Two-colors varietys have the gene BETA?

Started by Adrian, 2023-08-22, 01:25:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Adrian

I grow this year pineaple and orange russian 117.
Someone know if theses two varietys can have the gene BETA (BB) or its just a mutation of yellow flesh (rr)?
A parent of Or117 is Georgia Streak.

Maf

I would guess it is a double mutation of ry (reddish yellow) which is an allele of r, and t (tangerine). I don't think Beta is involved because rr yellow defeats it and plants that are rrBB are pure yellow, no orange. For ryryBB I would guess the red parts might turn orange but the yellow parts would stay light yellow. t has a better interaction with yellow which seems more like what I am seeing in the photo's of Orange Russian 117 and Georgia Streak, graduations of different tones of orange depending if the background flesh colour is yellow or red.

An easy way to check for t (tangerine) is to look at the flowers. Anther cones will be orange rather than yellow.

Steph S

I agree it is probably not Beta.  As far as I know, Beta is only functional in a red RR background.

Many of the ryry fruits seem to be more of an orange flesh than yellow.  This is possibly a dispersed level of lycopene and not an additional orange gene like tt or B.
At least, in the cross I've been working on with an orange fleshed bicolor, so far I haven't seen any segregation to suggest tangerine or Beta plays a role.

Adrian

#3
Probably
This fruit is a cross roman candle w (canestrino di lucca x andine cornue)


Maf

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-08-23, 05:50:54 PMI agree it is probably not Beta.  As far as I know, Beta is only functional in a red RR background.

That is not quite true, Beta is funtional in RR, Rr, rR, and is only defeated in full rr. In the heterozygous (red dominant) condition the lycopene pathway is still functional and therefore Beta can do its job of converting lycopone to beta carotene.

Quote from: Steph S on 2023-08-23, 05:50:54 PMMany of the ryry fruits seem to be more of an orange flesh than yellow.  This is possibly a dispersed level of lycopene and not an additional orange gene like tt or B.
At least, in the cross I've been working on with an orange fleshed bicolour, so far I haven't seen any segregation to suggest tangerine or Beta plays a role.
This is probably true, I haven't worked with enough bicolor ry varieties to be sure. However, I have grown ones that seemed much more yellow in the base colour (and green if gf is present) than Orange Russian 117 and Pineapple which makes me wonder if there is something additional in play in those varieties?.

Steph S

Yes, well given that Beta is functional with one or more R allele, and is also semi-functional with a single Beta allele, I am thinking about what I would expect to see in the segregating F2, where one parent was RR and bb, and one parent ryry, of unknown Beta status (both stable OP's).
If Beta is present BB in the ryry parent, you would expect to see some orange in the R/ry, and you would expect expression of Beta in some degree in F2s that are RRB/- RryB/- RryBB and of course full orange in RRBB, that is, all the non-ry fruit as well as the parent type.
So in that case, you are really expecting a lot of Beta to show up in your F2, to some degree.  Only 1/4 of your plants (expected) the bb condition with no Beta to express.
I think that is true even in case of gf being present, Beta changes flesh color to a muddy brown whereas the ryry condition observed in the F2 has green flesh with a red splash.  I grew 10 plants in that F2, one ryry fruit with orange flesh like the parent, one gf ry plant with green/red, and a majority of red and pink fruited plants that didn't show any evidence of Beta being present.
So although my experience with ry is limited to that one fairly recent cross, it doesn't lead me to believe that Beta plays a part in the more orangey bicolors.  On the basis of those results, I would say the effect is not due to Beta.  (I am familiar with Beta in R and gf backgrounds).

I agree @Maf about something else going on to create a range of colors in the bicolor, which hasn't been explained in any papers that I've read.

Based on observations I believe there are either multiple alleles or modifiers of r yellow giving different shades, and the same is apparent in ry, that different alleles or presence of modifiers affects the color pretty dramatically in yellow vs orangey bicolors.   The extent of the red expression is also quite varied, but would be hard to quantify since it also varies from fruit to fruit.. Maybe there are simply QTLs for pigment production that make the orangey bicolor with high intensity of the yellow pigment?  IDK, speculating.

So I don't know of a confirmed explanation for the different shades of ry. Also I haven't crossed with Beta or observed results of a Beta/ry cross.   We had quite a long discussion about ry inheritance, with links to other discussions in there as well, and pretty much concluded that we need to set up some crosses and see how they turn out.
https://www.tomatojunction.com/viewtopic.php?t=2025



Adrian

#6
Two cross was tried with orange russian 117 this year.
Or 117 x green zebra
And
Or 117 x ((roman candle) x (canestrino
di lucca x andine cornue))

Unfortunately the fruits are very long to started to get fat.
I think that its better to fecondated many flowers.

Adrian

#7
Flowers are not fall but fruits don't get fat 2 months after the croce. The fruit can get fat many months after the fecondation?
No fruit crossed has get fat this year but all the flowers stay on the plant even many months later.
Some fruits seem get fat very slowly.

Some options for the next season:
Crossed or 117 with a F2 of (canestrino di lucca x andine cornue) x roman candle
Or
Crossed or 117 with a orange tomato with BETA or tangerine.