Intergeneric - Interfamilial Solanaceae hybrids

Started by Garrett Schantz, 2021-07-05, 10:24:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Garrett Schantz

Figured that I would post another S. laciniatum - the past flower was closing up. S. aviculare is starting to flower now as well.

First image is the S. laciniatum which has large flowers.

Second image is S. aviculare which has flowers closer in size to tomato's. This plant in the middle of a bush habrochaites, was being careful not to step on anything...

Third image is S. sisymbriifolium again. But this time with a bee!

A large completely black Bombus species seems to have moved into my area. It pollinates S. laciniatum and S. sisymbriifolium - and then leaves / comes back. S. habrochaites and some of the other Solanum species are probably too small for the bee to bother with or land on properly. No idea what species of Bombus this is.


Next year there should be more bees looking for these types of flowers in this area again. Some of the larger flowered species that I will be planting next year are closely related, this large species appearing is pretty nice.

Garrett Schantz

If anyone has interesting / edible Solanum - Physalis - Jaltomata - Lycianthes - Capsicum - Cyphomandra species that they would like to mention here, let me know. Always nice to hear about interesting Solanaceae species.


S. lycopersicoides and S. sitiens are probably in the same clade as S. peruvianum - S. habrochaites etc. But they appear to have branched off from each other at some point. Not going to mention those species very much here - those would fit into another thread.

It would be interesting to attempt S. lycopersicoides hybrids with S. caripense or other closely related Solanum species. The offspring could than be further crossed with something like tomatoes.

I am planning on growing a bunch of Jaltomata species together and around S. caripense - Lycianthes moziniana - S. peruvianum pretty much everything. Unlike most Solanaceae species - genera, Jaltomata species produce pollen AND nectar. Honeybees and bumblebees pollinating tomatoes would be amazing (Especially for the SI populations - honeybees form larger groups than Bombus species).

But of course Jaltomata are in their own genus for a reason, they branched off from the other groups a long time ago. There are probably a lot of incompatibilities present.


Nicolas


Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Nicollas on 2021-08-25, 10:55:51 PM
I just bought seeds of a non bitter Physalis alkekengi : https://www.ebay.com/itm/324626063304

If I remember correctly, the main toxins in Physalis alkekengi are solanine along with Physalins (Steroidal compounds). Nice find.

Garrett Schantz

Some leaf comparisons:

Solanum laciniatum in the first image. There is also a habrochaites branch using the plant as a support, I just sort of let it happen. The bees enjoy having the habrochaites and laciniatum flowers side by side from what I can tell.

S. aviculare is the second image.

S. sisymbriifolium is the third image.

S. aviculare and S. laciniatum can look very similar from a distance. S. laciniatum has larger fruit, flowers - also seems hardier so far in comparison to aviculare .


I have mentioned hybrids with S. lycopersicon in the future being of interest.

S. sisymbriifolium has spines - but it does grow upright. Both of these would probably be incompatible to some extent with tomato species - tomatoes are usually vines. I am unsure if S. sisymbriifolium could handle larger fruit without support.

S. laciniatum also grows upright, no spines, flowers are somewhat closer in size to those of tomatoes. I have also noticed a few shoots coming out of the soil surrounding the plant. The fruits are toxic to some extent due to steroidal compounds. The fruits are decent sized for a seemingly undomesticated Solanum species - could probably support tomatoes while staying upright.

After growing S. sisymbriifolium and S. laciniatum, imagining how nice hybrids with tomatoes or pepinos would be - researching Solanum groups, sections and the like, I realized something. These two species are pretty closely related, there are even Kangaroo apple species in Australia with spines and calyxes covering the fruit. Leaf structures on the two species are similar, branching and growth habit are very similar.

Both species have things I want and don't want in a crop. Ideally, I could end up with a plant that has large purple globe shaped flower, medium sized leaves, cold hardy, medium sized edible fruit with no spines. This sort of cross would probably work better in terms of a Lycopersicon cross. I could of course use such a cross to remove existing issues with those species from contaminating a promiscuous tomato population.


I am not expecting any crosses with S. sisymbriifolium and S. laciniatum, I will have excess fruit / seed so I may as well check for anything unusual. They would probably need to be hybridized in a lab setting.

Garrett Schantz

Might as well mention a potential Kangaroo apple hybrid here. Solanum aviculare in particular.

First two image has what appears to be the "normal" type - at least from what I can see on Google images. S. laciniatum and S. aviculare both show up in the image results because S. laciniatum is commonly marketed as S. aviculare.

Next two images have the off-type plant's flower / developing fruit.

Final image has both plants side by side - the normal type on the left, off-type on the right.


I wouldn't be surprised if the off-type plant is a hybrid with S. laciniatum, I bought both species from HRseeds - both are exserted. Maximum leaf sizes are different, flower sizes / colors are slightly different. The plant on the right grew much faster. The off-type plant has deep purple flowers, unlike the normal type.

S. aviculare started flowering later than S. laciniatum and I am worried about whether or not the fruits will develop and mature quickly enough before it gets colder. If I have a hybrid between the two species, I will select for faster growth, edibility and larger flowers.

Dunno if anyone on here knows anything about bush tucker plant - Australian solanum species in particular. I am sort of new to them. Even if there are just variations within populations, I am more than happy with that. I would like to make some hybrids between different Kangaroo apples in the future anyways.

Once the fruits develop more, I can probably say whether one of these are hybrids or not.


A source of information for some species / some images there as well.
http://unusualediblesandtheirwildrelatives.blogspot.com/2017/07/kangaroo-apples-solanum-sect.html

Nicolas

Solanum lycopersicum x S. sisymbriifolium hybrid thanks to embryo rescue

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9

Garrett Schantz

Found a seller on Etsy / Ebay selling S. americanum and S. chenopodioides. The seller is from Florida - both of these species are invasive there. So these are probably the correct species.

I ordered from Etsy originally, bought S. chenopodioides, noticed afterwards that they were selling more items on Ebay - including S. americanum.

If these are both the correct species, they should be diploids.

S. chenopodioides arrived (Yesterday I think?). The seeds are much smaller than "Garden Huckleberry" (Solanum nigrum) seeds and the Sunberry (Solanum retroflexum).

All of my Black Nighshade seeds have came in small plastic bags, I can put the bags over each other to compare sizes, which is quite nice.


As S. chenopodioides and S. americanum can be pretty toxic - especially with wild types, I probably won't really be eating these until I get a few crosses / backcrosses with an edible species. Some sources have noted that some tribes could have gotten cancer due to using S. americanum as a food source. I want to lower the toxins as much as possible while still eventually ending up with diploids.

I also don't want to use these as a base in a S. lycopersicum cross if they are in any way toxic.

Garrett Schantz

#23
Another post on somatic mutations got me thinking a bit.

There are some interesting mutations or rare characteristics present in many different tomato varieties -

Silvery Fir Tree: Slender leaves, short stature

Cherokee Tiger Large: Chartreuse colored foliage, compact growth habit or dwarf

Woolly Kate: Fuzzy leaves (Also has antho traits)

Lutescent - Honor Bright: Leaves that turn yellow, also has cream colored flowers.

Lutescent Long Red - Similar to Honor Bright, the yellowing of the leaves apparently not as pronounced.



The cream colored flower would be very nice in breeding projects.

A lot of other Solanum species have white - cream colored flowers.

S. sisymbriifolium, S. stramoniifolium, S. lasiocarpum, S. quitoense, S. pachyandrum, S. canense, S. caripense, Cyphomandra betacea as well as black nightshades. S. melongena and S. muricatum can also have all-white flowers. Cyphomandra corymbiflora can also be a bit odd with flower colors.

I could incorporate the white flowers into small flower/seed/fruit S. lycopersicon variety that I am creating. Ending up with small cream flowers, small seeds, exsertion could increase the amount of pollinators going back and forth between white flowered solanum species. The small seeds / flower structure will hopefully allow crosses to occur.


S. stramoniifolium, S. lasiocarpum, S. quitoense and a few other species will readily hybridize with each other. These hybrids could be planted near other Solanum interspecific hybrids. May or may not result in any further crosses.

S. caripense has problems crossing over to tomatoes despite being very closely related to them. This could be due to the very small seed size or other factors.



There is a good chance that the cream colored flowers are related or a part of the yellow foliage trait. If this is the case, the plants may be weak / sickly which isn't ideal. Some different wild tomato species have different colored leaves - hopefully I can make something work.

I may purchase Lutescent Long Red and Honor Bright as Lutescent Long Red apparently has a less pronounced yellow effect on the leaves - this could indicate that there are multiple genes that make up the trait. Or another trait is effected the trait. No idea if Lutescent Long Red has the cream flowers.

Unsure if Cherokee Tiger Large and Honor Bright have the same gene responsible for the change in leaf color. I haven't heard of cream or oddly colored flowers on that variety

This could help a lot with any "natural" interspecific crosses. I am assuming that most of them will still need to be cultured. If nothing else I could make some interesting tomato varieties.


Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Nicollas on 2021-09-11, 12:55:08 AM
Solanum lycopersicum x S. sisymbriifolium hybrid thanks to embryo rescue

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9

I have read about that before. Hoping to see if they can be crossed using interspecific hybrids, embryo rescue is probably needed but it doesn't hurt to experiment a bit.


Pollination doesn't seem to be an issue at my garden.
https://www.instagram.com/p/CTxSGAJJGZm/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link

Nicolas

I guess you are aware of the white flower (wf) gene ?


Nicolas

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-09-13, 12:36:25 PM
Another post on somatic mutations got me thinking a bit.
S. caripense has problems crossing over to tomatoes despite being very closely related to them. This could be due to the very small seed size or other factors.

Have you a phylogenetic tree or other kind of resources to assess genetic distance between (edible) solanum species ? I'm interested :)

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Nicollas on 2021-09-13, 11:51:42 PM
Have you a phylogenetic tree or other kind of resources to assess genetic distance between (edible) solanum species ? I'm interested :)

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-08-18, 09:55:51 PM
Next year I will be growing a lot of Solanaceae species. I can get away with starting most of the tropical / subtropical species in January, others need grown indoors. The species that need started indoors will be started as soon as possible. Some of these, I have grown before and saved seed - others are new to me.

Capsiceae:

Lycianthes moziniana – Tlanoxtle

Capsicum annuum

C. chinense

C. chinense x annuum

C. flexuosum

C. rhomboideum

C. baccatum

C. pubescens

C. praetermissum

C. lanceolatum (Possibly)

C. exile (Possibly)

The peppers include a few different varieties depending on the species. I may not grow every single species here as some of them take over 1 - 2 years before they begin to flower. I am starting to amass quite the collection. Hopefully next year I can start some pepper breeding threads.


Morelloid clade:

Solanum retroflexum

Solanum nigrum

Solanum villosum

Solanum melanocerasum (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6070582/ This may not be a species - could be a subspecies, should still fit into the Morelloid)


Archaesolanum subgenus: Kangaroo apples / some Leptostemonum species as well - Australian species

Solanum aviculare

Solanum linearifolium x aviculare

Solanum vescum x aviculare

Solanum laciniatum

Solanum lasiophyllum

Solanum sturtianum

(If anyone is able to send other solanum Bush Tucker species - or Solanum plastisexum - Solanum jobsonii, I would be interested in trading seed)


Subgenus Leptostemonum Listing these separately from the Australian species

Solanum candidum

Solanum stramoniifolium

Solanum quitoense

Solanum pachyandrum

Solanum sisymbriifolium

Solanum abutiloides

A lot of these species fit into different clades in the Leptostemonum subgenus, I might edit this in the future to separate them


Cyphomandra Genus/Clade:

Cyphomandra corymbiflora

Cyphomandra beataceae


Jaltomata Genus:

J. bohsiana

J. ventricosa


Lycopersicon-Potatoe Subgenus/Clade:

Lycopersicon Hybrids

L. peruvianum

L. corneliomulleri

L. habrochaites

L. neorickii

L. pimpinellifolium

L. galapagense

L. cheesmanii

L. chmielewskii

L. lycopersicum

S. caripense

S. muricatum (https://bohs.biology.utah.edu/PDFs/Lynn/Bohs-2005.pdf - https://homepages.uc.edu/~tepeej/EricTepe/Research-Solanum.html)

I am probably going to end up growing more Lycopersicon species than what I listed. This "clade" is still being made, genetic tests and everything else are needed to piece everything together.




I will probably just plant closely related species closer together and see what happens. This is my first time growing most of these species, so I will get a feel for them before I try anything. I did use a phytosanitary to import a lot of these species - so diseases shouldn't be an issue.

This is the current tree that I have put together so far. A lot of these fall into subcategories / clades so I will end up redoing the list at some point.

The Lycopersicon-Potatoe Subgenus/Clade is still in the works. Same story with a few others. But there are sources online that put Pepinos, potatoes and tomatoes into the same group.

Most lists include non-edible species, I will attempt to make some sort of tree with branches shown - clades / groups etc.


Pepinos and S. caripense are closely related to Tomatoes, but they do not cross where they overlap in nature. They probably branched off at some point after incompatibilities started showing up.

Planting interspecific hybrids near Pepinos / S. caripense could result in hybrids. Another large issue would be that Pepinos have oregano sized seeds. Seeds are more or less the embryos - most tomato seeds are probably too large to be compatible.

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Nicollas on 2021-09-13, 11:46:36 PM
I guess you are aware of the white flower (wf) gene ?



Yeah, I read about it a bit earlier. I think that insects will go back and forth between the other Solanum species more frequently with similar colored / sized flowers.

The Honor Bright tomato having leaves that turn yellow, and white flowers is making me think that some sort of mutation caused things to be deleted at some point. This could of course be some other gene causing a change in the flower color.

The mutant first appeared as a sport of Livingston's Stone Tomato in 1894 according to VictorySeeds.


Garrett Schantz

#29
The Experimental Farm Network is selling a Black Nightshade called  West African Njama Njama Landrace, which is a landrace of S. scabrum variants. S. nigrum and villosum could probably hybridize with it as well. S. scabrum's chromosome count can vary a bit from what I have read - a landrace / hybrid population could be interesting.

I am going off a previously cited source for chromosome counts, these can vary due to some species being removed or changed along with just general variation.