Montana Tomato Project

Started by William Schlegel, 2022-11-13, 08:23:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

#195
Mine aren't within species crosses. I don't think I would be 100% confident the cross was successful. I think I would rather have a high percentage back cross. Then I can breed in OSSI descent and some of the already useful local genetics from the regional breeding programs of Idaho, North Dakota, and Alberta universities.

I think back crossing a higher percentage Solanum galapagense hybrid makes really good sense. Salt tolerance is supposed to be multi gene so would be good to have an unbroken version and that is a pathway towards that goal!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-07, 09:39:44 AMI don't think I would be 100% confident the cross was successful.

Oh just on this point - if it's an SC species, so long as the first cross with lyc is to the wild female (assuming you want the wild cytoplasm), this should not be an issue, since the F1 would be obvious, then you can pollinate that F1 with the wild species again - either the cross is successful and and the wild percentage increases, or it fails (e.g. selfs) and doesn't. But it could not be confused with the pure wild so long as the seeds are properly tracked.

William Schlegel

https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/collections/new-for-2024/products/mission-mountain-tomato-grex

Variety description for Mission Mountain Grex:

All tomatoes in this grex are descended from OSSI pledged tomatoes, and I consider the project to be one where you: the end user of these seeds and I are working towards breeding more open source tomatoes together. I hope you take this variable and still segregating population and find something in it that does well in your garden. Then save seeds, name your new variety, and hopefully eventually repledge it to the Open Source Seed Initiative

This grex of tomatoes is one I have made in the last few years working towards some new Montana bred tomato varieties. It contains seed for what will be F2, F3, and F4 seedlings. Ancestors of this mix include Joseph Lofthouse's Open Source Seed Initiative (OSSI) pledged Big Hill (HX-9), OSSI pledged Dwarf Mocha's Cherry, and OSSI pledged Dwarf Gloria's Treat. I also included as ancestors for disease resistance two accessions of the current tomato Solanum pimpinellifolium LA1375 PI365967 an accession known for tolerance to brown rugose fruit virus, and PI 270443 which may be the source material for PH5 late blight resistance. I used Purple Zebra F1, a remarkable modern hybrid, bred for looks and heirloom flavor by artisanal breeder Mark Mccaslin as another parent that may confer some resistances to a small portion of its offspring. I made a cross with a Solanum galapagense hybrid that showed up in my 2022 garden for another ancestor. Other ancestors include Mission Mountain Sunrise, a tomato Joseph Lofthouse calls Brad, Sweet Cherriette, microdwarf Aztek, Brad Gate's Blue Gold, Brad Gate's Brad's Atomic Grape, as well as some unknown pollen donors. This mix is largely composed of F2 seed that will segregate in spectacular fashion. Reds, yellows, orange, green when ripe, bicolors, blue skin, potato leaf, regular leaf, and stripes are all possibilities. A small portion of the population may have elongated styles that stick out from the pollen cone facilitating higher rates of natural outcrossing and it is possible that additional crosses could have occurred in 2023.

Specific Crosses include:
Mission Mountain Morning is a cross between Mission Mountain Sunrise and Big Hill (HX-9), the only F4 seed in the mix. Mission Mountain Sunrise is Brad x Blue Gold
Mission Mountain Morning x Aztek now in the F3
Mission Mountain Morning x LA1375
Mission Mountain Morning x PI270443
Dwarf Gloria's Treat x LA1375
Dwarf Glorias Treat x Unknown Regular Leaf Blue Bicolor Beefsteak
Mission Mountain Morning best stigma exsertion in F2 x Unknown fathers
Mission Mountain Morning x Sweet Cherriette now in the F3
Mission Mountain Morning x Brad's Atomic Grape
Mission Mountain Morning x (Solanum galapagense x unknown domestic)
Mission Mountain Morning x Purple Zebra F1
Dwarf Mocha's Treat x Mission Mountain Sunrise
Note: if not otherwise mentioned, they are F2 seeds.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#198
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-13, 05:51:51 AMI don't mean in general but mainly for this topic. If you look at the start of the topic, this topic is clearly not about interspecific hybrids.


I looked back to the first post and it doesn't make any mention of heirlooms, just "Open Pollinated cultivar" like you quoted, which is what I was referring to. And there's certainly been a lot of conversation of non-heirloom varieties on this topic, for example regarding modern dwarf tomato varieties.

When I think of 'interspecific hybrids' I think of tomatoes that have a relatively high percentage of wild species. They can still be OP cultivars. But even tomatoes not usually thought of as interspecific hybrids often have wild genetics, like Stupice for example, which I read is a mix of Mikado, Sláva Porýni, and Solanum pimpinellifolium.

In the context of this topic, I was actually thinking of the latter, tomatoes that people would think of as 'Solanum lycopersicum', but have some degree of wild introgression. Like for example any of the popular OP tomatoes that have some anthocyanin in the skin, or having late blight resistance (which is one of the things that made Stupice popular, and any of the tomatoes using PH genes also), or various other forms of disease resistance that give so many non-heirloom OP tomatoes advantages. It would seem to me to be in line with the first post to be using such tomatoes. And it would seem potentially highly advantageous. So I don't see the point of deliberately excluding the last 50 or more years of tomato breeding by restricting it to only heirlooms, that's all I'm saying.

Looking back at the first page, Andrew seems to be making a similar point:
I'm not saying don't use heirlooms. I was just questioning why. Especially in reference to low statistical chance of F1 improvement over F0 in the paper shared, and how that might differ if one is open to the wider genepool of the post-heirloom domestic tomatoes.

I was just thinking the other day that I should really cross Stupice into the Montana Tomato Project because of its vast popularity here in MT and all the way west from here. Carol Deppe who gardens in Corvallis Oregon mentions the variety several times in her The Tao of Vegetable Gardening Cultivating Tomatoes Greens Peas Beans Squash Joy and Serenity. I think she considers it an heirloom. Actually I think even Craig LeHoullier gives Solanum pimpinellifolium a pass when it comes to heirloom status. Though it might technically be "early modern"

Why has Stupice from the Czech Republic outcompeted the amazing University bred tomatoes from Idaho and North Dakota? Both contain some S. pimpinellifolium genetics. It would be better to breed a popular tomato than an unpopular but what makes one popular and another obscure?

Actually I think some of those Idaho and North Dakota tomatoes did have their times of popularity. I read somewhere recently that one of them was the top tomato in Costa Rica for a decade and then forgot where I found the fun fact. Also some forum members have found some of the Idaho bred tomatoes useful in far off places like Britain!

There are also some different definitions of Heirloom. I think Craig might have the most strict a historical cutoff as introgression breeding picked up. Which happened quite awhile ago with regional tomatoes like Farthest North, Owyhee, and Payette picking up pimpinellifolium, peruvianum, and habrochaites introgressions all over fifty years ago. Fifty years is another definition a rolling cutoff. Then in the public usage any stable variety can go into the heirloom section. So people falsely label all of Brad Gates and Tom Wagners tomatoes as heirloom because its come to be associated and synonymous with non-commercial types. I also think the commercial tomato industry has developed some tomatoes to be passed off in grocery stores as that!

Also to my earlier pondering on popularity vs. Obscurity. Victory Seeds one week sale of unpopular varieties had both some important older varieties like Tom Wagner's Lime Green Salad and some of the new dwarf tomato varieties including I think Banana Toes which I bought and tried and rather decided not to use in breeding. I was thinking those unpopular varieties might have statistical predictive value as to what makes a variety popular or unpopular? Honestly it could in part just be the name! A name can be off putting or it can be inspiring. Number names or number letter names like the obscure variety 033 probably doom a variety to obscurity. The old practice of renaming probably used to help with that by reducing naming bias of single named for single varieties but I would rather breed another unique variety and try again! Then yield, flavor, and fruit traits probably help. Classic red is likely highly preferred and most popular for most people. Good flavor likely helps. Non-cracking, ease of processing. Fruit size is important. Productivity is important. Disease resistance.

I was going through OSSI tomatoes wondering if we had captured the range of morphological diversity in fruit with them and I saw gaps. Very little ribbing. Didn't notice any pear shaped ones. Those more obscure fruit shape traits lile ribbing likely decrease popularity just as they did in the days of Livingston because they cause more difficulty with processing. Some popularity might be inadvertent. If I set out to breed a popular tomato it might by chance become obscure and an tomato I thought irrelevant might go on to become popular?!

Mission Mountain Sunrise one of my first tomatoes is sitting at F7 in an envelope in my seed sorter. Its first offspring Mission Mountain Morning is sitting at F4. I suspect MMS to be not at all useful for disease resistance. MMM not much better in that regard and is mainly just potentially larger and perhaps exserted an outcross to Big Hill HX-9 which is OSSI pledged. However then I made lots of crosses with MMM and crosses with the crosses! Even a couple back crosses! From those there are now some crosses from which I might be able to recover disease resistance and earliness and the MMS or really Blue Gold type. A tomato which I might think should be popular? Though also given my sharings of unfinished work like the Mission Mountain Grex I just shared it is very likely that someone who grows out that grex in an area with disease pressures will be the one, not I, to develop from it a tomato that can handle such things! An east coast tomato or a Midwest tomato or a west coast tomato or a British tomato- somewhere with more humidity and higher disease pressure. Montana might be fine with MMS. New Jersey? Doubtful!

Circling back to Stupice. Does it's local and widespread popularity and perhaps also Carol Deppe's high esteem for it for several reasons including earliness and flavor make it a good choice for a cross? It's pimpinellifolium content? I believe it is potato leaved which makes the crosses obvious and is always a plus.
Triple Divide our only MT vegetable seed company sells it: https://tripledivideseeds.com/product/stupice-organic-tomato-seed/
Do those factors and considerations push it high enough up my grow list? Or my list for my best crossing space in the greenhouse or the backyard bed? Hmm I think I might grow it out- out on the garden land. I did make more crosses there than ever before last year but it isn't my best crossing space. So I guess crossing with Stupice is a middle priority- moving up from a low priority. A very practical cross but not the most exciting personally!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 06:56:17 AMI was just thinking the other day that I should really cross Stupice into the Montana Tomato Project because of its vast popularity here in MT and all the way west from here. Carol Deppe who gardens in Corvallis Oregon mentions the variety several times in her The Tao of Vegetable Gardening Cultivating Tomatoes Greens Peas Beans Squash Joy and Serenity. I think she considers it an heirloom. Actually I think even Craig LeHoullier gives Solanum pimpinellifolium a pass when it comes to heirloom status. Though it might technically be "early modern"

I thought 'heirloom' was more about the age rather than what introgressions, no? From what I understand Stupice was bred in the 1940's and released in the 1950's. So it makes sense many would consider it an heirloom. I guess it might depend if going by the 'at least 50 years old' definition, or the 1951 cut-off point or 100 years etc. But yes, either way there must be various heirlooms derived from interspecific crosses with pimp, or some per and hab depending on the date one chooses, but seems much more utilisation of wild genes since then.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 06:56:17 AMWhy has Stupice from the Czech Republic outcompeted the amazing University bred tomatoes from Idaho and North Dakota? Both contain some S. pimpinellifolium genetics. It would be better to breed a popular tomato than an unpopular but what makes one popular and another obscure?

Could it be due to superior taste? Or superior name recognition? Or, due to more focus on capitalist traits in the more recent ones, such as harder fruit and longer shelf life, that might be better for profits but worse for the consumer?

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 06:56:17 AMThere are also some different definitions of Heirloom. [...] Fifty years is another definition a rolling cutoff.

Yes. That's why I wrote "excluding the last 50 or more years". I don't know what the most usual date is but have assumed it's maybe 1951 cut off? But I know usage varies so I tried to cover the general concept by saying that.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 06:56:17 AMBanana Toes which I bought and tried and rather decided not to use in breeding. I was thinking those unpopular varieties might have statistical predictive value as to what makes a variety popular or unpopular? Honestly it could in part just be the name! A name can be off putting or it can be inspiring.

Hmm, good point! Perhaps many people don't want to be thinking about toes when eating fresh food.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 06:56:17 AMClassic red is likely highly preferred and most popular.


That makes sense although, if the red tomato market is saturated, it might be easier to penetrate into the non-plain-red market?


Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-13, 06:56:17 AMI was going through OSSI tomatoes wondering if we had captured the range of morphological diversity in fruit with them and I saw gaps. Very little ribbing. Didn't notice any pear shaped ones. Those traits likely decrease popularity just as they did in the days of Livingston because they cause more difficulty with processing.

Just to share my subjective experience - before I ever grew tomatoes, I would avoid ribbed tomatoes because I don't really like tomato skin. For the same reason I avoided cherry tomatoes. I always wanted to be eating a maximum flesh:skin ratio, basically. Both for fresh eating and for cooking. Perhaps that has something to do with it for some other people too. But then, if there is a relative lack of the ribbed ones, that might be an easier niche to enter also.


William Schlegel

#200
https://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-015-1444-1

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41438-020-0291-7

Two articles recently caught my attention. The first shows that South American red tomato diversity particularly in Ecuador and Peru is of remarkable importance. The second is an experimental course of action creating a very interesting research population of tomatoes to better understand that diversity.

The course of action this suggests to me is to make some more crosses with tomatoes from South America. I was able to order a few more recently from Seed Saver's Exchange- the actual exchange not the catalog. I think, once those arrive safely, I will have a total of nine red groups (pimp, gal, che, lyc) South American tomatoes both wild and domestic with which to make crosses.

I think that based on these articles that South American red group tomatoes, particularly the domestic heirlooms, are an underutilized and straightforwardly easy way to improve the resiliency of tomatoes. Though this diversity is across accessions and not just within accessions as may be the case with some of the obligate outcrossing but difficult to work with species. So the more accessions used the better. In the second article they make crosses with 163 accessions. If I can make crosses with nine that might be enough for my effort and for my portion of the Montana Tomato Project to incorporate. However, a larger effort, perhaps OSSI wide in a new dwarf tomato project level effort could think about a larger goal such as making distinct crosses with 100 accessions or 163 or 200. If indigenous farmers and gardeners in the heart of tomato diversity and with disease pressures have been sustainably growing tomatoes for deep time in Ecuador and Peru this just makes sense to incorporate the same levels of genetic diversity as found there. OSSI wide that could mean something simple like pairing each existing OSSI variety with a different accession and making a cross, then developing a new variety from each cross focusing on morphological variation. This would double the number of OSSI varieties but more than double their genetic level distinctiveness.

For my own work I have something like 92 extant crosses, most of them of OSSI descent, but a much smaller subset are distinctive crosses either morphologically or genetically. There is some interesting morphological variation in the South American material and that can add something. However, I think for a variety to successfully add something to the tomato world, to be conserved by multiple seed savers, it has to have distinction. So most of my crosses likely represent either dead ends or intermediate steps requiring an additional cross to be useful for the development of a new variety.

I was explaining my basic philosophy of tomato breeding to someone the other day. I said basically there are three things I need to combine. A short season tomato already well adapted to Montana, a tomato that is amazing for its fanciness like say Brad Gate's Atomic Grape or Tom Wagner's Muddy Waters, and a tomato that contributes some important diversity at the genetic level like Galahad F1 or Purple Zebra F1. These South American tomatoes come in as an alternative and perhaps more resilient approach for the latter. Potentially more resilient because this approach, instead of broadly incorporating the same genetics to make tomatoes more modern, incorporates more genetic diversity across new varieties which means the same pathogen can't adapt if there are multiple different resistances represented by that deeper diversity. It is a novel approach- save heirloom tomato genetics by incorporating the heirloom diversity from Ecuador and Peru instead of by incorporating the modernization introgressions already widely used commercially. Though I will also mix methods and let segregation happen.

So one of the highest priorities in 2024 for my high value growing spaces in the greenhouse and backyard where I can most easily make crosses, will be growing out South American red tomato group accessions for crosses.

I got these from seed saver's exchange.

Tomato 1147 South American Large Round Accession 122549
Tomato 1962 PI 129129 (Panama) Accession 123363 (A little far North but maybe)
Tomato 2067 PI 118686 (Brazil) Accession 123468
Tomato 1148 South American Oval Accession 122550
Tomato 2065 PI 79532 (Peru) Accession 123466
Tomato 5658 PI 158171 (Venezuela) Accession 127037
Tomato 5659 PI 158164 (Venezuela) Accession 127038
Tomato 4852 Peruvian Bush Accession 126231
Tomato 4848 Oaxacan Pink Accession 126227 (Mexican but still interesting)
Tomato 2070 PI 128445 (Argentina) Accession 123471

I also accidentally ordered the variety Perun a yellow pear type from the Czech Republic. Oops, it came up when I searched for Peru.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

QuoteIf I set out to breed a popular tomato it might by chance become obscure and an tomato I thought irrelevant might go on to become popular?!

William this sounds like my experience in selling my hand made items. I can have 200 great items and 10 of that will be items that I really love and kind of want to keep for myself. Then I'll bring 10 items that are just sitting around and I think are ugly or something lacking. But bring them just because I have them.

Those last 10 items are just about guaranteed to sell! The more ugly I think it is, the more likely it is to be the first of my items to sell!

I just shake my head. No accounting for what's going to be in fashion or personal tastes haha.

William Schlegel

#202
Here are crosses that each have three things. A source of diversity or resistances, a source of morphological diversity, and a source of local adaptedness. I think that makes these the highest priority combinations and the remainder in need of additional crossing before I am satisfied with them, or potentially just discard some!?. Of these however, I count only about a dozen potentially distinct morphological groups. Part of me thinks that equates to just a dozen future varieties, but in truth, it could end up being more than that because of segregation for size and so forth. 


Striped Potential from Purple Zebra
(MMM F2 x Purple Zebra F1) x (MMM F2 x PH5 pimpinillifolium)
(MMM x Purple Zebra F1) x (MMM x LA1375)
(MMM x Purple zebra) x (mmm x galapagense x)
MMM x Purple Zebra F1
Galahad F1 x (MMM X Purple Zebra F1)

Striped Tricolor potential from Brad's Atomic Grape
(MMM X Purple Zebra) X (MMM x Brad's Atomic Grape)

Galapagense potential
(MMM x LA1375) x (MMM x galapagense X)
MMM x (Galapagense x Unknown)
Payette x (MMM x Galapagense X)

Improved MMM Potential
(MMM x PH5 LB pimp) x (MMM x LA1375)
(MMM x Sweet Cherriette) x (MMM x LA1375)
Bison x (MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375)
MMM x (MMM x LA1375)
MMM x (MMM x LB Pimp)
MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375
MMM x LB PH5 Pimp
MMS x (MMM x LA1375)
Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ)
Payette x (MMM x LA1375)
The One! X MM
Wilford x (MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375)
Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375)

Amethyst Cream Potential
Amethyst Cream x (MMM X PZ)

Dwarf Eagle Smiley Potential
Dwarf Eagle Smiley x (MMM x Brown Rugose LA1375)

Dwarf Gloria's Treat Potential
Dwarf Gloria's Treat x Pimps

Paste Potential
Fisher's Earliest Paste x (MMM x LA1375)

Heat Tolerance Potential with potentially carrot leaves
Flamenco x (MMM x galapagense X)

Yellow Pointed Tomato potential
MMR Dwarf No Blue x (MMM X PH5 LB Pimp)

Yellow Cherry tomato potential
Sunviva x MMMF3
Ida Gold x (MMM x LA1375)

Excluding LA2329 Solanum habrochaites crosses for now, though I have some hope that something at least palatable will segregate out in 2024.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

My packet from Experimental Farm Network came. Hummingbird F2. Probably cross it with some of my current crosses, Improved wild galapagos, will try to cross with it maybe it will be easier than LA1410 and of course is from Ecuador originally so adds genetic diversity. Puerto Cortes, not sure genetically if as exciting coming from central america not south but still an indigenous cherry tomato and will try to cross with it, and Cosmic Purple Rain which I reckon will add some fancy to a cross.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-05, 02:53:11 PMI have just sorted out four seeds each of:

Nodak Early- a new to me dwarf released in 1990 by NDSU and Dr. Boe.

Sandpoint x (MMM X Sweet Cherriette)
Payette x (MMM x LA1375)
Payette x (MMM x galapagense x)
Payette x (MMM x Sweet Cherriette)

Goal is to plant them and make crosses and get some early F2 seed, hopefully in time for a 2024 F2 grow out to recover dwarfs.

Edit: got them planted. 20 seeds.

After three weeks, the house warmed up and they are finally germinating. I count six so far, everything but the Nodak Early.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Hummingbird F2 sounds like an exciting choice. I thought I had my tomato seeds for 2024, but apparently I'm not done yet. :-)

William Schlegel

https://www.etsy.com/ca/listing/1165103330/exserted-tiger-tomato-directly-from

My wife reopened her Etsy shop, it has ET, EO, and HX-9 should anyone still need them.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#207
New generations of EO, MMS, and ET have been grown for Snake River Seeds I notice!

https://snakeriverseeds.com/products/tomato-mission-mountain-sunrise?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

I may have 95 new to me tomatoes to grow and make crosses with in 2024. Oops?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

That sounds like plenty. I'm feeling a bit overwhelmed with less than 20.