F1s for the People!

Started by Tim DH, 2022-05-15, 08:21:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

KaguyaCloud

#180
Very interesting to see what the flavor segregation was for your Rosella Cherry cross. Based off of my personal experience, it seems that quite a lot of flavor from Rosella Cherry seems to be masked in the F1 generation, as the F1 cross between it and a neutral acidic micro resulted in a tomato with a slightly rich, but standard tomato flavor. Sweetness levels seems to be still high however.

It wasn't until the F2 generation of my trial that the familiar aroma came back.

Tim DH

#181
Hi Kaguya,
      That's an interesting observation. ... and a big shame, since I'm not intending to take any of these F1s to a second generation. Partly, I simply don't have the space, but also because my main interest is in harnessing the power of F1s for the People! Since **Sunviva** is an F1, there must be some great tasting F1s out there to be found. If Rosella doesn't contribute something interesting to its F1s I'll have to drop it from the programme.

      I also tried ABC x Rosella this year. It was the least productive of all my F1s, so it never entered the taste trials, tho' the fruit looked nice!

      Next years trial of BrandywineC x Rosella will decide whether I drop Rosella or not.

Tim DH

** Oops I meant Sungold! Sunviva isn't an F1!!**

ThomatoGarden

Hello Tim,

To utilize the heterosis effect you need two good parents. with good i mean growth, yield, taste, vitality.
Only then you get a better result. If you cross a bad parent with a good one you still get medium results!

If you cross Brandywine with Rosella you may get a good tasting Tomato but everything else (growth,yield, vitality) would be mediocre.

I am thinking for some time now to refresh this old Heirloom Tomatoes (Pineapple, Brandywine ...) to be more vital but i don't know how.

Greetings Thomas


Roland

Koralik can be a goot parrent for the F1, because it have a gene for brix increase that function dominant, but only in correct environment.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333654182_QTL_mapping_in_salad_tomatoes?fbclid=IwY2xjawG4-NpleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHbNfaBl_70-yvFdgFESjRZpguY0hSnIfnEv5WaVowma2SlT4kL4XO0x3TA_aem_kRtLA0S4Duu7sIysr-OYDg

Also production of Koralik is good and it have some nice resistance.
For late blight Koralik only have the ph2 gene (so not strong enough for Europe)
Netherlands

Tim DH

Hi Thomas,
   Apologies for any confusion. I've been working with BrandyWineCherry, rather than any of the more 'heritage' variants of Brandywine. I've found BWC to be reasonably vigorous.

   My understanding of 'the heterosis effect' is that, so long as the parents aren't closely related, I'm in with a chance!

Hi Roland,
   Thanks for recommending Koralik. I have previously considered working with it, but I'm  not a great fan of Determinates. Next year I will be trying a few of the (Greenhouse derived) DeterminateF1s outside. So, depending on how that goes, I may have space for Koralik in future programmes.

Tim DH

Roland

Determined is recessive so u will not see it in the F1.
Its more easy to use Koralik as pollen parrent because of the small flowers.
Netherlands

ThomatoGarden

Hi Tim,
 
Also Apologies for my a bit harsh post but im trying now for years to find out why some varieties,
including Brandywine wont grow here in the Greenhouse.

examples:
- Pineapple, Old German, German Gold , Brandywine, Cherokee Purple,
 Paul Robson Beefsteak
- Cherokee Lime Stripe, Anawine, Annanas Noire (Pineapple Noire)   

Tried different seed sources, 3 to of compost nothing worked.
Maybe i will try a good rootstock this year.

On the Topic 'Giant of Siebenburgen' is a very vigorous extremly healty plant.
(seeds are available) i will also use it this winter for crossing.

Tim DH

Hi TomatoGarden,
   I can recommend using rootstocks. My first trial, with SubmarineF1, was only just worthwhile. Since then I've used FortaminoF1, which has given me excellent results. The only problem I have is that getting the seed isn't easy!

   Your Primabella x Bulgarian Giant F1 grew really nicely for me. It had better looking leaf health than either Primabella or PotemkinF1. However my miserable season was too short for it. It did produce a bit more than Primabella, but a lot of fruit ended up being cooked green (which I don't count in my records)

Tim DH

 

Adrian

#188
Hi thomatogarden,
What is happend when you tryed to growed thoses varietys in greenhouse?
The grow is slow?
The plants stayed smalls?
The flowers avorted?
The plants caught diseases?

How are the plants before the transplantation in greenhouse?
 No nutriments defisciency?

Havz'e you a irrigation system?

ThomatoGarden

At first they grew just fine, and also produce big fruit, then in early summer some more smaller ones
and then rapidly slow growing and producing. they maybe get 180 cm but very thin weak tip (top 50-80cm).

This year i gave 3 tons of compost and 200 litres of liquid fertilizer (roten plants + pigeon shit)
+ extra fertilizer in a 4x6m Greenhouse,  also tried different seed sources.
Disease is not the problem as this already happens mid summer.
Other Beefsteak Tomatoes direct beside just grow fine and look much more vital, and go on till end of fall
Things i have to try:
- rootstock
- no pruning
- remove most fruit early on
 


Tim DH

I finally finished crunching the numbers for the F1 trials Outdoors

As mentioned earlier we had a really poor growing season, across just about all crops, this year.


Tomato yield on the Allotment averaged 380g per plant. Last year it was 1,200g per plant.

I trialled 4 CherryF1s which have Sunviva as a parent, since Sunviva has some Blight Resistance. ... I also grew PotemkinF1 (from the previous round of Early Red F1s) to compare with Primabella

The average yeild from the F1s was 590g per plant. The average yield from the Open Pollinated varieties was 200g per plant.

The two best F1s were PotemkinF1 (1,058g) and  BrandywineCherry X Sunviva (874g)

The two best OPs were Latah (504g) and Primabella (398g)


Tomato yield at Home was even worse! Average 247g per plant.

The average yield for F1s was 436g per plant. The average yield for OPs was 13g per plant.

The two best F1s were PotemkinF1 ( 663g) and BrandywineCherry X Sunviva (636g)

Only two of the OPs actually produced! Latah (59g) and Primabella (34g)


Two conclusions are: Firstly, that growing tomatoes outdoors here is a gamble. Secondly that using 'Homemade' F1s greatly improves the chances that growing tomatoes outdoors might be worthwhile.

All of the F1s trialled were from greenhouse raised seed. My attempts to produce F1 seed outdoors almost completely failed. Part of the problem seems to have been the difficulty in getting viable pollen. Maybe it was just a bad year. I've not attempted manual crossing outdoors before.

Last year I was sufficiently encouraged by the performance of PotemkinF1 to name it. In this difficult second season PotemkinF1 clearly out-produced Primabella, which, up to this point, has been my favourite outdoor tomato. Last year I think PotemkinF1's Blight resistance gave it the edge. This year I guess it was the earliness inherited from its parents which helped most.

The CherryF1 'BrandywineC x Sunviva' looks promising. I was hoping to trial it against some other Sunviva hybrids next season, however that will have to wait. Just like PotemkinF1, this cross was made as part of my Greenhouse programme. Its apparent suitability to outdoor culture is entirely fortuitous!

Since the best performing OP at both sites was a Determinate (Latah) maybe I should ignore my prejudice and try a few more Determinates outdoors. My principal objections to Determinates are that they are untidy and the fruit, being low down, is very susceptible to molluscs. My plans to raise some specific outdoor F1s largely failed, but I have plenty of F1 seed from the Greenhouse programme, some of that is DeterminateF1. So I'll run with that next season.



Adrian

#191
Warning with the fertilisers Thomatogarden,a  too high quantity of a nutrient can blocked the assimilation of others nutrients.
Some varieties are very sensitives at the nutrients disorders.
Too of natrium and potassium reduced the mainly the phosphore and calcium and the assimilation of others micro-nutrients very importants.
compost seem a good basis but add at the extra fertilizer the nutriments rate can be desequilibrated.

If you given your liquid fertiliser less concentrated but more often in the season you should reduced the leached nutrients
It can be more efficient diluted at a more low rate in the watered water.

Steph S

Sorry to hear about the tough season Tim!  It's bound to happen time to time, and I guess it keeps us on our toes looking for that perfectly tolerant tomato.

Thomatogarden:   There are quite a number of factors that might be cause of big tomato fail, but these I think are most likely:
1) Light limitation:  Are they getting more crowded and less light as the season goes on?  Low light pushes tomatoes towards vegetative vs reproductive growth.  Some are more susceptible than others, but big beefs do tend to be more susceptible IME.   Crowding is often the blame factor for me, in a small greenhouse and cloudy climate
2) Root volume:  IDK if you're growing in containers or in ground, but those large fruited tomatoes need a lot of space for their roots, probably twice the space that a small fruited tomato needs, at least.  A large fruit in a small container is pretty much a guarantee of low production.   Some people do force them with high nutrient flows in small pots, but afaik they only expect a fruit or two per plant for those efforts.

I would definitely suspect either or both of those conditions as the cause of a plant that produces a nice first fruit and then peters out.  Try more lavish spacing - those big plants will produce a lot for the rent, if your season is long enough.
A third factor that applies is fruit support, when you actually get some sets.  The plants are particular about not growing fruit weight that they can't easily support.  So if the plant architecture or support system don't seem to be enough, tying up the fruit really helps.

ThomatoGarden

Hello Tim,

sad to see that you have had such a bad year, it was extremly wet here but still got a good harvest.
Latah is early right? Have you tried Bloody Butcher? Also early and indeterminate and taste not bad.

Hello Adrian,
yes i gave the fertilizer al at once at the start of the season, most plants did very good, so overall
it shouldn't be the problem. 

Hello Steph,
1 and 2 shouldn't be the problem cause neighbor plants (also beefsteak) did pretty good.
But 3, fruit support is what im tending to more and more.

Steph S

@ThomatoGarden if that's the prime suspect, they do say that the earlier you provide support the better.  So as soon as you see sets, put something in place so that the plant feels fruit supported.