Phaseolus polystachios

Started by hortusbrambonii, 2019-03-31, 04:54:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

hortusbrambonii

I have seeds of the wild thicket bean (Phaseolus polystachios) from the experimental farm network. And I have a few questions:

1. The seeds are said to be edible as dry beans. Are they interesting? And is there any yield?
2. Is the plant interesting to look at? (Like P. coccineus and certain pink-flowering common beans or peas are)
3. I see all kind of speculations about the possibility of crosing it with either P. coccineus or (phylogetentically closer but climatologically less interesting in Western Europe) P. lunatus for a perennial bean. Did anyone at all ever succeed in that?

reed

#1
I have an established patch of them growing on the fence by my garden gate. I grow them mostly just for fun. Can hardly imaging harvesting enough of those tiny beans to make a meal plus they shatter very easily. I think to really try to harvest them you would have to do so while the pods were still pretty green. The flowers are pretty but certainly not spectacular. I have grown both  P. coccineus and  P. lunatus in close proximity and observed bumblebees moving between the flowers but have not found any obvious crosses when I plant the saved seeds. 

Over all they are nice to have around I think. They truly are perennial so once you get them established they are carefree after that. They are easy to sprout in the cold frame or by direct planting. They do spread by seed but are not a weedy problem.   Some years they make a lot of seeds and some not many, I guess that is probably weather related. 

AndrewB

Just learned about these. Feel like I have seen the Scientific name thrown around on this forum, but didn't know what they were. Sadly I know more common names of crops and ornamental plants than I do their respective scientific names.

But, anyway, these sound really interesting! I've always wondered what a wild ancestor of Lima beans might look like! Can these really readily cross with lima beans? And perennial to boot. Interesting. Anyone grow these. The description on Oikos makes them sound productive enough to eat once established.

https://oikostreecrops.com/products/wild-bean-seeds/


AndrewB

P.s. Anyone know how to find a source of this from Ontario, Canada? Apparently this species historical range went as far north as Ontario. I imagine a source from that far north could have special cold resistance or other genetic diversity.

UnicornEmily

The fact that it's perennial and crops late is very intriguing.  Is this a drying bean that could be harvested late in the year, well after frost?  If so, it would be very useful to have a crop that can wait until all the rush of the biggest harvest season is over to be picked.

UnicornEmily

A big and important question for me would be: Is it drought tolerant?  I'm very interested in any species that can handle little or no irrigation in a desert, and I'm even more interested if they can turn into low-care perennials.  We get most of our precipitation as snow, and crops that can stay alive through the winter and are drought tolerant may have an excellent chance of getting enough winter water to survive through the summer without irrigation in my climate.

At least, that's my hope.

AndrewB

#6
Emily, in regards to your first question probably yes, though the tendency toward highly explosive and shattering seed pods may make that more difficult. Sounds like there may be some hybrids already though that do not have shattering seed pods. I notice most online to have brown or grey (possibly mottled?) seed coats online, while the ones from EFN are black. Perhaps the EFN ones are hybridized?

I've sent an email to Dr. Egan, the one collecting them for the USDA genebank. Sounds like she may be from your neck of the woods and working at UVU. I'll let you know if I find anything out from her.

https://nmnh.typepad.com/the_plant_press/2016/03/the-quest-for-the-wild-kidney-bean.html

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jorge-Berny-2/publication/331745392_Chapter_4_Wild_Beans_Phaseolus_L_of_North_America/links/5c8ab9b392851c1df9419fec/Chapter-4-Wild-Beans-Phaseolus-L-of-North-America.pdf

UnicornEmily

Oh, that's very interesting!  UVU is very near me, so anything that's true of their climate is probably true of mine, too.

reed

#8
In my climate they are certainly perennial. Mine are a mix of some from North Carolina and some I found wild not far from my house. There is a bit of variation in seed color and seeds size, but all are still quite small. Pods are two inches long or less with three or four beans per. They bloom and mature very late, so much so that I doubt a cross with Lima beans could happen even if it was genetically possible. At least not with the Lima as the mother plant because it would not have time to mature. Maybe not the other way either as the Limas are about done blooming when they start. Perhaps in a climate where the bloom times could overlap more it would work.

I don't think they are quite as rare as some might believe. Once I actually grew some from the North Carolina seeds and saw first-hand what they look like I realized I had seen that plant before. The wild patch closest to me runs for a 1/4 mile or more along a little gravel backroad and is quite thick with them in spots. They are fairly common in Hoosier National Forest around Lake Monroe and at Big Oaks Wildlife Refuge in Indiana. I've also seen them by the Ohio River in both Indiana and Kentucky.

The habit of shattering and such small pods makes collecting them in any quantity very difficult. I also think wild turkeys might eat them. They are hardy perennials but above ground growth dies down in winter.
 






Garrett Schantz

The different seed coats are due to being collected from different populations. Prariemoon has some seeds I believe.

http://bonap.net/TDC/Image/Map?taxonType=Species&taxonId=11583&locationType=County&mapType=Normal

Here's a range map that was made for the species.

Pretty large range. I've heard of southern populations and whatnot as well.

To my understanding, they were very common but they prefer to grow around or in forests. Large forests were cut down or these were eradicated.


Raindanceseeds has some Peruvian / Amazonian lima beans.

I've been thinking of buying a bunch of limas and whatnot since I'm in Zone 8 now.


Attempting crosses with Phaseolus polystachios may be interesting.

Lima beans have multiple strains / origins-ancestors. Same with these beans.

Cotyledon

I have seeds on order for this species (from Prairiemoon) and hope to find more germplasm sources as well, it is an interesting species. I am also looking at Strophostyles this year, another interesting genus.


Garrett Schantz

I've been a bit busy discovering astral stuff and the like.

But, the morning glory breeding and stuff that you've brought up is neat.


With the astral stuff, I paused and went.

"Er, does Wrath / Ylal realize he's planted himself in a place owned by one of the fellows known as Enki - and that he's always been deathly afraid of him, and that the one hates the other?"


I kinda went like that, and I'm now kinda like "Ones rubbing their chin trying to think, the other hasn't checked."


Once they both figure things out, I'd assume it'll be like a western "You ain't from around these parts." sort of situation.


There's also the fact that the gold line Enki whoever hasn't realized that my energy isn't from someone who was gifted a sort of energy, I'm the source of it and I'm back.

Been meaning to apologize to the fellow for something in the past.





Quite a bit sorry. Got off track there. Been doing some stuff other than plants and the like recently.

Jeremy Weiss

I still have a bit of the OSSI thicket bean seed. I plan to mix it with some colomeca (Phaseolus maculatus) I got from NS/S, and some Phaseolus giganteus I managed to get online, to see if I can get something worthwhile (I'd love to include the unidentified Asian wild Phaseolus (I think) I used to find when I did seed searches, but I haven't seen any in three or four years and my own supply ran out long ago (it was never numerous)). 

 

Cotyledon

#14
Anyone testing these beans for popping ability?


That's a direction I am heading.

Thicker membranes that are reluctant to absorb water may be ideal for this type of preparation.