Breeding with wild tomato species

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-19, 02:22:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Diane Whitehead

Thanks!

One more question:  What do you send in to be tested?  Seeds?
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

William Schlegel

Quote from: Diane Whitehead on 2023-11-19, 02:25:03 PMThanks!

One more question:  What do you send in to be tested?  Seeds?

Fairly sure it is leaf tissue. Seeds are already the next generation.

Sometimes you can run these tests on large numbers of very young seedlings to make improbable outcomes actually happen.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-19, 08:36:44 AMA single tomato species from the mainland: likely an ancestor to Solanum pimpinillifolium colonized one island.
Solanum pimpinillifolium is red, but elders do not remember red tomatoes on island, only yellow. DNA of S.cheesmaniae and S.galapagense is only 56% same. So S.cheesmaniae became yellow from green-fruited parent like S.pimpinellifolium did. S.galapagense is hairy like hairy tomatoes S.habrochaites.

Alex

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-19, 08:05:52 AMYes, those are Wojciech's descriptions of the two he grows. And he is very knowledgable about plants. But my doubts explained above remain.
I have doubts too, but the seed size is too large to be a S.cheesmaniae x S.palapagense hybrid, but it could be a S.palapagense x S.pimpinellifolium hybrid or who knows.

William Schlegel

#409
Quote from: Alex on 2023-11-19, 07:03:59 PMSolanum pimpinillifolium is red, but elders do not remember red tomatoes on island, only yellow. DNA of S.cheesmaniae and S.galapagense is only 56% same. So S.cheesmaniae became yellow from green-fruited parent like S.pimpinellifolium did. S.galapagense is hairy like hairy tomatoes S.habrochaites.

I should clarify: I was guessing what happened not in the time of elders, but in some time millions of years ago. I was trying to explain a slightly improved model for thinking about speciation. For this purpose I did not google the precise facts of the real place. Some more precise facts can be found here: https://moylelab.bio.indiana.edu/evolution.html in this diagram from the Moyle lab in Indiana. It clearly shows that the four species in the esculentum group are closely related to each other. Interestingly the time frame for speciation from the diagram for the group of four is all within the last half million years and some of it on the recent side of that! Still deep time though.

So I have edited the original but will also add it here:

So: say we use volcanic islands as a classic (and hypothetical without precise Googling of facts so we will letter the species) example. Periodically a new island has formed, and an old island has sunken below the waves. A single tomato species from the mainland millions of years ago: Species X colonized one island. Over deep time that tomato changed due to adaptation and to genetic drift. Eventually that tomato became say Species Y. Then the tomato did some island hopping- again over deep time. On one of the smaller islands there wasn't much habitat so the tomato got better at living on the coast and became Species Z over deep time. This allowed the tomatoes to occupy the two sharply differentiated habitats available on the island coastal and inland. Could have been the coastal species first and the inland species second either way works for this example. Some more Island hopping occurred over deep time. Now many of the islands have populations of both species, though on each island those two species are likely very genetically and morphologically distinct from those on other islands with lots of time between gene flow events, during ice ages the islands are larger and thus closer together with more gene flow, and during interglacial periods smaller and farther apart. Enter modern times with humans with big silly boats full of gawking tourists. These silly humans have reintroduced Species X AND its domestic relative Species XX and now recent hybridizations have occurred given these newly broken-down geographic barriers.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#410
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-19, 09:08:19 AMI think with tomatoes specifically, that we are creating a little bit of a false narrative when we say that the normal mainstream way is to just bring in small introgressions with the specific traits commercial conventional tomato farmers want. This is because the introgressions are actually quite large and are accumulating over time from multiple species. These introgressions, especially when they vary from variety to variety, do make modern tomatoes a very good source of wild germplasm especially when compared to true heirlooms.

Yes, I get that  modern tomatoes are way more genetically diverse than heirlooms. But I guess I still have curiosity around:
1) I wonder what kind of percentage of wild genetics there is in commercial tomato varieties now.
2) I wonder if there may be qualitative advantages to 'amateur' genetic diversity over 'professional' genetic diversity.

On the second point, I'm thinking about the pressure of commercial selection criteria, specifically around growing conditions and farming methods. For example, are they slanting genetic selection to favour pesticide, fertiliser, and irrigation usage? And large greenhouses? For example if two groups of varieties or populations have 10% wild genetics but that 10% is taken up in one group by market driven phenotypes while keeping the growth-related genetics fairly homogenous in terms of performance in growing conditions, that might not be as useful in the face of climate change in a low input farming system, as a group where 10% of the genetics is wild but that is distributed over an array of diverse growth traits, such as variable root systems, tolerance to periods of dryness or variable nutrient availability, performance in different soil types or light levels, or whatever else.

I'm really just thinking aloud here but anyway these are some of the things on my mind.

I guess also just out of curiosity I'd find it interesting to see where different varieties lie in relation to different species. Like this image of where some cheesmaniae hybrids (indicated by arrows) lie relative to the pure species. 'Principal component analysis (PCA) of SNP markers identified from 67 samples of S. galapagense, S. cheesmaniae, S. pimpinellifolium, and S. lycopersicum, where each species/taxon clusters together, except for two accessions (indicated by arrows).':

Screenshot 2023-11-20 at 13.02.29.png

Source: Genetic Diversity and Population Structure of Two Tomato Species from the Galapagos Islands

I think I have maybe seen a dendrogram showing the relationship of various cherry tomatoes to pimp, maybe? The most I could find while searching now was in the paper 'Phenotypic and genetic diversity of Spanish tomato landraces.', which includes pennellii in one of their diagrams:
Screenshot 2023-11-20 at 12.43.09.png

Not so interesting but I'd love to see the various genetic analyses of various wild species plus old and new tomatoes all combined, to get an idea of where things lie in terms of rough amounts of which species. Though of course performance is the important thing after all.

Regarding marker assisted analysis for traits, $500 for 128 samples sounds interesting! I could imagine for example, that if a few folk within one country or region were all working on projects, perhaps they could band together to do testing, not each requiring such a large number. I could imagine for example crossing with a ph-2+3 homozygous tomato, deliberately infecting a large group of F2 seedlings with late blight, then having the survivors tested for those two genes. The infection treatment might screen out any without both genes, or maybe only ph-3 homozygous with hetero or no ph-2 might scrape through, but a final genetic test could be great after having narrowed it down as best as possible, to weed out all but ph-2+3 homozygous plants. I feel like I would rather do it that way and then be free to continue to select manually for other traits as the diversity continues over the next generations, whether aiming for stable varieties or a largely or purely outcrossing population, without having to worry anymore about the late blight trait, that being fixed.

I find the hybrid story rather sad. It does seem that that's the easiest way to make money from seeds, and it seems worth considering. But it also seems immoral somehow. I feel conflict there. Work should be rewarded, and if one can't be rewarded for ones very hard work of breeding by selling OP seeds, there is logic in the F1 root. But maybe it makes me think that the financial system is at fault there. Someone spends a vast amount of time breeding a variety, then as soon as they sell a packet of seeds, others grow them as start selling the seeds, and the market is gone! (Unless the breeder is a competitively successful marketer!)

This makes me ponder a different relationship between farmers and breeders. If breeders pay so much for F1 seeds, then we see willingness there to spend money on a good product. If the farmer would save their own seeds if that good product were OP, then we see the farmer valuing seeds being OP. I could imagine a scenario where instead of a cold commercial relationship between farmer and seed products, might instead be a more direct relationship with a breeder or breeders. Like, if a farmer were to consider these things perhaps:

- How much money will I spend on seeds over the next 20 years? (Or longer!)
- What will my harvests be like over that time?
- How pleased will my customers be?
- How will I feel in my heart about what I'm growing?
- How will the environment be affected by my activities?
- How do I feel emotionally about the breeders of my seeds?
- What situation will I leave for my children and grandchildren?

Even just considering that medium-term (if we might say 20 years is medium-term) time frame economically, it might be worth a network of farmers sponsoring the work of a breeder to breed OP varieties specifically for their conditions and requirements. Like to give a simple example, imagine if you could spend what you would spend on 15 years worth of F1 seeds, on a single packet of OP seeds. Sounds crazy expensive! But if they performed the same, that would be a 25% saving! Plus there would be no more expenditure after that too, the next 20 years would be free. A simplified example since it doesn't account for the labour the farmer needs for processing their own seeds each year, nor on the other hand, the benefit of that if the population has enough diversity to make some improved adaptation to the farmer's land, but you get the principle.

Or on a smaller scale, like on a farming based intentional community, it could be worth the community supporting their own plant breeders or breeding projects, with one or more person's time mostly dedicated to that work, for the benefit of the whole community. If the economics of the community itself is well balanced, then the breeder doesn't struggle, the community benefits by eating and perhaps also selling good food grown by suitably low-input methods, and the leaking (which could include selling) of OP seeds from the community might be of no economic harm (since as a community they could have a diversity of income streams), whilst having a very positive impact on the wider community. I think in an intentional community or network of communities, it's easier to take this longer term approach rather than the modern attitude of fragmented individuals considering what money they want to pay in the particular moment they are about to click 'buy' on a computer screen for a packet of seeds.

I would think perhaps this last scenario might be more similar to pre-capitalist society. I could even imagine small networks of such intentional communities having shared breeding projects, maybe one breeding hub for a regional network of communities.  But I guess that it harder in the common situation where finances are fragmented in a commercial world where each family is a separate financial unit. Though perhaps things like GoFundMe or Patreon could play some role. Or, perhaps from an overly optimistic hope, government funding, if policy makers might be pressured or influenced enough by the small minority of people who express concern about the rapidly impending food system collapse we are heading into as our governments steam full speed ahead in destroying the environment.

 

William Schlegel

I really like your latest post Justin!

So much there.

Fred Hempel was sharing a photo of one of his parent lines on Facebook awhile back. He explained that while he wouldn't be sharing it in that form, everyone was welcome to buy the F1 version which would have one copy of every important trait.

I would like to take that a step further if I ever made an F1 for sale and say "hey I made an attempt at an awesome breeding experiment- save seeds with me and let's see what we can segregate out of this!"

It really is the case as Alan Kapuler pointed out that we can go buy commercial hybrids, grow them out, and create our own open pollinated varieties just by saving seed. I'd much rather get that starting material from one of the few small artisinal companies than from the big chemical companies that keep the lobbiests working hard in their strange interests.

I do think there is something to our independent wild species breeding. That space between the mainstream introgressions that we are hopefully filling in.

Though it would be less frustrating if we could get a little scientific confirmation of the palatable lines (mostly Joseph's, Alan's, Tim's, and Lee Goodwin's we've managed to pull out of these experiments collectively.

We have picked the path less traveled here- and it's an uphill path!

Maybe that's why I also fool around with comparatively "easy" crosses. Though I would say that the galapagense, cheesemanii, pimpinillifolium, lycopersicum group is easy to segregate tasty tomatoes from and not just domestic x domestic.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex

#412
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-19, 07:40:41 PMSo: say we use volcanic islands as a classic (and hypothetical without precise Googling of facts so we will letter the species) example. Periodically a new island has formed, and an old island has sunken below the waves. A single tomato species from the mainland millions of years ago: Species X colonized one island. Over deep time that tomato changed due to adaptation and to genetic drift. Eventually that tomato became say Species Y. Then the tomato did some island hopping- again over deep time. On one of the smaller islands there wasn't much habitat so the tomato got better at living on the coast and became Species Z over deep time. This allowed the tomatoes to occupy the two sharply differentiated habitats available on the island coastal and inland. Could have been the coastal species first and the inland species second either way works for this example. Some more Island hopping occurred over deep time. Now many of the islands have populations of both species, though on each island those two species are likely very genetically and morphologically distinct from those on other islands with lots of time between gene flow events, during ice ages the islands are larger and thus closer together with more gene flow, and during interglacial periods smaller and farther apart. Enter modern times with humans with big silly boats full of gawking tourists. These silly humans have reintroduced Species X AND its domestic relative Species XX and now recent hybridizations have occurred given these newly broken-down geographic barriers.

"The systematics and genetics of tomatoes on the Galápagos Islands (Solanum, Solanaceae)" By Sarah Catherine Darwin, A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at University College London, August 2009:

The origin of the Galapagos tomatoes remains unresolved. Phylogenetic analyses using DNA sequences of the nuclear gene waxy (GBSSI: granule-bound starch synthase), show that these four species discussed here are extremely closely related, suggesting recent origins and rapid morphological differentiation (Peralta & Spooner, 2001). Rick (1963) proposed that the closest relatives to the Galapagos tomatoes were Solanum pimpinellifolium and S. habrochaites S. Knapp & D.M. Spooner (as Lycopersicon hirsutum Dunal). Allozyme electrophoresis (Rick & Fobes, 1975) suggested that the populations of S. pimpinellifolium most closely related to the Galapagos tomatoes were from coastal Peni and that the most similar morphologically were populations from the region of Motupe-Olmos in the northern Peruvian department of Lambayeque (c. 6"s latitude). The Humboldt Current flows from here to the Galapagos at certain times of year giving support to this suggestion (Rick & Fobes, 1975).


There was little genetic differentiation between the taxa and this was consistent with other studies, for example Rodrigez et al. (2009). However the difference that was found here was consistent, highly diagnostic and thus allowed the species to be clearly differentiated. The private and fixed alleles in two loci, DIA and PGM, found in the two endemic Galápagos tomato species indicated three things: 1) that they share a common ancestor (as was suggested by Rick and Fobes, 1975), 2) they are more closely related to each other than they are to either of the two introduced tomatoes and 3) that they have evolved in-situ from a common ancestor since their original colonisation. Charles Rick from the TGRC spent many years studying the Galápagos tomatoes and concluded that they had evolved monophyletically (Rick, 1975) and confirmed by Rodrigez et al. (2009).

History of the Galápagos tomatoes
The fact that S. cheesmaniae and S. galapagense share a private fixed allele (derived novelty) indicated that they may share a common history. In addition to this they also share a unique fruit colour not found in the other 'red' fruited tomatoes (Rick, 1971). The two species probably evolved from a common ancestor in the islands (Spooner et al., 1992, Rodriguez et al. 2009).

William Schlegel

#413
That research all sounds relatively consistent rather than inconsistent with what I shared as a generalized thought on how it might have happened.

From your highlighting of the text you shared it looks like you are using a few citations including one from Rick in 1963 to suggest that Solanum habrochaites might have some influence on the Galapagense island tomatoes. If you look at the figure at the below link from the Moyer lab I would suggest that those very old citations pre-gene sequencing should carry very little weight as their doesn't appear to be a close relationship there.

https://moylelab.bio.indiana.edu/evolution.html

Sure it is possible that the fuzziness was introgressed in some past interspecies interaction. However, that doesn't seem like it is showing up at all in the genetic relatedness of the groups. So I would guess it just re-emerged as convergent evolution in the coastal island environment where those arthropod resistance traits were needed.

Though the stories we are able to ascertain from genetic studies are constantly shifting as the technology improves and sometimes are that complex that an introgression could have happened. The DNA could show that eventually if that's what did happen. Wonder if anyone has tried those sorts of genetic comparisons yet?

With human ancestors we now know amazing things like that several of the closely related ancient ancestral species interbred and that their were introgressions that are still present in human DNA. So the technology is potentially to the point there to know for instance if the Type IV trichomes found in both galapagense and habrochaites and associated with arthropod resistance are convergent or if they were the result of a past introgression.


Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Alex


William Schlegel

Quote from: Alex on 2023-11-24, 09:59:17 PMNot X->Y->Z, but X->Y and X->Z

Quote from: Alex on 2023-11-24, 09:09:21 PMThere was little genetic differentiation between the taxa and this was consistent with other studies, for example Rodrigez et al. (2009). However the difference that was found here was consistent, highly diagnostic and thus allowed the species to be clearly differentiated. The private and fixed alleles in two loci, DIA and PGM, found in the two endemic Galápagos tomato species indicated three things: 1) that they share a common ancestor (as was suggested by Rick and Fobes, 1975), 2) they are more closely related to each other than they are to either of the two introduced tomatoes and 3) that they have evolved in-situ from a common ancestor since their original colonisation. Charles Rick from the TGRC spent many years studying the Galápagos tomatoes and concluded that they had evolved monophyletically (Rick, 1975) and confirmed by Rodrigez et al. (2009).

History of the Galápagos tomatoes
The fact that S. cheesmaniae and S. galapagense share a private fixed allele (derived novelty) indicated that they may share a common history. In addition to this they also share a unique fruit colour not found in the other 'red' fruited tomatoes (Rick, 1971). The two species probably evolved from a common ancestor in the islands (Spooner et al., 1992, Rodriguez et al. 2009).

It's late and I am tired but your own text above seems to support X to Y to Z.

Though I also think you are arguing a point that was never intended to be a point of contention.

X to Y and X to Z is a perfectly good way for speciation to occur with geographic barriers as well.

My example was always intended to be an example of how biogeographic speciation could work, not a precise example of how evidence has suggested it did work.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

#416
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-24, 09:51:44 PMFrom your highlighting of the text you shared it looks like you are using a few citations including one from Rick in 1963 to suggest that Solanum habrochaites might have some influence on the Galapagense island tomatoes. If you look at the figure at the below link from the Moyer lab I would suggest that those very old citations pre-gene sequencing should carry very little weight as their doesn't appear to be a close relationship there.

https://moylelab.bio.indiana.edu/evolution.html

I agree. The Lycopersicon group (che, gal, pimp, lyc) is closer related to the arcanum group (arc, chm, neo) than it is to the Eriopersicon group, to which habrochaites (and chil, hua, corn, per) belongs, and even in that group, hab stands out as your source shows (plus the genetic trees do appear somewhat different depending on what markers they measure etc. but still hab stands out), so some people might not even like to group hab with chil, hua, corn, and per. Either way, the assumption of the close relationship with hab has been disproven.

Although there is something potentially misleading about that chart William. It gives only 2 accessions each of che and gal, and one che shown as more related to gal than the other. This is misleading because the other che, LA3124, is actually now considered (in the below paper, hence the star by that accession) a hybrid with either lyc or pimp. I've actually grown that accession (the growth habit was noticably different from all pure che accessions I grew) and to me is seems like a pimp hybrid, but that's just my guess, mainly based on fruit size, seed size, and sweetness. LA0436 is a good representative of gal, I could not find data on nor photos of LA3909 but likely also a good representative.

The following chart, from Genetic Diversity and Population Structure of Two Tomato Species from the Galapagos Islands, Yveline Pailles et al, 2017, gives a clearer picture of the genetics of these two Galapagos species and at least a look at their relation to some lyc and pimp. N.B. in black at the top of this chart we have LA0480 which is pimp, LA2706 is lyc (Moneymaker), and LA4345 lyc (Heinz 1706). This (and along with the chart I provided above in a previous comment, which shows both of these hybrids)) also shows LA0531 to be a gal+che hybrid:
 Screenshot 2023-11-25 at 19.52.19.png

Kadence Luneman

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-17, 07:59:22 PMGenetic drift! I think is the number one cause of decline. Even with the TGRC accession grow out protocols that are designed to minimize it. Optimum conservation of populations would be In Situ + Ex Situ conservation. Without further access to the wild In Situ populations the research and breeding populations at the gene banks will eventually no longer be representative of the wild resource. If the species all survive in the wild. All the populations likely will not.

This is very interesting. I've kind of thought about this before.

Growing the wild tomatoes in Ohio, Utah, Montana, California,... is not the same as them growing where they came from. No matter what we do they will always be different. Because our systems are all different. Even multiple gardens not far apart in each state would be exactly the same because of different micro climates and how we garden.
I'd imagine even if you went all out and built a special greenhouse and made it into the exact conditions of the wild origin, and even hauled in native soil... They would change and drift!

Life always, uh, finds a way. 😉

To my mind the only thing that we can do is to..
1) Support someone who is at the place(s) of origin and doing like a nature reserve type deal for the wild species. Which I've not heard of exists.
2) Utilize the wild stuff we can get. Grow it here and let it become "Lofthouse Utah habrochaites" or "Luneman Ohio pimpinellifolium" etc populations. That way we at least have some of it available to pull from.
Utilize crossing them into the "useful" varieties that are edible, tasty, hardy, whatever traits we need or like. Like the Panamorous project and it's branches in many places. Like William's.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2023-11-25, 09:52:52 PMEven multiple gardens not far apart in each state would be exactly the same because of different micro climates and how we garden.

I disagree, I think the more gardens we get these more diverse genetics into the better. Population size matters! Habitat variation also matters! The bigger the population in the most seed saving gardens, the more genes are preserved and the more opportunities for adaptations to show up that really matter.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

My bad, typo. I meant they would not be exactly the same! For the same reasons as you list.

For example Joseph has posted about the pimp that he got from a neighbor who it always volunteered in their garden. He shared with another neighbor. They had it start to volunteer. But it did not volunteer in Joseph's garden.

I love the roadside chicory. My favorite flower. I can't get it to grow in my yard or pasture, seemingly because the better conditions lol.

Look at this cliff face Arcanum!
https://www.nhm.ac.uk/natureplus/blogs/solanacae-in-south-america/tags/tomatoes.html

And then I see everything you guys do to try and get some of the wild ones to grow to try to cross it. Lol maybe treat some like roadside weeds?