Newfoundland tomato projects 2023

Started by Steph S, 2023-04-09, 01:05:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Steph S

I have potted up all the determinate plants including two each from Nev1 and Nev2 F2, from the half gallon pots, and one  Bicolor Rumpus F3. 
Plants are starting to flower so I've been taking pics, trying to find good light, and taking note of the different stages.  Thought I would post a couple now, which might be helpful to Nicolas with the dg-gf selection if they must go to flower.
A couple of the indeterminate Bicolor Rumpus were really precocious, so I have a pic of the usual bicolor flower type, which is the same as R.  The determinate selection has turned out to be gf-ry!  I had forgotten that gf is lurking there as well.  The gf-ry flower type is the same as gf-R:  no warm orange shade on the anther cone. 


Steph S

Just a note about the stages for identification by flower color.
It is important that the flower should be fully mature and ideally within a few days of being fully open.  The petals should be fully colored for the mature open stage.  If petals are still pale, the flower may not have developed its full 'mature' color on the anther cone either.
Just a pic of a R type cluster showing the mature and immature color differences. While the petals are still pale, the anther cone is pale or greenish and too young to tell between R and gf.
I have also seen gf flowers, in some cases, that started to develop a warmer hue on the anther cone as the flower aged into day 5 or 6 from fully open.  So the freshly mature flower is your best bet for an ID of gf flower type.

Steph S

Here are a few pictures of some other gf type flowers.  Skipper Pink is gf-y, with a clear yellow anther cone.  Rodney is gf-R and the anther cone is greenish yellow even as it's opening.  The BND cherry - which was also marked for gf cotyledon type - has greenish yellow anther cone.

Steph S

One thing I noticed about the tangerine flowers, it is very easy to tell them apart at the early stage when just about to open.  The anther cone on a tt flower is dark orange while the petals are still pale.  While both gf and R type flowers have pale to greenish or yellowish anther cones in the early stage at least until the petals are fully yellow and open.

Steph S

My two earliest determinates in the Nev lines are flowering, and one of them is tangerine.  This is a great stroke of luck.
Segregation for recessive traits is pretty odd in this batch.
Nev1 line has 3 of 6 determinates.  (Two are far behind with small buds as yet and will be much later) The first determinate is tangerine and I have one each black and red in the indeterminates, so color ratio may be as expected.
Nev 2 line has 2 of 6 determinates, which is still better than 1/4 expected. The earliest is a red.
5/12 determinates for the two Nev lines together is still a whopping 42%.
BND cherry has 5 indeterminates (apparently) and one plant that terminated without making a flower bud.  That one is currently working on suckers but so far no sign of any buds on them, getting to leaf 7.
So there could be 0/6 functional determinates.
5/18 total would put me close to the expected ratio.  Still the distribution is pretty strange.

As with the Black Cherry cross parent to BND, the tendency to really tall growth and lots of extra leaves is obvious, and I remember that first F2 batch, they all looked indeterminate until a couple of them terminated as determinates after multiple clusters in the usual indet 3 leaf-cluster-3 leaf-cluster pattern. So it is still possible that some of the indets could turn out to be otherwise.
So far I have one tangerine of 4 BND flowering, and I probably won't keep any of the others, since they are shaping up to be long vines, very long vines.

Joseph Lofthouse

Sorry for not understanding the genetics of this discussion. Does this flower represent tangerine? If yes, what does that imply about the fruits, and their biochemistry...

This is a wild ancestor of The Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato project.

LA1777-Solanum-habrochaites-flower.jpg

Steph S

#21
I'm not sure what pigments account for the color of the flower there, Joseph.  It looks like the dark orange 'prolycopene' as in tangerine tomatoes to me.

Solanum habrochaites is an interesting case, there are multiple blocks in the genome that prevent carotenoid synthesis, so regardless of the flower pigment though, you won't find the same profile as tt tangerine fruit for prolycopene or other carotenoids in the fruit. 
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29048567/
The flower color though, certainly says that some carotenoids are synthesized in the flowers.  Not only the dark orange which could be prolycopene in high concentration (if not Beta carotene), but the petals are a bright yellow which suggests xanthophylls may be effectively made as well (or maybe lutein). I haven't come across an explanation for that.
I did read some of the full text, which has a lot to say about specific enzyme activities in habrochaites, and seems like a lot of the equipment to carry out the carotenoid task is available and robust, while some is completely lacking.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5853803/
So possibly some of these enzymes do very well when combined with the missing ticket from a promiscuous tomato, but whether there is already a predisposition to tangerine pathway vs beta carotene, I don't know. I would suspect that the orange tomato parent is contributing that part of the path and is the origin of the color genetics whether beta or tangerine.
I did see that they compared S. habrochaites fruit chemistry to the gf tomato, where chlorophyll is retained and not degraded.  This is another feature that could contribute to taste as well as color in the crossed population. 

I recently found this general review of carotenoids in tomato, which is not a bad read. If you scroll down a little there's an up to date diagram of the synthesis path, which shows the relationship with plant hormones and also where all the common variants occur on the path.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1674205214000070
There is an interesting bit about how carotenoids contribute to flavor as well, with refs to authors and such for deeper dives.

AndrewB

#22
LA0214 is also interesting as it states it has "Dark anthers from S. peruvianum".

https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Accession/detail/LA0214

This suggests to me that S. peruvianum and some of the other wild species may have dark anthers. Do these dark anthers correlate to tangerine fruits? I don't know, but I would probably assume possibly not. If no, then breeding with wild tomato species may present a small challenge to those using flower color as a breeding phenotype marker.

Edit: it also states "Anthers dark brown", so maybe this is more brown than orange? Joseph, do you have a photo of an S. peruvianum flower?

Joseph Lofthouse

Solanum peruvianum
solanum-peruvianum-flower.jpg

Solanum habrochaites. Anthers dark brown due to being bruised by bumblebees.
solanum-habrochaites-bumblebee.jpg

Steph S

I found this reference to wild species fruit vs flower colors in a study of the white flowered mutant tomato here:
https://academic.oup.com/plcell/article/18/8/1947/6115334?login=false

"Among the known eight wild species of tomato only two, Solanum pimpinellifolium and Solanum cheesmanii, have red- or orange-colored fruits. The rest have green to pale yellow fruits. However, the color of flowers in all wild species of tomato is a strong yellow as a result of accumulation of xanthophylls, mainly neoxanthin (data not shown). We therefore conclude that the duplication and preservation of a second carotene hydroxylase gene in tomato that is dedicated to the generation of yellow pigments in flowers has been under strong selection pressure. Genetic evidence derived from ILs indicates the existence of CrtR-b2 that is also responsible for flower coloration in the green-fruited species Solanum pennellii and Solanum habrochaites. We suggest that the generation by gene duplication of a chromoplast pathway of carotenoid biosynthesis had occurred initially to enhance carotenogenesis in flowers, and only later in evolution were these genes recruited to increase pigmentation in fruit chromoplasts in the colored-fruited species S. cheesmanii, S. pimpinellifium, and S. lycopersicum."

So the yellow pigments in flowers of habrochaites and pennellii, presumably both petals and anthers, are simply xanthophylls, and the pathway is not connected to fruit color.  The anther cone that appears dark orange is perhaps a mixture of xanthophylls with a brown pigment, either a product of its breakdown or a brown pigment from another pathway.

I haven't found anything about using flower color in habrochaites crosses as a tell for fruit color, which would allow you to make an early selection away from green fruit if that's the intention.  So some of you working with these crosses should make some careful observations and some pics of how that goes, in the transition from colorless to colored fruit. 

Does the F1 cross with tomato still have browning anthers and pale fruit? 
If so, you could weed out the green fruit in the F2 at the stage of fully flowering.
I've seen pics posted elsewhere that suggest F1 fruit may be colored or not, depending on whether the tomato parent is R, r, or ? Maybe the dominant Beta with R? 
For sure you shouldn't get any color from the recessive tangerine t/- in the F1, as the complementary allele isn't there in habrochaites, if I read correctly.

William Schlegel

#25
I have F1 and F2 plants of domestic x LA2329 Solanum habrochaites plants this year. Not flowering or fruiting yet though. I would say my F1 fruits last year were a bit yellow in color compared to the pure wild. I have promiscuous x LA2329 F1 and promiscuous x LA2329 F2. Big Hill x LA2329 F1 and MMM x LA2329 F1.

In my experience which includes working with Joseph's crosses since 2018 early generation habrochaites crosses are difficult to get to segregate back to a domestic type. These pale yellowish but mostly wild type fruits can persist into the F2 and F3 perhaps much longer without obvious segregation. With Joseph's project he eventually went to 3/4 domestic and I have a few 3/4 domestic plants for 2023 from my own crosses in consequence. Those may be easier to recover colored fruit from.

Not sure if I can promise observations or not though!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Well finally, I found something on the question of Beta vs tangerine in habrochaites.
This seminal work on tomato fruit color in 1952 describes the origin of tangerine as "obscure" but specifies that a high carotene tomato was obtained by crossing with habrochaites in 1947, which has the B Beta allele in spite of its uncolored fruit.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1209591/pdf/107.pdf
This indicates that orange offspring from habrochaites crosses would occur with a red tomato parent.
It isn't helpful wrt flower tells, since the Beta flower is quite like the wild type Red.
But if you have questions about orange fruit from those crosses, the answer is Beta not tangerine.

"The high beta-carotene selection had been obtained from the inter-
specific hybrid between L. esculentum and the related green-fruited wild
species L. hirsutum ( KOHLERet al. 1947). A single gene ( B ), derived from
hirsutum, when segregating with its esculentum allele ( b ) gave the following
percentages of beta-carotene in Ff: bb 0-24, Lib, 25-74.9, B B 75-100. The
increase in beta-carotene content was accompanied by a corresponding decrease
in lycopene.
"



Steph S

That's very interesting, William.  Must be due to the multiple elements missing for carotenoid synthesis and accumulation in habrochaites.  It makes sense that color would be harder to find, if these separate requirements for color are segregating independently in a simple F2.
So crossing your F1s to another domestic tomato would be the way to go, to restore colored fruit.
Very cool though that you could introgress Beta and get orange fruit just from crossing with a red!

William Schlegel

#28
Orange does seem to show up!

That is what I did last year crossed some of last year's F1s to my Mission Mountain Morning project.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Nice! 
Overall this bit of information reinforces the idea that all of the Beta tomatoes in circulation got the B allele from breeding with a wild ancestor somewhere back down the line, whether galapagense or habrochaites.  I wonder whether penellii has it too.
So cool that the allele was just waiting there in a species with no way to color its fruit!  Waiting for a cross with a relative, I guess.