seems weak and not very stable. Very hopeful for the new crosses I made with it this year though. If you did find a bicolor out of it congratulations you've found some kind of recent cross segregate. I wouldn't recommend it particularly for flavor. Its ok, I guess. The purpose of the release was to share with other breeders the exsertion with the stripes. I was always disappointed that I didn't find a yellow segregate with the stripes and the exsertion to the same degree. New chances await in the new crosses I guess!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

I'll try posting some fruits of the one Exserted Tiger plant that I have.


Just recently checked the page after your reply and noticed that they aren't all red and don't all have the markings on them.


Unfortunately there have been issues with very high temperatures here.


I'll still be getting some fruit off the one plant again, saving seed.



I was actually looking at Muddy Waters yesterday. Rebel Starfighter Prime though, has nicely sized fruits and other nice traits.


Muddy Waters is one of the most attractive tomatoes I've seen. Plus it has the whole green when ripe trait.

I didn't mention it here, since I'm probably going with Rebel Starfighter Prime.

It has an irregular fruit gene, can't quite remember the name. But you'll end up with pear shaped fruit and beefsteaks on the same plant.


Tom Wagner has a lot of nice material out there.



I'm still on the lookout for anything with new flavors.




I tried some other things recently for multiple reasons. Get a few things that I haven't tasted before.

I was having some pest problems of a certain kind in the garden.


Someone recommended that I mash up some stuff to get rid of pests, take care of them.


I gathered some Magnolia buds and leaves and Gardenia flowers and leaves.


I will say that some pests in the garden, don't really go when you want them to.



So, I scrunched those up and chewed them for a bit.


Yeah, chewed.

It works better for some stuff.


And the stuff isn't toxic.


Well, unless you eat it.


I needed stuff as a semi paste, and to stick together and be shredded.


I also don't want anything like that in a blender or whatever.


After about 20 seconds I got the whole mouthful of saponins flavor.



Some relatives have mentioned doing it before with small batches of stuff that takes care of certain stuff.



There's also Pokeweed, that had an intense sweet flavor, followed by intense bitterness an unpleasantness. Again, spit and rinse.


It won't kill me by chewing on some berries.


There's also some Solanum carolinense here, which I've considered tasting. I was staring at for a bit. The berries are considered toxic but they can be used medicinally. A few berries will send you to the bathroom for a few hours like some Melothria species can.

Didn't see the pest messing with those things, but you could tell it was there due to this and that.

Can't have things killing my tomato plants though.

What I mixed up should deter certain types of pests.



There are toxic things I won't try such as mushrooms and certain berries or things.



Trying to expand my palate a bit.

There have been wolf spiders dead all over the property since then. Plus the tomatoes are recovering.

So those species helped out a lot. Granted I'd prefer not to have actual spiders drop. Just pests and arthropods that decide to harm the crops for no actual reason.





Regardless, I'll also likely be growing out some more wild tomatoes again and looking for fun flavors or anything unique.


I feel like crossing uniquely flavored things into tomatoes with tropical flavors and things will result in less breeding work down the road. Stabilizing flavors is a big thing.

In the Promiscuous populations you need to stabilize some possibly self incompatible or widely hybridized offspring and things.



The main flavor that I got from the mentioned leaves and things was Saponins. Tasted fine till the 20 second mark. Which to me, means that it's chewed up enough.


I should probably buy or make something just for making mixtures.



Justin Jardinier

Has anyone worked with cheesmaniae LA0429? The leaves and stems go totally purple, really quite dark. It seems only the young leaves and stems, and the sepals, are green. The fruits are yellow-orange.

I'm interested in doing the combination of this antho trait with peruvianum and/or chilense, as in the paper about it. But I'm not sure if this is the same gene as the cheesmaniae used in the paper. Plus, the commercially available antho domestic tomatoes don't have purple leaves, do they?

I'm most interested if anyone knows of benefits or drawbacks of having purple leaves. I did notice that the only mustard leaf variety of mine that is still going strong is one with purpled leaves, and I thought maybe that was connected to the slugs eating all the others but not this one. That might not be relevant to tomatoes, but anyway I am curious about this leaf antho trait from cheesmaniae.

William Schlegel

Three new antho dwarfs are available from the dwarf tomato project and Patrina on Victory Seeds. Too long season for me.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-27, 08:40:11 AMThree new antho dwarfs are available from the dwarf tomato project and Patrina on Victory Seeds. Too long season for me.
Nice! William, how do peruvianums fair for you in terms of earliness? I ask because of the potential of making new antho dwarfs using per. antho, with or without combining it with Galapagos antho. As opposed to using already existing antho in late domestic tomatoes.

William Schlegel

#10
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-12-27, 09:10:33 AMNice! William, how do peruvianums fair for you in terms of earliness? I ask because of the potential of making new antho dwarfs using per. antho, with or without combining it with Galapagos antho. As opposed to using already existing antho in late domestic tomatoes.

The Solanum peruvianum strains I got from Joseph in 2017 were able to volunteer in my garden for multiple years before dying out. I thought them R selected and adapted to be a field weed like current tomatoes. I had a few 2023 volunteers from my 2022 grow outs but apparently they were SI so didn't set seed in 2023. Solanum arcanum is a similarly capable wild tomato that might be a little easier to cross with. Though it sounds like you've had success with both! Also even Solanum habrochaites LA2329 has anthocyanin fruit skin. So some different anthocyanin possibilities might come up in the future.

Far easier though to work with existing antho lines for most breeders who havent caught on to the joy of breeding with unpalatable wild tomatoes! I say they are tomatoes only a botanist could love. That must make you a fellow botanist Justin! Botany is traditionally an open field so that is quite possible, though this might be more horticulture. I'd definitely say Rick straddled the line and was both a botanist and horticulturist and that wild tomato breeding and research in general does straddle the line between disciplines.

All these three new ones from Patrina lack is shortness of season being in the 80 day from transplant range. Personally I already have a cross made with Dwarf Mocha's Cherry and I think I'll get some shorter season antho dwarfs segregating from it this year. Crosses made with Patrina's newly released varieties though would save a breeder considerable time stabilizing both dwarf and antho traits if crossed with other antho varieties.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

I also had success growing peruvianum outside. I have wondered before about possible relationships between earliness and fruit size, so I still wonder about whether their 'earliness power' might be eclipsed by fruit size increase, if size works against earliness, i.e. whether bringing per into domestic populations might result in overall increase in lateness for the hybrids. But I did at least make efforts to choose specifically (relatively) early per. accessions (and chilense). I guess I will see how it goes. I'll be working to combine them also with some gal. and che. that have either antho in stems and leaves, or in fruits (some only speckles, one quite extensive antho in fruit). Che. and gal. are short day but the F1 hybrids are not, if the or some of the F2 are not short day, I don't know how early or late they might be, but anyway I guess I will see whether or not I can end up with early enough antho tomatoes.