Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project

Started by AndrewB, 2021-04-23, 09:42:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

My Solanum peruvianum row has also got pretty flowers. I don't recall checking carefully for fruit set. Will try to next weekend. A few plants or clumps of plants were heavily predated by Colorado potato beetles. One plant a mostly domestic produced one early ripe fruit that proved to be empty. It however seems to now be loaded.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

Last year, I attempted to pollinate Solanum pimpinelifolium, with pollen from the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomatoes project, which I think are self-incompatible. The fruits from the collected seeds are ripening now.

The flavor of the ripening fruits approximates that of Solanum pimpinelifolium, so I am not impressed. They are ripening to yellow/orange, instead of the red that would have been expected from Mendelian genetics in highly inbred domestic lines. That is consistent with hybrids between red domestic tomatoes and Solanum habrochaites, which produces F1 fruits that are yellow/orange.

The crossed plants show hybrid vigor. They are growing much faster and larger than S pimpinelifolium. They are earlier. About 40% of the plants are hybrids. The rest are archetypal of pimpinelifolium.

Flower size and shape of the hybrids closely resembles S pimpinelifolium.

The fruits are much larger (1") than the current tomato mother (3/8").



William Schlegel

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2022-08-08, 06:04:10 AM
My Solanum peruvianum row has also got pretty flowers. I don't recall checking carefully for fruit set. Will try to next weekend. A few plants or clumps of plants were heavily predated by Colorado potato beetles. One plant a mostly domestic produced one early ripe fruit that proved to be empty. It however seems to now be loaded.

I checked for fruit set, I even picked two or three fruits that seemed ripe. Decent fruit set. Need to weed the row- ideally.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Has anyone noticed any lines that are resistant or repellant of tomato hornworms?

Had the second round of picking of hornworms of decimated tomato plants. Oddly only the tomatoes in the raised black bucket planters are affected. The other two raised beds are not affected despite having all the same mostly half wild tomato varieties. I wonder if the soil in those planters is so terrible that these tomatoes attracted the moths when the others did not? Curious.

The S. peruvianum plants seem unaffected.

William Schlegel

My S. Peruvianum row seemed pretty attractive to Colorado potato beetles.

I could send you some seed for LA2329 and back some LA1410. They are the foundation for my arthropod resistance project.

I've never had a tomato hornworm. I saw one once in Utah. Cool looking.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2022-08-17, 06:18:14 PM
My S. Peruvianum row seemed pretty attractive to Colorado potato beetles.

I could send you some seed for LA2329 and back some LA1410. They are the foundation for my arthropod resistance project.

I've never had a tomato hornworm. I saw one once in Utah. Cool looking.

Technically these ones might be tobacco hornworms, but they are more or less the same species. I've not seen them often,  but when I have its only been on tomato plants or grape vine leaves. They are huge. As big as my finger and squishy like a gummy bear when you grab them to pick them off. The moths must be equally as huge. I wonder if they pollinate flowers at night.

Joseph Lofthouse


Tomato hornworms turn into hummingbird moths. They pollinate in late afternoon to evening.

S.Simonsen

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2022-08-17, 08:37:21 AM
Has anyone noticed any lines that are resistant or repellant of tomato hornworms?

Had the second round of picking of hornworms of decimated tomato plants. Oddly only the tomatoes in the raised black bucket planters are affected. The other two raised beds are not affected despite having all the same mostly half wild tomato varieties. I wonder if the soil in those planters is so terrible that these tomatoes attracted the moths when the others did not? Curious.

The S. peruvianum plants seem unaffected.

John Kempf has a lot of talks explaining how insects can only eat plants with unbalanced nutrition (often excess nitrogen but there are other potential issues). Sounds like you observed the phenomenon in action with your tomatoes on different soil.

William Schlegel

#113
One of my local friends recently had their entire garden wiped out by grasshoppers. Likely common species in the genus Melanoplus such as Melanoplus sanguinipes https://fieldguide.mt.gov/speciesDetail.aspx?elcode=IIORT01210 which given its massive range those of you in North America would likely recognize as a familiar species. They said the tomatoes were one of the last things but even trees and shrubs were defoliated. I worked with some grasshopper researchers a few years back on a small project for school and one of the things I found out was that they had studied the importance of grasshoppers for nutrient cycling. This is a very important natural process and the researchers actually opposed grasshopper control both chemical and biological because they thought it so important to allow the nutrient cycling to progress.

In my own garden this year I have struggled with Colorado potato beetle in just one of my seven gardens spread out over the eight useable acres of the garden land. It had a non-uniform effect on the tomato plants, and this could correlate to nutrients in part. For instance, it hit rather hard in an area where I added some composted barnyard manure, we purchased last year. The garden in question has potato beetles because it has a large natural population of an annual nightshade which attracts them. Then when the larvae are hungry, they also attack tomato plants. They attacked their preferred host even more this year and I had a question in my mind about if they would even produce seed. Not to fear I noticed some berries forming on the annual nightshade. I plan to turn this to my advantage next year and move the arthropod resistance project to the garden in question. However, I had wondered if the effect could be made more uniform within the garden. One thought I had would be to collect nightshade seed and seed it with the tomato seed. To try to make the nightshade sort of uniform in the hopes that would improve the uniformity of potato beetle attack. I've also wondered in places in this same garden if my tomato seedlings were suffering from a bit of flea beetle attack like what Joseph and Andrew describe in their direct seeding attempts. Not uniform though. It would be nice to have a nice uniform arthropod problem! Of course, I asked my friend with the grasshoppers if they might be willing to grow a replicate of the arthropod resistance project and they said yes. Though I doubt that will be nice and uniform two years in a row.

Hmm. Just had a thought. For the grasshopper experiments we used cages to keep them in. Also, it seems to me that it's just possible that Colorado potato beetles and larvae especially can be picked off one plant and placed on another.

Also, another thought. What if I used a bit of a unbalanced organic nitrogen source on a replicate like say just add blood meal? Or maybe specifically marked out a couple of the real problem spots this year to try to put a replicate in a problem spot specifically?

I wonder if standard soil testing might be able to pick up anything (like a nitrogen imbalance) about why a problem spot is a problem spot?

All in an attempt to get a replicate with uniform arthropod predation so that the differences between resistance in individuals would stand out. Hmm, would also be nice to have tomato clones.

Ok slight change of topic: Within this garden there is a patch of dense volunteer promiscuous project tomatoes. Because the patch is so dense fruit set is minimal. That is within species competition was very high. So these plants have been subjected to high competition and have exhibited some arthropod resistance as portions of the row got hit hard by the potato beetles. However, I might be looking at something like 20 small tomatoes from ~1000 dense plants. Interesting right? Also just saying, if your volunteer or direct seeded tomatoes come up too thick it might be a good idea to thin if you don't want to test for within species competitive ability or if you want very many seeds back. I generally never thin but there was a certain stretch of a direct seeded patch last year I seeded too densely and had a similar effect and now this. Wondering how Joseph's direct seeded patch did this year from a within species competition standpoint?

Also in contrast, Joseph sent me a relatively small seed lot for his survivors from his promiscuous project direct seeding in 2021. I seeded it in three rows, and it came up relatively sparsely and is looking great. It is in the Northeast Garden with the Carol Deppe squash, the flint corn, and what look to be some volunteer exserted tiger tomatoes but those are just far enough away from the promiscuous project tomatoes that I doubt much crossing will occur- possible but my guess is really low rates compared to if they were interplanted- which they were last year as last year's direct seeded mix in that garden included both ET and Promiscuous. The ET is also doing great, but it was bred largely by direct seeding in my garden so it kind of stands to reason that it would do great in my garden.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

S.Simonsen

I have seen a plague of caterpillars- dozens of different species bursting into enormous populations at the same time. It happened after a prolonged drought (when nitrate tends to accumulate in soil) which was broken by a series of thunderstorms (which also dump nitrogen into the soil- you aren't imagining it when plants look extra green after storms). This was sustained over a long enough period to allow two generations of butterflies to reproduce and create the boom.

You have to wonder if such a nitrogen overflow is a functional part of the system and not some kind of error.

As to your questions- definitely check out the extensive work of John Kempf on plant-insect relationships. No need to reinvent the wheel.

William Schlegel

#115
I got several more just first blush ripe "The One" fruits and a little pumpkins fruit that I would be very surprised if has any seeds.

I also got the first few ripe fruits from the Lofthouse direct seeded promiscuous project plants.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Quote from: S.Simonsen on 2022-08-20, 03:01:07 PM
I have seen a plague of caterpillars- dozens of different species bursting into enormous populations at the same time. It happened after a prolonged drought (when nitrate tends to accumulate in soil) which was broken by a series of thunderstorms (which also dump nitrogen into the soil- you aren't imagining it when plants look extra green after storms). This was sustained over a long enough period to allow two generations of butterflies to reproduce and create the boom.

You have to wonder if such a nitrogen overflow is a functional part of the system and not some kind of error.

As to your questions- definitely check out the extensive work of John Kempf on plant-insect relationships. No need to reinvent the wheel.

Interesting. I had tried to also grow peas in these planters this year and they did poor. Nitrogen excess could be a real possibility.

In all three spots, especially the other two, I think LA1996 has been doing the best in terms of production,  lack of disease,  and some resistance to poor soil. The slight purple blush on the fruits might also deter pests to some degree. Perhaps the S. chilense ancestry has a big effect. Might be worth crossing into this project by hand.

William Schlegel

Crosses are fun.

Had a small tomato from MMS x unknown. Bright red. Figured was MMS x ET till I cut it open. Kind of yellow inside. Great flavor. MMS x promiscuous I'm guessing.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Tried my first "The One" still good. 10 seeds.

Tried my first little pumpkins yellow and yucky, need to pull that plant! Zero seeds.

Tried my first five ripe direct seeded promiscuous all yucky, bitter. Fermenting the seed but wrote a yucky warning on it already. Not sure if I should toss them?!

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Nicolas

So The One has the same persimmon taste this year William ? :)