Independent Plant Breeder Access to GRIN Germplasm

Started by Carol Deppe, 2026-10-19, 03:13:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Carol Deppe

Are you having trouble getting germplasm from the Grin system? If so, this is something OSSI would like to know about. And to do something about if we can.

Please tell me about it. Ideally, tell me about when it happened and who you were interacting with.

I suggest telling anyone at GRIN you interact with in the future that you are a member in good standing of the Open Source Seed Initiative Open Source Plant Breeding Forum (give link). And the germplasm you are requesting is not readily available commercially in USA and you need it for your plant breeding work.

Carol Deppe PhD, Chair
OSSI Board of Directors

AndrewB

This is a known problem going back a ways. I've been rejected more than once for various reasons and never consistent. Each species or curator / facility have their own guidelines.

But in general they tend to discriminate against non academic requesters and those with residential addresses. This not only applies to ARS GRIN, but the tomato genetics resource center. They don't like back garden breeders at all.

Which I get. There should be some sort of vetting process. I've seen that with my own sharing of seeds with others and the same phenomenon is seen with open source software. Many people take and don't give back or have crop failures because of lack of experience and lack or foresight to keep backup seed, etc.

And it costs money. A simple fee could be a good way to pay for that resource. It's a complex set of issues.

Regardless, I don't use ARS GRIN if I can avoid it. And I still have not figured out how to create or donate an accession back if I come up with something great.

But having academic support through OSSI for this when and if needed sounds great.

Carol Deppe

What happens if you use a seed company email address and home address? That is johndoe@seedcompany.com, not a gmail address. But are not a university employee.

???

William Schlegel

#3
I've never had a problem with GRIN and I used a home address. Though also in my state it's easy to get an business name. I changed mine recently to Montana Tomato Project. Also you could get a P.O. for your business. In any regard I think it's important to be professional in dealings with GRIN and represent yourself well as an independent breeder. Perhaps developing a small breeding resume before approaching them might be helpful. Like developing and pledging a variety or two with readily available germplasm?

TGRC did deny my third request years ago. Though they left open some potential future possibilities. If you were a enrolled student taking a university plant breeding course or associated with a university lab or if you were associated with a seed bank. Which intrigued me as starting a seed bank for breeders might be interesting.

Also remember that the seed savers exchange and native seed search are gene banks. Native Seed Search I once asked if they could send a chia from their official seed bank as I was curious if it might be adaptable farther north but they thought it too risky and it may have been as EFN sent me a sample of the same species they'd adapted to Jersey and it didn't bloom for me.

Seed savers exchange would also let you offer any finished varieties or I think many germplasm varieties as long as they are stable and edible/palatable. I was able to get a good small collection of South American tomatoes from them.

Personally I've recieved so much germplasm at this point (from seed savers exchange, Experimental Farm Network, other breeders, native seed search,  catalogs, and  directly from GRIN) thatI'm still trying to process what I have. So any additional requests have been on pause for several years.

Though I am the tomato steward for the Going to Seed organization and we might want to put together a request eventually. Though I'd feel personally responsible for the additional accessions. The Going to Seed organization has made some organized requests for germplasm including doing some grow outs and returns of material to GRIN. I think they've done favas for example. That gives those of us who are members of both communities the opportunity to use the germplasm as part of a larger breeding team as it were. A lot of the purpose of the Going to Seed Organization is to keep adaptive breeder's grex populations available to the growing breeding community especially inspired by Joseph's work. Joseph used to keep a small catalogue of his intentionally broad selected germplasm pools and still contributes quite a few to the EFN catalogue and the Going to Seed offerings. The Going to Seed organization essentially functions as a pooled seed library for that same purpose to allow many breeders to function together as a breeding team.

Also sharing germplasm with other independent breeders is very useful. Andrew, Joseph, and I did this year's ago- by sharing the germplasm with each other we were able to back it up and return seed to each other if one of us was successful at growing it. Essentially functioning as a small breeding team. I tend to save a packet or more every time I grow out an accession and usually have some to spare in small quantities. So, I've also been able to share germplasm with others on this board over the years. That helps insure that someone in the community will make good use of it. Though my main focus of the last few years has been to work through some red South American tomatoes and get that germplasm into something Northern tier state adapted and fancy. I think if we can make the germplasm exciting crop genetic conservation will be accomplished through our new varieties and widely adopted by small seed companies.

It's hard for me not to feel personally responsible for stewarding each accession I acquire as well. Even though my goal is to create new material from them.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Carol Deppe

I am guessing that by OSSI-Pledging a variety you minimize or cease to have trouble getting access to the Grin system because a simple search using name plus "plant breeder" brings up your affiliation with OSSI, your plant breeder page at ossi, etc.

Try it with "William Schlegel plant breeder," for example.

If you have pledged one or more varieties simply say that you are an OSSI-associated plant breeder. I think GRIN wants to see some kind of organizational connection. I don't think it has to be a university. And the ossi connection appears prominently in search results.

Maybe a seed company name will do.

I think the more difficult issue is assuring access for people who have not yet pledged a variety.

William Schlegel

#5
Perhaps, though if some germplasm can be obtained through venues like Going to Seed, Experimental Farm Network, Native Seeds Search, and Seed Savers Exchange, a breeder could get a couple of varieties started, pledge them, release them, and that might open the door to GRIN.

More importantly practicing breeding skills for a round might help folks have the skills to make good use of the germplasm. To me the heart of this effort is conserving and repackaging (in tasty, resilient, and beautiful new combinations) crop and crop wild relative diversity.

The flipside of conserving crop and crop wild relative diversity is conserving wildland plant and pollinator diversity and that is also very important to me (tends to take me 40 hours a week). Interestingly the conservation of my favorite crop tomatoes requires both as its dependent on native pollinators for pollination and those pollinators are dependent on native plants.

A slow ramp up to accessing GRIN might be to read Carol's book most carefully- and perhaps go further in research. Make a couple of common crosses and do the harder work of shepherding them towards a variety and pledge that work to OSSI. Obtain everything you can get commercially and through seed savers exchange. Post and interact on a plant breeding forum like this one to develop some real relationships. Swap some lines and germplasm with those new colleagues. Then when your ready- alone and representing yourself well, or as part of a group effort like with Going to Seed (and representing the group well) obtain some additional germplasm from GRIN.

One example of what not to do from my experience is my apple breeding project. I read a national geographic online article about Kazakhstan wild/indigenous apple germplasm. The article said you could request 100 seeds from the Geneva New York GRIN facility. The curator encouraged it. So I did in 2003. Some of those trees are still growing today but none have yet flowered. I'm very attached to them and would dig them up and move them if I had a place to take them. It turns out my property is highly hostile to apples. On the plus side the survivors may yet produce fruit that I can seed save and have an viable apple breeding project from trees that withstood quite hostile conditions. Another component though is that a year later I also ordered some scionwood and every graft with it failed. I hadn't grafted before and even though I made quite a few practice grafts concurrently with some family trees I grew up with and wanted to propagate I wish I had worked with them for a few years before I ordered scions from GRIN.

That's not to say that germplasm shouldn't be shared by GRIN with folks who are early on in their careers as independent plant breeders, its just that it's a somewhat limited resource and we need to be very responsible with it. Having the experience to be successful with the material might be helpful to both obtaining it and making good use of it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days