Trying to get dark greens tomatoes

Started by Nicolas, 2023-03-19, 06:24:27 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nicolas

Here is a fun project i decided to open to other breeders/growers to try to collectively find a dark green colored tomato.

Here is the description i've made of it. If anyone is interested let me know. I'm in Europe. Link to the doc which may have a better formatting.

Dark Green Tomato Collaborative Breeding Project

Project goal

Discover tomatoes with dark colored fruits (dark green, dark purple, dark brown), by growing collaboratively a lot of F2 plants .

Target color (right fruits) :
336774834_234936325594427_2585065664954824979_n.jpg

Origin of the project

A spontaneous mutation was discovered in the cultivar Manalpa, leading to an accumulation of chlorophyll before maturation (see above picture). The involved gene is a recessive gene name dg (dark green) or hp-2 (hight pigment). The accumulated chlorophyll is then converted during maturation, giving fruits of a lit bit more intense red color.

Goal of the project is to combine the dg gene with other genes that helps to keep the chlorophyll during maturation, thus giving a dark color, and even better to combine it also with genes stopping other pigment colors to appears to keep a dark green colored tomato.

In 2011, I crossed the accession LA3005 containing the mutant gene dg with the cultivar Captain Lucky.

During 2022, I cultivated some F1 plants. All plant had red colored fruits, which was expected because all involved genes are recessive.

2023 is the exciting year ! Growing F2 generation should allow for the recombination of recessive genes giving the desired phenotype.


A bit of Genetic

The project is based of three categories of genes :

  • The recessive gene leading to accumulation of chlorophyll, dg.
  • The recessive gene blocking the degradation of chlorophyll during maturation, gf.
  • The recessive gene (partially) blocking the creation of the lycopène red pigment, ry.

The dark green color is thus a combination of three recessive genes : dg + gf + ry.

Knowing the number and nature of involved genes, one can compute the number of plants that need to be grown in order to have a given percent of chance to succeed.

To have a 90% chance of finding a dark green colored fruited tomato, one has to grow ~150 plants of tomato.

This statistic is valid even spread among different people. Thus if 6 people grow each 25 plants, there is 90% chance of success that at least one of the grower will discover the dark green tomato.


How the project works

What you'll receive

Based on your capacity to grow a number of plants protected from late blight, you'll receive a number of seeds each of F2 generation.


Your contribution to the project

  • You commit to grow in good faith the number of plants we agreed at the start of the project.
  • In the case where you discover a dark colored tomato plant among your plants, you commit to share some seeds with at least a few folks contributing to the project, with the goal to spread seeds among participants and outside of the project.

 
What to expect ?

The following table list the chances of obtaining a dark green tomato plant (left), or more broadly a dark colored tomato (right).

Nb of plants / % chance to find a dark green tomato

25 / 32%
50 / 54%
75 / 69%
100 / 79%
125 / 86%
150 / 90%


Once a dark green tomato is found, jackpot ! The recessive character of all three involved gene guarantee that all further generations will be dark colored (excluding spontaneous mutation or accidental cross).

Of course not all characteristics of the plant will be fixed in the F3 generation. The plant will need a few more years to be fully stabilized. Meanwhile, those F3 seeds will still be precious to share among other breeders to start a dark green tomato revolution !

What next ?

What about crossing these dark green tomato with blue (anthocyanin) tomatoes ? The accumulation of chlorophyll could lead to very dark blue tomatoes. What about adding stripes ? Or developing a 'real' dark green tomato crossing the dark green tomato with green tomatoes like green zebra ?

336785195_228617842908176_5598729800611254834_n.jpg

AndrewB

Interesting project. What happens when you have a green tomato with the green shoulders gene?

I've never grown a green when ripe tomato, but a lot of people seem to think they taste really good and perhaps better than red ones. And the green shoulders gene helps accumulate added sugars from the chlorophyll. So I would think that should also be something someone should try. Might be very worthwhile.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-19, 07:42:00 AMInteresting project. What happens when you have a green tomato with the green shoulders gene?

I've never grown a green when ripe tomato, but a lot of people seem to think they taste really good and perhaps better than red ones. And the green shoulders gene helps accumulate added sugars from the chlorophyll. So I would think that should also be something someone should try. Might be very worthwhile.

They are, but "deceptor" green when ripes can drive you CRAZY! A deceptor is any green when ripe that has NO secondary colors to the green (no yellow, no orange, no pink spots) and a colorless skin. So you wind up with a tomato that gives NO SIGN when it is actually ripe. And so, if you are the kind of person who doesn't like abusing your tomatoes by squeezing them constantly over the season to see if they are done, you literally end up waiting FOREVER. My round green cherries are deceptors, as are the oval ones I can sometimes get at the farmer's market and there is a full size one I have called "Hopefully Optimistic" or something like that.)

For the Dark brown, you might do better to look into "integrated" browns rather than standard ones. That is, ones where the pigments are mixed up so the flesh actually IS brown, as opposed to dark orange or red with greeny patches near the top or a yellow skin over it. Mr. Brown comes to mind.

As for dark purples, Purple Calabash is the darkest purple tomato I know (it's basically the color of a bruise.) so that might be a good starting choice.)

And, of course, you may want to try and contact Tom Wagner, as he probably knows more about green when ripe tomatoes than anyone else, since he's bred so many. And he was doing a lot with the blue skin gene as well a while back (I was part of the test group to try and grow out "Searching for the Blue Wooly Mammoth."   

Nicolas

Andrew, it is my hope too that more chlorophyll = better taste. Having Captain Lucky as one of the parent won't hurt to try to have an outstanding flavor :)

Vesa Tee

#4
I have read that some hp genes can be identified at seedling stage by a pink hypocotyls below the soil level. There are a couple of research notes back from 1960's or so, see e.g. the below one. Those notes also hints that when combined with genes like gf or r, the hp may be difficult to identify from the full grown plant. You could test your dg parent if it has this pink hypo phenotype which might help in the selection of F2 plants. I have a potential hp cross myself and I did such test, however, no pink below the soil in my case.

IDENTIFICATION OF HIGH-PIGMENT, hp, TOMATOES IN THE SEEDLING STAGE

What comes to the good flavor of these high pigment lines, it may not be that simple that more chrolophyl automatically does the trick. There are more of everything, also the acids (like vitamine C). My lines (which may not be high pigment lines at all) have good zing, really strong acidic flavor. Not bad but still very strong. There must be a good amount of sugars too, otherwise they would be too acidic to eat.

Nicolas

@Vesa Tee
True, but the gf gene blur this convenient early identification (it is in the paper)

Vesa Tee

Maybe the dg phenotype is easier to identify at mature stage. It seems to be very dark green, even the leaves, not only the immature fruit. The pink hypo could just be another method in your toolbox in case it worked for the dg. 

BTW, the presence of gf can also be tested with low tech methods, I have read. Because the chrolophyl does not break easily (as the related enzyme is low or missing), one can put the leaves of gf and non-gf plants in a dark moist place and see how quickly the leaves turn yellow. The gf is expressed both in fruits and the leaves which makes the gf plants look very green and healthy too. Often misinterpretted as a sign for disease resistance I believe. Anyway, gf leaves are supposed to stay green also in the dark for longer period of time. Cannot remember how long the leaves needs to be kept in dark, less than a week I believe. No need to put the whole plant into dark, one leave in a water class should be enough. I have not tested this method myself, should try to locate the original research somewhere.

How did the LA3005 taste like? Was it more in the sweet or acidic side of the spectrum?

Roland

Do we know what kind of undesirable pleiotropic effects hp-2 genes have?
Netherlands

Nicolas

Quote from: Vesa Tee on 2023-03-20, 12:00:37 AMBTW, the presence of gf can also be tested with low tech methods, I have read. Because the chrolophyl does not break easily (as the related enzyme is low or missing), one can put the leaves of gf and non-gf plants in a dark moist place and see how quickly the leaves turn yellow.

Vesa you keep blowing my mind with your tips on linked genes or early way to spot them ! Please keep posting stuff like this :)

From Altered patterns of senescence and ripening in gf, a stay-green mutant of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)

Last picture is wild type vs gf leaves that were in the dark for 9 days
Capture d’écran du 2023-03-20 18-24-03.png

Quote from: Vesa Tee on 2023-03-20, 12:00:37 AMHow did the LA3005 taste like? Was it more in the sweet or acidic side of the spectrum?

The blight prevented me to have a crop to taste ...

Roland

This is very interesting thank u @Vesa Tee.

Because of this i can select small plants for the gf genes.

The yellow gen r can be detected to compaire the collor of the flowers. Same as Tangerine.



https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1214808109
Netherlands

Vesa Tee

#10
Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-03-20, 11:26:02 AMFrom Altered patterns of senescence and ripening in gf, a stay-green mutant of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)

Good find Nicolas, this was the paper I was looking for. :) Finding a research paper that so clearly helps amateur plant breeders is very rare. This one is a happy exception.

It was unclear at the time to me if gf fruit can loose the chlorophyll over time because I was observing such behavior in one of my plants and become uncertain if it had gf gene or something else. In this paper, they reported that the wild type fruit lost most of the chlorophyll three days after the breaker stage (B+3). But their gf fruit had 84% of chlorophyll at B+3 and 28% at B+10. So those gf fruits in the study also loose the green colour over time. Learning about the leaf behavior was a bonus.

The flower colour of tangerine is a classic that has been very useful for me as well. But I think there might be more variation in the yellow and red flesh flower colours than in that picture. It would be a good idea to document the flower colours of the parents at the time of the cross (which I never do) and trying to use it as a selection criteria in later generations.

Roland

It seems you want to ad one gene (hp-2 dg) in you're very tasty green when ripe heirloom Captain Lucky.

I think a Back Cross method can work perfectly to ad the hp-2 gene in you're heirloom. When you use back crossing the advantage is that you back cross the better genes of Heirloom Captain Lucky and breed out the lesser genes of Manalpa (LA3005).

You proceed as follows:
Year 0: P: CL x M = F1
Year 1: F1 x CL = BC1

Year 2: 5 plants BC1 x CL = BC2
Year 2: same 5 plants BC1 x M = T2
Year 2 winter: grow 5 plants T2 per BC (25 plants), check which BC2 plant has hp-2 gene

Year 3: 5 plants BC2 x CL = BC3
Year 3: same 5 plants BC2 x M = T3
Year 3: winter: grow 5 plants T3 per BC (25 plants), check which BC3 plant has hp-2 gene

Etc.

When you think your BC.. generation is sufficiently similar according to CL, you make a selfing to find a homozygous plant for hp-2 combined with all the genes and tastes from CL.

11 plants are needed to have a 95% chance of finding the homozygous hp-2 plant.

CL=Captain Lucky
M=Manalpa
BC = Back Cross
T=Test generation

Every year you make a back cross generation and a test generation to check which BC plant has the hp-2 gene (heterozygous). And with the seeds of this BC plant you can continue the following year.

By using 5 plants per generation, with the selection on 1 gene, you have a 95% chance of finding this gene in at least 1 BC plant.

Same for the test generation, using 5 plants pollinated by Manalpa u have 95% change to find a homozygous hp-2 plant for identification what BC plant is heterozygous for hp-2.
Netherlands

Nicolas

True, recurrent backcrossing makes sens to introgress one gene? With recessives it is painful though.


For now the dark green tomatoes project is just a proof of concept. I hope to obtain the phenotype quickly (in  3 years) and then let the community try a lot of great things that i didnt even think of. I have more 'important' projects to do, as my main focus is to make tomatoes i can grow outdoor at my place.

Steph S

It is really a shame that the tomato brown rugose fruit virus has caused so many restrictions on exchanging tomato seed across borders.  Not sure if the EU has any restrictions between nations. 

Just thinking about easy ways to do this...
Did I read that the hp2 plants are smaller than normal?  If that was the case, you may recognize them as well before fruit is set.
I also wonder whether the dg effect would have the same effect on leaf yellowing as the gf?
Either way, if you had a good setup for the leaf test,  you could grow 4X the number of seedlings that you have room for, and select those that have gf leaf characters, which should be 1/4 roughly.  So for 25 plants you could grow 100 seedlings. 
This would give you 4 to 6 dg/gf plants, and 4 to 6 gf/ry. 
3/4 of dg/gf should have an allele for ry.  likewise 3/4 gf/ry would have a dg allele. So to ensure all 3 traits in the next generation you would save seeds from multiple lines.
If dg plants can be recognized by smaller stature, you could grow the gf/ry lines in greater numbers than you have spaces and keep the plants that show dg characters.
If there's no tip for the dg plants, just growing a half dozen each of four gf/ry lines should still positively get you the triple trait. or vice versa with the dg/gf.
So I think even with 25 spaces, you could do this in two years.

Nicolas

Steph,

Yes dg has smaller seedlings. Since gf blurs the other detection (pink hypocotyl), i dont know if it will not have epistatic effect on seedlings size too, but i'll keep my eyes on it.

The great tip about gf selection lift a huge burden on the F2 growout. With early detection of gf, only 35plants are needed to get dg and r^y. If one can manage early detection of dg thanks to seedling size, it becomes too easy ! ;)

With these new infos i think i'll grow the F2s in containers to protect them from late blight.

8 people have pledged to grow 120 plants, so if it possible to combine the genes as i want, we'll have good chances to find a plant that match the criteria

With some luck, you can get LA3005 from TGRC