Back Crossing Latah

Started by Tim DH, 2022-09-02, 02:13:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

UnicornEmily

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-11-11, 12:34:28 PMSecondly, I had assumed that, since I was selecting for two non-Latah traits there would be a certain amount of other non-Latah genetics that would be difficult to eliminate because of gene linkage. However since the two non-Latah traits I want are themselves so strongly linked, there will be a lot less other non-Latah material than if the traits had been on separate chromosomes.

Excellent.  I love it when two traits you want are closely linked.  It makes things so much easier!


Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-11-11, 12:34:28 PMIf you HADN'T posted this article I would have been curious about the lack of Determinate plants in the F2 and even more perplexed come F4, when standard Mendelian genetics would suggest up to half of the plants should be Determinate.

Ha ha!  It's nice to get a mystery cleared up before it even happens!  :D

Roland

Quote from: Vesa Tee on 2022-11-11, 03:41:15 PMHi Tim, I am glad that you found the article useful!

If you find a determinate PL during the process, you may want to save it too. Such cultivars are rare, and might be worth saving. Breaking the linkage is rare but must happen sometimes.

I have been planning a small back crossing project myself too but only with one dominant trait, the green shoulders (U). I have some compact determinate lines which have the uniform (u) trait and would benefit from U as flavour booster. I was thinking of crossing uu x UU first, and the F1 uU immediately back to the uu parent, all within one year. 50% of the resulting plants should be Uu which I could continue to stabilize. I could do some further back crossing, however, it would require using multiple parallel plants because I would not know anymore if the U gene is there or not. The first two crosses are safe to do with single plants.

If your base breed has the recessive gene, you can easily test annually which backcross has the dominant gene. You can do this for about 7 generations, also in winter you can grow a few Back cross plants for a generation because you only have to select for the U gene.

If you select on 1 gene, you have a 50% chance that the offspring will inherit this gene. If you grow 5 plants, you have a 95% chance that you have at least one plant with this dominant gene.

After 7 generations you have more than 90% of your original breed with a Heterozygous U gene. This allows you to self-pollinate and hope you select a homozygous plant. You can continue to self-pollinate and always select the uu plants. At some point you will no longer find any uu plants because you have selected a homozygous UU plant. Your new variety is now seed resistant.

However, I am very curious if you will really find a better taste because of the U gene?
This is claimed in some articles, however in these articles heirloom varieties with good taste and UU gene are compared to the tasteless commercial varieties that have the uu gene.

My own experience with Galahad F2 and F3 where about 25% of the plants are uu, we do not notice a better taste in the plants with a U gene. Also, the brix is ��not higher with the U plants.
Netherlands

Vesa Tee

#17
Hi Roland, and thanks for good proposals and advices!

I agree that the U does not automatically guarantee flavor or sweetness. I have tasted u plants with sweet taste and U plants with acidic taste. I have also read the conflicting research papers, some promoting U for flavor and others questioning the claim. But I am still becoming little by little a believer that "U often helps". I am leaning more towards this general principle that U often helps because all of my U lines are sweeter than my u lines.

I have some 15 breeding lines, all targeting one specific compact determinate plant architecture. The U and u lines that I plan to cross are already very close to the same growth habit which hopefully makes the back crossing process much shorter for me than if I started from the beginning.

I haven't published much information of my project in this forum except this posting a year ago: Triple Crown project

Roland

Quote from: Vesa Tee on 2022-11-10, 02:22:51 PMAnd then I found the reference, seems to be from year 1934 (look for Chromosome IV group).

https://www.ias.ac.in/describe/article/jgen/029/01/0123-0133

For my breeding project i want to make a bush tomato variety, beef tomatoes, clear skin and the recessive u gene.
I also want to add orange fruit tangerine in it. Im doing this by backcrossing to the base variety.
I know it's difficult to breed a respective gene in a variety by backcrossing, but I have a method.

In the very nice article I see the t and u genes are linked but still 40% of the time there is a crossover?

What does this mean for my breeding, can I select for the dark shoulder U gene because its linked to the t gene. Or is 40% crossover meaning the link between the genes to far separated?
Netherlands

Roland

Are there more articles of this kind with other genes like gf green flesh, gs green stripe, r yellow fruit, B beta orange, Ph2, ph3 phytophthora, etc.?

im also breeding with these genes.
Netherlands

Vesa Tee

I didn't realize that there was a link between t and u too. I have both u and U variants of t in my lines, from different sources though. A good tt+uu plant is Gold Dust, it is very mild tasting and very compact but still relative large fruit. Little short in flavour, need to wait for full ripening before some flavour develops.

IDK how to interpret the 40% linkage. It seems to me that the sample was rather small, it should have segregated to 9:3:3:1 but it come out closer to 8:2:2:1 (if I calculated correctly).

There are similar articles, a good term to google is "tomato linkage studies".

TCG has also a lot of these older genetic information, just search from the site with a gene name, e.g. tangerine

Out of you list of interesting genes, I only know that B is supposed to be linked to sp. So, if you want a Beta determinate line, you need to find a Beta determinate parent. I assume the same applies to old gold (crimson) as it is a defect in Beta.

Nicolas

#21
Nice find @vesa !


I'm not sure to understand the notion of cross over from the genetic linkage papers.

About the linkage of potato leaves (c) and determinate (sp), what i understand from the number of plants of their F2 pop (117 C Sp : 52 C sp : 50 c Sp : 0 c sp)

  • If you want to select for c/sp, you'll need to grow a lot of plants (they got 0 out of 219). But they managed to get some (no mention of the growout). Is there any c/sp cultivars out there ?
  • It can be useful to cross a determinate (C/sp) with an indeterminate potato leaf (c/Sp) if you want to select for sp (determinate) because your chances of recovering it in the F2 will be 1/3 and not 1/4 if you select for the regular leaf at seedling stage
  • The same cross is also useful if one of your parent is determinate and you want to select for indeterminate because selecting for potato leaf in the F2 will lead to ~100% indeterminate

I wonder if there are other linkage useful to not fall in dead ends or to ease finding what we want. We should make a list :)

After some looking, it is also difficult to get dwarf with peach/fuzzy skin (d+p)


Vesa Tee

#22
The only practically useful linkage rule for me has been this group of c, og, B and sp. There might of course be others but a challenge is that many of the genes listed in these maps are not easily identifiable. And sometimes the phenotype is because of multiple genes.

Wikipedia/Genetic linkage explains how to interpret the recombination frequency. If there is no linkage, the frequency is 50%. The basic unit (cM) is 1% of recombination. Frequency less than 7 is considered hard to break.

QuoteRecombination frequency is a measure of genetic linkage and is used in the creation of a genetic linkage map. Recombination frequency (θ) is the frequency with which a single chromosomal crossover will take place between two genes during meiosis. A centimorgan (cM) is a unit that describes a recombination frequency of 1%.

QuoteIf the loci we're analysing are very close (less than 7 cM) a double crossover is very unlikely.

QuoteWhen two genes are close together on the same chromosome, they do not assort independently and are said to be linked. Whereas genes located on different chromosomes assort independently and have a recombination frequency of 50%, linked genes have a recombination frequency that is less than 50%.

In below tomato linkage map from 1963 (pages 6 and 7), the distance between c and sp is 2 (10-8) which I think means frequency of 2%. So some cross over does happen. But c and og (or B and sp) have difference of 0. So these links must be very difficult to break.

https://tgc.ifas.ufl.edu/vol13/Volume13.pdf

Edit: this version of the map lists gf, gs, y, r genes too, just to mention some


Tim DH

Hi Nicolas,
   According to Tatiana, 'Glacier' is a Determinate Potato Leaf. However, according to the paper I referenced earlier, although Glacier is very closely related to both Stupice and Bloody Butcher it doesn't have the c mutation!
   SO if you wanted Determinate Potato Leaved plants that would be an easy way to bypass the c/sp linkage!!

   I guess it depends on whether you think the postulated benefits of Potato Leaf cultivars are due to the leaf shape (morphology) or some other function of the c mutation.

   Every answer seems to throw up more questions!!

Hi Vesa,
   Thanks for sharing another amazing link. ... I'm glad this info. has come up in the Winter! I just wouldn't have time to process it in the growing season. Apart from anything else, I just love the way that it looks like a scan of a document which was originally produced on a typewriter. I remember the pain of trying to get layout right on those things!!

Tim DH

Vesa Tee

Quote from: Tim DH on 2022-11-10, 02:49:44 PMHi Emily,
    This paper:
https://nph.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/nph.16403
    suggests that tomato plants with 'rounder leaves having significantly improved fruit quality '

        Maybe when I've got my PL Latah I'll be able to give an opinion on that too!!



About the paper Tim referred earlier, it is really an interesting paper, I have checked it earlier too.

They tested 18 broad leaf heirloom cultivars that are all classified as "potato leaf" by phenotype. But as Tim commented above, not all were c cultivars, it was enough that these 18 cultivars looked like potato leaf. But more importantly, they didn't study any regular leaf cultivars, only broader leaf types.

So, if we were selecting between broad leaf plants, the ones with rounder leaflets tends to have better quality. Yes, there is some evidence pointing to this direction.

Does the same principle apply if we were selecting among regular leaf plants or between regular and potato leaf plants? Not so sure. They didn't at least study these issues.

Nicolas

There are some accessions on TGRC with c + sp

LA0336 a; c; sp; y
LA2487  c^int; sp; t; u (another allele of c, same phenotype apparently)
LA3806 B^og; c; Mi; sp; yv : This one is for @Vesa ;) Slow stck but i guess it is from the yv gene

Nicolas

So if i've understood correctly, if we cross a PL determinate with a RL indeterminate, almost all PL of F2 would be determinate

Roland

yes, only 2% will not be conform this rule.
Netherlands

Joseph Lofthouse

Here's a graphic demonstrating cross over.

When a DNA molecule splits during reproduction, the strands of DNA switch sides 1 to 2 times as they are unzipping. Only one strand is passed on to the offspring. The location of the split(s) is random.

independent-assortment-F1.png 


Tim DH

Happy New Year!

The race is on to see if I can get three generations of my Latah Backcross done in a year. (I'd have begun yesterday, only the bags of compost were frozen.)

For starters, here is a visual comparison of the (F2) fermented and spat seed. (See post #4 & #9 on this thread. Also the thread 'F1s for the People!' #40 & #41 for more info..) I've sown eight of each to see if they grow differently. In theory those 16 F2 seedlings should provide me with approx 4 Potato Leaved plants.