Tomatoes with fruity flavors

Started by Nicolas, 2023-03-22, 12:23:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nicolas

I'm starting a thread about tomato with fruity flavors, as a lot of us are interested by this topic :

  • What cultivars has fruity flavors
  • What have been created and what is available from recent breeding projects that aims to get fruity flavors (as the promiscous project)
  • Best ways to breed fruity flavored tomatoes

Nicolas

#1
From TGC 65 :

QuoteThe above picture shows the F2 progeny of a cross between a large oxheart-type S.
lycopersicum, weighing about 300 gms (bottom left and right in the picture) and
Solanum galapagense, weighing about 1 gm, (top, middle). My original idea was to investigate the
high-solids characteristics of this species. However, it has become increasingly clear that this
species has many other interesting traits to investigate. Besides the high brix of many of
these individuals, up to 11 % (non-replicated), we noticed probable resistance to Powdery
Mildew (Leveillula taurica), Oidium powdery mildew, Cladosporium leaf mold, and tolerance
to greenhouse whiteflies. Based on the environmental conditions of the native habitat of
these accessions, we expect them to be tolerant to drought and salinity. The flavor is also
interesting, with many individuals having complex flavor with "fruity and floral" notes
(however, watch out for the tomatine).

Important in this discussion is that fact that S.galapagense crosses easily with cultivated
tomato, and segregation is normal.

William Schlegel

#2
Here is an attempt to list some fruity tomatoes we have spoken about:

Wild Species that may be a source of fruity flavors:

Solanum cheesemaniae
Solanum galapagense
Solanum pennellii
Solanum habrochaites


Hybrids:

Sungold F1
    Dehybridizations: Ambrosia line from Lee Goodwin, Big Sungold Select from Brad Gates

Sunsugar F1

Segregating Populations:

Fruity Mix from Tim Peters
    Selection from that: Tim's Taste of Paradise

Lofthouse promiscuous tomato project
    S35, S36, S37
          The One

Open Pollinated:

Terrior Seeds Yellow Galapagos tomato

Sunviva- European Sister Org of OSSI

Santiam Sunrise- Adaptive Seeds OSSI

Dwarf Eagle Smiley - OSSI Dwarf Tomato Project

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Those galapagense crosses would be worth growing for the disease resistances alone. 

I was thinking about this the other day and wondering whether the fruity flavors typically found in yellows could also be expressed in pink or red tomatoes.
Complex fruity yellows, includes  Galinas Yellow, Medovaya Kaplya
But there are simple fruit notes in many tomatoes.
Zolotoy Zapas, iirc tangerine tt, has notes of canteloupe.
Anna Russian, pink heart, tastes like watermelon.
Oaxaca Jewel PL, bicolor, is peachy.

I'm a fan of fruity tastes in tomatoes! 

Cathy A

What exactly do we mean when we talk about fruity flavors in tomatoes?

Jeremy Weiss

I lost it due to holding the seed to long, but I had a white cherry tomato that tasted so much like a grape it really DIDN'T belong in a salad (only time I ever regretted adding vinegar). No idea what kind (it was just two cherries sitting on top of a punnet of mixed heirlooms I got at a gourmet market,) but I remember it was the most transparent tomato I had ever seen, so clear that not only could you see the veins in the fruit through the skin, but the seeds as well (for those that ask, I have tried "Transparent" and "Gummi Bear", those aren't it). 

Garrett Schantz

White Currant maybe?

Those things have a decent flavor.

Everglades tomato sized, can see vein things on them.

Joseph Lofthouse

#7
Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-03-23, 05:55:32 PMWhat exactly do we mean when we talk about fruity flavors in tomatoes?

A group of chefs described the first taste testing of The Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomatoes project like this.

taste-testing.png

Joseph Lofthouse

As an anecdotal story, we were doing a taste testing at a farm in Idaho that grew several hundred plants from The Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project. I was serving fruits to the local farmers, and they were keeping notes.

I also picked a regular domestic tomato, and included it among the many. After it was served, the host went to the kitchen, and got a rag, so that we could wash the cutting board, and not contaminate the rest of the taste testing. Bwah, ha, ha.




Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-03-23, 08:11:56 PMWhite Currant maybe?

Those things have a decent flavor.

Everglades tomato sized, can see vein things on them.
No, they were too big to be those. At the time, I referred to them as "eyeball" tomatoes. 

Since a lot of those hyper-mixed supermarket supplies are from people who don't take particular care to keep their types discrete, it is entirely possible they belonged to no named variety. The people who buy those mixes generally just want "heirloom tomatoes", not any specific one. I've long since given up on identifying the specific types that show up in the ones I get from the Farmer's market stand now, or from the commercial mixes either, for that matter.   

Cathy A

#10
Mango, honeydew/melon, lime, citrus - wow!

It would be very popular to have a mango-flavired, stabilized variety of tomato. We could grow it where we couldn't possibly grow mangoes.

Though I wonder if some of the desirable flavors require heterozygosity at one or more locations, and therefore could only be maintained in a landrace, never stabilized.

Given that repeated attempts have failed to stabilize the Sungold F1 while maintaining all its desired traits, I suspect it requires heterozygosity at multiple sites.

Garrett Schantz

White currants are about the width of a penny, smaller than cherry tomatoes. Anything smaller would be considered those "pea tomatoes".

I can keep looking. White Beauty also has fruity flavors.

Lot of the white ones do for whatever reason.

Vesa Tee

Quote from: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-03-23, 06:26:56 PMI lost it due to holding the seed to long, but I had a white cherry tomato that tasted so much like a grape it really DIDN'T belong in a salad (only time I ever regretted adding vinegar). No idea what kind (it was just two cherries sitting on top of a punnet of mixed heirlooms I got at a gourmet market,) but I remember it was the most transparent tomato I had ever seen, so clear that not only could you see the veins in the fruit through the skin, but the seeds as well (for those that ask, I have tried "Transparent" and "Gummi Bear", those aren't it). 

By the description, what comes to my mind is Dr. Carolyn. Never tasted that myself but related Green Doctors and Green Doctors Frosted are insanely sweet.

Steph S

Those taste descriptions are great, hahaha.   8)
Vocabulary of taste, well it's bound to use tastes we know to compare.. otherwise, where are the words?  I find myself really grasping to describe tastes of green vegetables.
Thank goodness that tomatoes can be compared to fruit!

Anything 'mango' or 'tropical fruit' is bound to be a favorite in my camp.

William Schlegel

I described the original "The One" plant as something akin to Fuyu persimmon. My wife said "that's a tomato?" However it took me growing a huge number of Joseph's wild crossed tomatoes to really experience an really exciting one. I still haven't tasted a cantaloupe one. Though I am not that excited about Cantaloupe.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days