Breeding for Late Blight Resistant Tomatoes

Started by Diane Whitehead, 2019-02-28, 07:12:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tim DH

That is an interesting offer. .... I don't qualify, but I know someone who has signed up.

(https://www.seedsovereignty.info/outdoor-blight-resistant-tomato-trial/)

Personally I'm a bit bemused. Why would a breeder be interested in developing an OP version of their own (commercially successful) F1?

This article is about the same (F1) breeding program and sites S.pimp as the source of the Blight resistance.

https://www.theenglishgarden.co.uk/plants/fruits-vegetables-and-herbs/grow-blight-resistant-tomatoes/

Searching 'crawford stroud tomato' will bring up loads of other refs

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Tim DH on 2024-04-08, 01:13:21 PMThat is an interesting offer. .... I don't qualify, but I know someone who has signed up.

(https://www.seedsovereignty.info/outdoor-blight-resistant-tomato-trial/)

Personally I'm a bit bemused. Why would a breeder be interested in developing an OP version of their own (commercially successful) F1?

I posted about this before, I really hope enough people signed up for it! Simon told me he believes they have additional resistance, not just the regular Ph genes. As for why breed them - I guess that depends on who's funding the breeding! He worked for Burpee before, not sure about now.

Roland

Here aslo some information about teh Burpee blight resistant tomatoes:
https://landscapingmatters.co.uk/blight-resistance-reigns-supreme-at-the-burpee-europe-trials/

Toddler seems pretty good with good taste and brix 10% and best resistance genes.
Netherlands

Roland

Netherlands

Roland

I fount it's a crossing 'West Virginia '63' x  wild tomato (Solanum  habrochaites), so maybe only ph2 genes. Mannon focused on Septoria resistance.
Netherlands

ThomatoGarden

Yesterday (6.6.) i discovered the first plant with Late Blight (Hot Streak F2). For now i removed the infected Leaves. Normally i would cull infected plants, but its so early in the year. What are your procedures with infected plants over the year?

reed

Interesting Hot Streak F2 has disease. I'm growing the F1 this year and so far, I've have had no issues. Did you notice the same with F1, and are all of the F2 plants diseased, or just some.

If it's bad enough that the plant isn't likely to make fruit, or if there is any sign of disease on the fruits themselves rather than just the leaves or stems, I pull the plant out and plant something in its place. I don't remove it from the garden make any other effort to control spread of the disease.

Roland

For selection I normally leave the affected plants so that only the resistant F2 plants remain. However, since it hits so early this year, I expect that in some time the resistant plants will also be affected. perhaps even before you can harvest seeds.

Between the F2 of Hot Streak we expect 40% of the plants to show insufficient or no resistance.
Netherlands

Adrian

#293
You also can make cuttings of the less attaqued plants and tryed to pick up seeds in more isolated conditions if the blught attack is too important.
If the plant is very tolerant the infection will stop to progressed on the cutting.

ThomatoGarden


Hello,

i was able to stop the infection by removing infected
leaves, allthough it was so cold that even fungus couldn't grow (13-19°C).
it was just to early to let it go. Normaly i just remove only the lowest heavy infected
leaves which would be removed anyway and which are dead soon, or the Plant if no leaves
 left.

While the Temp got up a little (20°C)
Vivagrande (and some Vivagrande x Sunviva F2) seem to be very very subsceptible
to Alternaria !? (half of the leaves allready dead in a few days)

An other weird thing is the selection of MM F3 here, the Salad size selection turns out
to be more in the determinant direction ? Was a parent big and determinant ?
Didn't see this in the F2 Generation !?


Greetings Thomas

(5pm , 17°C and raining again tz )

Roland

Mountain magic is a cross between a determinant beef tomato x indeterminant cherry.
Netherlands

ThomatoGarden

#296
Hello, i know its to early to make any real conclusions about anything, but for
entertainment and discussion, here are some observations i made :
(cause of unstable weather taste is overall bland this year, maybe gets better sometimes)

Black Centiflor: Really healthy at first but also extremly
                 susceptible to late Blight (even fruits allready!)

Tims Taste of Paradiese: Some disease at first but no Late blight until now,
                 really unique Leaves and look. small yellow fruit 1.5 cm.

Rote Zora : Some disease at first but no Late blight until now.

Vivagrande: Extremly much diseases at first (half of leaves allready dead), no late Blight, now recovering

Vivagrande x Sunviva F2:
        Some extremley much diseases up now (half of leaves allready dead), no late Blight, some recovering
        Some pretty healthy
        Some really early, 110 days from seed, Outside, Salad Size, very big plant, productive !.
        Sadly the earlyst, nicest Plant is a little bit subsceptible. (plan to do a trial against Bloody
        Butcher next year to verify)
        for Ref. Gardeners Delight/Black cherry in Greenhouse at 122/124 days from seed here.

Primabella x Sunviva F1: A few leaves infected at the bottom, big plant

Primabella x Bulgarian Giant tom. F1: Surprisingly healthy Plants until now, Salad size, medium to big plant.
               Didn't expect the plant to be this good. I start to think that the overall vitality is also a
               big factor in disease Resistance. Therefore also fruit size reduces the resistance to some degree,
               cause it stresses the plant. Just some random thoughts.

Honey Moon F1: looks ok, healthy up now, nice fruit, low to medium size plant.
               fertilisation not the best under sub optimal conditions.

Bauna F1: healty at first but little Late Blight now and bad fertilisation under sub optimal conditions.

Gourmantsun F1: Little disease at first and no late blight until now !? but i think Buffalosun F1
                 was also a bit resistant at first so... .

Wasipicon Peach: Sadly Late Blight pretty early this year, but only at the bottom, otherwise healty plant

Primabella: 4 of 6 Plants pretty healthy, it seems there are allways some
                  plants which are a little bit weaker to diseases , but no late blight!
                  (This is only for selecting fresh seed and crossing partners,
                     overall the 2 plants have still very little disease !)

Hot Streak F2: 10 of 30 were Potato leaves.
               Most have at least good resistance, also to late blight !
               Most Plants have beefsteak like Tomatoes and are not big plants,
                 a few have big Salad size fruits these are also bigger plants.
               The fertilisation is not good under bad conditions.
               The weak one from June allready has fruit late blight.
               Some have rotten fruit but the plant is healthy !?? Fruit Shape maybe not optimal so water
               remains near steam of fruit (we had extrem rain)?


Mountain Magic F3: Many Plants have the Brachytic Gen from NC 2 Grape, the extreme one is just 80cm high
                   with leaves every 3-4 cm.
                   Some are Determinant.
                   Resistance is really really good until now.
                   (The F3 i collected were all indeterminant 2m high plants !)
                   Many let grow the Fruit trus like a new stem !?
                   This may also partially be caused by the unstable weather
                   (from 15°C max to 30°C max at day, and nights down to 5°C in early Summer) ?
                   Few have smaller, spare leaves.
                   Fruit size differs much more than F2 !?
                                   

Matt's Wild Cherry: Some Diseases , no Late Blight.

Philamina: Bad Seed Source, all 3 have different Fruit (one yellow). very subsceptible to Diseases. Sad.

   
Plants which i will remove soon:
Black Centiflor
Philamina
few Vivagrande x Sunviva F2
few Hot Streak F2

Is someone  interesed in Determinant or small Brachytic MM F3 Plants ? Otherwise i wouldn't take seeds.

Greetings Thomas

Roland

We think that Vivagrande is susceptible to Verticillium because the lower leaves also died here. Yet the plant remained otherwise healthy.

Since a small part of your F2 is also susceptible, I would suspect that it is a recessive gene that ensures that the plant is extra susceptible. This is because other varieties are not affected.

We also found potato leaves in the F2 of Hot Streak. (Rose Crush is also a carrier for the potate leave gene. Just like Mountain Rouge)
Why do seed breeders use a potato leave parent?

Primabella is very resistant but end of 2023 it got late blight in my garden. Primabella is resistant to Leave mold and 2024 I have a lot of problems with leave mold in the other varieties.
As far as I know, Primabella is the strongest outdoor tomato available.

I would like some seeds from your small Brachytic MM F3 Plants. Maybe in the future I will start another breeding project with the Brachytic gene in combination with my Nebula project.

p.s. Here the first cherry tomatoes are ripening. Fruit set of the beef varieties is only now starting due to the cold and wet year (rain every day and at night around 10C).
Netherlands

Roland

Did u find the Crimson ogc gene in Mountain Magic?

The Crimson ogc gene gives extra dark red fruit and the F1 is heterozygous.
Netherlands

ThomatoGarden

No, didn't see any extra dark red fruit last year, and MM is a little bit later so most have no ripe fruit jet.
ok, will collect some seed from small Brachytic MM F3 Plants.

Yes Primabella is the best stable tomato atm. Reliable survives till frost.
The MM F3's look also very good (until now), and the plants i took seeds from last year were as good as
Primabella.