Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Only have one cell left to plant, a cell of S. peruvianum because I failed to bring back a seed packet from the seed store out on the garden land.

Planted:
twelve cells of LA 2329 S. habrochaites
132 additional cells of Big Hill x W4 F2
3 Cells S. pennellii
5 Cells of purish penellii F1 and F2
3 Cells BH-3 species
4 Cells S. hab pollinated by BH x W
1 cell dwarf hirsutum cross
1 cell weight in gold
1 cell wild child
13 cells Solanum arcanum
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#46
Planted that last cell with five seeds of peruvianum from Joseph's 2018 large seeded selection. Will thin to one plant for the penellii isolation- if it works. The major fail point could be me getting real pure penellii to grow and bloom successfully. Though if it failed I would try to use the pureish penellii but would that have a chance of success?

I noticed that the F2 purish penellii seed is much larger than the F1 purish penellii seed. Suggesting that it is indeed a hybrid. The question is, with what (found old post below)? It was an isolation experiment Joseph did in 2018 where he planted one penellii amongst something like everything but pure penellii. Peruvianum was among the possible pollen parents along with penellii x domestic. The F2 seeds are almost perfectly the same size as Arcanum and peruvianum seeds- just a little bigger than the penellii seeds. Or it could be something very similar to the 75% hab with hab as the mother but instead penellii as the mother a 75% penellii. Whatever the F1 was last year, the F2 had three way, penellii x domestics F1 and F2?, and 3/4 habrochures within easy pollinator access. So the F2 seedlings could be 5/8th penellii, or three way hybrids with 3/8 penellii. If by some miracle there was peruvianum in there in 2019 then pollination by the likes of Threeway could have lead to some four way seedlings. Though every thing looked pretty penellii last year so best guess is it was 3/4 penellii and most likely pollinated by the penellii hybrids. Another possibility is pollination by the 3/4 hab plants which were champion pollen producers. If so, the result might be a 3/8 habrochaites and 3/8 penellii with 1/4 domestic.

Quote from: @joseph" source="/post/129733/thread" timestamp="1534709475I harvested 7 fruits from a S pennellii plant that was grown away from other S pennellii, but with F2:[domestic x habrochaites] or F2:[domestic X pennellii], or S peruvianum, or S corneliomulleri as possible pollen donors. Guess that I'll check for seeds in a week or so.

I'm likewise not finding many seeds in the inter-species hybrid fruits. Enough to continue the project, but not near as many as I had been hoping for, compared to the quantity of fruits that I have harvested. Fruits that I hand pollinated early in the season were much seedier than mid-season fruits that were allowed natural pollination.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Interesting. I think crossing ability goes up between species when they are already shuffled in hybrids.

But generally even with tomatoes it seems that bumblebees still generally travel from plant to plant next to each other,  so statistically speaking whatever was literally right next that plant is most likely to have pollinated it (if it was producing viable pollen).

The original F2 pennellii seed I shared one plant was actually grown right next to a flowering peruvianum plant that the bees kept jumping from one to the other. I did have other F1 penellii plants in a row in the garden which also produced seed and were not terribly far away,  so its hard to say what actually pollinated what, but the possibility is there.

The real question is how to tell if a plant actually has peruvianum traits... or if those are pennellii traits when combined with domestic traits...

William Schlegel

Yeah, though all of the above were quite close. I think that F2 penellii started out the closest and then Threeway eventually outgrew them and literally came to be touching the purish penellii. The new F1 you (Andrew) sent was just on the far side of the three way. The three or so 75% habrochaites that were prodigious pollen producers were within ten feet as well. The new Arcanum was across the garden but it may have travelled over via pollen spoon. Wish I had planted them side by side.

I had some seedlings last year that came up unmarked and looked like peruvianum. When they grew up they turned out to be the variety coyote. So looks can deceive. The specific strains of Arcanum I am working with is supposed to produce 0.2 viable seeds per pollination of domestic. So possible hybrids are out there. Though I suspect that I'll have lots of 50% Arcanum and 50% peruvianum. Though not necessarily as species barriers may exist. I think I dumped all the peruvianum seed I grew into a wild direct seeding mix and the reciprocal cross possibility as well. Now I hesitate to plant that mix because it needs to be kept separate from most things and I think most of my isolation gardens will be quite small. Perhaps 10 x 10.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

#49
Joseph, do you think you could create a wild species leaf or growth visual identification chart like you did with squash? Or is there too much variety for something like that to work? Do certain traits run In tomato families or are similar in some that they could be grouped in a rough dichotomous key?

Edit: I guess there is this https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/key.aspx

But it isn't very helpful to me because I need visual pictures,  and most of the terminology I don't know, so one translated into easy to understand terminology would be much more helpful. Maybe I will write to the tgrc and see if they can make an updated one with pictures.

Joseph Lofthouse


Joseph Lofthouse

#51
In my garden, S pennellii is a little delicate plant. If one ever grew that was robust, I would suspect it of being an interspecies hybrid. If one ever grew in my typical garden soil and potting mixes, I would suspect it of being an interspecies hybrid. And fruits from a pennellii mother with purple tint to them, or with stripes would be suspected interspecies hybrids.

I typically grow S pennellii in one gallon pots, with the only type of soil that I've ever found in which they grow adequately. It would be easy to grow both S pennellii and S peruvianum in pots, and put them into an isolation garden for some type of pollination.... (edited this paragraph)


The rounded leaf trait of S pennellii seems to be strongly conserved. Which is another way to identify suspected hybrids showing up in other populations.

William Schlegel

#52
I'm a little dubious about my ability to grow pure penellii. That one ~75%? Purish penellii plant last year was the closest I've come. Previous attempts died young. So Joseph if you end up growing a penellii plant you want to put in with peruvianum I am all for it! The more replicates the better.

I thought it was Penellii as a pollen donor that worked? I was thinking one peruvianum and as many penellii as I manage to grow. I guess I put all my Joseph grown pure penellii seeds from 2018 and 2020 into three cells. I did that because a small clump is how I grew  the Purish plant that survived last year. Though only one of the plants produced.

Curious as to how arcanum might play into this. It will donate pollen to domestic, but will it, like peruvianum, accept pollen from penellii?

It would be too cool if my purish penellii did have peruvianum as a parent. If so though, it would be down to 25% in the seed I produced and clearly not dominate. However not this year, but next year's seed might be telling if anything cool like that were in the mix. I planted a new cell with the F1 and four with the G2. All with multiple seeds. Will be interesting to see what it does this year. Would be nice to confirm it's hybrid nature and get hints at which of the possible pollen donors it accepted in both generations.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse

#53
I trialed S pennellii in lots of different soils. One batch of compost was the only one that thrived. It was obvious from even tiny seedlings which worked best. Therefore, I keep a bin of that compost specifically for growing pennellii, and nothing else. Sometimes, I'll fill a pot with that soil, and then sink it's bottom into my garden soil for better moisture retention and so I don't have to monitor soil moisture so carefully.


Quote from: William S. on 2020-03-20, 05:18:40 PMI thought it was Penellii as a pollen donor that worked?

It would suck to try to make the cross in the wrong direction!!!!!

William Schlegel

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2020-03-20, 08:26:45 PM
I trialed S pennellii in lots of different soils. One batch of compost was the only one that thrived. It was obvious from even tiny seedlings which worked best. Therefore, I keep a bin of that compost specifically for growing pennellii, and nothing else. Sometimes, I'll fill a pot with that soil, and then sink it's bottom into my garden soil for better moisture retention and so I don't have to monitor soil moisture so carefully.


It would suck to try to make the cross in the wrong direction!!!!!

I think you said peruvianum as mother abouy a year ago. Then Andrew said he was going to try the other way recently. Then you said one penellii amongst peruvianum. So I'm confused and haven't looked at the source material. Pretty much just trying to keep up with you too on this particular cross! Also you kind of already tried peruvianum as father with the strain I keep calling purish penellii. For which something worked cause it grew for me and it set seed, and that seed is larger than the seed from the original packet you sent me...

Could just plant both species together with multiple plants of each and hope for the best...
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Joseph Lofthouse


https://vanderknaaplab.uga.edu/files/Bedinger_Sex_Plant_Review.pdf

I found this article that says pennellii can pollinate habrochaites, but the reciprocal cross didn't work. (habrochaites can only pollinate itself and the red-fruited species).

Pennellii can pollinate the red-fruited species, habrochaites, and sometimes peruvianum.

Therefore,  a patch of pennellii with one peruvianum plant, or one habrochaites plant.

I tried the peruvianum --> habrochaites cross, and got no fruit set on the habrochaites.

It might be possible to break off the style, and apply pollen directly to the wound, which would greatly minimize the distance that the pollen would need to grow to find it's mate.




William Schlegel

Why not one peruvianum and one habrochaites?

Nick just posted on the crossing peruvianum thread. My Arcanum accessions are a bit of a dead end. Incompatible with peruvianum supposedly. So only interesting in their own right as a pollen parent on domestic. However, that could prove interesting. They did well for a first year wild. However, might be imporant to make an extremely large number of deliberate crosses as F1's need other F1's something someone maybe Walt mentioned once. Casual crosses as might occur on my exserteds are liable to occur then die out for lack of a pollen donor in the F1. So far deliberate crosses work best for me indoors. That possibly means having a decent population of plants indoors.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

#57
I haven't read the Bedinger papers in awhile,  but they are the most informative on this subject. I really like the cut style idea because I think from what I read sometimes the incompatibility is just the amount of energy the pollen has to move through,  and sometimes shorter styles do help.

The other was the forcing pollination on -5 day old immature flowers with some sort of style exudiate sticky stuff to help the pollen stick (like the walnut oil mix talked about before).

It probably would help if trying it in the correct direction, but I'm not sure the correct direction should be chosen based only on only one lab's study. Though, it's a start and a hint of what might work. So probably a lot of reading for me would be what I would need to do to see if that has been replicated by anyone else.

William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days