Brassica carinata

Started by S.Simonsen, 2020-08-19, 06:51:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

S.Simonsen

I am wondering how many people are familiar with this wonderful (hybrid oleracea x nigra) species. It is traditionally grown in Ethiopia so is sometimes called Ethiopian/Abyssinian spinach/kale. It grows to nearly 1 m tall with large mid green juicy leaves that have a flavor similar to asian brassicas like pak choi. I sow in autumn in our subtropical climate and it doesnt bolt until spring, even if the weather is uneven and difficult. It seems to have a very strong root system. When it flowers it produces masses of seed (it is sometimes used as an oil seed crop), but I like adding it to green manure mixes.

Is there much genetic diversity in this species? In Australia we often miss out on variations, though I have never seen anything mentioned online.

Ocimum

You may be interested in Crambe abyssinica, which is also called Abyssinian kale. (or is it even the same, with different authors using a different scientific name?)

I came across this recently
https://www.vupt.cz/en/breeding-program/katran-etiopsky

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: Ocimum on 2020-08-19, 08:34:49 AM
You may be interested in Crambe abyssinica, which is also called Abyssinian kale. (or is it even the same, with different authors using a different scientific name?)

I came across this recently
https://www.vupt.cz/en/breeding-program/katran-etiopsky

Google images shows a different leaf color for Crambe abyssinica seems like, it also appears to have globe shaped seed pods(Crambe usually have those). So I would say that they are in a different genus. Have grown two different species from the Crambe genus (Crambe tataria and Crambe maritima from Cultivariable) Something ate them down as seedling though. I tried the leaves and they both tasted a bit different with texture / taste to Brassicas which are in the same family. Some Crambes are also biannual - perennial.

I haven't noticed much diversity within Brassica carinata, could be due to status as a hybrid. I haven't noticed it crossing back to any parent species, so it could be stuck with whatever the two original parent's genes were / only crossing with it's current "new species". Granted it could be that we only have certain types available outside of Ethiopia where it supposedly came about.

Walk

Are either of these plants similar to Camelina sativa? It's seeds are used as an oil source.

S.Simonsen

Crambe abyssinica is interesting but definitely a different genus (white flowers, puffy seed pods).

Interesting to see other people also havent seen any variation in the B. carinata around. I suspect it was an isolated original hybrid. Funny it is so stable now- I wonder how all the hybrid diversity was weeded out of it but left such an incredibly vigorous plant. Ethiopia has some truly amazing indigenous crops the world doesn't know about.

I wonder if there is any point trying to repeat the nigra x oleracea origin of the carinata line. I grow both but the idea of hand pollinating brassica flowers doesn't appeal to me. In many ways I don't really care since carinata is already so exceptionally good at what it does and I can't see any reason to improve it.

triffid

I think this is also known as Texsel Greens? If so, I've grown it here in England, and enjoyed it very much. As far as I'm aware there's only one variety available here.
Zone 9a - brown calcareous earth, high natural fertility base-rich loam - coastal maritime climate

Diane Whitehead

I sowed it last week for the first time, with seeds from Westcoast Seeds in Vancouver.  It germinated in four days.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

S.Simonsen

Texcel greens is the same species, but to my eyes it looks quite distinct from my form (not dramatically so, but the whiter veins stand out to me at least). I will give this one a go and try mixing it into my existing carinata line.

I agree about the germination and growth. It is by far my strongest growing brassica. If I only had to grow one brassica this would be it.

Steph S

B. carinata is certainly interesting, I haven't had a chance to grow it yet but there's a lot to be said for the multiple stress tolerance (drought, heat and frost - nice!).  I've mostly considered using it as a rotation for garlic, for the biofumigant potential (and condiment seed).

It seems that a number of different varieties have been obtained by selection for specific traits especially oil content and type - so for example, if I were to find a seed source selling B. carinata as a biofumigant, it would probably be the seed line that was selected for that purpose, while the Texcel were selected for greens.

There's a ton of information about cross breeding with other brassicas as well, if you scroll down this document:
https://www.inspection.gc.ca/plant-varieties/plants-with-novel-traits/applicants/directive-94-08/biology-documents/brassica-carinata/eng/1501087371874/1501087468251

S.Simonsen

I am also curious about using the abundant seed to make something like mustard. Do you think there are any potential toxicity issues to worry about? Raw crushed mustard seed isnt exactly "edible"....that is kind of the point of mustard right? Even my vegetable strain produces so much seed I never quite know what to do with it (though it is great for green manure rotations- that is how I mostly grow it now while still harvesting greens lightly from each plant)

Daniel C.

For some mustard seed there could be the issue of erucic acid, but I doubt it would be an issue if using it as a condiment or spice. I wouldn't try to get oil out of them

S.Simonsen

I did some simple research and mustard is made from a range of other brassica species (even Sinapis alba) so there is no obvious reason why carinata would not work. All those have some erucic acid in them, and apparently the early rat feeding trials showing toxicity don't translate well to human physiology. Looks like I will need to do some kitchen experiments and report back. I wonder if some mustard like condiment already exists in Ethiopian cuisine and I am just reinventing the wheel.

reed

There is possibility of some kind of toxicity in mustard seeds?? I hope not cause I have often crushed them up with a little bit of vinegar and used them as well, mustard. I do the same thing with radish seed. I like them both, I sometimes eat them when immature, they taste great I think. Only small amounts as it a lot of hassle to remove them from the pods so maybe it's not  problem?

Walk

We've always used various mustard seeds for cooking uses, old batches of seed that are downgraded to the kitchen. The quantities used are small so if there are bad compounds in them the amount we're consuming is very little. But this year we grew the yellow-seeded mustard, Brassica hirta (or Sinapsis alba), just for culinary use. Haven't got the batch cleaned up yet to try. My friend, Kathleen of Plum Creek Seeds, passed this seed on to me and she said that she thought that the bristly (hairy) pods helped to protect them from birds. I also observed that the birds left our patch alone, preferring seedpods of the Osaka and other mustards growing nearby. That is a big plus in our garden.

Steph S

From what I have read, the issue with erucic acid is when it is present in oil used for cooking on a regular basis, so forming quite a significant part of the diet.   In some countries rapeseed oil (with high erucic acid) is the preferred cooking oil, so you could consume quite a bit of it by daily use.
I haven't seen any comment about hazards of mustard as a condiment anywhere.
In western Canada where a lot of mustard is grown, there is one variety of "Oriental Mustard" (B juncea) which was bred for zero erucic acid and could be used for oil:
https://www.nrcresearchpress.com/doi/pdf/10.4141/CJPS09155

https://www.mustard21.com/canadian-varieties/oriental-mustard/

But the other mustards which are grown, appear to be selected for other traits - there's no mention of erucic acid.  Nothing here about B. carinata so I guess it's use or cultivation has not taken off as competition to the others.

https://www.mustard21.com/canadian-varieties/yellow-mustard/

https://www.mustard21.com/canadian-varieties/brown-mustard/

My favorite (bought) mustard condiment is an 'old fashioned' style mustard which is a mix of brown and yellow seeds in a base of powdered yellow.  I would think that mixing seeds whole and/or crushed/powdered in some ratio with vinegar and salt would pretty well be it.  :)