Spaghetti Squash

Started by Lauren, 2020-10-22, 06:10:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Lauren

I want to do a spaghetti squash landrace, so last year I crossed spaghetti squash with pumpkin and zucchini. One of each grew and fruited. I haven't tried the pumpkin x yet, but the other acted just like a spaghetti squash, but with the initial coloring and shape of the zucchini. It ripened to the normal orange. Next year I'll plant the F2's next to each other.

I learned something interesting today that makes me wonder. Apparently the "stranding" of the spaghetti squash is created by a specific recessive gene (sp) which theoretically wouldn't exist in the pumpkin or zucchini populations. According to what I read, spaghetti squash would almost require an inbred population in order to retain its expected behavior.

I can't find anything indicating whether this is something specific to this variety, or if it might be in all pepos to various levels. Any ideas?

Ocimum

No idea, but I had a similar idea but with introducing the hullless gene into spaghetti squashes, to have a dual purpose one.

Lauren


Ferdzy

From eating a lot of squash, it's plain to me that with poor conditions or careless seed saving, pretty much all squash can become unpleasantly stringy. Spaghetti squash takes that unpleasant stringiness to a logical extreme, with the result that it is so bad, it's good. That's my theory anyway.

One of my big complaints about spaghetti squash: the ones I've grown in my own garden have been good (as have been, I think, farmers' market ones). The ones I buy at the grocery store have been so frequently poor that I don't even bother any more. By poor, I mean they are not super stringy, but have soft flesh interspersed with the strings, leading to a dish of mushy, stringy squash instead of something spaghetti-like. I do not know what makes the commercial ones so sucky. Poor quality seed source? Sub-optimal growing conditions? I'll say lack of educated consumer feed-back, for sure.

Because spaghetti squash exists at an extreme end of squash traits, I'm not sure it's ideal for the landrace idea. But obviously I think there is some room for improvement there, so worth playing around with it. I have never bothered trying to save seed as we grow so many pepos, and my impression of multi-crossed pepos is that they frequently revert to the lowest common denominator, otherwise known as lousy.

Lauren

It's something I have seeds for, and a variety of squash the people around me like. So I figure it's worth a try.

I don't want an inbred variety, though, hence adding in the zucchini and Pumpkin genes. Hopefully I can stabilize to something more robust that will actually thrive here but has the same traits.

Lauren

This year I planted the zucchetti and pumpetti early, so they endured one frost and very cold temperatures for a few months. One plant survived, which turned out to be a zucchetti and currently has two ripening squash (size and approximate shape of a spaghetti squash, stripes of a zucchini). I planted others after the cold ended.

I will be removing all male blossoms from the spaghetti squash plants so they have to be pollinated by the others. Seeds will primarily be kept from the pure spaghetti squash, although I also want genes from the zucchetti that is apparently cold tolerant. So far only the one zucchetti is old enough to bloom.

Lauren

I opened up the first of the zucchetti. We had it for lunch. The second is in storage to see how long it lasts.

The skin was incredibly hard, similar to the full sized seed zucchini, which I need to break open with a sledge hammer or on the cement steps. The flesh was green instead of orange or yellow, but still did the spaghetti squash thing. Most strands were an inch or two long, but they were there. The taste was slightly stronger than zucchini but different from both parents.

So in this one plant, after two generations I have the production of the zucchini (4 more currently on the plant, and more female blossoms coming), the quick ripening of the spaghetti squash, the flesh of the spaghetti squash, and some (possible) level of cold tolerance.

I bring my quandary to you. The pure bred spaghetti squash aren't big enough to bloom yet. I had planned to take all the male blossoms off those and use them as my primary female parent for the next generation to reinforce the spaghetti traits. But now I have this other, with most of the traits I want.

Possibilities:

1) Continue as planned and ignore the possible fluke
2) Use this zucchetti as the primary female parent, knowing it might not cross back into the spaghetti squash
3) Keep seeds for both and cross back into the spaghetti squash next year
4) Other ??

Adrian

#7
It difficult but in your place i will have try to did the cross in the two sens, the season is not finish and the spaghetti squash will well open a male flower one day.

For the solution 2 it is possible to found the spaghetti squash in the f2 plants but not sure.You will have 2/8 of spaghetti squash.
If you lost the characters of the spaghetti squash you lost nothing to cross again the f2 plants with the pure spaghetti squash.

William Schlegel

I keep seed saving spaghetti squash. My mom thought my pepo squash F1 between Goldini and Mandan was a spaghetti squash this year. Tempted to cross it with the spaghetti squash and just go ahead and make a spaghetti squash.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days