Breeding Sweet Potatoes (turning them into a seed grown annual)

Started by reed, 2019-01-13, 06:44:39 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

Haven't had any sweet potato news for a good bit, wrong time of the year for it. Spring is about here though so last evening I got out and inspected those I had saved for possible cloning this year. I'm thinking now I will only be cloning from four different saved roots. Three of them have reddish/purple skin and one has white. The white one is also white inside the others are orange. Two have regular leaves and two have the ivy leaf type.

To reduce chances that I'll change my mind I removed the tags from all the rest and put them in the bin to eat. I think I will grow just one big tube of each, close enough together for the vines and flowers to comingle, thus encouraging crossing by the bees. I even thought of growing just one, the best of the best but then I remembered the non-self-compatible nature of some sweet potatoes and decided for insurance I better keep a variety.

Anyway, that frees up the rest of my big tubs. I also have about 100 smaller pots and I'm thinking I'll make a five x fifty-foot row for inground planting. I'm going to plant around 1000 seeds mostly direct sown in the tubs, pots and ground. 

It's time to get back to the original purpose of turning them into a seed grown annual instead of saving and cloning. I hope with planting 1000 seeds it will be enough to:
1- Find at least 200 that sprout quickly and easily, although I expect there may be more than that.
2- Out of those hoped for 200, find 50 that meet all or at least most of the preferred traits. Seedy, bushy, clump root, sweet.

Even if I end up with just 25 that meet the criteria hopefully, I'll also end up with lots more fresh seeds.

At that point, with the 25 plants worthy of cloning the following year and the seeds this project will officially exceed my ability to continue by myself.

whwoz

Sounds like a fun season coming up for you mate.  I have some seed raised tubers in pots that I have to get the slips into the ground from then work covers over to keep them going over winter, not the best situation but they were late getting here from Qld, so making the best of the situation I can.  Just need one or two plants of each to survive and I will be away.

reed

Quote from: whwoz on 2022-04-19, 04:15:42 AM
Sounds like a fun season coming up for you mate.  I have some seed raised tubers in pots that I have to get the slips into the ground from then work covers over to keep them going over winter, not the best situation but they were late getting here from Qld, so making the best of the situation I can.  Just need one or two plants of each to survive and I will be away.

Cuttings are very easy to keep as house plants. In your case I guess a nice north window would do the trick. If your inside conditions are better than mine, as in warmer and brighter they could get a bit overgrown by spring. No problem, you can just clip them into pieces and start more or you could use the extra growth as greens.

Something a lot of folks don't realize about them, at least in my experience is that they are extremely easy to start and when transplanting a stem section with very little root growth actually takes off and produces better than one with an established root system. When I plant out my slips, I cut off most or even all of the roots and let the plant start over.

whwoz

Thanks Reed, keeping some as cuttings either inside or out on the deck in a mini greenhouse is what I intend to do, but there are more slips than I really want to carry over that way, so will plant surplus in soil under plastic.  Can do peppers that way easily here, so will see how they go. Not worried about production now, only that I get a couple to survive.

reed

Sweet potato season is getting underway here, it seems late but that's just because it's been very hot. Slips have been removed from last year's storage roots and are developing new roots of their own right now. I fill cell packs with sand and stick a slip in each one and set it in a tray of water. They were outside in full sun as they developed so no need for a transition as far as that goes. I'll be putting in several each from the best of last year's plants and a couple from the year before.

This project has reached the point where turning sweet potatoes into a seed grown annual is now relatively easy and reliable. It's OK to celebrate that I reckon but as it turns out it may have been the easy part. That random discovery several years ago and a lot of bumblebee activity provided for that. I helped out by planting the seeds but beyond that they and the bees just did it themselves.

Still so many unknowns and so many experiments to conduct in effort to find out other things. The question of compatibility for example. I know some are self-compatible while most are not. I also very strongly suspect that one may be compatible with one or more other one(s) but not necessarily with just any other.  I'll probably never really figure that out but I think it is important. That's because for example, if I sold or gifted say, ten seeds and due to still low germination only two sprouted, would those two be enough to insure compatibility?  At this point I just don't know. Apparently in a patch of at least 25, or sometimes a lot more any that can make seeds finds a pollinator.

Anyway, there will still be lots more questions for a long time but for now I'm going to establish a germination rate. I already know it is increasing in later generations from seed to seed and from others I have shared seed with, I know it can be as high as 90% or so using controlled conditions like in a greenhouse with consistent high temperatures but I don't use controlled conditions.

This year I didn't even use the cold frame but instead have planted around 1000 seeds directly in the ground. I don't know if it is really a 1000 seeds because I got tired of counting sweet potato seeds. I just planted two seed beds, each about 4 x 10 feet with rows about four inches apart and the seeds thickly in each row. They transplant very easily so I am not worried about separating those that come up on top of each other but having the 4 inches between will make it easier. They were planted on our official last frost date of May 15. It had been very dry in the three weeks before but it rained a little bit on the 17th. On the 19th, 22 seeds had sprouted. So, 0.2% germination within four days. It rained a lot more last night, the 19th/20th and is projected to be in the 90s F today, the 20th and for the next couple of days. I know they like it pretty warm to sprout so it will be interesting over the next few days to see how many more pop up.

I have a total of 18 of the large tubs now but half of them are reserved for the slips cloned from the previous year's plants. I think I can put as many as five seedlings in each one of the rest and they will do fine so that's (45). I also have about 30 large pots that will hold two each (60) and about 50 pots big enough for one (50). That adds up to room for around 150 but with the very warm weather I expect more than that may sprout. I have a great big pile of partially composted wood chips mixed up with other compost and regular soil to fill the pots as needed.

I don't know what I will do if more than anticipated end up sprouting. If just 20%  end up sprouting, let alone 30% or 40% I'll be in a pickle.  I really want to make some good progress with my sweet potatoes this year so if a lot sprout, I may rip out something else to make room for an inground patch. I also have a couple hundred small 1 gallon pots. That certainly is too small but I wonder if I might be able to use them anyway, possibly to determine those that have the clump root trait that I like. If a plant managed to make even a small storage root inside a 1 gallon pot it might indicate that trait.

However it works out I hope to first recoup the investment of seeds. I expect that will be doable, assuming of course I am there to spend the time, at the appropriate time to collect them. If I'm lucky I might also find a bunch of new ones that exhibit all or most of the traits I favor which I can save and clone next year.

On an aside, the woman here by trickery, because she didn't know what she was eating, has come to realize that some of mine taste better than her previous favorite, an heirloom called Puerto Rico. I'm so glad of that because Puerto Rico has never bloomed for me and I'm tired of wasting space on it.

AndrewB

Quote from: reed on 2022-05-20, 07:51:14 AM
This project has reached the point where turning sweet potatoes into a seed grown annual is now relatively easy and reliable. It's OK to celebrate that I reckon but as it turns out it may have been the easy part. That random discovery several years ago and a lot of bumblebee activity provided for that. I helped out by planting the seeds but beyond that they and the bees just did it themselves.

I also very strongly suspect that one may be compatible with one or more other one(s) but not necessarily with just any other.  I'll probably never really figure that out but I think it is important. That's because for example, if I sold or gifted say, ten seeds and due to still low germination only two sprouted, would those two be enough to insure compatibility?  At this point I just don't know. Apparently in a patch of at least 25, or sometimes a lot more any that can make seeds finds a pollinator.

Anyway, there will still be lots more questions for a long time but for now I'm going to establish a germination rate. I already know it is increasing in later generations from seed to seed and from others I have shared seed with, I know it can be as high as 90% or so using controlled conditions like in a greenhouse with consistent high temperatures but I don't use controlled conditions.

Woo Hoo! Congrats! I've been patiently waiting for this to inch closer and closer to getting some seeds. Heck at this point I would even buy seeds from you.

Sounds like this may be somewhat similar to tomatillos or Joseph's self incompatible tomato project. Good to know that we might need more than 10 seeds. Perhaps a standard seed sharing size should be more like 40-60? A minimum of 30?

From what bill was saying on his blog about regular TPS that he has found a higher success rate by very shallowly planting the seeds and even using plastic wrap to make a mini "greenhouse". Do you think something like that could help? Can't find his experiment page with plastic wrap.

https://www.cultivariable.com/instructions/potatoes/how-to-grow-true-potato-seeds-tps/

reed

I think about any method of increasing the temp would work to enhance germination, I just choose not to do any of them other than waiting for warm weather. I have plenty of growing season so no real need for getting them started early, plus I want to select for those that sprout easier on their own.

Sweet potatoes have other issues concerning germination, but I don't do anything about that either.  I don't nick the seed or soak it in acid, I just want them to do it themselves. A lot of the seed I planted were from older generations that lack any adaptation for easy sprouting. I suspect I have just sacrificed several hundred seeds, but I guess that is just the price I have to pay to find some that may have a genetic predisposition for easier sprouting.

From what I've seen, as long as I don't bury that spot in deep mulch or something they will keep sprouting for months, even for two or three years. I just wanted the ones that sprout in the first couple of weeks or so but I'm up to about 50 now. I did not expect this many so quickly, it's just the 6th day and I'm up to about 50. Actually, any that sprout before July will have time to make usable sized roots.

Sweet potatoes have very little in common with potatoes. I found TPS to be pretty easy to sprout, both in trays and direct planted but in three years all I got was three seed berries and a total of maybe a quart of marble sized potatoes. In my climate I think there is little chance that potatoes could be a seed grown annual, in that you actually get something to eat from them in the first year. You have to save the little tuber and grow it the next year. Sweet potatoes can make a harvest from seed just as good or even better than from clones.

I don't think that in a sense, sweet potatoes don't actually mature. In their native climate they are perennial, and I guess the roots just keep getting bigger. When I talk about maturity in 100 days or less, I just mean they make roots big enough to be worth the effort in that time. By selecting for that I think, aside from my own preference for quick maturity they may be more adaptable for people in with shorter seasons.

nathanp


QuoteI know some are self-compatible while most are not. I also very strongly suspect that one may be compatible with one or more other one(s) but not necessarily with just any other.

Craig Yencho, in a previously linked to youtube video, says there are probably four compatibility groups with sweet potatoes.  Nearly all would be self incompatible, and compatibility from group to group is not guaranteed, except between some specific groups.  Not all groups are compatible with all the other groups.

Quote from: reed on 2022-05-21, 04:21:52 AM
Sweet potatoes have very little in common with potatoes. I found TPS to be pretty easy to sprout, both in trays and direct planted but in three years all I got was three seed berries and a total of maybe a quart of marble sized potatoes. In my climate I think there is little chance that potatoes could be a seed grown annual, in that you actually get something to eat from them in the first year. You have to save the little tuber and grow it the next year. Sweet potatoes can make a harvest from seed just as good or even better than from clones.

I don't think that in a sense, sweet potatoes don't actually mature. In their native climate they are perennial, and I guess the roots just keep getting bigger. When I talk about maturity in 100 days or less, I just mean they make roots big enough to be worth the effort in that time. By selecting for that I think, aside from my own preference for quick maturity they may be more adaptable for people in with shorter seasons.

With TPS potatoes, you nearly always need at least a 150 day growing season after transplanting (after 8 weeks indoors or in a greenhouse), to have a reasonable chance of a harvest that approaches that of tuber grown potatoes.  And many will still not be close.  If you had a 180 day growing season, you would have a pretty safe guarantee that a good percentage might make it.  But if you are directly sowing seeds outdoors, you would likely need 200+ day growing seasons to reach that.  And you need parent varieties that produce a lot of berries to have enough seeds to direct sow outdoors, because only a low percentage would germinate and grow long enough to create viable plants in most climates.

I think a more realistic approach with TPS is using it as a means to create new seed tubers for subsequent years.  Saving the best, healthiest, etc (whatever you want to select for) to use as seed potatoes could easily be done with minimal space required.

AndrewB

Cool. Looking forward to eventually growing TSPS!

Keep up the good work!

50 sounds like a good population size to work with from a genetics standpoint!

reed

Good golly, lots more have sprouted. I'm guessing in the range of about 300, way off the charts of what I expected, and I don't have nearly enough pots for them all. Sweet potatoes are the crown jewel of my plant breeding projects so I guess I'll sacrifice a couple of my corn patches and plant some of them in the ground.  I'll need to build some trellises too cause it's hard on a feller's back, searching for seeds when they are grown in the ground.  I'll also try some in the small 1-gallon pots to see what happens, maybe it will work to identify the clump root plants. Can't tell yet what leaf shape they will have but there is a big range of color in the seed leaves.

One of the "vampires" showed up too. I figured it would die today but it's cloudy and raining so I have time to rescue it just for the heck of it. It makes maybe the 5th one I have seen over the years; they apparently can't make chlorophyl but will grow slowly as long as they are kept in the shade. I grew one for several weeks one time but when I tried to acclimate it to the sun a ten-minute exposure killed it.  I would never allow one of these to bloom. Also, since it looks to be a rainy day, I think I'll practice with my new image software so I can post some pictures.

Nathan,
on the Yencho videos, are you talking about the ones where he discusses his work in Africa, breeding for use as French fries and the variety Covington? I guess I need to watch it again, I don't remember him mentioning the compatibility groups. If there is a non-laboratory way to identify those groups, it would be a giant help to me.

on TPS, I have plenty of season length, but I think too much heat. One year growing TPS my plants were almost as big as the patch grown from tubers, and they were covered with absolutely beautiful flowers. Then one of our hot dry spells came along and all the flowers dried up and fell off. Then the plants themselves started drying up. From a fifty-foot row I got one seed berry and a cup full of little potatoes, the biggest was about the size of a medium sized grape, most were more like peas. I planted those that survived in the refrigerator the next year, but an earlier hot dry spell killed them, so I gave up on potatoes except for buying a few new seed tubers each year. 

nathanp

QuoteNathan,
on the Yencho videos, are you talking about the ones where he discusses his work in Africa, breeding for use as French fries and the variety Covington? I guess I need to watch it again, I don't remember him mentioning the compatibility groups. If there is a non-laboratory way to identify those groups, it would be a giant help to me.

I believe that was the one.  But now I'm 2ng guessing myself that maybe it was the podcast interview Bill Whitson did with Telsing Andrews. But I don't believe there was information mentioned about what was in any compatibility groups, just that there were four groups with varying amounts of group compatibility.

Quote
on TPS, I have plenty of season length, but I think too much heat. One year growing TPS my plants were almost as big as the patch grown from tubers, and they were covered with absolutely beautiful flowers. Then one of our hot dry spells came along and all the flowers dried up and fell off. Then the plants themselves started drying up. From a fifty-foot row I got one seed berry and a cup full of little potatoes, the biggest was about the size of a medium sized grape, most were more like peas. I planted those that survived in the refrigerator the next year, but an earlier hot dry spell killed them, so I gave up on potatoes except for buying a few new seed tubers each year. 

Potatoes certainly do not like very warm temperatures, nor very warm soil.  Flowering, in particular, seems to be reduced above 80F with nearly all potatoes, and at 90F nearly no potatoes will flower.  But my answer about handling heat and dry spells would be that you were not working with germplasm that can handle it, not that all potatoes cannot.  Rich Machado successfully bred potatoes to handle high soil temperatures in Southern California.  I've seen a number of potatoes weather 6+ weeks of nearly zero rain.  I think that's just a matter of working with the right parents and selecting for potatoes that can handle it.  Probably would mean survival of the fittest with a wide germplasm base to begin, then work with the survivors, if you were inclined to try.  There are a number of Mexican bred, late blight resistant clones, for example, that I bet would do fine.  But expecting good harvests from TPS plants is another matter and perhaps a different set of goals or factors than growing TPS plants to select for seed tubers for the next year.

reed

Quote from: nathanp on 2022-05-22, 06:12:47 PM
... expecting good harvests from TPS plants is another matter and perhaps a different set of goals or factors than growing TPS plants to select for seed tubers for the next year.
Yep, that's exactly it. I want food from seed, eliminating the need to store cloneable material until the next season. With TSPS the university breeders and the few other individuals I know of, in that aspect, are treating them like TPS. That is, just looking for that great one to clone from then on. I have discarded many that at least in my estimation were fine for perpetuating as clones and I have cloned many for a year or two, but just to backcross and reinforce the traits I like in the next generation of seed. I'm doing that again with some nice ones from 2020 and 2021.

I don't intend to ever name and propagate a food quality sweet potato for sale or sharing as a clone. Instead, I want seeds that have been bred and selected to the point I'm confident they will produce quality food in good quantity and more seeds, in 100 days or less.

I'll take listen to that podcast, but I admit I'm skeptical about the compatibility groups. Not necessarily that that they don't exist but that they could possibly be identified, unless maybe in a laboratory. Even with that, considering the massive genetic variation of sweet potatoes and their penchant for random mutation it would be difficult at best.


reed

I found this very interesting video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1vzRPms15E. Especially the first few minutes gives me the idea that maybe I can screen for traits early on, rather than waiting all the way till fall to observe things like color, size and growth habit of the roots. He does early screening in May and plants out the selections in June. I'm a bit behind that in my climate but maybe I could do initial screening in June and plant my selections in July.

If I could do it by early July, there should still be time to grow to more maturity and get seeds. The last part of the video is interesting as well. He doesn't really talk about it, but I notice that all of theirs have the "clump root" trait that I have been chasing. Maybe the early screening along with growing lots in small pots could help me better identify that in time for a larger amount of my seed to carry the trait.

reed

Just a few days till June 1st and I'm in the neighborhood of 400 - 450 seeds sprouted. More than enough to offset the remorse of discarding any that sprout later. I was more careful this year to make evenly deep rows and consistent soil conditions instead of just sowing them sloppily like last year. I figured the uneven treatment might be giving a false image of how quicky they came up. Seems to have worked with each row sprouting evenly instead a cluster here and none there like last year.

When I planted two weeks ago it was hot, high 80s to low 90s and dry. It had been that way for a couple of weeks. When it rained a couple days later, and they started sprouting I never expected to be trialing for cold tolerance. Since that first rain though, it has rained several more times and stayed cloudy and cool a lot. A few clear nights have dipped into the low 50s. I don't know how it was established or by whom but 50 is the commonly accepted lower limit for growth in sweet potatoes. I don't know if the roots keep growing but, in the fall, the vines and seed production doesn't seem effected until the 30s and it takes an actual frost to kill them down. Maybe their growth isn't as fast as might have been, but the seedlings seem fine.

Off to a bit of weird start, will be interesting to see how the rest of the season goes. 

AndrewB

Really interesting discussion. I really like the main goal of breeding for fast tuber growth and seeds in one season as opposed to for cloning like was mentioned. I wonder if the same could be bred for in regular potatoes with TPS.

Either way, cool stuff.